Forrest v Australian Securities and Investment Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON AND KIEFEL JJ

Matter No P44/2011

JOHN ANDREW HENRY FORREST  APPELLANT

AND

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No P45/2011

FORTESCUE METALS GROUP LTD   APPELLANT

AND

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Fortescue Metals Group Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

[2012] HCA 39

2 October 2012

P44/2011 & P45/2011

ORDER

In each matter:

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 18 February 2011 as varied on 20 May 2011 and, in their place, order that the appeal by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3.Special leave to cross-appeal granted, treated as instituted and heard instanter, and dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

A J Myers QC with M Thangaraj SC for the appellant in P44/2011 and the second respondent in P45/2011 (instructed by Gadens Lawyers)

D F Jackson QC with B Dharmananda SC for the appellant in P45/2011 and the second respondent in P44/2011 (instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth)

N J Young QC with M K Moshinsky SC, J A Thomson and A D Pound for the first respondent in both matters (instructed by King & Wood Mallesons)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ.   In 2004, Fortescue Metals Group Ltd ("Fortescue") was a public company whose shares were listed on the Australian Stock Exchange Limited ("the ASX").  Mr John Andrew Henry Forrest was chairman and chief executive of Fortescue and a substantial shareholder in the company.

  2. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission ("ASIC") alleged that Fortescue and Mr Forrest contravened the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) when, at various times in 2004 and 2005, Fortescue gave information to the ASX about a proposed mining project in Western Australia called the Pilbara Iron Ore and Infrastructure Project. The project was to consist of a mine in the Pilbara region of Western Australia, a port at Port Hedland and a railway to connect the mine to the port. ASIC alleged that, contrary to s 1041H of the Corporations Act, Fortescue engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to a financial product (shares in Fortescue) by publishing notices in relation to that financial product that were misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive. ASIC further alleged that Fortescue contravened the continuous disclosure requirements of s 674 of the Corporations Act and that, contrary to s 180(1) of the Corporations Act, on each occasion Fortescue contravened the Corporations Act Mr Forrest had not exercised his powers or discharged his duties as a director of Fortescue with the degree of care and diligence required by s 180(1).

  3. The case which ASIC sought to make against both…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forrest v Australian Securities and Investment Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] HCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard appeals concerning allegations of misleading or deceptive conduct and continuous disclosure breaches by Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (Fortescue) and its chairman, Andrew Forrest. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) alleged that public statements made by Fortescue regarding agreements with Chinese state-owned entities to build, transfer, and finance mining infrastructure were misleading or deceptive, and that Fortescue failed to disclose the actual terms of these agreements as required by continuous disclosure rules. ASIC also alleged that Mr Forrest breached his director's duties by allowing Fortescue to engage in such conduct.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether Fortescue's public statements about entering into binding agreements constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under s 1041H of the Corporations Act, and whether Fortescue was obliged to disclose the full terms of these agreements under s 674 of the Corporations Act. The Court also considered whether Mr Forrest breached his director's duties under s 180(1) of the Corporations Act, contingent on Fortescue's contravention of the other provisions. A further procedural issue arose regarding the appropriateness of ASIC's pleading of numerous allegations in the alternative.

The High Court reasoned that the question of whether a statement is misleading or deceptive depends on what an ordinary or reasonable member of the audience would understand it to convey, requiring a careful analysis of the specific facts and evidence. The Court rejected ASIC's submission that a company must always publish the entirety of an agreement to avoid contravening disclosure obligations, finding this impractical and not supported by the legislation. The Court determined that ASIC had not discharged its burden of proof in establishing that Fortescue's statements were misleading or deceptive under s 1041H, nor that Fortescue had breached its continuous disclosure obligations under s 674. Consequently, the claim against Mr Forrest for breach of director's duties also failed.

The High Court allowed the appeals, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The Court ordered that ASIC's appeal to the Full Court be dismissed with costs. Special leave to cross-appeal was granted but subsequently dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

In each matter:

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 18 February 2011 as varied on 20 May 2011 and, in their place, order that the appeal by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3. Special leave to cross-appeal granted, treated as instituted and heard instanter, and dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

