Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd v Leigh

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd v Leigh [2019] QDC 266

PARTIES:

BRUDER EXPEDITION PTY LTD (ACN 603 551 579)
(applicant/plaintiff)

v

TRACY LEIGH
(respondent/defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BD No 2380 of 2019

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Trial – Further orders

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane (Date of Order: 1 November 2019)

DELIVERED ON:

20 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

JUDGE:

Sheridan DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The second order made on 1 November 2019 is set aside.

2.   In lieu thereof, it is ordered that the respondent be restrained by herself or her servants or agents from publishing, causing to be published, encouraging, requesting or enabling to be published by any means whatsoever any statements, comments or images with respect to the applicant and the products sold by any means whatsoever including but not limited to on a Facebook page entitled ‘Lemon Caravans and RV’s in Aus’ to the same effect or matters substantially to the same effect as statements, comments or images that:

off road caravans which are defective;Bruder produces        (a)     

Bruder produces off road caravans which are of poor quality;       (b)     

Bruder produces off road caravans which are unsafe;        (c)     

Bruder’s off road caravans are overpriced and not good value for money;       (d)     

Bruder refuses to assist its customers;         (e)     

The application filed by Bruder was vexatious litigation;        (f)     

Bruder sold a caravan which was severely defective;        (g)     

Bruder was required to provide a refund to the owner of the severely defective caravan;       (h)     

The severely defective caravan sold by Bruder could have killed the owner due to the suspension giving away whilst driving.          (i)     

The orders made on 1 November 2019 are otherwise undisturbed.

3.   

CATCHWORDS:

DEFAMATION – INJUNCTIONS – where the defendant elected to a trial by jury – where the jury found that each of the four statements were published maliciously, and in the case of the third statement, published with a reckless disregard as to its truth, however, the jury found that only the publication of the first and fourth statements caused the plaintiff to suffer actual damage – where the form of injunctive relief sought by the plaintiff extended to the second and third statements – where the statements were interrelated – whether the court has jurisdiction in equity to grant injunctive relief on the terms sought by the plaintiff

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT – where the plaintiff was successful in its claim for damages and injunctive relief – where the defendant sought to vary the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff its costs of and incidental to the proceeding – where the plaintiff succeeded on a significant majority of its pleaded case – where the plaintiff did not press parts of its pleaded case – whether the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff its costs of and incidental to the proceeding should be varied in the circumstances

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd v Leigh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QDC 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd brought an action against Leigh, seeking damages and injunctive relief in relation to defamatory statements made by Leigh on a Facebook page. The dispute reached the court which had to determine whether the plaintiff could obtain injunctive relief in relation to all four defamatory statements, despite the jury finding that only two of the statements had caused actual damage. The court also had to determine the costs to be awarded to the plaintiff in light of the partial success of the plaintiff's claims.

The court found that, as the statements were interrelated, the court had jurisdiction to grant injunctive relief in relation to all four defamatory statements. The court also found that, given the plaintiff had succeeded on a significant majority of its pleaded case, it was appropriate to order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the proceeding. The court found that the plaintiff's claims in relation to the second and third defamatory statements were vexatious and that the defendant should not be ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to those claims.

The court set aside the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff its costs of and incidental to the proceeding, and ordered that the defendant be restrained from publishing, causing to be published, encouraging, requesting or enabling to be published by any means whatsoever any statements, comments or images with respect to the plaintiff and the products sold by any means whatsoever including but not limited to on a Facebook page entitled ‘Lemon Caravans and RV’s in Aus’ to the same effect or matters substantially to the same effect as statements, comments or images that: off road caravans which are defective; Bruder produces (a) Bruder produces off road caravans which are of poor quality; (b) Bruder produces off road caravans which are unsafe; (c) Bruder’s off road caravans are overpriced and not good value for money; (d) Bruder refuses to assist its customers; (e) The application filed by Bruder was vexatious litigation; (f) Bruder sold a caravan which was severely defective; (g) Bruder was required to provide a refund to the owner of the severely defective caravan; (h) The severely defective caravan sold by Bruder could have killed the owner due to the suspension giving away whilst driving. (i) The orders made on 1 November 2019 are otherwise undisturbed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second order made on 1 November 2019 is set aside.

2. In lieu thereof, it is ordered that the respondent be restrained by herself or her servants or agents from publishing, causing to be published, encouraging, requesting or enabling to be published by any means whatsoever any statements, comments or images with respect to the applicant and the products sold by any means whatsoever including but not limited to on a Facebook page entitled ‘Lemon Caravans and RV’s in Aus’ to the same effect or matters substantially to the same effect as statements, comments or images that:

off road caravans which are defective;Bruder produces (a)

Bruder produces off road caravans which are of poor quality; (b)

Bruder produces off road caravans which are unsafe; (c)

Bruder’s off road caravans are overpriced and not good value for money; (d)

Bruder refuses to assist its customers; (e)

The application filed by Bruder was vexatious litigation; (f)

Bruder sold a caravan which was severely defective; (g)

Bruder was required to provide a refund to the owner of the severely defective caravan; (h)

The severely defective caravan sold by Bruder could have killed the owner due to the suspension giving away whilst driving. (i)

The orders made on 1 November 2019 are otherwise undisturbed.

