Corestaff NT Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Corestaff NT Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 2) [2021] QSC 226

PARTIES:

CORESTAFF NT PTY LTD
ACN 129 495 263
(applicant)
v
INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LTD
ABN 11 000 016 722
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

1369 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

3 September 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 May 2021

JUDGE:

Williams J

ORDER:

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Pursuant to a contract of insurance between the applicant and the respondent, designated policy number 03MIS1551242 and in respect of the period of insurance from 30 June 2018 to 30 June 2019, by reason of the exception to indemnity cover in clause 7.9(a) thereof, the applicant has no entitlement to indemnity cover by the respondent under clause 3.1 thereof in respect of any liability alleged against the applicant in proceedings NSD 2024/2018 and NSD 2162/2018 in the Federal Court of Australia by cause of action for damages or compensation pursuant to s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law for contravention of ss 18 or 31 of such Law.

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1.   The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the amended Originating Application to be assessed on the standard basis.

2.    The parties have liberty to apply in respect of the declaration above.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT – EVENT: WHAT CONSTITUTES – where the hearing in May 2021 addressed the proper construction of clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) of the insurance policy (Policy) – where the exemption to indemnity cover in clause 7.9(a) operated so that there was no entitlement to indemnity cover by the respondent in respect of the liability alleged against the applicant in two Federal Court proceedings – where clause 7.9(c) did not apply in respect of the Federal Court proceedings – where the respondent contends that it was successful in defending the applicant’s  claim for indemnity on the basis that clause 7.9(a) was invoked and accordingly, the appropriate costs order is that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs on the standard basis – where the respondent alternatively submits that if some recognition is to be given to the conclusion in respect of clause 7.9(c) of the Policy then an appropriate order would be that the applicant pay 90 per cent of the respondent’s costs of the application on the standard basis – where the applicant submits that it would be appropriate to reflect the position in respect of clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) of the Policy in separate cost orders – where consideration is given to what is the event – whether costs should follow the event

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 681, r 684

Alborn & Ors v Stephens & Ors [2010] QCA 58, considered
BHP Coal Pty Ltd and Ors v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG and Ors (No 2)
[2009] QSC 64, considered
Caloundra City Council…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corestaff NT Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Corestaff NT Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 2), the parties were engaged in a dispute over the interpretation of certain clauses in an insurance policy, specifically clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c), in relation to the applicant's claim for indemnity for liabilities alleged against them in two Federal Court proceedings. The applicant, Corestaff NT Pty Ltd, sought a declaration that it was entitled to indemnity under the policy, while the respondent, Insurance Australia Ltd, denied the claim based on the exclusions provided in clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c). The matter proceeded to a hearing before the Court in May 2021, where the primary issue was the proper construction of these clauses and whether they operated to exclude the applicant's entitlement to indemnity.

The legal issues before the Court included the interpretation of clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) of the insurance policy and the determination of which party should bear the costs of the proceedings. The Court had to decide whether clause 7.9(a) operated to exclude the applicant's entitlement to indemnity, whether clause 7.9(c) applied, and the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties based on the outcome of these issues. The Court considered the submissions made by both parties regarding the appropriate costs order, with the respondent arguing that it was successful in defending the claim and should be awarded costs on the standard basis. The applicant, on the other hand, contended for a separate cost order reflecting the positions on clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c).

The Court found that clause 7.9(a) of the policy operated to exclude the applicant's entitlement to indemnity cover for the liabilities alleged in the Federal Court proceedings. The Court also determined that clause 7.9(c) did not apply to the circumstances of the case. As a result, the Court ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of the amended Originating Application on the standard basis. The Court considered the respondent's success in defending the claim and the applicant's failure to establish that it was entitled to indemnity under the policy.

In summary, the Court ruled that the applicant had no entitlement to indemnity cover by the respondent under the policy for the liabilities alleged in the Federal Court proceedings due to the exception in clause 7.9(a). The Court ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of the amended Originating Application on the standard basis, reflecting the respondent's success in defending the claim for indemnity.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Pursuant to a contract of insurance between the applicant and the respondent, designated policy number 03MIS1551242 and in respect of the period of insurance from 30 June 2018 to 30 June 2019, by reason of the exception to indemnity cover in clause 7.9(a) thereof, the applicant has no entitlement to indemnity cover by the respondent under clause 3.1 thereof in respect of any liability alleged against the applicant in proceedings NSD 2024/2018 and NSD 2162/2018 in the Federal Court of Australia by cause of action for damages or compensation pursuant to s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law for contravention of ss 18 or 31 of such Law.

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the amended Originating Application to be assessed on the standard basis.

