Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wiesac Pty Ltd & Anor v Insurance Australia Limited [2018] QSC 123

PARTIES:

WIESAC PTY LTD
(first plaintiff)
MURPHYSCHMIDT SOLICITORS (A FIRM)

(second plaintiff)

v
INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
ABN 11 000 016 722

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 538 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

1 June 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5, 6, 7 December 2017

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDER:

1.    The emails between the parties and my Associate dated 2 March 2018 and 5 March 2018 are collectively admitted and marked exhibit 8.

2.    The claims of both plaintiffs are dismissed.

3.    I will hear the parties on costs.

CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE – PROPERTY AND PECUNIARY LOSS INSURANCE  – CONDITIONS, WARRANTIES AND EXCEPTIONS – EXCLUSION CLAUSES – FLOOD DAMAGE – where the plaintiffs had insurance in relation to a property in the Brisbane CBD which was affected by the 2011 Brisbane floods – where the basement of the insured premises was inundated by water through drainage pipes – where the insurance policy excluded claims for loss “occasioned by or happening through” flood – where flood was defined as “the inundation of normally dry land water escaping or released from the normal confines of any natural water course or lake” – whether the land was normally dry land – whether the water was escaping or released from the normal confines of the river – whether the flood exclusion defeated the plaintiffs’ claim

INSURANCE – THE POLICY – CLAIMS GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs’ insurance covered loss consequential to property damage – where the insurance policy included a method for calculation of indemnity for loss of earnings – where the evidence was unavailable to apply that method – whether the indemnity could be ordered

Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 7, s 57

Caine v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (2008) 15 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-756, cited
CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1994] NSWCA 359; (1995) 8 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-232, applied
Coalex Pty Ltd v Commercial Union Assurance Co of Australia Ltd (1988) 5 ANZ Ins Cas 60-858, applied
Countrywide Finance Ltd v State Insurance Ltd [1993] 3 NZLR 745, cited
Eastern Suburbs Leagues Club Ltd v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Australia Ltd [2003] QSC 413, cited
Elilade Pty Ltd v Nonpareil Pty Ltd (2002) 124 FCR 1, followed
Fink v Fink (1946) 74 CLR 127, cited
Freshmark Ltd v Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Australia) Ltd [1994] 2 Qd R 390, cited
Hams & Anor v CGU Insurance Limited (2002) 12 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-525, applied
Hungerfords v Walker (1989) 171 CLR 125, applied
LMT Surgical Pty Ltd v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2014] 2 Qd R 118, distinguished
McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd (2000) 203 CLR 579, cited
McCarthy v St Paul International Insurance Co Ltd (2007) 157 FCR 402, cited
Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Aust) v Rowprint Services (Victoria) Pty Ltd [1998] VSCA 147, followed
New Zealand…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wiesac Pty Ltd v Insurance Australia Limited concerned a property in the Brisbane CBD affected by the 2011 Brisbane floods. The plaintiffs sought damages under a property and pecuniary loss insurance policy but were denied due to an exclusion clause for flood damage. The basement of the insured premises was inundated by water through drainage pipes, which the policy defined as "the inundation of normally dry land water escaping or released from the normal confines of any natural water course or lake." The central issue was whether the basement constituted "normally dry land" and whether the water was "escaping" from the river's normal confines. The court examined the definition of "escape" and concluded that water must still be in the act of escaping to trigger the exclusion clause. Since river water entered the subterranean soils and basement, pushing groundwater into the basement, the exclusion applied. The court also noted that while local runoff entering the basement was not flood damage, it was still excluded if forced in by river water. Regarding the business interruption claim, the court found that the policy provided for consequential loss, but the method for calculating the indemnity was unavailable due to missing evidence. The court admitted certain emails as evidence and dismissed the plaintiffs' claims, reserving the issue of costs for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The emails between the parties and my Associate dated 2 March 2018 and 5 March 2018 are collectively admitted and marked exhibit 8.

2. The claims of both plaintiffs are dismissed.

3. I will hear the parties on costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

“Escaping” is obviously “the act of the escape”.[143] Mr Ashton QC’s submission that water is not “escaping” but has “escaped” once it leaves the confines of the river must be rejected. Only water which has actually left the confines of the river can do damage and cause loss, relevantly by “inundating normally dry land”. Therefore, for the exclusion clause to have any operation to exclude loss caused by escaping water, the water must be, for the purposes of the clause, still in the act of escaping after leaving the confines of the river. The point at which water ceases to be “escaping” and has “escaped” obviously is a matter of fact. However, here all the experts say that river water entered the subterranean soils between the pipes and the basement wall and entered the basement. That water was therefore “escaping from the confines of [the river]” and inundated “normally dry land”, namely the subterranean soils and the basement of the premises.[143] The Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd edition, Clarendon Press.Conclusions on the exclusion clause In the context of the present case, the exclusion clause operates as follows. The damage to the basement was caused by water from various sources:1.River water in the pipes;2.Local runoff in the pipes; and3.Groundwater in the subterranean soils between the pipes and the basement. The river water entered the subterranean soils (“normally dry land”), and the basement (“normally dry land”), and in the process pushed groundwater into the basement. The river water was water “escaping the confines of [the river]”. The entry of the river water into subterranean soils and the basement was an inundation of the two places. Damage done by the river water and the groundwater pushed into the basement by the river water was damage “occasioned by or happening through” the escaping river water. Damage done by local runoff entering the basement is not damage caused by “flood”,[144] but on a proper construction of the flood exclusion, the exclusion is available to the defendant. [144] Except to the extent that local runoff was forced into the basement by river water. The plaintiffs’ claims are excluded by the flood exclusion. I should, though, deal with the other issues raised in the case. What was the amount of the loss which was suffered by the second plaintiff by way of business interruption resulting from the inundation of the basement in January 2011? There is no contest that the second plaintiff’s practice was interrupted by the damage caused by water entering the basement. The disagreement[145] is as to the quantum of the loss.[146][145] Apart from the question of the flood exclusion. [146] Agreed list of issues at [18]. The policy responds to the business interruption through “Section 2: Consequential Loss”. The “Basis of Settlement” provision dictates the calculation of any indemnity. This and all the relevant provisions are set out in paragraphs [50] to [62] of these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established