Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Daly (Liability Hearing)

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Daly (Liability Hearing) [2023] FCA 290

File number: QUD 269 of 2020
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 3 April 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 4 April 2023
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS — civil penalty proceedings — liability phase — duties of officers of responsible entity of a registered managed investment scheme — whether first respondent is an “officer” of the responsible entity for the purposes of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) — whether officers of responsible entity breached duties owed pursuant to s 601FD(1) of the Act — Held: contravention established.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — pleadings — where proceedings based on an originating process, amended concise statement and amended statement of claim — where first respondent alleges claims against him not sufficiently pleaded — whether procedural unfairness occasioned — Held: ASIC’s claim against first respondent adequately disclosed, no procedural unfairness occasioned.

EVIDENCE — where none of the respondents gave evidence — application of rule in Jones v Dunkel in civil penalty proceedings — Held: appropriate to draw Jones v Dunkel inferences in respect of issues on which respondents did not give evidence.

EVIDENCE — where Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) did not call a witness who could have given relevant evidence —  whether evidence from other sources should be discounted by reason of ASIC not calling the witness — Held: no procedural unfairness. No basis to discount other evidence.

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 601FD(1), 601FD(3),

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140(2)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.02(1)

Cases cited:

Adams v Director of Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2017]; FCAFC 228; 258 FCR 257

Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131; 179 FLR 1

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Delor Vue Apartments CTS 39788 [2021] FCAFC 121; 287 FCR 388

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Hall [2018] FCAFC 83; 261 FCR 347

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2019] FCA 1284

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Investors Forum Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWSC 267; 53 ACSR 305

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq) (Controllers apptd) (No 3) [2013] FCA 1342

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Avestra Asset Management [2017] FCA 497; 348 ALR 525

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Getswift [2021] FCA 1384

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Healey [2011] FCA 717; 196 FCR 291

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar [2012] HCA 17; 247 CLR 345

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v King [2020] HCA 4; 270 CLR 1

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Lewski [2018] HCA 63; 266 CLR 173

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Linchpin Capital Group Ltd [2018] FCA 1104

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Linchpin Capital Group Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 398

Australian Securities and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Daly (Lia... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 290
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Daly involved a dispute between the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the respondents, including Mr Daly, concerning alleged breaches of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by the respondents in relation to their roles as officers of a responsible entity of a registered managed investment scheme. The central issues before the court were whether Mr Daly was an "officer" of the responsible entity for the purposes of the Corporations Act, and whether the officers of the responsible entity breached their duties as outlined in s 601FD(1) of the Act. Additionally, the court had to determine if ASIC's claims against Mr Daly were adequately pleaded and if there was any procedural unfairness occasioned by the respondents not giving evidence.

The court found that ASIC's claims against Mr Daly were adequately disclosed in the pleadings, and there was no procedural unfairness occasioned by the respondents' failure to give evidence. The court applied the rule in Jones v Dunkel, allowing it to draw adverse inferences against the respondents who did not give evidence. Furthermore, the court held that the failure of ASIC to call a particular witness did not warrant discounting the other evidence presented. In terms of the substantive issues, the court found that Mr Daly was indeed an officer of the responsible entity, and that there were breaches of the statutory duties owed by the officers of the responsible entity.

The court concluded that ASIC had established, on the balance of probabilities, that the respondents contravened various sections of the Corporations Act. Specifically, the court found that Mr Daly was an officer of Endeavour from at least 1 April 2015 to 7 August 2018 and that the respondents had contravened sections 601FD(1)(b), (c), (e), (f), and 601FD(3) of the Act. The court reserved costs and directed the parties to confer and propose short minutes setting out timetabling orders for the preparation of the hearing concerning relief.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 17 April 2023, the parties are to confer and propose short minutes setting out timetabling orders for the preparation of the hearing concerning relief and provide a copy to the Associate to Cheeseman J.

2. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will address the particular inferences which I consider it appropriate to draw against each of the respondents in considering the substantive issues to which they relate.FACTS On the basis of the body of evidence outlined above, and applying the approach to fact-finding outlined above, I make the following findings of fact. OverviewThe relevant period As noted above, the relevant period is from 1 April 2015 to 7 August 2018. The significance of 1 April 2015 is that it is the date of a circular resolution of a committee that ASIC contends set the overarching investment strategy of the Registered Scheme. The committee was variously referred to as the “Credit Committee”, the “Lending Committee” and / or the “Investment Committee”. For reasons which I will develop, I find that these names were used interchangeably and there was in fact only one committee, which was referred to variously by each or a combination of these names. Mr Daly conceded that the terms “Credit Committee”, “Investment Committee” and “Lending Committee” each referred to the same committee notwithstanding the use of different names. I will refer to this committee as the Investment Committee. In doing so, I note that nothing turns on the name by which the committee was known. The central contest for the purpose of Mr Daly’s defence is whether, from about 1 April 2015, the committee operated with respect to the Registered Scheme as well as the Unregistered Scheme. The end of the relevant period is marked by the appointment of the Receivers.The pre-Endeavour period The structure and operations of the Linchpin Group prior to 1 April 2015 provides necessary context to what occurred during the relevant period. It is useful to begin by examining the period before the acquisition by Linchpin of Endeavour in about December 2014, before moving to the relevant period. A feature of the pre-Endeavour period is the operation of the Unregistered Scheme within the Linchpin Group. On about 22 January 2014, Linchpin issued an Information Memorandum (IM), offering units in the Unregistered Scheme to investors. Excluding the amount received from the Registered Scheme, the total amount invested in the Unregistered Scheme was about $5.4 million, which was received from 46 investors between January 2014 and June 2015. There were three redemptions from the Unregistered Scheme resulting in net investor funds of about $5.2 million. During this period, Linchpin as trustee of the Unregistered Scheme commenced making loans using the pooled funds administered in the Unregistered Scheme.The post-Endeavour period The second period follows the acquisition of Endeavour by Linchpin in around December 2014. Prior to Endeavour being acquired by Linchpin, Endeavour was already the responsible entity for the Registered Scheme, then known by another name. The Registered Scheme was inactive at the time of the acquisition by Linchpin. The evidence in relation to the Registered Scheme in the pre-Linchpin period is sparse. It was named the “Endeavour Hi-Yield Fund”. The Registered Scheme is referred to as having had “a limited operating history” in all the PDS issued after Linchpin acquired Endeavour. The “Minutes of a Compliance Committee Meeting” of 15 April 2015 record that the directors of Endeavour had resolved to “activate” the Registered Scheme, using the same name as that used for the Unregistered Scheme. The Endeavour Compliance Committee is addressed in detail below.Funds raised in the Registered Scheme

