Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   AGRICULTURAL LAND MANAGEMENT LTD -v- JACKSON [No 2] [2014] WASC 102

CORAM:   EDELMAN J

HEARD:   27 NOVEMBER 2013, 2 DECEMBER 2013, 10 DECEMBER 2013, 16 DECEMBER 2013, 30 - 31 JANUARY 2014 & FINAL WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON 19 FEBRUARY 2014

DELIVERED          :   28 MARCH 2014

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1626 of 2008

BETWEEN:   AGRICULTURAL LAND MANAGEMENT LTD

Plaintiff

AND

BRETT LESLIE JACKSON
First Defendant

GRAEME MICHAEL GOFF
Second Defendant

BUNBURY CENTRO PTY LTD
Third Defendant

Catchwords:

Equity - Fiduciary duties - Whether mere existence of conflict is actionable - Whether a breach of conflict rule requires a fiduciary actually to act in a position of conflict and pursue or prefer a personal interest - Judgment pars [263] - [275]

Equity - Fiduciary duties - Whether a clause of a constitution of a trustee company can exclude all fiduciary duties - Consistency with s 601FC Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – Effect on fiduciary duties owed by directors to the company - Judgment pars [276] - [284]

Equity - Equitable compensation - Where fiduciary duties owed by directors to a company – Whether the company can sue its directors for loss if contract entered into at an undervalue by trustee company on behalf of beneficiaries - Misleading to ask whether fiduciary duties are owed to the company 'in its own right' or 'as trustee' - Irrelevance to the award of compensation of whether the trustee will hold any recovery on trust for beneficiaries - Judgment pars [300] - [331]

Equity - Equitable compensation - Difference between substitutive compensation and reparative compensation - When substitutive compensation is available - Judgment pars [333] - [385]

Equity - Equitable compensation - Causation - 'Common sense' test of causation - Scope of liability for consequences - Need to identify precisely the scope of duty owed - Judgment pars [390] - [399]

Corporations - Meaning of 'compensation' and causation requirements in s 1317H of the Corporations Act - Judgment pars [434] - [452]

Corporations - Effect of deregistration of a registered scheme on 'compensation' in s 1317H of the Corporations Act - Judgment pars [453] - [461]

Corporations - Meaning of 'knowingly concerned in' in s 79(c) of the Corporations Act - Requirement of 'practical connection' with at least one element of the contravention - Judgment pars [285] - [298]

Limitation of actions - Application of limitation period by analogy - Limitation period for breach of equitable duty of care and skill by analogy with breach of common law duty of care and skill and by analogy with s 180 of Corporations Act - Judgment pars [206] - [213]

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Limitation Act 1935 (WA)

Result:

Claim dismissed in part; further consequential submissions required

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr M L Bennett

First Defendant             :     Mr J C Vaughan SC

Second Defendant         :     Mr J C Vaughan SC

Third Defendant           :     Mr J C Vaughan SC

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Bennett & Co

First Defendant             :…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Agricultural Land Management Ltd (Agricultural) brought an action against Jackson, among others, in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The case concerns allegations of mismanagement, breaches of fiduciary duties, and improper transactions involving property development and management. The primary dispute revolves around whether certain directors breached their fiduciary duties, whether the company can claim compensation for losses incurred due to those breaches, and the applicability of statutory provisions regarding compensation under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The court addressed several legal issues, including the nature and extent of fiduciary duties owed by directors to a company, whether a constitution of a trustee company can exclude all fiduciary duties, and the availability of equitable compensation for breaches of fiduciary duties. It also examined the meaning and requirements of 'compensation' under the Corporations Act, the impact of deregistration of a registered scheme on compensation claims, and the definition of 'knowingly concerned in' a contravention under the Act. Additionally, the court considered the application of limitation periods to equitable duties by analogy with common law duties.

The court reasoned that while a conflict of interest does not automatically constitute a breach of fiduciary duty, actual action in a position of conflict and the pursuit of personal interests can amount to a breach. It found that a clause in a company's constitution cannot exclude all fiduciary duties, as it must be consistent with statutory provisions. The court determined that a company could sue its directors for losses incurred due to an undervalued contract, irrespective of whether the fiduciary duties are owed 'in its own right' or 'as trustee'. It distinguished between substitutive and reparative compensation, emphasizing that substitutive compensation is available when the company has suffered a loss due to a breach of fiduciary duty. The court applied a 'common sense' test of causation, requiring a precise identification of the scope of the duty owed. It interpreted statutory provisions on compensation and causation under the Corporations Act, concluding that deregistration of a scheme does not necessarily bar a compensation claim. The court also defined 'knowingly concerned in' a contravention, requiring a practical connection with at least one element of the contravention.

