Alcan Gove Pty Ltd v Zabic

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE AND NETTLE JJ

ALCAN GOVE PTY LTD  APPELLANT

AND

ZORKO ZABIC  RESPONDENT

Alcan Gove Pty Ltd v Zabic

[2015] HCA 33

Date of Order:  12 August 2015
Date of Publication of Reasons:  7 October 2015

D5/2015

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory

Representation

G M Watson SC with J C Sheller for the appellant (instructed by Bartier Perry)

B W Walker SC with G F Little SC for the respondent (instructed by Shine Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Limitation of actions – When cause of action accrues – Negligence – Damage – Statute abolished cause of action unless accrued before 1 January 1987 – Whether compensable damage suffered upon changes to mesothelial cells following exposure to asbestos – Whether mesothelioma inevitable – Relevance of hindsight – Whether "trigger" for development of disease endogenous or exogenous.

Torts – Negligence – Damage – Dust diseases – Mesothelioma – Whether changes to mesothelial cells compensable damage.

Words and phrases – "compensable damage", "endogenous", "exogenous", "hindsight", "mesothelial cell changes", "trigger".

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act (NT), ss 52(1), 189(1).

  1. FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE AND NETTLE JJ.   The issue in this appeal was whether the respondent's cause of action in negligence for damages for mesothelioma caused by the inhalation of asbestos fibres in the course of his employment with the appellant between 1974 and 1977 accrued before 1 January 1987.  The issue arose because, on 1 January 1987, the substantive provisions of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act (NT) ("the Act") came into force[1].  The Act abolished common law actions in negligence with respect to workplace injuries and provided for limited statutory rights to compensation for injured workers.  If the cause of action accrued on or after 1 January 1987, it would have been statute barred.

    [1]The Act was enacted as the Work Health Act 1986 (NT).

  2. The judge at first instance (Barr J) held that the cause of action did not accrue until the onset of malignant mesothelioma; and, according to the evidence given at trial, that was probably at a point between one and five years before the respondent first experienced symptoms of mesothelioma in 2013 or 2014.On that basis, the judge held that the cause of action did not accrue until well after 1 January 1987[2].

  3. The Court of Appeal of the Northern Territory (Riley CJ, Southwood and Hiley JJ) reversed the judge's decision[3].  They found that, with the benefit of hindsight, it was possible to say that the respondent's mesothelial cells were so damaged shortly after inhalation of asbestos fibres between 1974 and 1977 as "inevitably and inexorably" to lead to the eventual onset of the malignant mesothelioma[4].  On that basis, the Court of Appeal concluded that the damage done to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alcan Gove Pty Ltd v Zabic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] HCA 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from Alcan Gove Pty Ltd (the appellant) against a decision concerning a claim for damages for personal injury. The respondent, Mr Zabic, had contracted mesothelioma, a malignant tumour of the mesothelial cells, which he alleged was caused by inhaling asbestos fibres during his employment with the appellant between 1974 and 1977. The central dispute revolved around when the respondent's cause of action for negligence accrued, particularly in light of legislation that abolished such actions unless they had accrued before 1 January 1987.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the initial, asymptomatic molecular changes to the respondent's mesothelial cells, which occurred soon after his exposure to asbestos fibres and before 1 January 1987, constituted "compensable damage" for the purposes of founding a cause of action in negligence. The court was required to determine whether these early cellular changes, which were not themselves malignant and did not necessarily lead to mesothelioma, were sufficient to establish that the respondent had suffered actionable damage at the time of exposure, or shortly thereafter. This involved considering the nature of damage in tort law, particularly in the context of latent diseases, and the distinction between an injury and the eventual manifestation of a disease.

