Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Adler and Anor v Australian Securities and Investments Commission;  Williams v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003]  NSWCA 131

FILE NUMBER(S):
40538/02
40556/02

HEARING DATE(S):               17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 24, 25, 26, 27 March 2003

JUDGMENT DATE: 08/07/2003

PARTIES:
Rodney Stephen Adler and Adler Corporation Pty Ltd - Appellants in matter No 40538/02
Raymond Reginald Williams - Appellant  in matter No 40556/02
Australian Securities and Investments Commission - Respondent in both matters

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Beazley JA Giles JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 2753/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Santow J

COUNSEL:
B W Walker SC, I M Jackman SC - Mr Adler & Adler Corporation Pty Ltd
P D Crutchfield - Mr Williams
R B Macfarlan QC, P Durack, A J Abadee - ASIC

SOLICITORS:
Gilbert + Tobin - Mr Adler & Adler Corporation Pty Ltd
Arnold Bloch Leibler - Mr Williams
Jan Redfern, Australian Securities & Investment Commission - ASIC

CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS ACT - CONTRAVENTIONS OF CIVIL PENALTY PROVISIONS - orders for compensation and pecuniary penalties and disqualification from managing corporations - whether error shown in the trial judge's findings of contraventions - consideration of appellate review of first instance findings - whether findings paid regard to matters outside the plaintiff's pleaded and particularised case - consideration of functions of pleadings and particulars - to ensure procedural fairness -- CONTRAVENTIONS OF S208 OF THE ACT RELATING TO GIVING A FINANCIAL BENEFIT TO A RELATED PARTY - whether payment of money to related party as loan or held on trust - if held on trust whether a bare trust for payer - in any event was giving a financial benefit - financial benefit not on reasonable arms length terms - no error in findings - INVOLVEMENT IN THE CONTRAVENTIONS OF S208 - whether necessary to know financial benefit was given otherwise on reasonable arms length terms - sufficient to know facts whereby financial benefit was given otherwise than on reasonable arms length terms - CONTRAVENTIONS OF S260A OF THE ACT RELATING TO A COMPANY GIVING FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO ACQUIRE ITS SHARES - same payment of money - whether material prejudice to the company - whether opinion evidence of material prejudice properly admitted - no error in holding that opinion wholly or substantially based on witness's experience - even without the opinion evidence, material prejudice whether or not money held on trust - no error in findings - INVOLVEMENT IN THE CONTRAVENTIONS OF S260A - whether plaintiff must prove knowledge of facts constituting material prejudice to the company - not necessary - in any event there was knowledge - CONTRAVENTIONS OF SS180, 181, 182 AND 183 OF THE ACT RELATING TO DIRECTOR'S DUTIES - same payment of money and use of the money in various ways - whether opinion evidence that conduct was contrary to the provisions properly admitted - again no error in holding - no error in trial judge's findings of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWCA 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned alleged contraventions of various provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by Mr Adler and Mr Williams, and the consequential orders for compensation, pecuniary penalties, and disqualification from managing corporations. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) was the respondent. The dispute centred on a payment of money by Adler Corporation to a related party, which ASIC alleged constituted a contravention of sections 208 and 260A of the Act, as well as director's duties under sections 180, 181, 182, and 183.

The court was required to determine whether the trial judge erred in finding that Mr Adler and Mr Williams had contravened the civil penalty provisions of the Act. Specifically, the court considered whether the payment of money to a related party, whether as a loan or held on trust, constituted a financial benefit given otherwise than on reasonable arm's length terms, and whether the company giving financial assistance for the acquisition of its shares suffered material prejudice. The court also examined the extent of knowledge required for involvement in such contraventions and the admissibility and weight of opinion evidence regarding the propriety of the transactions and the existence of material prejudice. Furthermore, the court considered the availability of *Jones v Dunkel* inferences in civil penalty proceedings and the application of rules of prosecutorial fairness. Finally, the court reviewed the trial judge's findings on causation of loss to the company and the calculation of compensation and pecuniary penalties.

The court affirmed the trial judge's findings that Mr Adler and Mr Williams had contravened sections 208 and 260A of the Act, finding no error in the determination that the financial benefit was not on reasonable arm's length terms and that the company suffered material prejudice. The court also upheld the findings of contraventions of sections 180, 181, and 182, but varied the declarations to exclude section 183. The court found that *Jones v Dunkel* inferences were available and that the trial judge had not erred in their application, nor in dismissing submissions regarding prosecutorial fairness. The court also found no error in the trial judge's findings on causation of loss and the calculation of compensation, although it adjusted the specific interest rate for calculating loss. The court affirmed the trial judge's orders for pecuniary penalties and disqualifications, holding that disqualification orders cannot be made distributively and must apply to the management of all corporations.

The appeals were allowed in part, with declarations and orders varied to reflect the exclusion of section 183 and to recalculate compensation based on the court's reasons. The appeals were otherwise dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

