SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] QCA 39
PARTIES:
SPEETS INVESTMENT PTY LTD
ACN 607 713 164
(appellant)
v
BENCOL PTY LTD
ACN 010 066 681
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
Appeal No 10496 of 2019
DC No 242 of 2016DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
General Civil Appeal – Further Orders
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Townsville (Coker DCJ) – Unreported, 29 August 2019
DELIVERED ON:
9 March 2021
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
Heard on the papers
JUDGES:
Sofronoff P and Bond and Callaghan JJ
ORDER:
1. It is declared that the appellant is liable under clause 7.2 of the lease to replace the Motel’s shower system (excluding shower screens) in rooms 1 to 8 and 10 to 30.
2. The respondent must pay 60 per cent of the appellant’s costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.
3. The costs order made at trial by the primary judge should be set aside and in lieu thereof it should be ordered that there should be no order as to the costs of the proceeding in the District Court.
CATCHWORDS:
EQUITY – EQUITABLE REMEDIES – OTHER REMEDIES – where the parties provided further submissions regarding the appellant’s responsibility for the shower system defects – where it was common ground between the parties that the Court should declare that the appellant is so liable under clause 7.2 of the lease – where the respondent also sought declarations concerning the quality of the appellant’s actions in discharging its liability and the time in which the work ought be carried out
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT – PARTIAL SUCCESS –where the parties provided further submissions on the issue of costs – where the appellant succeeded in setting aside all the orders made against its interests in relation to the defects at trial – where the respondent succeeded on the question of liability for a particular defect – whether the general rule that costs should follow the outcome of the appeal should apply – whether, in light of the successful appeal, there should be an order as to the costs of the trial – where the appellant submitted that its success on appeal added to its success at trial – where the respondent contended for an issues-based costs order
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 681, r 766(1)(d)
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Swainson[2011] QCA 179, cited
BHP Coal Pty Ltd v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG (No 2) [2009] QSC 64, cited
Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads v Cidneo Pty Ltd[2015] QCA 168, cited
Courtney v Chalfen[2021] QCA 25, approved
Interchase Corporation Limited (in liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2003] 1 Qd R 26; [2001] QCA 191, cited
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; [1998] HCA…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] QCA 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the appellant was liable under clause 7.2 of the lease to replace the motel's shower system, excluding shower screens, in specific rooms. Additionally, the court considered the quality of the appellant's actions in discharging its liability and the time frame for completing the repairs. The respondent sought further declarations on these aspects. Another significant issue was the allocation of costs between the parties, considering the appellant’s success on appeal and the partial success of the respondent at trial.
The Court of Appeal found that it was common ground that the appellant was liable under clause 7.2 to replace the shower system. The court held that the appellant’s success on appeal did not warrant a departure from the general rule that costs follow the event. Instead, the court considered the success of the parties on particular issues. The appellant successfully set aside all orders made against its interests at trial, while the respondent succeeded on the liability issue. Therefore, the court ordered that the costs order from the trial should be set aside and no order should be made regarding the costs of the proceeding in the District Court.
No further orders were made beyond those outlined in the judgment. The court declared the appellant’s liability under clause 7.2 and addressed the costs issue by setting aside the previous costs order and directing that there should be no order regarding the costs of the trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. It is declared that the appellant is liable under clause 7.2 of the lease to replace the Motel’s shower system (excluding shower screens) in rooms 1 to 8 and 10 to 30.
2. The respondent must pay 60 per cent of the appellant’s costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.
3. The costs order made at trial by the primary judge should be set aside and in lieu thereof it should be ordered that there should be no order as to the costs of the proceeding in the District Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the District Court of New South Wales where the respondent sought a declaration that the appellant was liable for defects in the motel's shower system under clause 7.2 of the lease. The District Court found in favour of the respondent and ordered the appellant to replace the motel's shower system. The appellant appealed the decision to the New South Wales Court of Appeal. After the appeal was heard, the parties provided further submissions regarding the appellant's responsibility for the shower system defects and the costs of the proceeding.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the appellant liable under clause 7.2 of the lease to replace the motel's shower system?
2. Should the quality of the appellant's actions in discharging its liability and the time in which the work ought be carried out be declared by the court?
3. What is the appropriate order for the costs of the appeal and the trial in light of the partial success of the parties?
Held
1. The court held that the appellant is liable under clause 7.2 of the lease to replace the motel's shower system. The declaration was made excluding shower screens in rooms 1 to 8 and 10 to 30.
2. The court did not grant the declarations sought by the respondent concerning the quality of the appellant's actions in discharging its liability and the time in which the work ought be carried out.
3. The court ordered that the respondent must pay 60 per cent of the appellant's costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis. The costs order made at trial by the primary judge was set aside and in lieu thereof, it was ordered that there should be no order as to the costs of the proceeding in the District Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by considering the liability of the appellant under clause 7.2 of the lease. The parties had agreed that the appellant was liable for replacing the motel's shower system, excluding shower screens in rooms 1 to 8 and 10 to 30. This was confirmed by the court, which declared the appellant's liability under the lease. The court found it unnecessary to delve into the quality of the appellant's actions or the time for carrying out the work, as these were not the primary issues before it.
In regard to the costs, the court acknowledged the partial success of both parties in the appeal. The appellant had successfully set aside all the orders made against its interests in relation to the defects at trial, while the respondent had succeeded on the question of liability for a particular defect. The court noted the appellant's argument that its success on appeal added to its success at trial, whereas the respondent advocated for an issues-based costs order. The court balanced these submissions and decided that the respondent should pay 60 per cent of the appellant's costs of the appeal. The costs order made at trial was set aside, and the court ruled that there should be no order as to the costs of the proceeding in the District Court, considering the appellant's overall success in the appeal. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's approach to costs in cases of partial success, where it applied a nuanced consideration of the parties' overall success rather than strictly adhering to the general rule that costs follow the event.