The court held that the issues of liability and compensation were not significantly discrete, and thus, the costs order would not be adjusted based on particular issues. It found that the defendants were not demonstrably at fault concerning specific issues, and that the evidence related to both liability and compensation was interdependent. The court ultimately decided that the trial would not have been significantly abbreviated even if the defendants had conceded certain issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence from Mr Catlin and Mr Nuttall Mr Catlin was the only person to give oral evidence. Affidavit evidence was given by Mr Nuttall. Mr Catlin has been a licensed valuer since 1987.[67] Although he no longer practises as a valuer, he has had many years of experience, including having conducted valuations of more than 20 to 30 accommodation hotels.[68] He was called to give evidence by Agricultural, solely for the purpose of tendering his 29 April 2002 valuation.[69] Subsequently, he was cross‑examined and re‑examined in detail in relation to matters relating to that valuation. Mr Catlin's 29 April 2002 valuation,[70] was conducted on the basis of an 'as if complete' development of the Kalgoorlie Property. He was instructed to, and did, value the Kalgoorlie Property on a 'hypothetical development' approach. That approach led to an assessment that if the Kalgoorlie Property were completely developed on 29 April 2002 it would have a value of $19.5 million, net of GST. [70] Exhibit 43. It must be reiterated that the focus of Mr Catlin's valuation was upon determining the 'as if complete' value of the Kalgoorlie Property. In determining the 'as if complete' value of the Kalgoorlie Property, Mr Catlin used two valuation methods:(i)a capitalisation approach which assessed fair occupancy rates and capitalised the net returns;[71] and(ii)direct comparison to recently recorded sales of quality hotels and resorts.[71] Exhibit 43 (Trial bundle page 668). Mr Catlin's 'as if complete' valuation was 58 pages long. In the course of that valuation, Mr Catlin also considered the fair market value of the 'land component' of the Kalgoorlie Property. That land component was assessed as a 'final check to value' for the assessment of the $19.5 million 'as if complete' valuation.[72] It involved a process by which Mr Catlin started with the $19.5 million figure for gross realisation and then deducted an allowance for selling expenses, legal expenses, advertising, profit and risk, loss of interest over the development and selling period, development costs, construction costs, rates and taxes and initial expenses. The end figure was then considered to be a realistic guide to the market value of the Kalgoorlie Property.[73] [72] Exhibit 43 (Trial bundle page 677).[73] Exhibit 43 (Trial bundle page 677). In the crucial paragraphs of his 29 April 2002 valuation, Mr Catlin explained the following matters.(i)Using the hypothetical development approach, and working backwards from the 'as complete' assessment of $19.5 million, he reached a conclusion of $2,250,000 land value for the Kalgoorlie Property.(ii)The $2,250,000 assessment included[74] costs incurred to date [emphasis added] in relation to demolition fees and site costs together with architectural drawings required to obtain approval for the subject development in accordance with the proposed development ...[and including] approvals as obtained and pending ... [and] the costs associated with obtaining such approvals in relation to fees incurred regarding working drawings, engineers' costs and other preliminaries.(iii)The $2,250,000 assessment did not include additional costs which meant that the Kalgoorlie Property could potentially be sold to the Syndicate for a value higher than this assessed value. Those additional costs were matters such as:Interest and finance costs, sales and marketing costs, responsible entity fees and other scheme costs included.(iv)The land value of $2,250,000 reflected a rate of $258 per square metre and $24,457 per hotel room.[74] Exhibit 43 (Trial bundle page 679 - 680).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In any event, in O'Rourke v P & B Corporation Pty Ltd,[432] the Chief Justice said that the Court should only adjust a costs order by reference to particular issues if 'it is clear that [(i)] those issues were significantly discrete, [(ii) they] raised costs that can be separately and specifically determined, and [(iii) they] were issues upon which the unsuccessful party has demonstrably failed'.[433][432] O'Rourke v P & B Corporation Pty Ltd [2008] WASC 36 (S) [13] (Martin CJ). [433] O'Rourke v P & B Corporation Pty Ltd [2008] WASC 36 (S) [13] (Martin CJ). I do not accept the submission by counsel for Agricultural that the issues of liability were significantly discrete from those concerning compensation or the account of profits. One reason for this is that it is, at least, strongly arguable that loss is an element of an action for negligence in equity. A second reason is that the extent of any loss on the sale of the Kalgoorlie Property or Licence is a matter which would be relevant to any inference drawn concerning liability issues such as whether the directors acted in good faith or in the best interests of Agricultural. Nor do I accept that the evidence to which the liability issues and the compensation issues related was independent. The expert evidence concerning the value of the Kalgoorlie Property and Licence was not merely relevant to a quantification of any alleged loss that was suffered. As I have explained, it was also relevant to the question of liability in a number of ways such as whether the directors acted in the best interests of Agricultural, or whether they acted in good faith, or whether they acted for proper purposes. Nor do I accept that these were issues upon which the defendants demonstrably failed. One significant part of Agricultural's case in relation to liability was its claim concerning losses in relation to the Project Management Agreement. Agricultural failed in that part of its case because it was time barred and lacking in a factual basis.[434] Agricultural also failed to prove numerous contraventions and breaches alleged against the defendants. All of the first group of alleged breaches failed.[435] All of the contraventions within the fourth group of alleged breaches failed.[436] All of the contraventions within the fifth group of alleged breaches failed.[437] A number of the breaches in the sixth and seventh group of alleged breaches failed.[434] Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson [No 2] [2014] WASC 102 [191] ‑ [215].[435] Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson [No 2] [2014] WASC 102 [233].[436] Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson [No 2] [2014] WASC 102 [256].[437] Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson [No 2] [2014] WASC 102 [258]. Finally, I do not accept that any of the issues upon which Agricultural succeeded appreciably increased the costs of the trial. The point could be tested by asking whether the trial would have been abbreviated if the defendants had conceded all of the issues on which Agricultural succeeded. My conclusion is that any reduction in trial time would have been almost non‑existent. For instance, as senior counsel for the defendants submitted, the only issue upon which I found for Agricultural that was not conceded by the defendants, or based upon a matter conceded by the defendants, was in relation to breach of fiduciary duty. My finding in relation to breach of fiduciary duty involved no different factual basis from issues raised in relation to the remainder of the trial and the submissions on this point occupied only nine lines of Agricultural's lengthy closing submissions.