Fair Work Ombudsman v DTF World Square Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v DTF World Square Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3)
[2023] FCA 201

File number: NSD 669 of 2020
Judgment of: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 15 March 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – allegations of multiple contraventions by two related companies of numerous civil penalty provisions of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) spanning a period of time before and after amendments introduced by Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth) – where uncontradicted evidence given of the making and keeping of false and misleading records, whether the two companies contravened s 535(4) of FW Act and/or reg 3.44 of Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) by knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records – whether companies contravened s 535(1) of FW Act by failing to make and keep records containing prescribed information – whether companies contravened s 536(2) of FW Act by failing to give full-time employees pay slips containing the actual gross and net amounts paid to them and casual employees pay slips containing the actual gross and net amounts paid to them, the actual hourly rates of pay and the actual number of hours worked in the pay periods – whether companies contravened s 536(3) of FW Act by providing pay slips which they knew to be false or misleading – whether companies contravened s 45 of FW Act by failing to pay minimum entitlements under applicable modern award – whether companies requested or required certain employees to work unreasonable additional hours in contravention of ss 62(1) and 44 of FW Act – whether companies knowingly contravened the various statutory provisions – whether conduct constituting contraventions was part of a systematic pattern of conduct – whether general manager and HR coordinator involved in contraventions
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 13, 14, 45, 62, 535, 536, 549, 550, 551, 557A, 557C, 712, 793

Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth)

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) regs 3.31, 3.33, 3.34, 3.44, 3.45, 3.46

Heydon JD, Cross on Evidence (13th ed., LexisNexis, 2021)

Heydon JD, Cases and Materials on Evidence (Butterworths, 1975)

Macquarie Dictionary (7th ed, Macquarie Dictionary Publishers, 2017)

Oxford English Dictionary, Oxford University Press, June 2022, online

Cases cited:

Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131; 21 ACLC 1810; 46 ACSR 504; 179 FLR 1

Amcor Packaging (Aust) Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union of Australia [2006] FCA 1265; 157 IR 32

Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union v Dick Stone Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 512; 314 IR 441

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Hall [2017] FCA 274; 269 IR 1

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Parker [2017] FCA 564; 266 IR 340;

Australian Communications and Media Authority v Mobilegate Ltd a company incorporated in Hong Kong (No 8) [2010] FCA 1197; (2010) 275 ALR 293

Australian Competition and Consumer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v DTF World Square Pty Ltd (in liq) (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Fair Work Ombudsman brought proceedings against DTF World Square Pty Ltd (in liquidation) and Selden Pty Ltd, two related companies operating under the "Din Tai Fung" brand, for alleged multiple contraventions of civil penalty provisions under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The proceedings spanned a period before and after the introduction of amendments by the Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth). The primary focus was on whether the companies knowingly made and kept false or misleading records, failed to make and keep records containing prescribed information, provided incorrect pay slips, failed to pay minimum entitlements, and required employees to work unreasonable hours. The court considered whether these actions were part of a systematic pattern and whether certain employees were involved in the contraventions.

The court identified several legal issues, including whether the companies contravened specific sections of the Fair Work Act by knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records, failing to maintain accurate records, and providing incorrect pay slips. It also considered whether the companies failed to pay minimum entitlements under the applicable modern award and required employees to work unreasonable hours. The court had to determine whether the conduct was part of a systematic pattern and whether specific employees were knowingly involved in the contraventions. The burden of proof was on the Fair Work Ombudsman to establish the contraventions to the requisite standard.

The court found that the Fair Work Ombudsman had successfully proven all the allegations against the companies. The evidence demonstrated that the companies knowingly made and kept false or misleading records, provided incorrect pay slips, failed to pay minimum entitlements, and required employees to work unreasonable hours. The court accepted that Ms Parmenas, the HR coordinator, knew about these issues and participated in the contraventions. The general manager, Ms Handoko, was also found to be knowingly involved. The court drew adverse inferences from the absence of evidence from the companies and their key employees, which supported the Fair Work Ombudsman's case.

The court ordered that within 14 days, the parties should agree on orders giving effect to these reasons and the matter should be listed for further case management. The court encouraged the parties to resolve as many remaining issues as possible to keep costs to a minimum. The final orders included setting a date for case management and providing liberty to apply on two days' notice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days, the parties agree upon orders giving effect to these reasons.

