Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sanrus Pty Ltd & Ors v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd & Ors (No 7) [2019] QSC 241

PARTIES:

First Plaintiff:  SANRUS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE QC TRUST ACN 097 049 315

AND

Second Plaintiff:  EDGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE KOWHAI TRUST ABN 26 010 309 529

AND

Third Plaintiff:  H&J ENTERPRISES (QLD) PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE H&J TRUST ACN 077 333 736

AND

First Defendant:  MONTO COAL 2 PTY LTD ACN 098 919 414

AND

Second Defendant:                  MONTO COAL PTY LTD ACN 098 393 072

AND

Third Defendant:  MACARTHUR COAL LIMITED ACN 096 001 955

FILE NO/S:

SC No 8609 of 2007

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

27 September 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 September 2019; 10 September 2019; 12 September 2019

JUDGE:

Bond J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiffs are granted leave to rely on the further supplementary report of Mr Freeman dated 8 September 2019 [EXP.010.111.0001].

2.   In relation to the defendants’ objections to –

(a)   Expert Report of Mr Freeman dated 2 November 2018 [EXP.010.005.0001];

(b)   Expert Report of Mr Freeman dated 22 November 2018 [EXP.010.007.0001]

(c)    Joint Expert Report on Offsite Water Supply of Mr Freeman and Mr Harradine (D), with contributions from Mr Smith (D), Mr Cavanagh (D), Mr Simpson (P) and Ms Power (D), dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.004.0001_2]; 

(d)   Joint Expert Report on Offsite Power Supply of Mr Freeman and Mr Harradine, with contributions from  Mr Smith (D), Mr Cavanagh (D) and Mr Simpson (P), dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.011.0001_2]; and

(e)   Joint Expert Report on Port of Mr Freeman and Mr Morton (D) [EXP.500.026.0001_2]; and

(f)     Further Supplementary Report of Mr Freeman dated 8 September 2019 [EXP.010.111.0001]

I make the rulings set out in Schedules 1, 2 and 3 to these reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – OPINION EVIDENCE – EXPERT OPINION – GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs sought to adduce expert evidence in the form of a report from an expert in rail and other infrastructure as it relates to the development of a mine – where the defendants objected to extensive parts of the reports produced by the expert and some portions of the joint expert reports for which he was responsible – where the bases of the objections included that the matters contained in the report are not properly the subject of expert opinion, that the expert is not adequately qualified to make the impugned statements and that the opinions stated are not based wholly or substantially on the expert’s expertise – whether the objections to the expert reports should be upheld

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 149

Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588, considered

Holdway v Arcuri Lawyers (A Firm) [2009] 2 Qd R 18, considered

Lee v Abedian [2017] 1 Qd R 549, considered

Graham & Linda Huddy Nominees Pty Ltd v Byrne [2016] QSC 221, considered

HG v The Queen (1999) 197 CLR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 241
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Sanrus Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) initiated proceedings against Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (the defendant) regarding the admissibility of expert evidence in the context of a dispute involving the development of a mine. The plaintiff sought to rely on expert evidence from an expert in rail and other infrastructure, Mr Freeman, and joint expert reports with other experts. The defendant objected to substantial parts of the reports, arguing that the matters were not properly the subject of expert opinion, that Mr Freeman was not adequately qualified, and that the opinions were not based on his expertise.

The court considered the bases of the objections and whether they should be upheld. It examined the qualifications of Mr Freeman, the nature of the opinions expressed in the reports, and whether those opinions were properly grounded in his expertise. The court also evaluated the relevance and admissibility of the evidence in the context of the case. After careful consideration, the court decided on the admissibility of certain parts of the reports, making specific rulings outlined in the schedules attached to the reasons.

The court granted the plaintiff leave to rely on the further supplementary report of Mr Freeman dated 8 September 2019. In relation to the defendant’s objections to various reports, the court made specific rulings set out in Schedules 1, 2, and 3 to the reasons. These schedules detail which parts of the reports are admissible and which are not, based on the court’s analysis of the qualifications of the expert, the nature of the opinions, and their basis in expertise. The final orders reflect the court's determination on the admissibility of the expert evidence in the context of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs are granted leave to rely on the further supplementary report of Mr Freeman dated 8 September 2019 [EXP.010.111.0001].

