Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 3) [2021] QSC 69

PARTIES:

WIESAC PTY LTD
ACN 112 764 584

(first plaintiff/first respondent)

and
MURPHY SCHMIDT SOLICITORS (A Firm)

(second plaintiff/second respondent)
v
INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED

ACN 000 016 722
(defendant/applicant)

FILE NO:

No 538 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

16 April 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 February 2021

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.    The certificate of Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam dated 10 December 2020 (Assessor’s Certificate) is varied to allow the following additional amounts for disbursements:

(a)      $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2016 of the defendant’s amended costs statement dated 2 March 2020 (Costs Statement);

(b)      $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2052 of the Costs Statement;

(c)       $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2087 of the Costs Statement;

(d)      $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2149 of the Costs Statement.

2.    The decision at Item 3 of the Assessor’s Certificate is set aside and referred to Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam for reconsideration consequential upon the variation in paragraph 1 above.

3.    The decision at Item 6 of the Assessor’s Certificate is set aside and referred to Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam for reconsideration consequential upon the variations in paragraphs 1 and 2 above.

4.    The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs of the application on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – TAXATION AND OTHER FORMS OF ASSESSMENT – PARTICULAR ITEMS – COUNSEL FEES – NUMBER OF COUNSEL – TWO COUNSEL – where there was a three-day trial of a claim under an insurance policy arising out of the 2011 Brisbane floods – where liability and quantum were live issues at trial – where the defendant engaged senior and junior counsel at trial – where both counsel examined and cross-examined witnesses – where the defendant was successful at trial – where the costs assessor disallowed junior counsel’s fees for the entirety of the trial – whether the costs of junior counsel were  necessary and proper for the attainment of justice or for enforcing or defending the defendant’s rights – whether the costs assessor’s decision to disallow those costs was manifestly wrong

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 702, r 721, r 738, r 742

Jovanovski v Tafcom Contractors Pty Ltd (in liq) (Supreme Court of Queensland, Dowsett J, 19 March 1993), considered
Pinehurst Nominees Pty Ltd v Coeur De Lion Investments Pty Ltd [2015] QSC 122, applied
Stanley v Phillips (1966) 115 CLR 470; [1966] HCA 24, applied

W & A Gilbey Ltd v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd [1964] NSWR 527, cited

COUNSEL:

P Franco QC for the applicant

M P Williams for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Carter Newell Lawyers for the applicant
Synkronos Legal for the respondents

  1. By amended application, the defendant seeks a review of a decision included in a costs assessor’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wiesac Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, filed a claim against Insurance Australia Ltd, the defendant, arising from damage caused by the 2011 Brisbane floods. After a three-day trial, Davis J dismissed the plaintiff's claims and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs on the standard basis. The defendant subsequently filed a costs statement, which the plaintiff objected to, leading to a costs assessment. The plaintiff challenged the costs assessor's decision to disallow the fees of the defendant's junior counsel for appearing at the trial. The court was required to determine whether the costs of the junior counsel were necessary and proper for the attainment of justice or for enforcing or defending the defendant's rights.

The court considered the relevant rules of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, specifically rule 702(2) which provides that a costs assessor must allow all costs necessary or proper for the attainment of justice or for enforcing or defending the rights of the party whose costs are being assessed. The court noted that the distinction between "necessary" and "proper" is significant and that the test is to be applied by reference to the circumstances that existed when the costs were incurred. The court also considered rule 721 which provides a list of factors that a costs assessor must consider when assessing costs. The court found that the costs of the junior counsel were necessary and proper for the attainment of justice or for enforcing or defending the defendant's rights and that the costs assessor's decision to disallow those costs was manifestly wrong.

