FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
Chopsonion Pty Ltd v Mulga Corporation Pty Ltd [2024] FedCFamC2G 1450
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Chopsonion Pty Ltd v Mulga Corporation Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FedCFamC2G 1450
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court held that several paragraphs of the Amended SOC were deficient and should be struck out. Paragraph 10 and subparagraph 1.4 were found to be confusing and lacking in precision, making it difficult to ascertain the specific conduct that was alleged to be misleading or deceptive. The Court also ruled that subparagraph 10.3 did not sufficiently allege the elements of accessorial liability under the Australian Consumer Law. Despite these deficiencies, the Court considered the relatively early stage of the proceedings and the absence of any other filings beyond the Statement of Claim and the Amended SOC. Consequently, the Court granted leave to replead the struck-out paragraphs within a specified timeframe, namely by 31 January 2025. The Court also scheduled a future hearing to address the issue of costs.
The Court concluded that the Amended SOC contained significant deficiencies in the pleading of misleading and deceptive conduct and accessorial liability. By striking out paragraphs 10, 11A, and subparagraphs 1.4 and 10.3, the Court aimed to ensure that the pleadings were clear and precise, avoiding confusion and unnecessary speculation. The decision to grant leave to replead was influenced by the early stage of the proceedings and the potential for the deficiencies to be rectified. The Court’s ruling underscored the importance of precision and clarity in legal pleadings, particularly in cases involving complex allegations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
To plead, as CPL has done in subparagraph 1.4, “applicable ethical standards” without identifying those standards or the relevant provisions of those standards is a plainly deficient pleading. CPL appear to recognise the deficiency in the pleading at subparagraph 1.4, their solicitors having written to MFT’s solicitors proffering an amendment in the terms set out at [16] above. For some reason, no amendment has been sought. It follows that subparagraph 1.4 is deficiently pleaded and ought to be struck out.Paragraph 10 - consideration At paragraph 10 of the Amended SOC it is pleaded that the conduct of MFT relied on is that as pleaded in paragraphs 8 and 9 of the Amended SOC. Inconsistently, and confusingly, at sub-subparagraph 10.1.1 of the Amended SOC it is pleaded that the conduct of MFT relied on is that pleaded also in subparagraph 10.3 of the Amended SOC. Paragraph 10.1.1 of the Amended SOC is therefore confusing, as it does not refer to paragraph 9 of the Amended SOC at all but to paragraph 8, and subparagraph 10.3 of the Amended SOC and is therefore embarrassing. There is difficulty in identifying the conduct complained of in paragraph 8 of the Amended SOC. It is a long and complex paragraph which contains pleadings of an alleged breach of trust. The alleged impugnable misleading or deceptive conduct is not identified with any precision in paragraph 8 of the Amended SOC and whether the impugnable conduct took the form of something written, something oral, something gestural, or silence in circumstances where an explanation was necessary, or any combination of these things, is not made apparent. Nor is it apparent whether the alleged conduct occurred on one or more occasions. There is no pleading that any representation was false or that any conduct led to a misleading and deceptive state of affairs, or that if there was such conduct who precisely was misled or deceived by that conduct, or that MFT had any knowledge of any falsity. MFT is therefore required to engage in speculation as to precisely what circumstances give rise to conduct which is said to be misleading or deceptive on the basis of the alleged facts in connection with paragraph 8 of the Amended SOC, and on that basis paragraph 10 of the Amended SOC is embarrassing and ought to be struck out. Paragraph 9 of the Amended SOC does not assist CPL as it pleads a breach of trust and an entitlement to compensation and consequential loss (being the consequential loss outlined in 10.2 of the Amended SOC). In relation to subparagraph 10.3 there is no pleading of any representation of falsity, or knowledge of falsity, on the part of MFT. There are further difficulties with subparagraph 10.3. It purports to allege that MFT was “involved”, within the meaning of that word in s 2(1) of the ACL, in misleading and deceptive conduct, that is, that MFT is liable as an accessory for misleading and deceptive conduct. Section 2(1) of the ACL provides that:involved: a person is involved, in a contravention of a provision of this Schedule or in conduct that constitutes such a contravention, if the person:(a) has aided, abetted, counselled or procured the contravention; or (b)has induced, whether by threats or promises or otherwise, the contravention; or (c)has been in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention; or (d) has conspired with others to effect the contravention.