The High Court reasoned that actionable damage in negligence requires a detriment that leaves the plaintiff worse off. Drawing on established principles, the court noted that while the development of mesothelioma was caused by the appellant's breach of duty, the critical question was when compensable damage first occurred. The court distinguished the initial, asymptomatic molecular changes in mesothelial cells from conditions like pleural thickening or plaques, which had previously been held not to constitute actionable damage in the absence of further development or symptoms. The court concluded that the initial cellular changes, being asymptomatic, undetectable, and not inevitably leading to mesothelioma, did not amount to compensable damage at the time they occurred. Therefore, the cause of action did not accrue before 1 January 1987.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court of Appeal was correct. On 12 August 2015, this Court made orders dismissing the appeal. These are the reasons for those orders.The facts The expert evidence given at trial was that asbestos fibres are hydrated silicates of aluminium and magnesium which are known to generate oxygen free radicals capable of setting off adverse genetic changes in susceptible cells. When asbestos fibres are inhaled they work their way to the periphery of the lung, eventually through the visceral pleura and ultimately onto the parietal pleura. Mesothelial cells form part of the parietal pleura. They contain "oncogenes" which may be so influenced by methylation and acetylation caused by free radicals as in some cases to lead to the development of abnormal "switches" in the genetic regulation of cell reproduction. Initial molecular changes occur in the mesothelial cells of the pleura soon after inhalation of asbestos fibres. To begin with, those changes are asymptomatic, and otherwise undetectable, and do not in all cases lead to mesothelioma. In cases like the respondent's, however, where they do lead to mesothelioma, the changes typically lie dormant for years, often for decades, until an unknown "trigger" sets off the development of abnormal genetic switches resulting in malignancy and the "domino effect" that culminates in the malignant mesothelial tumour which constitutes mesothelioma. In this case, the respondent inhaled asbestos fibres in the course of his employment between 1974 and 1977 and it was probable that he did not develop a malignant mesothelial tumour until shortly before first experiencing the symptoms of mesothelioma in 2013 or 2014. Nonetheless, based upon the expert evidence concerning the pathology of the disease, it could be inferred that the asbestos fibres inhaled between 1974 and 1977 had then or shortly afterwards (and therefore before 1 January 1987) resulted in initial molecular changes to mesothelial cells which ultimately culminated in the malignant mesothelial tumour. Initially asymptomatic and otherwise undetectable, the changes are likely to have lain dormant until between one to five years before the first manifestation of symptoms. At that point an unknown trigger set off the development of abnormal genetic switches that resulted in malignancy. As will be seen, the evidence of the precise nature of that trigger is decisive in this case. The expert evidence regarding the trigger and the conclusions to be drawn from the evidence are discussed in detail later in these reasons.The Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act At the relevant times[5], s 52(1) of the Act provided:[5]These proceedings were commenced on 28 August 2014. The Act was subsequently renamed the Return to Work Act (NT): see Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2015 (NT)."Subject to section 189, no action for damages in favour of a worker or a dependant of a worker shall lie against:(a) the employer of the worker;...in respect of:(d) an injury to the worker".Section 189(1) provided: "Where a cause of action in respect of an injury to or death of a person arising out of or in the course of his or her employment arose before the commencement of this section, a claim or action (including a claim or action at common law) in respect of that injury or death may be made, commenced or continued after the commencement of this section as if this Act had never commenced and for that purpose the repealed Act shall be deemed to continue in force."Section 3(1) relevantly defined "injury" as including a disease, and "disease" as including a physical "ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition, whether of sudden or gradual development". "Cause of action" was not defined in the Act, but it plainly refers to the "fact or combination of facts which gives rise to a right to sue"[6].[6]Do Carmo v Ford Excavations Pty Ltd (1984) 154 CLR 234 at 245 per Wilson J; [1984] HCA 17.Damage is the gist of the action

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE AND NETTLE JJ
The law is clear that actual damage or injury is an essential element of a cause of action in negligence for personal injury[7]. (It is not disputed that the respondent established the other elements of his cause of action, namely, the existence and breach of a duty of care, and that the mesothelioma was caused by the appellant's breach of duty.) What may qualify as actionable damage is, however, a question of fact and degree and ultimately of policy[8]. Kiefel J observed in Tabet v Gett that the "damage necessary to found an action in negligence ... is the injury itself and its foreseeable consequences"[9]. As Hayne and Bell JJ said in the same case, damage refers to "some difference to the plaintiff [which] must be detrimental"[10]. In similar vein, in Harriton v Stephens, Crennan J, with whom Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Heydon JJ agreed, said[11]:"Because damage constitutes the gist of an action in negligence, a plaintiff needs to prove actual damage or loss and a court must be able to apprehend and evaluate the damage, that is the loss, deprivation or detriment caused by the alleged breach of duty. Inherent in that principle is the requirement that a plaintiff is left worse off as a result of the negligence complained about, which can be established by the comparison of a plaintiff's damage or loss caused by the negligent conduct, with the plaintiff's circumstances absent the negligent conduct."[7]Williams v Milotin (1957) 97 CLR 465 at 474; [1957] HCA 83; Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514 at 526 per Mason CJ, Dawson, Gaudron and McHugh JJ; [1992] HCA 55; Harriton v Stephens (2006) 226 CLR 52 at 102 [161] per Hayne J, 115 [218] per Crennan J (Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Heydon JJ agreeing at 58 [1]-[4], 113 [208]); [2006] HCA 15.[8]See and compare Stapleton, "The Gist of Negligence – Part I: Minimum Actionable Damage", (1988) 104 Law Quarterly Review 213; Fleming's The Law of Torts, 10th ed (2011) at 225-226.[9](2010) 240 CLR 537 at 585 [135] (emphasis removed); [2010] HCA 12.[10](2010) 240 CLR 537 at 564 [66]. See also Rothwell v Chemical & Insulating Co Ltd [2008] AC 281 at 289 [7] per Lord Hoffmann.[11](2006) 226 CLR 52 at 126 [251].The effect of previous decisions Over the last thirty years, there have been a number of decisions concerning actionable damage in relation to mesothelioma. They provide a degree of guidance as to relevant considerations. It is necessary, however, to keep in mind that, because the question is essentially one of fact, each case turns on its own facts and circumstances and, therefore, what has been decided in the past may not necessarily be of great assistance in deciding new and different cases. In Battaglia v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd[12], Vincent J was required to decide whether "pleural thickening" which occurred relatively shortly after the inhalation of asbestos fibres was sufficient to found a cause of action. Pleural thickening is different from the kind of initial mesothelial cell changes which may occur shortly after inhalation of asbestos fibres. It is not malignant and, so far as is known, is not part of any process which leads to malignancy. At most it is an indicium of the possible presence of otherwise undetectable mesothelial cell changes which may lead to mesothelioma. Vincent J ruled that because there was no evidence that the pleural thickening would or even could lead to malignant mesothelioma, it was not compensable damage[13]. Soon after, in Papadopoulos v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd, Kaye J held that pleural plaques, which can lead to pleural thickening, were not sufficient damage to found a cause of action because, at the time of trial, the pleural plaques had not developed into mesothelioma or resulted in other symptoms[14].[12]Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 12 March 1987.[13]Battaglia unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 12 March 1987 at 17‑18.[14]Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 12 February 1988 at 10‑11.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE AND NETTLE JJ

Full text does not contain this section.