The court varied the certificate of the costs assessor to allow the fees of the junior counsel and set aside the decision at Item 3 and Item 6 of the Assessor’s Certificate. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the application on the standard basis. The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the circumstances that existed when the costs were incurred and the distinction between "necessary" and "proper" when assessing costs on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The certificate of Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam dated 10 December 2020 (Assessor’s Certificate) is varied to allow the following additional amounts for disbursements:

(a) $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2016 of the defendant’s amended costs statement dated 2 March 2020 (Costs Statement);

(b) $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2052 of the Costs Statement;

(c) $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2087 of the Costs Statement;

(d) $3,800 of the amount claimed at Item 2149 of the Costs Statement.

2. The decision at Item 3 of the Assessor’s Certificate is set aside and referred to Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam for reconsideration consequential upon the variation in paragraph 1 above.

3. The decision at Item 6 of the Assessor’s Certificate is set aside and referred to Mr Lawrence Clarence Ronald Hallam for reconsideration consequential upon the variations in paragraphs 1 and 2 above.

4. The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs of the application on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 June 2018, Davis J gave judgment dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims.[1][1]Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Limited [2019] 1 Qd R 198 (Trial Judgment). On 9 August 2018, his Honour ordered that the plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on the standard basis.[2] On 21 January 2019, the defendant delivered its Form 60A Costs Statement.[3] On 18 February 2019 the plaintiffs provided a Form 61 Notice of Objection to the Costs Statement.[4] On 15 November 2019, the defendant provided a response to the plaintiffs’ Notice of Objection to the Costs Statement.[5] The costs assessor was appointed on 28 February 2020[6] and delivered his Certificate of Assessment to the parties on 10 December 2020.[7][2]Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Limited (No 2) [2018] QSC 171.[3]Affidavit of Patrick Gerald Mead filed 18 December 2020, CD48, paragraph 6.[4]Affidavit of Patrick Gerald Mead filed 18 December 2020, CD48, paragraph 7.[5]Affidavit of Patrick Gerald Mead filed 18 December 2020, CD48, paragraph 9.[6]Order of Registrar dated 28 February 2020, CD45.[7]Affidavit of Patrick Gerald Mead filed 18 December 2020, CD48, paragraphs 13 and 15. The decision that is sought to be reviewed is the costs assessor’s decision to disallow the cost of the defendant’s junior counsel for appearance at the trial. The defendant seeks to vary the certificate by allowing junior counsel’s fees, which are items 2016, 2052, 2087 and 2149 in the Costs Statement. If that relief is granted, it is accepted that the discretion in relation to the costs of the assessment will also need to be revisited.[8][8]Applicant’s Written Submissions filed by leave on 19 February 2021, paragraph 7.The relevant rules of the UCPR The costs assessor was required to assess costs on the standard basis. Rule 702(2) provides that, when assessing costs on the standard basis, a costs assessor must allow all costs necessary or proper for the attainment of justice or for enforcing or defending the rights of the party whose costs are being assessed. A distinction is drawn between the words “necessary” and “proper”; they are not interchangeable.[9] The test is to be applied by reference to the circumstances that existed when the costs were incurred,[10] and the defendant should not be penalised for incurring costs that were reasonable and proper at the time but which, with the benefit of hindsight, may not have been strictly necessary given the eventual course of the proceeding.[11][9]W & A Gilbey Ltd v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd [1964] NSWR 527, 533 (Asprey J).[10]The Beach Retreat Pty Ltd v Mooloolaba Marina Ltd [2009] 2 Qd R 356, [18]-[19] (Martin J), citing, inter alia, W & A Gilbey Ltd v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd [1964] NSWR 527, 535 (Asprey J).[11]W & A Gilbey Ltd v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd [1964] NSWR 527, 535 (Asprey J). Rule 721 provides:“In assessing costs, a costs assessor must consider the following –(a)any other fees and allowances payable to the solicitor or counsel for other items in the same proceeding;(b)the nature and importance of the proceeding;(c)the amount involved;(d)the principle involved;(e)the interests of the parties;(f)the person who is to pay the costs, or the fund or estate out of which the costs are to be paid;(g)the general conduct and cost of the proceeding;(h)any other relevant circumstances.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established