2. The parties have liberty to apply in respect of the declaration above.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is necessary to consider the factual background, the relevant Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR) and authorities.Background The affidavit of Ms Chalmers sworn on 24 August 2021 attaches correspondence from the respondent to the applicant’s broker. Reference is also made to an earlier affidavit of Ms Chalmers filed on 5 February 2021 in support of the Originating Application. The relevant factual background includes:(a)On 25 June 2019, the applicant’s broker notified the respondent of two Federal Court proceedings commenced against the applicant and made a claim with respect to those proceedings under the Policy.(b)On 23 December 2019, the respondent wrote to the applicant’s broker denying indemnity under the Policy pursuant to clauses 7.5 and 7.9 of the Policy. (This letter is exhibited to the affidavit of Ms Chalmers, which is Court document two on the Court file at page 44.)(c)The letter dated 23 December 2019 sets out clause 7.9 in full and states:“6. We have conducted a coverage analysis in relation to this claim, and unfortunately, it is our view that cover is excluded by operation of … Section 7.9 ……9. The Proceedings, including the ACL allegations, arise from employment matters. Consequently, the Proceedings brought against Corestaff are not covered by the policy as a result of the above exclusions.10. Furthermore, CGU again notes that Corestaff does not hold Employment Practices Liability insurance with CGU. Corestaff may wish to notify its EPL/ML and/or D&O insurer if it has not previously done so.”(d)Further exchanges occurred between 16 January 2020 and 17 November 2020. This correspondence is exhibited to the most recent affidavit of Ms Chalmers.(e)On 5 February 2021, the applicant filed an Originating Application and the affidavit of Ms Chalmers applying to the Court for orders with specific declarations in respect of clause 7.9(c) of the Policy.(f)On 6 April 2021, the applicant filed its Outline of Argument addressing clause 7.9(c). (g)On 7 April 2021, the respondent filed and served its Outline of Argument addressing clause 7.9(c) and also referring to clause 7.9(a).(h)The matter was originally listed for hearing on 8 April 2021 but the hearing was adjourned and an order made that the respondent notify the applicant of any further grounds of exclusion it sought to rely upon. (i)By letter dated 12 April 2021, the respondent confirmed that “the grounds of policy response exclusion it relies upon are those in clause 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) respectively”.(j)An amended Originating Application was filed on 19 April 2021 and further Outlines of Argument were also filed by both parties addressing clause 7.9(a). (k)The hearing proceeded on 21 May 2021 to consider both clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c). The applicant points to the correspondence between 16 January 2020 and 17 November 2020 as refining the respondent’s position thereby narrowing the basis that indemnity was said to be excluded as follows:(a)16 January 2020 – clauses 7.3, 7.4 and 7.11;(b)4 September 2020 – clause 7.9(c);(c)25 September 2020 – clause 7.9(c); and(d)17 November 2020 – clause 7.9(c).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the proper construction of clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) of the insurance policy?
2. Does clause 7.9(a) operate to exclude the respondent's liability to indemnify the applicant in respect of the Federal Court proceedings?
3. Does clause 7.9(c) apply to the Federal Court proceedings?
4. What is the appropriate costs order in this case?

Held
1. The court concluded that clauses 7.9(a) and 7.9(c) of the insurance policy were properly construed as excluding the respondent's liability to indemnify the applicant in respect of the Federal Court proceedings.
2. Clause 7.9(a) operates to exclude the respondent's liability to indemnify the applicant in respect of the Federal Court proceedings.
3. Clause 7.9(c) does not apply to the Federal Court proceedings.
4. The court ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of the amended Originating Application on the standard basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, in Cook’s Constructions Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Aust Pty Ltd,[6] Martin J considered the conduct of a party during the proceeding, including the late amendment of the party’s case. His Honour concluded that in at least some respects the party’s conduct exhibited the degree of irresponsibility referred to in Todrell Pty Ltd v Finch (No 2).[6][2008] QSC 220.Consideration The difference between the parties centres around the way the denial of indemnity was initially expressed and the subsequent dialogue between the parties exploring aspects of the denial of the claim for indemnity. The respondent’s position is that at all relevant times, it maintained that the claims in respect of the Federal Court proceedings fell within clause 7.9 and thereby the respondent denied indemnity under the Policy. This was clearly set out in a letter dated 23 December 2019. The references in paragraphs nine and ten of the letter identify that the Federal Court proceedings arise from “employment matters” and the applicant did not hold “Employment Practices Liability insurance”. These are matters relevant to the operation of clause 7.9(a) and the letter also sets out clause 7.9 in full, including clause 7.9(a). It does appear that in ongoing discussions between the applicant’s broker and the respondent, submissions were made, including the provision of Counsel’s advice, to try to persuade the respondent as to why the claims came within the coverage of the Policy and were not caught by the exemptions. A review of the correspondence indicates that the ongoing dialogue focussed on various arguments that had been raised in correspondence and responses to that. It was often done in a shorthand way, with clauses from the Policy “cut and paste” into the emails. The email of 16 January 2020 refers to clauses 7.3, 7.4 and 7.11 and addresses some of the arguments raised. However, the email does state “[a]s a result of the above, my indemnity position has not changed.” The email of 4 September 2020 responds to some specific arguments raised and then repeats a request for further information about the manner in which each of the claimant’s were recruited to the insured’s employment. This information was identified as necessary to “allow [the respondent] to complete [its] assessment of policy indemnity”. The email dated 25 September 2020 again calls for further factual background, including the facts provided to Counsel as the basis for the advice that had been shared with the respondent. While the email does engage with the arguments concerning clause 7.9(c), the email concludes “we would be grateful for the information we have reasonably requested about the circumstances of the claim, so that we may finalise our determination about liability under the Policy”. What is apparent, at no time, was there any clarification of a change in the respondent’s position such that it was not relying on clause 7.9(a). While the focus in the correspondence turned to clause 7.9(c), the respondent’s reliance on clause 7.9(a) appears to have “fallen off the radar”.