2. The matter be listed for case management of the remaining questions at 9:30am on 6 April 2023.

3. There be liberty to apply on two (2) days’ notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

[1]

THE EVIDENCE

[8]

ABSENT WITNESSES

[16]

SOME UNCONTROVERSIAL FACTS

[21]

The respondents

[22]

The Employees

[29]

The relevant award

[54]

THE PAYROLL SYSTEM

[55]

Fingerprint timesheets

[61]

Staff Received Payment Forms (SRP forms)

[63]

The ADP and MYOB Payroll Systems

[64]

ADP and MYOB e-timesheets

[66]

ADP payroll journals and MYOB pay run summaries

[67]

Pay slips

[68]

Payroll reports

[78]

Payments to employees

[80]

THE EMPLOYERS’ RECORDS

[86]

THE BURDEN AND STANDARD OF PROOF

[89]

THRESHOLD ISSUES

[97]

Is the conduct and state of mind of each of Mr Harjanto, Ms Handoko, Ms Parmenas, Mr Tandra and any other payroll officers attributable to DTF (WS) and Selden?

[98]

Did the Employees in question perform work at the restaurant and, if so, did they perform the roles and duties pleaded?

[101]

Did the Employees fall within the pleaded classifications in the Restaurant Award?

[101]

Did the Employers calculate the amounts payable to the Employees, and pay the Employees, on the basis pleaded at FASOC [16]-[19]?

[104]

Do the fingerprint timesheets accurately record the matters they purport to record?

[109]

RECORD KEEPING AND PAY SLIP CONTRAVENTIONS

[111]

The legislative requirements

[111]

Contraventions of s 535(4) of the FW Act and reg 3.44(1) – False or Misleading Records Contraventions

[121]

Pay slips

[121]

ADP records

[123]

MYOB records

[124]

The Ombudsman’s allegations

[125]

Consideration

[129]

Contraventions of s 535(1) of the FW Act

[135]

Contraventions of s 536(2) of the FW Act

[144]

Contraventions of s 536(3) of the FW Act

[148]

Conclusion

[152]

AWARD CONTRAVENTIONS

[154]

The legislative requirements

[154]

Minimum rates

[157]

Casual loading

[160]

Saturday, Sunday and public holiday penalty rates

[161]

Evening penalty rates

[163]

Overtime rates

[164]

Split shift allowances

[168]

The allegations

[169]

Consideration

[170]

Mr Liu

[177]

The other Employees

[185]

Conclusion

[207]

CONTRAVENTIONS OF THE NATIONAL EMPLOYMENT STANDARDS

[208]

The legislative requirements

[208]

The allegations

[211]

Consideration

[213]

Conclusion

[220]

SERIOUS CONTRAVENTIONS

[221]

The legislative provisions

[221]

The allegations

[226]

Consideration

[227]

Conclusion

[247]

ACCESSORIAL LIABILITY

[248]

The legislative provisions

[248]

The relevant principles

[250]

The allegations

[268]

Consideration

[273]

Ms Parmenas

[277]

The contraventions of reg 3.44(1) and s 535(4) (knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records)

[278]

The contraventions of s 536(2) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees which did not include all the prescribed information)

[283]

The contraventions of s 536(3) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees that the Employers knew were false or misleading)

[283]

The contraventions of s 535(1) (failing to keep records prescribed by the regulations)

[285]

The contraventions of s 45 of the FW Act (award contraventions)

[287]

The contraventions of s 44 (requiring or requesting certain employees to work in excess of 38 hours per week)

[301]

Ms Handoko

[308]

The contraventions of reg 3.44(1) of the FW Regulations and s 535(4) of the FW Act (knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records)

[308]

The contraventions of s 536(2) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees which did not include all the prescribed information)

[314]

The contraventions of s 536(3) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees that the Employers knew were false or misleading)

[314]

The contraventions of s 45 of the FW Act (award contraventions)

[317]

CONCLUSIONS

[332]

DISPOSITION

[333]

ANNEXURE A

[p 83]

GLOSSARY OF SELECT TERMS

[p 87]

