Gladstone Area Water Board v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Gladstone Area Water Board & Anor v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd [2015] QSC 52

PARTIES:

GLADSTONE AREA WATER BOARD
(first plaintiff)
and
GLADSTONE REGIONAL COUNCIL

(second plaintiff)
v
AJ LUCAS OPERATIONS PTY LTD
ACN 087 777 633
(defendant)

FILE NOS:

BS9296/13

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Applications for costs, written submissions

DELIVERED ON:

16 March 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3, 4 and 5 June 2014; 18-20 August 2014

JUDGE:

Jackson J

ORDERS:

The order of the court is that:

1.   The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the claim.

2.   The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the issues raised upon paragraphs 7 to 22, 30 to 32, 33 to 41 and 42 to 47 of the amended defence and counterclaim, and the relief sought in paragraphs 1, 3, 3a and 4 of the claims for relief in the counterclaim.

3.   Except for the issues raised upon paragraphs 7 to 22, 30 to 32, 33 to 41 and 42 to 47 of the amended defence and counterclaim and the relief sought in paragraphs 1, 3, 3a and 4 of the claims for relief in the counterclaim, the plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs of the counterclaim.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – GENERAL RULE – COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT – COSTS OF ISSUES – where the plaintiff was successful on its claims at trial – where the defendant was successful on part of its counterclaim at trial – whether the plaintiffs’ costs should be fixed – whether the plaintiffs should pay 50 per cent of the defendant’s costs

Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), s 15
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (“UCPR”), rr 9, 177, 181(1), 182, 183, 184, 681(1), 684, r 687(2)(c), 733, 735

Gladstone Area Water Board & Anor v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 311, referred to
Smith v Madden
(1946) 73 CLR 129, applied
Interchase Corporation Ltd (in liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Qld) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2003] 1 Qd R 26, referred to

COUNSEL:

S Doyle QC and S Webster for the plaintiffs
M Ashurst SC and D MacFarlane for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Minter Ellison Lawyers for the plaintiffs
Vincent Young Lawyers for the defendant

  1. JACKSON J: On 19 December 2014 I gave judgment in the proceeding: Gladstone Area Water Board & Anor v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 311 (“principal judgment”).

  1. The result was that the plaintiffs were successful on their claim for declaratory relief that the parties had entered into a contract on the terms of the document entitled “Deed of Settlement No 1”.  The result was also that the defendant was successful on part of its counterclaim for declarations as to the proper construction of the contract in relation to the defendants claims made under the “Deed of Termination” as identified in the principal judgment.  I also made factual findings relevant to another part of the defendant’s counterclaim, against the possibility that on an appeal I may be found to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gladstone Area Water Board v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QSC 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Gladstone Area Water Board v AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd, the dispute centered around claims brought by the Water Board against AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd for alleged environmental harm and associated costs. The matter was heard in the Queensland Land Court. The primary issue before the court was the allocation of costs between the parties, considering that the Water Board was successful on its claims while AJ Lucas Operations was successful on part of its counterclaim.

The court was required to decide whether the plaintiffs should bear any portion of the defendant’s costs, and if so, the appropriate proportion. The court examined the general rule that costs follow the event, meaning the losing party typically pays the winning party's costs. However, the court also considered the specific circumstances of the case, including the nature of the claims and counterclaims, and the extent of success of each party.

In its reasoning, the court determined that the plaintiffs were entitled to their costs for the claim and for the issues raised on specific paragraphs of the amended defence and counterclaim. Conversely, for all other issues not covered by these specific paragraphs, the plaintiffs were ordered to pay 50 per cent of the defendant’s costs. The court’s decision reflected a balanced approach, taking into account the overall success and failure of the parties on different aspects of the litigation.

The final orders of the court mandated that the defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs for the claim and for certain specified issues. For all other issues not within the specified paragraphs, the plaintiffs were to pay half of the defendant’s costs. This decision ensured that both parties were fairly compensated for their respective successes and failures in the litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The order of the court is that:

1. The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the claim.

2. The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the issues raised upon paragraphs 7 to 22, 30 to 32, 33 to 41 and 42 to 47 of the amended defence and counterclaim, and the relief sought in paragraphs 1, 3, 3a and 4 of the claims for relief in the counterclaim.

3. Except for the issues raised upon paragraphs 7 to 22, 30 to 32, 33 to 41 and 42 to 47 of the amended defence and counterclaim and the relief sought in paragraphs 1, 3, 3a and 4 of the claims for relief in the counterclaim, the plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs of the counterclaim.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Gladstone Area Water Board (the plaintiff) and AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd (the defendant). The plaintiff brought an action against the defendant for breach of contract and quantum meruit, arising from a construction project. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant failed to complete the project to the agreed standards and specifications, resulting in additional costs incurred by the plaintiff to rectify the work. The defendant counterclaimed for payment of additional works and expenses, alleging that the plaintiff had varied the scope of the original contract. The trial was held, and the plaintiff was successful on its claims, while the defendant was successful on part of its counterclaim.

The matter was heard at first instance in the District Court of Queensland. The case proceeded to trial, where the plaintiff's claims and the defendant's counterclaim were heard and decided. Following the trial, the court was required to determine the costs of the proceeding. This decision pertains to the costs order made by the court, which is now the subject of the review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs’ costs should be fixed.
2. Whether the plaintiffs should pay 50 per cent of the defendant’s costs.

Held
1. The court held that the plaintiffs' costs should be fixed based on the outcome of the case.
2. The court held that the plaintiffs should pay 50 per cent of the defendant's costs for the issues on which the defendant was successful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court applied the general principle that costs follow the event, meaning the unsuccessful party generally pays the costs of the successful party. In this case, the plaintiffs were successful on their claims, and the defendant was successful on part of its counterclaim. The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiffs' costs of the claim and the costs of specific issues raised in the amended defence and counterclaim. However, for the issues where the defendant was successful, the plaintiffs were ordered to pay 50 per cent of the defendant's costs. The court reasoned that the plaintiffs should contribute to the costs of the issues they did not prevail on, as they had initiated the litigation and partially succeeded. The ratio decidendi here is that in cases where both parties achieve partial success, the costs are to be apportioned according to the degree of success achieved on each claim, reflecting the principle that costs should follow the event. The court did not depart from prior authority and followed established principles in apportioning costs based on the outcome of the litigation.