IN THE APPEAL BY MR ADLER AND ADLER CORPORATION: (1) Appeal allowed in part; (2) Vary declarations 3 and 4 made on 27 March 2002 by adding before "182(1)" the word "and" and deleting the words and figures "and 183(1)"; (3) Direct that within 21 days the parties calculate the compensation payable to HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd in accordance with the reasons of this Court and advise the Registrar of the sum calculated; (4) Vary order 7 made on 6 June 2002 by deleting the sum of $7,986,402 and substituting the sum advised to the Registrar; (5) Liberty to apply in the event of disagreement as to the calculation; (6) Appeal otherwise dismissed; (7) Appellants pay the respondent's costs. IN THE APPEAL BY MR WILLIAMS: (1) Direct that within 21 days the parties calculate the compensation payable to HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd in accordance with the reasons of this Court and advise the Registrar of the sum calculated; (2) Vary order 7 made on 6 June 2002 by deleting the sum of $7,986,402 and substituting the sum advised to the Registrar; (3) Liberty to apply in the event of disagreement as to the calculation; (4) Appeal dismissed; (5) Appellant pay the respondent's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The submissions were a reprise of the appellants’ Jones v Dunkel submissions. While the trial judge was referring to Mr Adler’s failure to give evidence, it is not clear that it amounted to the drawing of a Jones v Dunkel inference. At this point the trial judge was not concerned with the findings of contraventions, but with the factors material to the orders to be made. However, for the reasons earlier given I do not think that so far as the trial judge paid regard to Mr Adler’s failure to give evidence he was in error, any more when considering the orders to be made than when finding the contraventions. (c) The evidence of Messrs Gardener, Cohen and Stitt It was submitted that the effect of the evidence of Messrs Gardener, Cohen and Stitt was that they saw nothing improper or unlawful in the transactions when they became aware of them in late 2000. It was acknowledged that their views were “not determinative of the appropriate approach which the Court should take”, but it was said that they “indicate the genuine assessment by experienced company directors of unquestioned integrity as to the conduct of a fellow director in which there is no evidence of their own participation”. The submission had been made to the trial judge. He did not advert to it in the orders judgment. That is readily understandable. It is plain from the liability judgment that the trial judge did not consider that the evidence of Messrs Gardener, Cohen and Stitt was to the effect that they saw nothing improper or unlawful in the transactions, and that to the extent that their evidence went in that direction he considered that they were wrong. There is no reason to think that the trial judge overlooked the evidence or the submission made to him.(d) An exception for Adler Corporation? The trial judge noted the submission on behalf of Mr Adler that any disqualification order should be made only in relation to the management of public companies, or that at the least it should permit Mr Adler to be involved in the management of Adler Corporation and its wholly owned subsidiaries -“ … on the basis that the failure to provide such an exception would be harsh, oppressive and unfair against Mr Adler because it would deprive him of the means of earning substantially all his income”. After explaining why that would be contrary to the protective purpose of disqualification orders, the trial judge said -“81 The second matter is one of jurisdiction. Section 206C and s206E both confer upon the Court the power to "disqualify a person from managing corporations". There is no suggestion that an order may discriminate between corporations and thus operate distributively only against a certain class of corporation such as any corporation that is not a public company, or any corporation that is not Adler Corporation and its wholly-owned subsidiaries. Indeed, that logically follows from the public protective purpose earlier identified. 82 Moreover, the power of the Court to grant leave under s206G, in contrast to s206C and s206E, does contain language expressly permitting application for leave to manage "a particular class of corporation", or "a particular corporation". That strongly suggests that the associated disqualification provisions are not to be read as permitting a qualified order.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Williams did not sell any of his shares in HIH.(b) The purchases of shares from Adler Corporation As at June 2000 Adler Corporation held 99,404 shares in dstore, having acquired them in February 2000 at a cost of $500,002.12; 1,000,000 shares in Planet Soccer, having acquired them in March 2000 at a cost of $820,748.52; and 3,627,143 shares in Nomad, having acquired them in August 1999 at a cost of $2,539,000.10. On 10 July 2000 Mr Adler sent a memorandum on a PEE letterhead to Mr Williams and Mr Howard. It read -“As the fund being managed by Pacific Eagle Equities Pty Limited (PEE) is to be a dynamic/non risk adverse fund, it should be noted that apart from subsequent investments made on the formation of the trust, I will place two of my own investments, being dStore [sic] and Planet Soccer into the fund at my original cost. Both would be valued at higher than that level, I am reliably informed. I will furnish further details through the normal reporting mechanisms when the fund reports.” There was no evidence of any response to this memorandum, or of further communications concerning placing dstore and Planet Soccer into the fund. The memorandum of 18 August 2000 to Mr Howard and the two other persons whose entities held A class units in the AEUT was headed “Re: Quarterly Report”, and amongst other things described the AEUT’s “investments”. The description included -“INVESTMENTSAt this time PEE as [sic] the following investments:1.HIH 3,924,545 publicly listed shares at an average price of AUD$1.022.dStore AUD$500,0003. Planet Soccer $US$500,000…DETAILS1. HIH Self-explanatory, publicly listed company.2.dStore* This is an online department store that intends to be listed next year.Has very good backing from LookSmart and various other known venture capitalists.3.Planet Soccer* This is an e-commerce site that provides soccer content to the sport’s one-billion –plus international fans. The site is positioned to capitalise on the resulting e-commerce and other revenue opportunities that arise out of this sport.Hope to list this year.…* Please note these two interests were purchased from Adler Corporation as per my original letter at the inception of the fund.” The “original letter at the inception of the fund” was presumably the memorandum of 10 July 2000. In fact neither dstore nor Planet Soccer had been placed into the fund as at 18 August 2000. On 25 August 2000 Mr Adler caused PEE, as trustee of the AEUT, to acquire Adler Corporation’s shares in dstore for $500,212. On the same date he caused PEE, as trustee of the AEUT, to acquire Adler Corporation’s shares in Planet Soccer for $820,748.52. In Mr Adler’s fax of 25 September 2000 to Mr Williams concerning reorganisation of the trust investment he stated, “4. The Trust will purchase from Adler Corporation its interest in Nomad Technologies”. The company so referred to was Nomad. So far as the evidence showed this was the first mention of Nomad, and there was no evidence of any response to the bald statement that the purchase would take place.