Prosser v AMP General Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Prosser & Anor v AMP General Insurance Ltd [2003] NTSC 80

PARTIES:PROSSER, ROBERT DOUGLAS and

PROSSER, DAWN MARIE

v

AMP GENERAL INSURANCE LTD

(ACN 008 405 632)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  CIVIL

FILE NO:No. 103 of 2000 (20012553)

DELIVERED:  22 JULY 2003

HEARING DATES:  16, 17 JUNE 2003

JUDGMENT OF:  ANGEL J

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs:Dr J De Koning

Defendant:J Reeves QC

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs:Ward Keller

Defendant:Paul Maher

Judgment category classification:           C

Judgment ID Number:  ang200306

Number of pages:  8

ang200306

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Prosser & Anor  v AMP General Insurance Ltd [2003] NTSC 80

No. 102 of 2000 (20012553)

BETWEEN:

ROBERT DOUGLAS PROSSER and

DAWN MARIE PROSSER

Plaintiffs

AND:

AMP GENERAL INSURANCE LTD

(ACN 008 405 632)

Defendant

CORAM:      ANGEL J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 22 July 2003)

  1. At about 6.30 pm on 26 January 1998 the house on the land of the plaintiffs at Lot 4381 Shadforth Road Katherine was inundated with water from the rear of the premises.  The water had been pooling to the rear of the plaintiffs’ block for some hours previously and the level had continued to rise during the afternoon.  When Mr Prosser eventually left the building at about 8.30 pm there was water some 300 mm deep throughout the house.  As a consequence the house and contents were damaged.  At the time the property and contents were insured with the defendant pursuant to a “Commonsense Farmers Insurance Policy” that insured the dwelling and contents for loss destruction and damage caused by storm or tempest or rain water “being rain falling naturally from the sky including rain water run–off over the surface of the land” but did not include loss, destruction or damage “by FLOOD being the inundation of normally dry land by water escaping or released from the normal confines of any natural water course or lake whether or not altered or modified or of any reservoir, canal or dam.”

  1. The plaintiffs sue for indemnity in respect of the damage to their premises and contents which they say was caused by storm or tempest or rain water.  The defendant says that any loss or damage to the plaintiffs’ property was caused by flood rather than storm or tempest or rain water, and flood being an excluded event under the policy it is therefore not liable to indemnify the plaintiffs.

  2. Photos numbered 4 and 5 comprising part of Exhibit P10 depict water pooling amongst mango trees to the rear of the plaintiffs’ property on 26 January 1998 sometime around 1 to 2 pm that afternoon.  According to Mr Prosser, whose evidence I accept, the water steadily increased in area extending further and further across the rear of the plaintiffs’ block and towards the house.  By 4 pm that afternoon the area of pooling had increased considerably.  The plaintiffs were concerned for a neighbour whose property was on lower lying land.  Mr Prosser arranged for the evacuation of his neighbour and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prosser v AMP General Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NTSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Robert Douglas Prosser and Dawn Marie Prosser, sought indemnity from the defendant, AMP General Insurance Ltd, for damages to their property and contents caused by water inundation. The property, located on Lot 4381 Shadforth Road in Katherine, was inundated with water on 26 January 1998. The plaintiffs' property was insured under a policy that covered loss, destruction, or damage caused by storm, tempest, or rainwater, but explicitly excluded flood. The defendant denied liability, arguing that the water inundation was caused by flood rather than rainwater, and thus fell outside the policy coverage. The court had to determine whether the inundation was due to rainwater run-off or flood, and whether the defendant was liable under the insurance policy.

The court examined the evidence, including expert hydrological evidence and photographs, to determine the cause of the inundation. The experts agreed that the rainfall alone was insufficient to cause the inundation. Instead, the inundation was a combination of rainwater run-off and sinkhole groundwater, dammed by the swollen Katherine River. The court accepted that the Katherine River flood level was an effective cause of the inundation. However, because the inundation resulted from concurrent causes, one covered by the policy (rainwater) and one excluded (flood), the court found that the defendant was not liable for the damages under the policy. This decision followed established case law that where there are concurrent effective or proximate causes, one covered and the other excluded by the policy, the insurer is not liable.

The court dismissed the plaintiffs' claim for indemnity, holding that the defendant was not liable to indemnify the plaintiffs for the damage caused by the water inundation. The court's judgment concluded that the plaintiffs' loss was caused by an event within the terms of the policy, but the concurrent cause of the Katherine River overflowing its banks excluded the defendant's liability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established