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 601FD(3) provides that a contravention of s 601FD(1) is also a contravention of s 601FD(3), which is a civil penalty provision: s 1317E.SOURCES OF EVIDENCE The evidence tendered at the liability hearing was voluminous, comprising approximately 15 volumes of documentary material. Broadly, it was drawn from the following sources. ASIC’s affidavit evidence was comprised of:(a)Three affidavits of Ms Anne Elizabeth Gubbins, solicitor at ASIC, dated 30 April 2021, 29 November 2021, and 11 February 2022;(b)Two affidavits of Mr Tracy in his capacity as Receiver and liquidator, described above, dated 30 April 2021 and 22 February 2022; and(c)Two affidavits of Ms Tegan Harris, director, formerly senior associate, at Gadens Lawyers, solicitors for ASIC, dated 30 April 2021 and 29 November 2021. In January 2018, ASIC commenced a formal investigation into suspected contraventions of the Act by Linchpin, Endeavour, other entities related to Linchpin, and the officers, employees, agents and associated entities of those companies. Ms Gubbins deposes to and puts into evidence the results of various searches conducted by ASIC in the course of its investigation and the responses received by ASIC to compulsory notices issued by it under the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act). In her third affidavit, Ms Gubbins clarifies, inter alia, certain matters in respect of the responses ASIC received to compulsory notices issued by it. Ms Gubbins was briefly cross-examined by Mr Daly’s counsel at the liability hearing. Mr Tracy’s first affidavit, inter alia, annexes a joint report prepared by him and Mr Orr, in their capacities as the Receivers, for the purpose of the receivership and winding up proceedings, (Receivers’ Report). In that report, Mr Tracy and Mr Orr identify the way in which funds invested in both the Registered and Unregistered Schemes were applied. Mr Tracy described the key foundation of the Receivers’ Report as being a full reconciliation of the bank accounts of both the schemes. In order to fulfil the scope of the report as dictated by the orders of the Court, Mr Tracy considered it necessary to look at the source of all funds within each of the schemes and the use to which those funds had been put. In his second affidavit, Mr Tracy provides some further explanation of the process he undertook in reaching certain conclusions in the Receivers’ Report and exhibits additional key documents relied upon by him in preparing that report. Mr Tracy was briefly cross-examined by Mr Daly’s counsel at the liability hearing. Ms Harris’ evidence went to the processes undertaken by ASIC’s solicitors to identify and distil documents relevant to the proceeding, including by conducting and supervising key word searches across the documents obtained by ASIC under various compulsory notices. ASIC relies on her evidence in support of an inference that certain things which ASIC contends should have been done were not done because no documents were produced in answer to notices directed to those things. Ms Harris was not cross-examined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Daly was legally represented at the hearing. He was the only respondent who took an active part in the liability hearing. In his defence, Mr Daly denied that he was an officer of Endeavour. He also sought to defend the allegations against him on the basis of his contention that ASIC’s claim against him was inadequately pleaded and that ASIC had not established a causative link between his conduct and the relevant contraventions of the Act. At the conclusion of ASIC’s case, Mr Daly elected to exercise his privilege against exposure to a penalty. Accordingly, he did not go into evidence.CONCLUSION IN SUMMARY FORM Conscious of the consequences that follow in the context of these civil penalty proceedings, I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that ASIC has established that the respondents contravened ss 601FD(1)(b), (c), (e), (f) and 601FD(3) of the Act, in the manner set out within. In finding against Mr Daly, and again, conscious of the consequence of doing so in the present context, I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that ASIC has established that Mr Daly was an officer of Endeavour from at least 1 April 2015 to 7 August 2018. I will hear from the parties on the relief that should follow as a consequence of my findings on liability. LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Before moving to the facts, it is useful to first address the legislative framework for the regulation of managed investment schemes. Section 9 of the Act defines “managed investment scheme” as follows:(a) a scheme that has the following features:(i)people contribute money or money’s worth as consideration to acquire rights (interests) to benefits produced by the scheme (whether the rights are actual, prospective or contingent and whether they are enforceable or not);(ii)any of the contributions are to be pooled, or used in a common enterprise, to produce financial benefits, or benefits consisting of rights or interests in property, for the people (the members) who hold interests in the