Background

Background to the litigation

Having regard to the positions Ms Handoko and Ms Parmenas held in the companies and the fact that they were parties to the proceeding, the absence of evidence from them is particularly significant. As Street J observed in Dilosa v Latec Finance Pty Ltd (1966) 84 WN (Pt 1) (NSW) 557 at 582, in a passage cited by Santow J in ASIC v Adler at [448]:The inference which a Court can properly draw in the absence of a witness, where such absence is not satisfactorily accounted for, is that nothing which this witness could say would assist the case of the party who would normally have been expected to have called that witness. The significance of this inference differs according to the closeness of the relationship of the absent witness with the party against whom the inference is sought to be propounded. Where the absent witness is a party himself then considerable importance may well attach to the inference. Similarly, the inference is significant if the absent witness is, as in the present case, a person who … was personally engaged in the transactions in question and who was in fact present at Court during part of the hearing …SOME UNCONTROVERSIAL FACTS Much of the Ombudsman’s evidence was uncontroversial. It is convenient at this point to set out some of those uncontroversial facts.The respondents The following matters were either agreed or not disputed. At all material times both DTF (WS) and Selden were “constitutional corporations” within the meaning of s 12 of the FW Act and “national system employers” within the meaning of s 14 of the Act. They were among a number of “related entities” within the meaning of s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), operating restaurants in Australia under the “Din Tai Fung” brand. At all material times DTF (WS) employed people to work at three restaurants, specialising in Taiwanese food. The restaurants were located at Shop 1104 World Square Shopping Centre, 664 George Street, Sydney (World Square Restaurant); the Emporium Shopping Centre, Level 4, 287 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne (Emporium Restaurant); and at Westfield Shopping Centre, Level 3, 1 Anderson Street, Chatswood NSW (Chatswood Restaurant). Each of the three restaurants provided sit-down services with meals primarily intended for consumption within the restaurants’ premises. At all such times DTF (WS) also employed people in an office at 15 Shirlow Street, Marrickville where administrative, human resources and payroll management functions were performed on behalf of the DTF Group (DTF Head Office). Mr Harjanto was a director of DTF (WS) and Selden throughout the relevant periods. All the evidence indicates that he was at the apex of the management of the restaurants. Ms Handoko was the General Manager of the DTF Group and DTF (WS) at this time. Ms Parmenas worked for the DTF Group as HR Coordinator or HR Manager. She informed FWIs Colalancia and Paul, and I accept, that she started in February 2015. The Employees The following matters were agreed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Lin and Mr Liu are former employees of DTF (WS). Mr Tandra was employed by DTF (WS) as a payroll officer from 11 July 2016 until about March 2018. His main responsibility was to process the fortnightly payroll for each of the companies in the DTF Group. I gave Mr Tandra a certificate under s 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act), which prevents the evidence the subject of the certificate from being used against him in any proceeding in an Australian court, save for a criminal proceeding related to the giving of false evidence. As the Ombudsman submitted, the cross-examination did not challenge the veracity of their evidence (or, for that matter, its reliability). Indeed, in some respects the cross-examination confirmed and advanced their evidence. Before DTF (WS) and Selden went into liquidation, the parties agreed on some facts and a statement of agreed facts was admitted into evidence. The respondents adduced no evidence. Two affidavits filed by the respondents in May 2022 were not read.ABSENT WITNESSES Any respondent is entitled to remain silent. That said, however, in a civil case, the unexplained failure of a party to give evidence or call witnesses may lead to an inference that the missing evidence or absent witness would not have assisted that party’s case: Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 at 308 (Kitto J); 312 (Menzies J); and 321 (Windeyer J). The Court may take that circumstance into account in deciding whether to accept particular evidence that relates to a matter on which the absent witness could have spoken: JD Heydon, Cross on Evidence (13th ed., LexisNexis, 2021) at [1215]. Moreover, in a civil case evidence the witness might have contradicted can be accepted more readily if the respondent fails to give evidence: Jones v Dunkel at 312 (Menzies J); and 321 (Windeyer J); RPS v The Queen (2000) 199 CLR 620 at [26] (Gaudron A-CJ, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ). And any inference favourable to the other party for which there is a foundation in the evidence can more comfortably be drawn: Jones v Dunkel at 308 (Kitto J); and 312 (Menzies J). It does not matter that the party who could have called the evidence does not bear the burden of proof. As Rich J put it in Insurance Commissioner v Joyce (1948) 77 CLR 39 at 49, “when circumstances are proved indicating a conclusion and the only party who can give direct evidence of the matter prefers the well of the court to the witness box a court is entitled to be bold”. A Jones