Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland [2019] FCAFC 102

Appeal from: Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 15) [2018] FCA 819
File number: NSD 1185 of 2018
Judges: MIDDLETON, PERRAM AND ANASTASSIOU JJ
Date of judgment: 21 June 2019
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – whether respondent trustee in breach of duties owed to noteholders due to failure to appoint investigative accountant

EVIDENCE – correctness of ruling excluding line of questioning in cross-examination on ‘alternative causal thesis’ for lack of relevance – whether alternative causal thesis pleaded – whether case confined by particulars to expert evidence – whether even if exclusion incorrect, ‘alternative causal thesis’ would have been independently causal vis-à-vis the primary causal thesis – appeal dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – parties’ obligation to plead all causes of action or defences explicitly

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 283CC, 283DA

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt IVA

Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) s 85

Trusts Act 1976 (Qld) s 76

Cases cited:

Banque Commerciale S.A., En Liquidation v Akhil Holdings Limited (1990) 169 CLR 279

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424

CCL Secure Pty Ltd v Berry [2019] FCAFC 81

Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1

Ingot Capital Investments Pty Ltd v Macquarie Equity Capital Markets Ltd (2008) 73 NSWLR 653

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 6) [2016] FCA 391

Water Board v Moustakas (1988) 180 CLR 491

White v Overland [2001] FCA 1333

Date of hearing: 14, 15, 18, 19 and 22 February 2019
Date of last submissions: 4 February 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 77
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr N C Hutley SC with Mr C H Withers and Mr A M Hochroth
Solicitor for the Appellant: Squire Patton Boggs
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Finch SC with Mr D O’Sullivan QC, Mr M O’Meara and Ms F Lubett
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

NSD 1185 of 2018
BETWEEN:

OZTECH PTY LTD ACN 005 907 871

Appellant

AND:

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND

Respondent

JUDGES:

MIDDLETON, PERRAM AND ANASTASSIOU JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JUNE 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

OVERVIEW

  1. This appeal arises essentially from a single evidentiary ruling by the primary judge during the trial of the proceeding.  The appellant says that the ruling precluded it from advancing an alternative cause of action for breach of duty (the alternative cause of action) as well as an alternative causal thesis.  It submits that the ruling caused a miscarriage of the principal proceeding.  It seeks a new trial of the whole proceeding before a different…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCAFC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland, the appellant, Oztech, sought to appeal the decision of the primary judge in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The appellant, a holder of unsecured notes, alleged that the respondent, the Public Trustee of Queensland, breached their duties as trustee by failing to appoint an investigative accountant. The primary judge had dismissed Oztech's claims, and Oztech appealed, arguing that the exclusion of certain evidence and the failure to consider an alternative causal thesis for the events leading to the financial collapse of Octaviar Limited (OL) was an error.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the exclusion of evidence regarding an 'alternative causal thesis' was correct and whether this exclusion, if incorrect, would have led to a different outcome. The court had to determine whether the alternative causal thesis was pleaded, whether the case was confined by particulars to expert evidence, and if the exclusion of the alternative causal thesis would have independently affected the primary causal thesis.

The court held that the exclusion of the alternative causal thesis was correct as it was not pleaded. Despite the concession by the appellant's counsel that the appeal should be dismissed if the alternative cause of action was not pleaded, the court examined the effect of the ruling on the alternative causal thesis. The court found that the alternative causal theory could have led to an examination of whether earlier events might have prompted inquiries by the respondent, potentially leading to more timely protective action. However, due to the evidentiary ruling, this counterfactual was not examined at trial. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

During the appeal, senior counsel for the appellant conceded, correctly, that if the Court found that the alternative cause of action was not pleaded, the appeal should be refused. In view of that concession, strictly it is unnecessary to decide whether the alternative causal theory advanced by the appellant would have led to the same or different result. However, it is appropriate that we briefly examine the appellant’s contention concerning the effect of the ruling in relation to the alternative causal thesis. BACKGROUND The background to the proceeding and the involvement of numerous entities in relevant events are described in the Reasons for Judgment at [1]-[13]. We shall refer to only so much of the background as is necessary to provide context to the questions raised in this appeal. The principal proceeding was a representative proceeding commenced under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The appellant was a holder of unsecured notes issued under the arrangements to which we shall refer. The respondent was the trustee for the noteholders. Between November 2006 and March 2007, a company now called Octaviar Investments Notes Limited (in liq) (OIN) issued unsecured notes with a total face value of about $348.6 million. OIN was at all relevant times a company within the Octaviar Group, the head entity of which was Octaviar Limited (receivers and managers appointed) (in liq) (OL). In November 2006, OL executed a deed poll in favour of the respondent as trustee of the noteholders by which it guaranteed OIN’s payment obligations under the notes. By about May – June 2007, OL had identified a cash deficiency of more than $200 million. OL announced that it proposed to sell an asset, being a part interest in a tourism business known as Stella, in the first half of 2007. However, by 18 May 2007, it had not sold an interest in Stella. OL had also attempted to obtain a $450 million commercial banking facility but had been unable to do so. The Fortress facility OL required bridging finance and on 1 June 2007 a related entity (referred to as OC in the Reasons for Judgment) took a facility with a non-bank lender, Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Limited (the Fortress facility). The Fortress facility was repayable on 1 September 2007 and was secured by fixed and floating charges given by OL, OC and a third Octaviar entity (referred to as OFS in the Reasons for Judgment) over nearly all of the non Stella assets in the Octaviar Group (Fortress charges). The Fortress facility is of particular significance to the alternative cause of action which the appellant says it was prevented from pursuing as we shall explain below. OL and OFS were Guarantors of OIN’s obligations under the trust deed (the OIN Trust Deed) which attached to the terms of issue of the notes. OL and OFS were required under s 283CC of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to notify the respondent of the Fortress charges. They failed to do so. The Fortress charges were lodged with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). On 6 June 2007 the respondent received an automatic notification of their lodgement by email (the 6 June notification). The 6 June notification did not contain particulars of the Fortress charges. The respondent’s practice was to request a copy of any document referred to in such a notification. For reasons which were not explained by the respondent, no documents were requested following the 6 June notification. The relevant officers within the respondent’s office remained unaware of the Fortress facility and the Fortress charges until much later. The financial position of the Octaviar Group

