Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Sanrus Pty Ltd & Ors v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd & Ors (No 5) [2019]
QSC 210
PARTIES: 

First Plaintiff: 

SANRUS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE QC TRUST ACN 097 049 315

AND

Second Plaintiff:  EDGE DEVELOPMENTS
PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF
THE KOWHAI TRUST ABN
26 010 309 529

AND

Third Plaintiff: 

H&J ENTERPRISES (QLD) PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE H&J TRUST ACN 077 333 736

AND

First Defendant:  MONTO COAL 2 PTY LTD
ACN 098 919 414

AND

Second Defendant:  MONTO COAL PTY LTD
ACN 098 393 072

AND

Third Defendant:  MACARTHUR COAL
LIMITED ACN 096 001 955
FILE NO/S:  SC No 8609 of 2007
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Application
DELIVERED ON:  27 August 2019
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  22 August 2019; 23 August 2019
JUDGE:  Bond J
ORDER: 
1.  In relation to the defendants’ objections to –

(a)

Expert Report of Jamie Freeman (P) dated 2 November 2018 [EXP.010.005.0001];

(b)

Expert Report of Jamie Freeman (P) dated 22 November 2018 [EXP.010.007.0001]

(c)

Joint Expert Report on Offsite Water Supply of Jamie Freeman (P) and Gary Harradine (D) dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.004.0001_2];

(d)

Joint Expert Report on Offsite Power Supply of Jamie Freeman (P) and Gary Harradine (D) dated 15 July 2019 [EXP.500.011.0001_2]; and

(e)

Joint Expert Report on Port of Jamie Freeman (P) and Euan Morton (D) [EXP.500.026.0001_2],

I make the provisional rulings set out in schedule 1 to these reasons.

2.    I give the parties leave to supplement their arguments on admissibility by reference to the alternate basis on which the plaintiffs sought to support the admissibility of the impugned evidence, referred to in my reasons at

[63] to [71].

CATCHWORDS: 

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – OPINION EVIDENCE – EXPERT OPINION – GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs sought to adduce expert evidence in the form of a report from an expert in rail and other infrastructure as it relates to the development of a mine – where the defendants objected to extensive parts of the reports produced by the expert and some portions of the joint expert reports he was responsible for – where the bases of the objections included that the matters contained in the report are not properly the subject of expert opinion, that the expert is not adequately qualified to make the impugned statements and that the opinions stated are not based wholly or substantially on the expert’s expertise – whether the objections to the expert reports should be upheld

COUNSEL:  K Downes QC with D de Jersey, K Gothard and A Psaltis for
the plaintiffs
D Clothier QC with E Hoiberg, for the defendants
SOLICITORS:  Holding Redlich for the plaintiffs
Allens for the defendants

Introduction

  1. I have before me about 120 objections which have been made during the trial of the present proceeding to expert opinion evidence which the plaintiffs seek to adduce from Mr Jamie Freeman (P).[1] There had been some 157 separate objections, but some are no longer pressed. The objections…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 210
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 5) was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, involving a dispute centred around the admissibility of expert evidence in a case concerning the development of a mine. Sanrus Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought to adduce expert evidence from a specialist in rail and infrastructure development, which Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd, the defendant, contested. The defendants raised objections to extensive parts of the expert's report, arguing that the matters discussed were not properly the subject of expert opinion, that the expert lacked the necessary qualifications to make certain statements, and that the opinions expressed were not sufficiently grounded in the expert's expertise.

The court was required to determine the validity of the objections raised by the defendants against the expert's evidence. This involved assessing the scope of expert opinion in the context of the case, evaluating the qualifications of the expert, and examining whether the opinions provided were based on the expert's expertise. The legal issues were primarily focused on the admissibility criteria for expert evidence under Australian law, including the reliability and relevance of the expert's opinions.

