Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd [2020] QCA 247

PARTIES:

SPEETS INVESTMENT PTY LTD
ACN 607 713 164
(appellant)
v
BENCOL PTY LTD
ACN 010 066 681
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 10496 of 2019
DC No 242 of 2016

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Townsville – Unreported, 29 August 2019 (Coker DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

10 November 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 March 2020

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and Bond and Callaghan JJ

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal is allowed on Grounds 2(a); 2(b); 2(c); 2(d) and 2(e).

2.   Ground 2(f) is dismissed.

3.   Orders 2 and 3 are set aside.

4.   Orders 1(a), 1(d) and 1(h) are set aside.

5.   In place of Orders 2 and 3, the Court orders that:

(i)     The parties are directed to bring in agreed minutes of order declaring the landlord’s responsibility for the shower system defects in terms consistent with this Court’s reasons within 14 days of the date of these reasons;

(ii)   If the parties are unable to reach agreement so as to permit compliance with the previous direction, they must file written submissions as to the appropriate form of declaration, limited to two pages, within a further seven days, and the Court will resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal;

(iii) It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for the treatment and painting of pipe columns at the front entry of the Motel as identified at pages 15-16 of the report of Mr Hopmeier dated 30 August 2016;

(iv)  It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for maintenance of the cold room and the repair of those parts of the cold room that have been damaged by rust;

(v)    It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for maintenance and repair of seals to the windows and of the security grills; and

6.   The parties are directed to file submissions on costs, limited to four pages, at the same time as the minutes of order referred to in 5(i) (or the submissions in 5(ii) if that becomes applicable), and the Court will resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS – COVENANTS – AS TO REPAIR – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – where the landlord and tenant each alleged that the other is responsible under a commercial lease for works on and repairs to a motel – where the trial judge made declarations as to liability in favour of the tenant in relation to some areas of the motel – where the trial judge made declarations as to liability in favour of the landlord in relation to some areas of the motel – where the landlord appeals against declarations which declared the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 247
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd was heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the parties, Speets Investment Pty Ltd (appellant) and Bencol Pty Ltd (respondent), disputed the allocation of responsibilities under a commercial lease agreement for works and repairs on a motel. The trial judge had made declarations attributing liability for certain works and repairs to either the landlord or the tenant, depending on the area of the motel in question. The landlord appealed against the declarations made in favor of the tenant, as well as those setting timeframes for the landlord to carry out works or repairs. Additionally, the landlord sought declarations attributing to the tenant liability under the lease for particular types of repair work.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the respondent tenant was liable under the lease for certain types of repair work, and whether the appellant landlord was liable under the lease for other types of repair work. Furthermore, the court considered whether the extrajudicial arrangement for an independent expert to adjudicate on any disputes arising from the carrying out of work or repairs under the commercial lease amounted to an improper delegation of judicial power, and whether the declarations should be set aside.

The court found that there were two flaws in the orders made by the trial judge. First, the orders were contingent upon a decision being made by an independent expert, which meant they could not stand. Second, the orders purported to make a declaration as to the timeframe within which the landlord was obliged to carry out the works, which was not appropriate. The court agreed with the observations made by Callaghan J, who stated that the declarations incorporated coercive elements of relief, which was not appropriate in this case.

The court set aside Orders 1(a), 2(a) and 3(a), and directed the parties to bring in agreed minutes of order declaring the landlord’s responsibility for the shower system defects in terms consistent with the court’s reasons within 14 days of the date of these reasons. If the parties were unable to reach agreement, they were to file written submissions as to the appropriate form of declaration, limited to 2 pages, within a further 7 days, and the court would resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal.

In summary, the court found that the trial judge had erred in making certain declarations and setting timeframes for the landlord to carry out works or repairs, and that the extrajudicial arrangement for an independent expert to adjudicate on any disputes arising from the carrying out of work or repairs under the commercial lease was not appropriate. The court set aside the relevant orders and directed the parties to reach an agreement on the appropriate form of declaration, or to file written submissions if they were unable to reach an agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed on Grounds 2(a); 2(b); 2(c); 2(d) and 2(e).

2. Ground 2(f) is dismissed.

3. Orders 2 and 3 are set aside.

4. Orders 1(a), 1(d) and 1(h) are set aside.

5. In place of Orders 2 and 3, the Court orders that:

(i) The parties are directed to bring in agreed minutes of order declaring the landlord’s responsibility for the shower system defects in terms consistent with this Court’s reasons within 14 days of the date of these reasons;

(ii) If the parties are unable to reach agreement so as to permit compliance with the previous direction, they must file written submissions as to the appropriate form of declaration, limited to two pages, within a further seven days, and the Court will resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal;

(iii) It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for the treatment and painting of pipe columns at the front entry of the Motel as identified at pages 15-16 of the report of Mr Hopmeier dated 30 August 2016;

(iv) It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for maintenance of the cold room and the repair of those parts of the cold room that have been damaged by rust;

(v) It is declared that the respondent is liable under clause 7.1 of the lease for maintenance and repair of seals to the windows and of the security grills; and