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent’s causation argument was put on a number of bases. One basis was that had the alternative cause of action been permitted, the breach would nevertheless have converged with later supervening events and thus the cause of action would have failed for want of causation for the same reasons that the other causes of action failed. This contention in effect posits that where two separate series of events, commencing from separate starting points and caused by separate breaches, converge with a single event directly causative of loss, the anterior events cease to have any causative effect. We do not agree entirely with the respondent’s contention. It elides the question of what other events may have occurred if the hypothetical alternative causal theory had been explored during the hearing of the proceeding. If that course had been open to the appellant, it is conceivable that the putative earlier events may have been the impetus for inquiries by the respondent and this in turn may have led to the more timely discovery of the need for protective action by the respondent. The question of whether the later supervening events would have occurred or would have had the same effect is a question that required scrutiny at the trial. Due to the evidentiary ruling this counterfactual was not examined at trial, nor analysed in the Reasons for Judgment of the primary judge: Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 15) [2018] FCA 819. During the appeal, senior counsel for the appellant conceded, correctly, that if the Court found that the alternative cause of action was not pleaded, the appeal should be refused. In view of that concession, strictly it is unnecessary to decide whether the alternative causal theory advanced by the appellant would have led to the same or different result. However, it is appropriate that we briefly examine the appellant’s contention concerning the effect of the ruling in relation to the alternative causal thesis. BACKGROUND The background to the proceeding and the involvement of numerous entities in relevant events are described in the Reasons for Judgment at [1]-[13]. We shall refer to only so much of the background as is necessary to provide context to the questions raised in this appeal. The principal proceeding was a representative proceeding commenced under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The appellant was a holder of unsecured notes issued under the arrangements to which we shall refer. The respondent was the trustee for the noteholders. Between November 2006 and March 2007, a company now called Octaviar Investments Notes Limited (in liq) (OIN) issued unsecured notes with a total face value of about $348.6 million. OIN was at all relevant times a company within the Octaviar Group, the head entity of which was Octaviar Limited (receivers and managers appointed) (in liq) (OL). In November 2006, OL executed a deed poll in favour of the respondent as trustee of the noteholders by which it guaranteed OIN’s payment obligations under the notes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

OL and OFS were required under s 283CC of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to notify the respondent of the Fortress charges. They failed to do so. The Fortress charges were lodged with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). On 6 June 2007 the respondent received an automatic notification of their lodgement by email (the 6 June notification). The 6 June notification did not contain particulars of the Fortress charges. The respondent’s practice was to request a copy of any document referred to in such a notification. For reasons which were not explained by the respondent, no documents were requested following the 6 June notification. The relevant officers within the respondent’s office remained unaware of the Fortress facility and the Fortress charges until much later. The financial position of the Octaviar Group On 8 June 2007, the respondent received a report from PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) which stated that based on the information on hand, it was unable to form an opinion as to whether OL would have the ability to repay the notes on maturity. PwC had been provided with a financial statement and assumptions by OL, but these documents were provided prior to the Fortress facility being entered into and did not show the Fortress facility. On 13 June 2007, OL announced to the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) that it did not intend to sell an interest in Stella until after the first quarter of the 2008 financial year (after 30 September 2007). By early July 2007, as we have said above, OL was unable to obtain a commercial banking facility of $450 million to meet its forecast cash flow deficiencies. As a result of the deferral of the Stella sale and OL’s inability to obtain a commercial banking facility, on 17 August 2007 the Fortress facility was amended. The date for repayment was extended to 1 December 2007. On 21 August 2007, OL released its annual report for the 2007 financial year. The OL balance sheet recorded an increase in current borrowings. The notes to the accounts explained this was primarily attributable to “bank loans” of $254.34 million secured by a fixed and floating charge over the assets of the Octaviar Group. This was a reference to the Fortress facility, though not expressly stated. The relevant officers of the respondent reviewed the 2007 annual report but did not notice the increase in current borrowings. On 28 November 2007, OL announced to the ASX that it was not going to sell an interest in Stella at all. OL did not have the means of repaying the Fortress facility due to be repaid on 1 December 2007. However, on 30 November 2007, the Fortress facility was again amended. The amendments required that $100 million be repaid immediately, with the remaining $150 million deferred until 29 February 2008. The Octaviar Group did not have $100 million in cash on 30 November 2007. To meet the partial repayment of $100 million, the officers of OL caused a related entity, referred to as MFS IN in the Reasons for Judgment, to borrow $147.5 million from the Royal Bank of Scotland and transfer $130 million of those funds to Octaviar Administration Pty Ltd (in liq) (OA). MFS IN was the responsible entity for a managed investment scheme called the Premium Income Fund (PIF). OA transferred $103 million to Fortress to repay the $100 million and pay an “extension fee” of $3 million. This transaction is referred to in the Reasons for Judgment as the PIF Transaction.