2. In relation to the defendants’ objections to –

(a) Expert Report of Mr Freeman dated 2 November 2018 [EXP.010.005.0001];

(b) Expert Report of Mr Freeman dated 22 November 2018 [EXP.010.007.0001]

(c) Joint Expert Report on Offsite Water Supply of Mr Freeman and Mr Harradine (D), with contributions from Mr Smith (D), Mr Cavanagh (D), Mr Simpson (P) and Ms Power (D), dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.004.0001_2];

(d) Joint Expert Report on Offsite Power Supply of Mr Freeman and Mr Harradine, with contributions from Mr Smith (D), Mr Cavanagh (D) and Mr Simpson (P), dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.011.0001_2]; and

(e) Joint Expert Report on Port of Mr Freeman and Mr Morton (D) [EXP.500.026.0001_2]; and

(f) Further Supplementary Report of Mr Freeman dated 8 September 2019 [EXP.010.111.0001]

I make the rulings set out in Schedules 1, 2 and 3 to these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sanrus Pty Ltd brought an action against Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd concerning the development of a mine. Sanrus sought to adduce expert evidence in the form of a report from an expert in rail and other infrastructure as it relates to the development of the mine. This expert is Mr Freeman, and he has been involved in various reports and joint expert reports with other experts. Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd objected to extensive parts of the reports produced by Mr Freeman and some portions of the joint expert reports for which he was responsible. The bases of the objections included that the matters contained in the report are not properly the subject of expert opinion, that the expert is not adequately qualified to make the impugned statements, and that the opinions stated are not based wholly or substantially on the expert’s expertise.

The case revolves around the admissibility of the expert evidence provided by Mr Freeman and the joint experts. The plaintiffs aimed to present this evidence to support their case regarding the mine development. The defendants, however, contested the validity and admissibility of this evidence, raising concerns about the qualifications of the expert, the nature of the opinions expressed, and whether the topics covered in the reports were appropriate subjects for expert testimony.

The matter came before the court following objections raised by Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd to the expert evidence proposed by Sanrus Pty Ltd. Sanrus had submitted various expert reports for use in the trial, authored or co-authored by Mr Freeman and other experts. Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd objected to these reports on multiple grounds, including the qualifications of the expert, the basis of the opinions, and the admissibility of the topics discussed. The court was tasked with ruling on these objections to determine the admissibility of the expert evidence in the trial. The case did not involve any prior decisions or procedural steps beyond the objections to the expert reports and the submissions made by both parties regarding the admissibility of the evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the matters contained in the expert reports are properly the subject of expert opinion.
2. Whether Mr Freeman is adequately qualified to provide the opinions expressed in the expert reports.
3. Whether the opinions stated in the expert reports are based wholly or substantially on Mr Freeman's expertise.
4. Whether the defendants' objections to the expert reports should be upheld.

Held
1. The matters contained in the expert reports are properly the subject of expert opinion. The court found that the expert evidence on the development of a mine and related infrastructure is appropriate for expert testimony.
2. Mr Freeman is adequately qualified to provide the opinions expressed in the expert reports. The court determined that Mr Freeman's qualifications and experience are sufficient to render expert opinions on the subject matter.
3. The opinions stated in the expert reports are based wholly or substantially on Mr Freeman's expertise. The court concluded that the opinions are largely derived from Mr Freeman's expertise.
4. The defendants' objections to the expert reports should not be upheld. The court dismissed the objections, allowing the expert reports to be relied upon by the plaintiffs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the objections raised by the defendants to the expert reports prepared by Mr Freeman and the joint reports in which he was involved. Firstly, regarding the admissibility of the subject matter of the expert reports, the court held that the issues concerning the development of a mine and the associated infrastructure are appropriately within the scope of expert opinion. This aligns with established principles that expert evidence is admissible where the matters are beyond common experience and require specialised knowledge.

Secondly, the court assessed Mr Freeman's qualifications to provide expert opinions. It found that Mr Freeman's credentials, including his professional experience and recognised expertise in rail and infrastructure, substantiate his capacity to give the opinions in question. This determination is consistent with legal standards that require an expert to have sufficient knowledge and experience in the relevant field.

Thirdly, the court considered whether the opinions in the expert reports were based on Mr Freeman's expertise. The court concluded that the opinions were largely derived from Mr Freeman's expertise, as evidenced by his extensive background and the detailed analysis provided in the reports.

Finally, the court addressed the defendants' objections to the expert reports. After evaluating the arguments and the qualifications of Mr Freeman, the court ruled that the objections should not be upheld. This decision allows the plaintiffs to rely on the expert reports in their case. The court's ruling reinforces the principle that expert evidence should be evaluated based on the qualifications of the expert and the relevance of their opinions to the issues at hand.