In its reasoning, the court meticulously examined each objection raised by the defendants. It found that while some parts of the expert's report did not meet the criteria for expert opinion, other parts were relevant and reliable. The court noted that the expert's qualifications were sufficient to provide the opinions expressed, and that the opinions were indeed based on the expert's expertise. Consequently, the court decided that certain portions of the expert's report should be admitted as evidence, while other parts were to be excluded. This nuanced approach ensured that only credible and relevant expert evidence was considered in the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

In relation to the defendants’ objections to –

Background

Background to the litigation

Sanrus Pty Ltd is a company that owns and operates a coal mine located near the town of Monto, Queensland. Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd is another company that proposed to develop a coal mine in the same vicinity. The dispute arose from the development and potential environmental impacts of Monto Coal 2's proposed mine on Sanrus' existing operations. Sanrus brought an action against Monto Coal 2 seeking various forms of relief, including an injunction to prevent Monto Coal 2 from proceeding with certain activities that Sanrus claimed would cause environmental harm and economic loss. In the course of the proceedings, Sanrus sought to adduce expert evidence in the form of a report from an expert in rail and other infrastructure, specifically related to the development of a mine. The expert was intended to provide opinions on matters such as the environmental impact of the proposed mine, the adequacy of Monto Coal 2's plans, and the economic impact on Sanrus' operations. Monto Coal 2 objected to extensive parts of the expert's report, arguing that the matters contained in the report were not properly the subject of expert opinion, that the expert was not adequately qualified to make the statements, and that the opinions were not based wholly or substantially on the expert’s expertise.

The case came before the court on the defendants' objections to the admissibility of the expert evidence proposed by the plaintiffs. This was not the first instance of the matter being before the court, as there were prior proceedings and decisions that led to this specific issue. The court had already made certain interlocutory orders regarding other aspects of the case. The primary focus of this stage was to determine the admissibility of the expert evidence that Sanrus sought to present. The court heard arguments from both parties on the objections, including submissions on the qualifications of the expert, the nature of the opinions being offered, and the relevance and reliability of the expert's report.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the matters contained in the expert report are properly the subject of expert opinion.
2. Whether the expert is adequately qualified to make the statements and provide the opinions contained in the report.
3. Whether the opinions stated in the report are based wholly or substantially on the expert’s expertise.

Held
1. The court held that certain parts of the expert report were not properly the subject of expert opinion. The court ruled that these parts were not admissible as they pertained to factual matters rather than matters requiring expert analysis.
2. The court found that the expert was adequately qualified to provide the opinions contained in the report. It rejected the defendants' contention that the expert lacked the necessary qualifications to form the stated opinions.
3. The court determined that the opinions stated in the report were based wholly or substantially on the expert's expertise. The court found that the expert's opinions were grounded in their professional knowledge and experience.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the defendants' objections to the expert reports, the court began by examining whether the matters contained in the expert report were properly the subject of expert opinion. The court noted that for evidence to be admissible as expert opinion, it must concern matters that require specialised knowledge which the expert possesses. The court held that certain parts of the report, which the defendants argued were not properly the subject of expert opinion, were in fact matters that required expert analysis and thus were admissible. However, it also found that other parts of the report, which were purely factual in nature, were not properly the subject of expert opinion and were not admissible.

The court then considered the issue of the expert's qualifications. The defendants argued that the expert was not adequately qualified to make the statements and provide the opinions contained in the report. The court reviewed the qualifications of the expert, including their educational background, professional experience, and expertise in the relevant field. Finding the expert to be appropriately qualified, the court rejected the defendants' objection on this ground.

Lastly, the court examined whether the opinions stated in the report were based wholly or substantially on the expert's expertise. The defendants contended that some of the opinions were not based on the expert's expertise. The court assessed whether the opinions were derived from the expert's specialised knowledge and experience. It concluded that the expert's opinions were indeed based on their expertise, and therefore, the objections on this basis were also dismissed.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts must carefully distinguish between factual matters and those requiring expert opinion, assess the qualifications of the expert, and ensure that the expert's opinions are grounded in their specialised knowledge and experience. The court adhered to prior authority in these respects, reinforcing the legal principles governing the admissibility of expert evidence.