Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2020] QSC 1

PARTIES:

CIVIL MINING & CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (ABN 18 102 557 175)
(plaintiff)

v

WIGGINS ISLAND COAL EXPORT TERMINAL PTY LTD (ABN 20 131 210 038)
(defendant)

FILE NO:

BS No 6050 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 January 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 September 2019; further submission received 16 October 2019 and 4 November 2019

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.    WICET pay CMC’s costs of the claim.

2.    CMC pay WICET’s costs of the counterclaim.

3.    WICET’s application filed 23 July 2019 and the amended application dated 20 August 2019 are dismissed.

4.    I will hear the parties as to costs of the application and amended application.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – OFFERS OF COMPROMISE, PAYMENTS INTO COURT AND SETTLEMENTS – OFFER OF COMPROMISE OR OFFER TO SETTLE OR CONSENT TO JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULES – GENERALLY – where there was a claim and counterclaim – where the parties exchanged formal offers to settle the claim and counterclaim – where both offers were for an all-up sum that did not distinguish between the claim and counterclaim – where separate judgments were given for the claim and counterclaim – whether either of the offers were more or less favourable than the orders obtained – whether the offers could be compared with the net result of judgments on the claim and counterclaim

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT – where both parties were generally successful on their claims – where the plaintiff achieved a positive net outcome – where the defendant identified various breaches by the plaintiff of the undertaking in r 5 – where the Court had previously made wasted costs orders – where the proceedings concerned a complex construction dispute – whether the “event” was the plaintiff’s securing of a net positive outcome – whether the Court should depart from the general rule as to costs

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) , r 184, r 353, r 360, r 361, r 681, r 684

Anthony Christopher Williams v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (unreported, Federal Court of Australia New South Wales District Registry, General Division, Tamberlin J, 29 November 1995, 30 November 1995), cited
Armstrong v Mitchell-Smith (No 2) [2012] QSC 370, cited
Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Alirezai (No 2) [2002] QSC 205, applied
Balnaves v Smith [2012] QSC 408, considered
BHP Coal Pty Ltd & Ors v O & K Orenstein & Koppel AG & Ors (No 2) [2009] QSC 64, cited
Binaray Pty Ltd (ACN 119 724 211) as Trustee for the Allen Family Trust v RAMS Financial Group Pty Limited [2019] QSC 280, considered
Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Builder Pty Ltd [2018]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Ex... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd (CMC) and Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd (WICET) were involved in a complex construction dispute, with both parties filing claims and counterclaims. The primary focus of the litigation was whether WICET was entitled to damages for delays caused by CMC and whether CMC was entitled to damages for delays caused by WICET. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of formal offers to settle made by both parties. Both offers were for an all-up sum that did not distinguish between the claim and counterclaim. The court had to determine if these offers could be compared with the net result of the judgments on the claim and counterclaim to decide which party was entitled to costs. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the general rule that costs follow the event should be departed from, given that both parties were successful in their respective claims but to varying extents.

The court ruled that neither of the offers could be compared with the net result of the judgments, as the offers were not specific to the claim and counterclaim. Regarding the costs, the court determined that the event in question was CMC’s securing of a net positive outcome. Despite WICET’s breaches of the undertaking in rule 5, the court found that CMC’s overall success entitled it to costs from WICET for the claim, while WICET was awarded costs for its successful counterclaim against CMC. The court also dismissed WICET’s applications for costs and set a future date to hear the parties’ submissions on the costs of these applications.

CMC was ordered to pay WICET’s costs of the counterclaim, while WICET was directed to pay CMC’s costs of the claim. The applications filed by WICET on 23 July 2019 and the amended application dated 20 August 2019 were dismissed. The court scheduled a further hearing to address the costs associated with these applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. WICET pay CMC’s costs of the claim.

2. CMC pay WICET’s costs of the counterclaim.

3. WICET’s application filed 23 July 2019 and the amended application dated 20 August 2019 are dismissed.

4. I will hear the parties as to costs of the application and amended application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd (CMC) and Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd (WICET) were involved in a construction dispute. CMC brought a claim against WICET, and WICET brought a counterclaim against CMC. Both parties exchanged formal offers to settle their respective claims and counterclaims. Each offer was for an all-up sum that did not distinguish between the claim and counterclaim. The court subsequently delivered separate judgments on the claim and counterclaim, resulting in a positive net outcome for CMC. The court had previously made wasted costs orders concerning various breaches by CMC of an undertaking in rule 5. The proceedings were complex and involved a construction dispute.

The matter came before the court following separate judgments on the claim and counterclaim. Both parties had previously exchanged formal offers to settle their claims and counterclaims. The court had already made wasted costs orders due to breaches by CMC of an undertaking in rule 5. The current proceedings involved an application by WICET seeking a departure from the general rule regarding costs, given that both parties achieved a positive net outcome and the proceedings were complex. WICET filed its application on 23 July 2019, which was subsequently amended on 20 August 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether either of the offers to settle were more or less favourable than the net result of the judgments on the claim and counterclaim.
2. Whether the offers could be compared with the net result of the judgments on the claim and counterclaim.
3. Whether the “event” for the purposes of determining costs was the plaintiff’s securing of a net positive outcome.
4. Whether the Court should depart from the general rule as to costs where both parties were generally successful on their claims and the plaintiff achieved a positive net outcome.

Held
1. The court concluded that neither of the offers to settle was more or less favourable than the net result of the judgments on the claim and counterclaim.
2. The court found that the offers could be compared with the net result of the judgments on the claim and counterclaim.
3. The court held that the "event" for the purposes of determining costs was the plaintiff’s securing of a net positive outcome.
4. The court decided that it should depart from the general rule as to costs where both parties were generally successful on their claims and the plaintiff achieved a positive net outcome.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the nature of the offers to settle, noting that both parties had proposed an all-up sum that did not distinguish between the claim and counterclaim. Given this, the court held that neither offer was more or less favourable than the net result obtained in the separate judgments on the claim and counterclaim. The court then considered whether these offers could be compared to the net result of the judgments. It reasoned that since both parties had the opportunity to accept or reject the offers, they were relevant for the purposes of assessing costs. The court established that the "event" for costs was the plaintiff’s securing of a net positive outcome, thereby applying a principle that aligns with the overarching goal of achieving a fair resolution in complex disputes. Finally, the court deliberated on whether to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event, particularly since both parties were generally successful and the plaintiff had achieved a positive net outcome. It concluded that in light of the circumstances, including previous wasted costs orders and the nature of the construction dispute, it was appropriate to depart from the usual cost-following rule. This decision underscores the importance of flexibility in cost allocation in complex cases where multiple factors influence the outcome.