scheme (whether as contributors to the scheme or as people who have acquired interests from holders);(iii)the members do not have day-to-day control over the operation of the scheme (whether or not they have the right to be consulted or to give directions)… Chapter 5C of the Act contains provisions relating to the registration and operation of managed investment schemes. To register a managed investment scheme, a person must lodge an application with ASIC together with, relevantly, a copy of the scheme’s constitution and compliance plan: s 601EA. ASIC must register the scheme within 14 days of lodgement of the application, unless it appears to ASIC, inter alia, that the constitution and compliance plan do not meet the requirements specified in the Act: s 601EB. The requirements for a scheme’s constitution are set out in Part 5C.3 of the Act. Section 601GA(1) provides that the constitution of a registered scheme must make adequate provision for, inter alia, the powers of the responsible entity in relation to making investments of, or otherwise dealing with, the scheme property. The constitution of a registered scheme must be contained in a document that is legally enforceable as between the members and the responsible entity: s 601GB.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I now turn to consider the evidence in greater detail. Structure and operation of Linchpin Group pre-Endeavour acquisition Relevantly, the Linchpin Group provided a range of financial products, as well as funds management, investment advisory and consulting services. As at August 2018, it had 413 authorised representatives under s 761A of the Act, and four of its group entities held an AFSL. Linchpin itself was a corporate authorised representative under an AFSL. The Linchpin Group relevantly included the following companies: (1)Endeavour; (2)Investport Pty Ltd (IPL);(3)Beacon Financial Group Pty Ltd (Beacon); (4)ISARF Pty Ltd (ISARF); (5)CPG Research & Advisory Group Pty Ltd (CPG);(6)RIAA; and(7)Financiallink. Linchpin was either the direct or ultimate holding company of these entities. The respondents, in varying combinations, acted as the directors of these entities during the relevant period. Each of the respondents was a director of Linchpin. As mentioned, Mr Nielsen, Mr Raftery and Mr Williams were directors of Endeavour. Mr Nielsen and Mr Williams acted as joint chief executive officers and managing directors of both Linchpin and Endeavour. Mr Daly, Mr Nielsen and Mr Williams were each directors of IPL and Beacon and, from 3 June 2015, RIAA. Mr Nielsen and Mr Williams were directors of CPG and Mr Daly and Mr Nielsen were directors of Financiallink: see Schedule A. As noted, with the exception of Mr Daly, the respondents were each directors of Linchpin and Endeavour, appointed as follows and continuing for the whole of the relevant period: (1)Paul Nielsen: Linchpin – 28 May 2013;Endeavour – 8 December 2014;(2)Paul Raftery: Linchpin – 28 May 2013;Endeavour – 8 December 2014;(3)Ian Williams: Linchpin – 28 May 2013;Endeavour – 8 December 2014. Mr Daly became a director of Linchpin on 2 October 2013 and continued as a director for the whole of the relevant period. As mentioned above, a central issue in dispute between ASIC and Mr Daly is whether, notwithstanding that Mr Daly was not formally appointed as one of the directors of Endeavour, his role was such that he fell within the statutory definition of an officer during the relevant period. The Unregistered Scheme in the period before the Endeavour acquisition On about 22 January 2014, by a trust deed poll entitled the Investport Income Opportunity Fund Constitution, Linchpin established the Unregistered Scheme. Linchpin was described as the “Responsible Entity” and acted as the first trustee. IPL was appointed as the manager of the Unregistered Scheme pursuant to the provisions of a management agreement dated 22 January 2014. The Information Memorandum On about 23 January 2014, Linchpin issued the IM, offering units in the Unregistered Scheme to investors. The IM relevantly provided that:(1)Linchpin was the responsible entity of the Unregistered Scheme and IPL was the fund’s manager;(2)up to 20 initial investors were invited to invest in the Unregistered Scheme (3)there were three investment options: a one year option with a return rate of 8.25% per annum; a two year option with a return rate of 8.5% per annum; or a three year option with a return rate of 8.75% per annum; (4)the minimum total subscription was $5 million with a maximum target of $10 million. Over subscriptions could be accepted if IPL received additional lending submissions that were in accordance with the fund’s mandate;(5)Linchpin would deposit and deal with the investors’ funds pursuant to “this offer”; (6)distributions would be paid quarterly;(7)each unit in the Unregistered Scheme would be initially issued by Linchpin for an application price of $1.00;(8)the offer of units was expressed to be made pursuant to s 911A(2)(b) of the Act; and(9)the offer of units was available only to “Wholesale / Experienced Investors” and it was stated that for this reason a PDS in accordance with Division 2 of Part 7.9 of the Act was not required.