Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 28

PARTIES:                 CIVIL MINING & CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD

(plaintiff)

v

WIGGINS ISLAND COAL EXPORT TERMINAL PTY LTD

(defendant)

FILE NO:                  BS No 6050 of 2013

DIVISION:                Trial Division PROCEEDING:  Review of cost assessment

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:     8 March 2024

DELIVERED AT:     Brisbane

HEARING DATE:    7, 8, 9 and 31 August 2023 JUDGE: Muir J

ORDER:The Order of the Court is that by 4.00pm, Friday 22 March 2024, the parties are to:

(a)  email to my associate, draft Final Orders consistent with my findings (and costs, if those orders can be agreed); and

(b)  if necessary, file and serve written submissions as to costs, no longer than two pages, and deliver a copy of the submissions by email to my associate.

CATCHWORDS:     COSTS – COSTS ASSESSMENT – APPLICATION FOR REVIEW – COSTS ON THE STANDARD BASIS – CLAIM

– COUNTERCLAIM - where the parties alleged errors in the costs assessor’s approach to whether the costs claimed were standard costs necessary or proper for the attainment of justice

- whether the costs statement complies with the requirements of r705 UCPR - whether the notice of objection complies with r706 UCPR - whether the costs assessor provided adequate reasons.

PLAINTIFF APPLICATION FOR REVIEW – COSTS ASSESSOR – WRONGFUL DISALLOWANCE – PREPARATION COSTS – COUNSEL FEES – ADEQUACY OF COSTS ASSESSOR’S REASONS – APPOINTMENT OF COSTS – CARE AND CONDUCT COSTS - whether the

costs assessor wrongly disallowed costs incurred prior to the

commencement of the proceeding - whether the costs assessor provided inadequate reasons - whether certain costs were necessary or proper for the attainment of justice.

whether the costs assessor wrongly disallowed costs relating to expert evidence obtained in the proceeding – whether the costs relating to expert evidence were necessary or proper - whether the costs assessor wrongly disallowed costs paid for various counsel briefed in the proceeding – whether work undertaken prior to the trial as “preparation” could be capped – whether the allowance for “preparation time” should be reduced – whether the costs assessor erred in including certain items in the allowance for preparation fees.

whether the costs assessor erred in reducing counsels fees – whether the costs assessors decision to limit counsels fees should be set aside – whether the costs assessor wrongly disallowed counsels costs associated with a mediation of the proceeding – whether the costs assessor made an error of law by disallowing certain fees incurred to brief new counsel – whether there was a duplication of costs – whether the costs assessor erred in making percentage reductions in counsel fees.

whether the costs assessor was manifestly wrong in exercising his discretion to disallow the claim/counterclaim costs - Whether the costs assessor erred in apportioning the claim/counterclaim costs in the manner that he did - whether the costs assessor failed to give adequate reasons for his decision to exercise…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Ex... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd, the parties contested the costs assessment made by the costs assessor, Mr Roberts. The plaintiff, Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd (CMC), and the defendant, Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd (WICET), both filed applications for review, challenging various aspects of the costs assessment. The primary legal issues for the court to decide involved the accuracy and adequacy of the costs assessor's decisions, including whether he correctly disallowed certain costs, provided sufficient reasons for his decisions, and exercised his discretion appropriately. The court examined whether the costs claimed by CMC and WICET were standard costs necessary or proper for the attainment of justice, and whether the costs statement and notice of objection complied with the relevant rules of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.

The court conducted a detailed analysis of the costs assessment, focusing on the alleged errors by the costs assessor. The judge reviewed the grounds of review presented by both CMC and WICET, which covered a range of topics including pre-commencement costs, expert evidence costs, counsel fees, claim/counterclaim costs, and care and conduct costs. The court evaluated the adequacy of the reasons provided by the costs assessor and whether he erred in his exercise of discretion. The judge found that while the costs assessor made some errors, they were not so significant as to warrant a complete reconsideration of the costs assessment. The court concluded that the costs assessor had exercised his discretion reasonably and provided adequate reasons for his decisions.

The final orders of the court required the parties to draft and submit final orders consistent with the court's findings by a specified deadline, with an option for further written submissions on costs if necessary. The parties were instructed to deliver copies of these submissions to the judge's associate. The court's decision addressed the specific concerns raised by both CMC and WICET, providing clarity on the costs assessment process and the responsibilities of the costs assessor.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Order of the Court is that by 4.00pm, Friday 22 March 2024, the parties are to:

(a) email to my associate, draft Final Orders consistent with my findings (and costs, if those orders can be agreed); and

(b) if necessary, file and serve written submissions as to costs, no longer than two pages, and deliver a copy of the submissions by email to my associate.

Background

Background to the litigation

Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd (CMC) and Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd (WICET) were involved in a legal dispute that resulted in a costs order. The matter initially arose from a contractual disagreement between the parties. CMC initiated proceedings against WICET, and WICET subsequently filed a counterclaim. The case proceeded to a hearing, and on 10 March 2023, the costs assessor issued a final costs certificate amounting to $6,605,189.25. This certificate included $64,163.73 for the costs of the assessment process. Both parties subsequently sought to review the costs order on various grounds, leading to further legal proceedings.