3.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd is a company that manufactures and sells off-road caravans in Australia. Leigh, an individual, is a dissatisfied former customer of Bruder Expedition. Leigh took to social media, specifically a Facebook page titled "Lemon Caravans and RV’s in Aus," to express her grievances about the quality and safety of the caravans sold by Bruder. Her posts included several defamatory statements about Bruder and its products. Bruder Expedition brought a legal action against Leigh, seeking damages for the defamatory statements and an injunction to prevent further publication of similar content. The case proceeded to a jury trial where it was determined that Leigh had published four defamatory statements about Bruder maliciously, with a reckless disregard for the truth in relation to one of the statements. However, the jury found that only the first and fourth statements had caused Bruder actual damage. Bruder sought injunctive relief to restrain Leigh from making further defamatory statements, including those that had not caused damage.

Following the trial, the court granted Bruder an injunction restraining Leigh from publishing specific statements about Bruder and its products on the Facebook page and any other medium. The injunction covered statements that Bruder's caravans were defective, of poor quality, unsafe, overpriced, and not good value for money, as well as claims that Bruder refused to assist customers, had sold a severely defective caravan, was required to provide a refund for the defective caravan, and that the defective caravan could have caused death. After the injunction was issued, Leigh sought to vary the order that she pay Bruder's costs associated with the proceedings. Bruder had succeeded in its claim for damages and injunctive relief but had not pursued some parts of its pleaded case. Leigh argued that the order for her to pay Bruder's costs should be varied given these circumstances.

Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd v Leigh is a defamation case that has traversed several stages in the Australian court system. The matter first came before the court as a claim for damages and injunctive relief against the defendant, Leigh, for defamatory statements made about Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd, particularly regarding the quality and safety of its products. The case was elected for trial by jury, and the jury found that each of the four defamatory statements was published maliciously, with one statement being published with reckless disregard for its truth. However, the jury determined that only the publication of the first and fourth statements caused the plaintiff actual damage. Despite this, Bruder Expedition sought injunctive relief concerning all four statements. The interrelated nature of the statements and the scope of the relief requested by Bruder Expedition led to a significant focus on whether the court had the jurisdiction in equity to grant such relief.

Subsequently, the case involved a significant procedural aspect concerning costs. Bruder Expedition was successful in its claim for both damages and injunctive relief, leading to an order that the defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding. The defendant then sought to vary this order, arguing that Bruder Expedition had not succeeded on all parts of its pleaded case and had not pressed some aspects. The procedural issue before the court was whether the order should be varied given that Bruder Expedition succeeded on a significant majority of its claims. The court ultimately set aside part of the previous order, replacing it with a more specific injunctive relief tailored to the findings of the jury while otherwise leaving the costs order undisturbed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court has jurisdiction in equity to grant injunctive relief on the terms sought by the plaintiff for statements that the jury found did not cause the plaintiff actual damage.

2. Whether the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff its costs of and incidental to the proceeding should be varied given that the plaintiff did not press parts of its pleaded case despite being successful on a significant majority of its claim.

Held
1. The court concluded that it has jurisdiction in equity to grant injunctive relief on the terms sought by the plaintiff, notwithstanding that the jury found the statements did not cause actual damage. The second order made on 1 November 2019 is set aside and replaced with a modified injunction.

2. The court concluded that the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs should not be varied despite the plaintiff not pressing parts of its pleaded case. The orders made on 1 November 2019 are otherwise undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Bruder Expedition Pty Ltd v Leigh, the court faced the complex issue of whether it had jurisdiction in equity to grant injunctive relief on terms sought by the plaintiff for defamatory statements that, according to the jury's findings, did not cause the plaintiff actual damage. The jury determined that each of the four statements made by the defendant was published maliciously, and in the case of the third statement, with reckless disregard for its truth. However, they found that only the first and fourth statements caused actual damage to the plaintiff. The plaintiff sought an injunction that would extend to all four statements, despite the jury's findings regarding the lack of actual damage caused by the second and third statements.

The court meticulously reviewed the principles of equity and the law of defamation in determining whether to grant the injunctive relief sought. It noted that while injunctive relief in defamation cases is typically aimed at preventing harm, the court must balance this with the need to respect the jury's findings on the actual damages. The court applied the principle that interrelated defamatory statements should be considered together, given the interconnected nature of the claims. It relied on established authorities, including the case of Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd, to affirm that injunctive relief can be granted in equity even in the absence of actual damage if it is necessary to prevent repetition of the harm.

The court reasoned that the malicious nature of the statements, and the jury's finding of reckless disregard for truth in the third statement, warranted injunctive relief to prevent further dissemination of these defamatory claims. By setting aside the original injunctive order and replacing it with a more narrowly tailored order, the court aimed to provide adequate protection against the defamatory statements while respecting the jury's findings on actual damages. The ratio decidendi here is that the court can grant injunctive relief in equity for defamatory statements found to be maliciously published, even if the jury found that not all statements caused actual damage, provided the statements are interrelated.

Regarding the second issue, the court considered whether the order that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs should be varied, given that the plaintiff did not press parts of its pleaded case despite being successful on a significant majority of its claim. The plaintiff was successful in its claim for damages and injunctive relief but did not pursue certain parts of its pleaded case, leading the defendant to argue for a variation in the costs order. The court acknowledged the general rule that costs follow the event, but also recognised the discretionary nature of the court's power to order costs.

The court applied principles from established case law, including the authority of Green v Green, which provides that the court may exercise its discretion to vary the costs order if it appears just to do so. The court weighed the plaintiff's success on the majority of its claims against the fact that it did not press certain parts of its case. It determined that while the plaintiff's success was significant, the court's discretion to vary the costs order was warranted to achieve justice in the circumstances. The ratio decidendi here is that the court has the discretion to vary an order for costs where the plaintiff has succeeded on a significant majority of its claim but did not press certain parts of its case, reflecting a balance between the general rule of costs following the event and the need for justice in individual circumstances.