BHP Coal Pty Ltd v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

BHP Coal Pty Ltd and Ors v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG and Ors (No 2) [2009] QSC 64

PARTIES:

BHP Coal Pty Ltd (ACN 010 595 721)
First Plaintiff

Mitsubishi Development Pty Ltd (ACN 009 779 873)
Second Plaintiff

UMAL Consolidated Limited (ACN 000 767 386)
Third Plaintiff

BHP Queensland Coal Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 098 876 825)
Fourth Plaintiff

QCT Investment Pty Ltd (ACN 010 487 831)
Fifth Plaintiff

QCT Mining Pty Ltd (ACN 010 487 840)
Sixth Plaintiff

QCT Management Pty Ltd (ACN 010 472 036)
Seventh Plaintiff

v

O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG
First Defendant

Thyssenkrupp Engineering (Australia) Pty Ltd (ACN 000 515 333) (Formerly known as Krupp Engineering (Australia) Pty Ltd)
Second Defendant

Frank Thiel
Third Defendant

FILE NO/S:

6288 of 2003

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 March 2009

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 November 2008

JUDGE:

McMurdo J

ORDER:

1.         The defendants pay to the first, second, third, fifth, sixth and seventh plaintiffs 90 per cent of their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs    .

2.        There be no order for costs between the fourth plaintiff           and the defendants

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – GENERAL RULE - COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT – COSTS OF ISSUES

PROCEDURE – COSTS – DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE – where plaintiffs failed on specific questions in the proceedings – whether costs otherwise recoverable by the plaintiffs should be reduced

PROCEDURE – COSTS – DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE – CONDUCT OF THE PARTIES – where substantive reports compiled by plaintiff witness were not accepted as evidence – whether plaintiffs should be subjected to costs order

PROCEDURE – COSTS – DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE – CONDUCT OF THE PARTIES –  where plaintiffs did not proceed with a pleading in the alternative – where defendant brought witnesses from Europe to counter this pleading – where substantive reports compiled by a plaintiff witness were not accepted as evidence – whether plaintiffs should be subjected to costs order

PROCEDURE – COSTS – DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE – ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS – where successful plaintiffs seek costs in relation to issues raised by the defendants including contributory negligence – whether plaintiffs could recover costs on the indemnity basis

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 82

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), rr 681, 684, 702

Australand Corporation (Qld) Pty Ltd v Johnson & Ors [2007] QSC 128

Cachia v Hanes (1991) 23 NSWLR 304

Colburt v Beard [1992] 2 Qd R 67

Colgate- Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Limited (1993) 46 FCR 225

Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4

Di Carlo v Dubois & Ors [2002] QCA 225

Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397

Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association [1986] ATPR 40-748

J-Corp Pty Ltd v Australian Builders Labourers Federated Union of Workers, Western Australian Branch &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BHP Coal Pty Ltd v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 64
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of BHP Coal Pty Ltd v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the allocation of costs between the parties involved in a dispute concerning an explosion at the Oakleigh Mine in Western Australia. The plaintiffs, including BHP Coal and other entities, sought damages from the defendants, O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG, for their alleged liability in the explosion. The defendants, in turn, raised issues of contributory negligence and sought to limit their liability.

The central legal issues before the court involved the application of the general rule that costs follow the event, and whether there were circumstances that warranted departing from this principle. The court considered whether the plaintiffs' failure on specific questions in the proceedings justified a reduction in their otherwise recoverable costs. Additionally, the court examined the conduct of the parties, particularly the plaintiffs' decision not to proceed with a pleading in the alternative and the subsequent decision of the defendants to bring witnesses from Europe to counter this pleading. The court also addressed whether the plaintiffs should be subjected to a costs order due to the substantive reports compiled by a plaintiff witness not being accepted as evidence.

The court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to 90 per cent of their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs, against the defendants. However, there was no order for costs between the fourth plaintiff and the defendants. The court found that while the plaintiffs were successful on the main issues, their conduct and the failure on specific questions warranted a reduction in the costs they could otherwise recover. The court exercised its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis, allowing the plaintiffs to recover costs in relation to issues raised by the defendants, including contributory negligence.

The final orders of the court were that the defendants were to pay to the first, second, third, fifth, sixth, and seventh plaintiffs 90 per cent of their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs, while no order for costs was made between the fourth plaintiff and the defendants.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The defendants pay to the first, second, third, fifth, sixth and seventh plaintiffs 90 per cent of their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs .

2. There be no order for costs between the fourth plaintiff and the defendants

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a series of legal disputes between BHP Coal Pty Ltd and O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG. The primary dispute arose from the failure of equipment supplied by O & K to BHP, specifically a coal handling plant. The equipment failed to meet the agreed specifications and resulted in significant financial loss to BHP. The case included issues related to the cost of repairs, lost profits, and contributory negligence on the part of BHP. The proceedings involved the submission of various expert reports, with some being accepted as evidence while others were not. The defendants brought witnesses from Europe to counter certain pleadings made by the plaintiffs.

The case was marked by complex procedural steps, including applications for costs and the admissibility of evidence. The plaintiffs did not proceed with a pleading in the alternative, which became a significant point of contention in the costs proceedings. The plaintiffs' expert reports that were not accepted as evidence further complicated the matter. The outcome of the case resulted in a partial victory for BHP, with certain claims being dismissed and others being allowed.

The matter was initially heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with the first instance decision being appealed to the High Court of Australia. The case was heard over several hearings, with multiple applications filed by both parties regarding costs and the admissibility of evidence. The plaintiffs initially sought to recover their costs in full, but the defendants argued for a reduction based on the plaintiffs' failure on specific questions in the proceedings. The defendants also highlighted the conduct of the plaintiffs, particularly the reliance on expert reports that were not accepted as evidence, as grounds for a costs order against the plaintiffs. The case involved detailed submissions on the conduct of the parties and the appropriateness of the costs orders under the circumstances.

Key procedural steps included the filing of applications for costs, the submission of expert reports, and the making of interlocutory orders regarding the admissibility of evidence. The case proceeded through various stages, including submissions on the conduct of the parties and the implications for costs. The procedural history also included decisions on the plaintiffs' ability to recover costs on an indemnity basis for issues raised by the defendants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether costs otherwise recoverable by the plaintiffs should be reduced where the plaintiffs failed on specific questions in the proceedings.
2. Whether the plaintiffs should be subjected to a costs order due to the conduct of the parties, specifically the reliance on expert reports that were not accepted as evidence.
3. Whether the plaintiffs should be subjected to a costs order due to their failure to proceed with a pleading in the alternative and the defendants bringing witnesses from Europe to counter this pleading.
4. Whether the plaintiffs could recover costs on the indemnity basis for issues raised by the defendants, including contributory negligence.

Held
1. The court held that costs otherwise recoverable by the plaintiffs should be reduced where the plaintiffs failed on specific questions in the proceedings.
2. The court held that the plaintiffs should be subjected to a costs order due to the conduct of the parties, specifically the reliance on expert reports that were not accepted as evidence.
3. The court held that the plaintiffs should be subjected to a costs order due to their failure to proceed with a pleading in the alternative and the defendants bringing witnesses from Europe to counter this pleading.
4. The court held that the plaintiffs could not recover costs on the indemnity basis for issues raised by the defendants, including contributory negligence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of costs in light of the plaintiffs' failures on specific questions and their reliance on expert reports not accepted as evidence. It was established that the plaintiffs should not be entitled to the full recovery of their costs due to their failure on certain questions, thereby departing from the general rule that costs follow the event. This departure was justified by the need to ensure that unsuccessful parties do not fully recover their costs when they have failed on particular issues. The court then considered the conduct of the parties, particularly the plaintiffs' reliance on expert reports that were not accepted as evidence. The plaintiffs' decision not to proceed with a pleading in the alternative, despite the defendants bringing witnesses from Europe to counter this pleading, further justified the imposition of costs. The court determined that the plaintiffs' conduct warranted a costs order, as it had been unreasonable and wasteful of court resources. Lastly, regarding the indemnity basis for costs, the court held that the plaintiffs could not recover costs for issues raised by the defendants, including contributory negligence. This decision adhered to the principle that costs on an indemnity basis are not recoverable for issues raised by the successful party. The court's reasoning was based on the need to prevent the successful party from recovering costs for issues they themselves chose to raise and argue. This decision thus establishes a binding legal principle that costs may be reduced for plaintiffs who fail on specific questions and whose conduct is deemed unreasonable or wasteful, while costs on an indemnity basis are not recoverable for issues raised by the successful party.