6. The parties are directed to file submissions on costs, limited to four pages, at the same time as the minutes of order referred to in 5(i) (or the submissions in 5(ii) if that becomes applicable), and the Court will resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The only remaining issue is the challenge to order 3(a). There were two flaws in that form of order. First, it suffered from the same vice as order 2(a) in that it was contingent upon a decision being made by an independent expert. For that reason it cannot stand. But second, it purported to make a declaration as to the timeframe within which the landlord was obliged to carry out the works. I agree with the observations made by Callaghan J at [113] to [115] of his reasons.Conclusion The following orders should be made:(a)Orders 1(a), 2(a) and 3(a) are set aside.(b)The parties are directed to bring in agreed minutes of order declaring the landlord’s responsibility for the shower system defects in terms consistent with this Court’s reasons within 14 days of the date of these reasons.(c)In the parties are unable to reach agreement so as to permit compliance with the previous direction, they must file written submissions as to the appropriate form of declaration, limited to 2 pages, within a further 7 days, and the Court will resolve on the papers the orders which should be made in final disposition of the appeal.Defects concerning rust to the bases of pipe columnsThe issues on appeal The primary judge had relevantly ordered:“(1)That there be a declaration as to the defects identified at the [motel].…(c)Rust to the bases of pipe columns at the front entry to the said motel.…(2)That there be a declaration as to the party responsible for the works to be performed pursuant to declaration 1 as may be directed by an independent expert.(a)The [landlord] is to be responsible for the costs of works required pursuant to declarations (1) … (c) ……(3)That there be a declaration that the timeframe for works to be performed pursuant to declarations (1) and (2) as herein as may be directed by an independent expert.…(b)Insofar as declarations (1) … (c) … are concerned, works are to be commenced within two months of direction determination of the independent expert and, unless otherwise agreed in writing, completed within four months of any such determination direction.” The relevant appeal grounds were:(a)Ground 2(a)(ii): that the primary judge had erred in fact and law in declaring that the landlord was to be responsible for the cost of works required by “rust to the bases of pipe columns at the front entry to the said motel”.(b)Ground 2(b): that the primary judge erred in fact and law in declaring that the timeframe for works to be performed pursuant to the declaration be “as may be directed by an independent expert”.(c)Ground 2(d): that the primary judge erred in fact and law in declaring that the works were to be commenced within two months of direction determination of the independent expert and, unless otherwise agreed in writing, completed within four months of any such determination direction. The relevant orders sought on appeal were:(a)that the declarations in orders 1(c), 2(a) and 3(b) be set aside; and(b)that the following declaration be made:“A declaration that the [tenant] is liable under clause 7.1 of the Lease for the treatment and painting of pipe columns at the front entry of the Motel as identified at pages 15-16 of the report of 30 August 2016;”The allocation of responsibility for these defects

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The qualification “admissible” was evidently a reference to a paragraph in the expert report of Mr Hopmeier dated 4 December 2017, in which he observed:[19]“Kitchen Coldroom: We [that is, Mr Hopmeier and an expert who had been engaged by the landlord, but who was not called and whose reports were not in evidence] are in agreement that this in poor condition & is a health hazard. However, the minor repair works suggest by [the landlord’s expert] would be inadequate. The [tenant] has had Stallard’s, a reputable Refrigeration company, look at the coldroom & they consider is at the end of it’s life & needs replacing. The only reusable part is existing blower. There estimate of cost is $7,029.00. This indicates that both my estimate & [the landlord’s expert’s estimate] are way below what is required.”[19]Appeal Record Book (volume 2), page 457 (emphasis added). All passages from Mr Hopmeier’s report have been reproduced verbatim, except for necessary modifications indicated by square brackets. It is obvious that the highlighted portion of the quote was inadmissible hearsay. And it was double hearsay in the sense that it did not even record an out-of-court statement made by the speaker to Mr Hopmeier, but was evidently Mr Hopmeier’s record of an out-of-court statement made to him by someone on behalf of the tenant about what someone on behalf of Stallard’s had said to them. It did not record Mr Hopmeier’s own observation or his own opinion that the cold room was at the end of its life and needed replacing. Indeed, it appeared that Mr Hopmeier’s opinion was different to that which some unidentified person at Stallard’s had apparently expressed to some unidentified person on behalf of the tenant. The tenant did not call anyone from Stallard’s to prove the opinion. Before the primary judge, objection was taken to the admissibility of Mr Hopmeier’s 4 December 2017 report in its entirety. That objection failed (except in relation to a passage dealing with a different category of defect) and the report was ultimately admitted by the primary judge on the basis that reliance would be placed on Mr Hopmeier’s observations and opinions.[20] The limited basis of admission of the report would not permit the tenant to place any reliance on the inadmissible part of the report either before the primary judge or in this Court. I agree with Callaghan J’s conclusion that that material must be disregarded.[20]Appeal Record Book (volume 2), page 608. Once that conclusion is reached, the inadequacy of the evidence concerning this category of defects means that it falls to be resolved in a similar way as the category concerning rust to the pipe columns. I agree with Callaghan J, for the reasons his Honour expresses, that the evidence that there was “rust around base of cold room and over door head” does not approach the level which would justify categorising the rust as a structural defect. The cold room fell within the definition of “Landlord’s Property”, but the admissible evidence did not suggest it needed to be replaced. Under cl 7.1(a), the tenant was obliged to keep the Motel clean and in good repair. “Motel” was defined to include the Landlord’s Property. Accordingly, the tenant’s obligation to keep the Motel in good repair extended to keeping the cold room in good repair. A more direct route to the same outcome could be found in cl 7.1(e), which expressed a direct obligation on the tenant, at its cost, to maintain and repair the Landlord’s Property.