At its heart this case is much simpler than it appears to be at first sight. The central question is whether Fortescue[32] contravened s 1041H of the Corporations Act by engaging in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive. [32]It is convenient to adopt the majority judgment's statement of the background to the appeals and to use the abbreviations of statutory and corporate names which it employs. Factual background In 2004, Fortescue had rights to mine iron ore in the Pilbara region of Western Australia. It developed a plan to mine iron ore at its tenements, build a railway to transport the ore to Port Hedland, and build a port facility there. It furthered that plan by entering three agreements, each with a State enterprise owned directly or indirectly by the People's Republic of China. The agreements which Fortescue made with CREC, CHEC and CMCC in late 2004 filled no more than 12 pages. At times ASIC treated them as only scraps of paper. What did the law require Fortescue to tell the market, through the ASX and the media, about its agreements? It could have permitted Fortescue to say nothing. It could have compelled Fortescue to release the agreements. Or it could have compelled Fortescue to release a summary of the agreements. The first possibility was not available. Low though ASIC's esteem was for the agreements, if Fortescue had said nothing about them it would probably have been in breach of the ASX listing rules. To some extent, in its case on s 1041H, ASIC toyed with the idea that it is not possible to say anything about a contract without setting it out in full. It put that case explicitly in respect of s 674 of the Corporations Act, which obliges listed companies to disclose information in accordance with the ASX listing rules. However, the submission in respect of s 1041H must be rejected, even though the Full Court gave it some passing approval[33]. If the law compelled Fortescue to have released the totality of the agreements, it would have compelled other companies making much more bulky agreements to do the same. That would not have assisted the cause of ensuring a speedily informed market. It would often be extremely inconvenient. It could require members of the target audience to procure expert assistance to analyse what particular agreements said. [33]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (2011) 190 FCR 364 at 406 [116]. That left Fortescue with the third course. It took that course. In relation to the CREC agreement, for example, it released to the ASX a short summary, and to the media a longer summary.ASIC's s 1041H case on the CREC agreement and the ASX announcement ASIC's pleaded case, and the way it was presented forensically, was lengthy and complex. But it boiled down to two allegations in respect of each agreement. These allegations can be illustrated by ASIC's case on the CREC agreement, which related to railway infrastructure. One allegation was that Fortescue had falsely represented that it had entered a binding contract of a specified kind with CREC. The other, alternative, allegation was that even if Fortescue had merely stated an opinion to that effect, it had no "genuine and/or reasonable basis" for stating that opinion because it "knew, or ought reasonably to have known, that the parties to the CREC [agreement] had not agreed on all the terms necessary for it to be practicable to force CREC to design, build, transfer and finance the railway".

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ HEYDON J
ASIC's allegations that Mr Forrest breached the duties imposed by s 180(1) of the Corporations Act on directors and officers depended upon it demonstrating that Fortescue had contravened s 1041H or s 674. Having failed to do that, ASIC's claim of contravention of s 180(1) also fails.Conclusion and orders In the Full Court, Keane CJ observed[30] that "the approach adopted by the trial judge artificially limits the protection afforded to the investing public by the Act by giving effect to a distinction [between statements of 'opinion' and 'fact'] which is not drawn by the legislation and not warranted by the facts of the case". These reasons have not endorsed the approach adopted by the trial judge, but, lest it be suggested that the conclusions reached in this case "artificially limit the protection afforded to the investing public", it is important to make the following points.[30](2011) 190 FCR 364 at 406 [116]. First, these reasons do not establish any general proposition to the effect that any public statement that Company A has made a contract with Company B necessarily conveys to its audience a message only about what the contractual document contains. That proposition is too broad. What message is conveyed to the ordinary or reasonable member of the intended audience cannot be determined without a close and careful analysis of the facts. In this, as in so many other areas[31], the facts of and evidence in the particular case are all important.[31]See, for example, Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar (2012) 86 ALJR 522; 286 ALR 501; [2012] HCA 17. Second, any concern about "artificially limiting" the protections conferred by prohibitions upon misleading or deceptive conduct would be driven largely, perhaps even entirely, by a concern with cases of fraud or dishonest attempts to characterise wrongly the effect of what has been said. But if a party says something knowing that what is conveyed by the statement is false, or reckless as to its truth or falsity, that party is guilty of deceit. And for the purposes of a claim of misleading or deceptive conduct, if a person seeks to characterise a public statement as a representation about the content of a document, the critical question will be what the statement conveyed to its intended audience, not what the party concerned says that it was intended to convey. Concerns about dishonesty provide no reason to distort settled understandings about misleading or deceptive conduct. Each appeal should be allowed with costs. In each appeal, ASIC should have special leave to cross‑appeal but that cross‑appeal should be dismissed with costs. In each appeal, the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia should be set aside and in their place there should be orders that ASIC's appeal to that Court is dismissed with costs. At its heart this case is much simpler than it appears to be at first sight. The central question is whether Fortescue[32] contravened s 1041H of the Corporations Act by engaging in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive. [32]It is convenient to adopt the majority judgment's statement of the background to the appeals and to use the abbreviations of statutory and corporate names which it employs. Factual background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ, HEYDON J

ASIC further argued, in support of an application for special leave to cross-appeal, that even if Fortescue had made no public announcements, it was obliged to disclose the terms of the agreements. Nothing in s 674 supported the existence of any such obligation in relation to the facts of the case as postulated by ASIC. On that case, the agreements were no more than unenforceable agreements to agree. If that were true, they would have been of trivial significance – not likely to influence the share price. To grant special leave would require an analysis of expert evidence called by ASIC which the trial judge rejected, which the Full Court did not consider, and which was not the subject of detailed submissions in this Court beyond a single, near-illegible footnote. In those circumstances, the application for special leave to cross-appeal should be refused. Section 180(1) of the Corporations Act ASIC argued that if Fortescue contravened ss 1041H or 674, Mr Forrest was in breach of s 180(1). But since Fortescue had not contravened those provisions, Mr Forrest was not in breach of s 180(1). Notice of contention ASIC filed a notice of contention in support of the argument that the Full Court ought to have found that Fortescue and Mr Forrest had no reasonable basis for believing that their public announcements accurately described the agreements. The Full Court did make that finding, at least in relation to the s 674 case, where ASIC did not bear the burden of proof. However, in relation to s 1041H, ASIC did bear the burden of proof. For reasons given above, ASIC did not discharge it. Orders The appeals should be allowed with costs and consequential orders made. The application for special leave to cross-appeal should be refused with costs.