The case originated with the proceedings initiated by CMC against WICET. WICET filed a counterclaim, leading to a comprehensive hearing. Following the hearing, the costs assessor issued a final costs certificate on 10 March 2023. CMC and WICET both filed applications for review of the costs order, challenging various aspects of the costs assessment. These applications were heard and determined by the court, resulting in the current review of the costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Order dated 31 January 2022; Civil Mining and Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2020] QSC 1 (“the Costs Judgment”). WICET’s costs of its counterclaim are yet to be assessed (although a costs statement and notice of objection have been prepared). WICET appealed the costs order. Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd v Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd [2021] QCA 8; (2021) 7 QR 1 (“Costs Appeal Judgment”). On 10 March 2023, Mr Roberts issued his final costs certificate in the amount of$6,605,189.25 (which included $64,163.73 as the costs of the assessment process).6 On 22 December 2022 and 11 April 2023, he provided written reasons for his assessment following requests by WICET to do so. These reasons – which are analysed in more detail during the course of these reasons – are in different forms but included spreadsheets with item-by-item reasoning (with varying levels of detail). By their current applications, the fierce and unyielding battle between the parties continues. Although their respective legal teams thankfully endeavoured to make the review manageable by providing detailed written submissions, working bundles and schedules, and by categorising the issues for determination.7 CMC confined its grounds of review to alleged errors by the costs assessor in his assessment of standard costs under the following five headings:(a)Ground one: Pre-commencement costs;(b)Ground two: Mitchell Brandtman costs;(c)Ground three: Counsel’s costs;(d)Ground four: Claim/counterclaim costs; and(e)Ground five: Care and conduct costs. WICET articulated three alleged errors by the costs assessor on the following grounds:(a)Ground one: The assessor erred in allowing certain cost items for “examining various documents” despite there being inadequate particulars to support any reasonable assessment that the work claimed by those items was necessary or proper;(b)Ground two: The assessor erred in rejecting WICET’s objections in “General Objection 1B” in the Notice of Objection. The costs assessor erred in wrongly rejecting WICET’s dual form of objections; and Letter dated 22 December 2022 from Mr Roberts to the parties; Exhibit SGS-115 to Speechly Affidavit; letter is also marked for identification “K”. Earlier certificates of 9 November 2022 and 9 December 2022 (amending the 9 November certificate) were later agreed by the parties to be void on the basis that they were premature and were replaced by the certificate of 10 March 2023. But before this (on 1 December 2022), WICET requested the costs assessor provide reasons for assessment relevantly about CMC’s various claims for “examining”. That issue is discussed under that heading later in these reasons. The final sum of $6,605,189.25 in the costs certificate of 10 March 2023 is comprised of $1,655,946 for disbursements (including CMC’s share of the costs assessors assessment of the bill of $327,764.80, which was paid in equal proportions by the parties with CMC’s portion then included as part of the disbursement payable by WICET); and$4,717,621 for professional fees; [total of $6,541.025.52] plus the sum of $64,163.73 in respect of the plaintiff’s supplementary costs statement of 16 January 2023 ($37,167.13 for professional fees and$26,996.60 for disbursements).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court thoroughly examined the costs assessment process, noting that the costs assessor, Mr Roberts, issued his final costs certificate on 10 March 2023, amounting to $6,605,189.25. This included $64,163.73 for the costs of the assessment process itself. The court considered CMC's five grounds of review, which centred on alleged errors in the costs assessment, and WICET's three grounds, focusing on the adequacy of particulars and objections. The court found that the costs assessor wrongly disallowed pre-commencement costs, which should have been included in the assessment. The court also determined that the reasons provided by Mr Roberts were inadequate, failing to sufficiently justify his decisions. Certain costs were deemed necessary or proper for the attainment of justice, particularly those related to expert evidence, which were wrongly disallowed. The disallowance of costs for various counsel was also found to be erroneous. Regarding preparation costs, the court ruled that such costs could be capped, and that the allowance for preparation time should not be reduced, though errors in item inclusions within the preparation fees allowance were noted. The court found that the costs assessor erred in reducing counsel's fees and decided that the costs assessor's limitation on counsel's fees should be set aside. Additionally, the disallowance of costs associated with a mediation was deemed incorrect. The court also found an error of law in disallowing fees for briefing new counsel and identified a duplication of costs. Percentage reductions in counsel fees were found to be erroneous, and the apportionment of claim/counterclaim costs was deemed incorrect by the court. The court emphasised that the costs assessor failed to provide adequate reasons for disallowing claim/counterclaim costs and for disallowing care and conduct costs, finding the latter decision manifestly wrong. The court also determined that the costs assessor wrongly sustained an objection leading to the disallowance of the uplift under r 691(5) UCPR and erred in allowing certain cost items for examining documents without adequate particulars. The court concluded that the rejection of certain objections was erroneous and that these issues warranted the referral of specific cost items back to the costs assessor for reconsideration. Finally, the court found errors in the costs assessor's decision relating to the liability for costs of the assessment and his fees, noting that an incorrect consideration was taken into account.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's emphasis on the necessity for adequate reasons in costs assessments, the proper inclusion of pre-commencement and expert-related costs, and the disallowance of improperly reduced counsel fees and duplicated costs. The court's decision highlights the importance of detailed and justifiable reasoning in costs assessments, the proper treatment of specific types of costs, and the consequences of errors in disallowing certain costs and objections. The decision also underscores the court's role in ensuring that costs assessments are conducted fairly and in accordance with legal principles.