v Dunkel inference cannot fill gaps in the evidence and cannot convert conjecture or suspicion into inference: Jones v Dunkel at 313 (Menzies J). But, if the inference is drawn, it can “weigh the scales, however slightly, in favour of the opposing party”: Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131; 21 ACLC 1810; 46 ACSR 504; 179 FLR 1 at [649] (Giles JA, with whom Mason P and Beazley JA agreed at [1] and [2] respectively). Moreover, as Heydon observed in Cases and Materials on Evidence (Butterworths, 1975) at 62:[A] party’s failure to give any satisfactory explanation of a prima facie case against him may suggest that the case is sound, either because silence is assent — an implied admission, or because it shows a consciousness of guilt or liability, or because inferences from the prima facie case, being unchallenged, are thereby strengthened. The presumption is the stronger where the facts are particularly within his knowledge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For all these reasons I am satisfied that Ms Handoko was knowingly concerned in all the contraventions of s 45 relating to the various breaches of the Restaurant Award.CONCLUSIONS I am satisfied, taking due account of what was said in Neat Holdings, that the Ombudsman has established her case to the requisite standard in all respects.DISPOSITION Within 14 days, the parties should bring in short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons. The matter will then be listed for further case management in relation to the preparation and timing of the hearing of the residual issues. The parties should confer in the meantime with a view to reaching an agreement on a timetable. I encourage the parties to endeavour to resolve as many, if not all, of the remaining issues in order to keep costs to a minimum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Consequently, she pleaded (at FASOC [57]–[59]) that:(1)DTF (WS) contravened s 535(4) and reg 3.44(1) of the FW Act by knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records of:(a)the rate of remuneration paid to the DTF (WS) Employees;(b)the gross and net amounts paid to the DTF (WS) Employees;(c)the hours worked by the Casual DTF (WS) employees; and(d)the loadings and penalty rates paid to the Casual DTF (WS) employees.(2)Selden contravened s 535(4) of the Act by knowingly making and keeping false or misleading records for the Selden Employees of:(e)the rate of remuneration paid to the Selden Employees;(f)the gross and net amounts paid to the Selden Employees;(g)the hours worked by the Selden Employees; and(h)the loadings and penalty rates paid to the Selden Employees.Consideration I am satisfied that each of these allegations has been proved. The Employees were not paid the rates of remuneration, the gross and net amounts or the loadings and penalty rates recorded in the inaccurate records. Mr Tandra’s evidence in this respect was clear, unequivocal, unchallenged and undisputed. Mr Liu and Ms Lin confirmed critical aspects of it and their evidence was not disputed either. Further, it was an agreed fact that the SRP forms are accurate records. It necessarily follows that, to the extent that the information they contain differs from the information in the inaccurate records, these records are false and misleading. They represent that the Employees were paid amounts that they were not paid. On the occasions that Ms Parmenas prepared the payroll and/or gave instructions to Mr Tandra and, throughout the period when she was supervising Mr Tandra, the only reasonable inference to be drawn from the evidence is that she condoned and participated in the creation of false and misleading records. She would have known that the pay slips did not correspond to the amounts recorded in the SRP forms and that the amounts recorded in the ADP and MYOB records differed from those in the SRP forms. Since she agreed that the SRP forms are accurate, I find that she knew that the pay slips, ADP and MYOB records were false or misleading.The contraventions of s 536(2) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees which did not include all the prescribed information)The contraventions of s 536(3) of the FW Act (giving pay slips to the Employees that the Employers knew were false or misleading) The essential element of these contraventions is the provision during the relevant periods of pay slips:(1)to the Casual Employees which did not record the actual gross and net amounts they were paid, the actual hourly pay rates or the actual number of hours they worked in each fortnightly pay period; (2)to the Full-time Employees which did not record the actual gross and net amounts they were paid; and (3)to all the relevant Employees (except for Ms Eliyani and Mr Low) that were false or misleading Largely for the reasons given above, I am satisfied that Ms Parmenas knew of these matters and knowingly participated in, and facilitated, these contraventions. I would only add that, in the case of the provision of the pay slips to the Casual Employees, having regard to what she told Mr Tandra, she would have known that the hours on the pay slips reflected the Payroll System Hours rather than their actual hours. That is because Mr Tandra’s unchallenged evidence was that he entered into the payroll system the Payroll System Hours rather than the number of hours employees actually worked. Further Ms Parmenas knew that employees were paid using a combination of EFT and cash, a practice which she would undoubtedly have known was not disclosed in the pay slips.The contraventions of s 535(1) (failing to keep records prescribed by the regulations)