McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GAUDRON, KIRBY, HAYNE AND CALLINAN JJ

HARRY KEVIN McCANN (for himself and
representing each of the persons identified in
Schedule 1 to the notice of appeal)   APPELLANT

AND

SWITZERLAND INSURANCE
AUSTRALIA LIMITED & ORS  RESPONDENTS

McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Limited
[2000] HCA 65
14 December 2000
S229/1999

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation:

A J Meagher SC with I McN Jackman for the appellant (instructed by Allen Allen & Hemsley)

N J Young QC with J T Gleeson for the respondents (instructed by Phillips Fox)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ.   The issue in this appeal concerns the meaning and effect of an exclusion clause in each of three policies of professional indemnity insurance.

  2. The appellants, partners in the legal firm of Allen Allen & Hemsley ("Allens"), incurred civil liability to a client, Nauru Phosphate Royalties Trust, ("the Nauru Trust" or "the Trust"), in an amount which included the sum of $US8.7 million.  The dispute concerns part of that sum, $US8.55 million.  For reasons that will appear, there is no dispute as to the balance of $US150,000.  The respondents, the insurers under the policies, are liable to indemnify the appellants against loss arising from any claims made against them during the relevant period in respect of any description of civil liability incurred in connection with their practice.  The Nauru Trust made such a claim.  It was settled on terms which gave Allens an entitlement to indemnity, subject to what follows.

  3. Each policy contained an exclusion clause in the following terms:

    "5(f)This Insurance shall not indemnify the Assured in respect of any liability:-

    …

    (v)brought about by the dishonest or fraudulent act or omission of the Assured including any Partner or former Partner of the Assured.  Save that this exclusion shall not apply to liability arising out of any claim brought about by the dishonest or fraudulent act or omission of any person employed in connection with the Practice [including any articled clerk and any solicitor who is a Consultant or Associate with the Firm];

    …"

  4. Allens had a London office.  At the relevant time, a partner (now a former partner) of the firm, Mr Powles, was in charge of that office.  The sum of $US8.7 million was paid by the Nauru Trust into a bank account in London in the name of Allens which Mr Powles maintained and controlled without the knowledge of his partners.  The Trust erroneously believed it was an Allens trust account.  Mr Powles and two other persons arranged between themselves to take secret commissions in respect of the transaction in a total of $US150,000.  Mr Powles later applied the sum of $US150,000 for that fraudulent purpose.  To that extent, Allens' entitlement to indemnity is excluded by cl 5(f).  The issue is as to the balance of $US8.55 million; but the fraudulent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] HCA 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in *McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd* concerned a claim under a professional indemnity insurance policy. The appellant, representing the interests of the law firm Allens, sought to recover a loss suffered by the firm due to its civil liability to the Nauru Phosphate Royalties Trust ("Nauru Trust"). The respondent insurer sought to rely on an exclusion clause in the policy, which excluded liability brought about by the dishonest or fraudulent act or omission of the assured. The High Court of Australia was required to determine whether the Nauru Trust's loss, arising from the actions of an Allens partner, Ronald Adrian Powles, was "brought about by [a] dishonest or fraudulent act or omission" on his part, thereby entitling the insurer to rely on the exclusion.

The central legal issue was the interpretation and application of the exclusion clause. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether Mr Powles' conduct constituted a dishonest or fraudulent act or omission for the purposes of the policy. This involved examining whether his actions, including the unauthorised opening and operation of a US dollar account, his involvement in attempts to purchase prime bank instruments, his arrangement to receive a secret commission, and his concealment of information from the Nauru Trust, were sufficiently dishonest or fraudulent to trigger the exclusion. The Court also considered the relationship between the dishonest conduct and the loss suffered by the Nauru Trust, and whether the exclusion clause was concerned with the proximate cause of the loss or the dishonest conduct itself.

The High Court, in dismissing the appeal, affirmed the findings of the Court of Appeal. The Court held that Mr Powles' conduct, including authorising the transfer of $US8.55 million out of the US dollar account with knowledge that it placed the Nauru Trust's moneys at considerable risk, constituted dishonest breaches of his trust and fiduciary duties. This conduct was characterised as deliberately concealing information and the truth from the Nauru Trust, failing to disclose his personal commission, and participating in arrangements for others to receive secret commissions. The Court emphasised that the exclusion clause was concerned with liability brought about by dishonest conduct, not solely with the direct or proximate cause of the loss. Therefore, Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust was indeed brought about by Mr Powles' dishonest breaches of duty, entitling the insurer to rely on the exclusion. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

It is not in issue that, for the purposes of the policy, Allens suffered a loss by reason of their civil liability to the Nauru Phosphate Royalties Trust ("Nauru Trust"). Nor is it in issue that that liability arose directly out of the acts and omissions of one of their partners, Ronald Adrian Powles. The only question in this appeal is whether their liability was "brought about by [a] dishonest or fraudulent act or omission" on his part.The facts A detailed account of the facts is set out in other judgments and they are repeated only to the extent necessary to make clear my reasons for holding that this appeal should be dismissed. In 1989, Mr Powles became Allens' resident partner in London. By that stage, he had already defrauded a number of his clients. His fraudulent behaviour continued in London in 1990 and 1991 and, as Hunter J found at first instance[8], "the extent of [his] defalcations as at the end of 1991 ... left him in need of several million dollars, if his frauds were to remain concealed."[8]McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, 26 June 1998. Allens maintained two bank accounts in London for the working needs of their London office. Neither was to be used as a trust account. Without authority from his partners, Mr Powles opened a third account in Allens' name in December 1990. That account has come to be known as "the US dollar account" and it is convenient to refer to it as such. The account was not a trust account and Mr Powles had no authority from his partners to open it or operate upon it. Mr Powles used the US dollar account for a number of financial transactions, including attempts to purchase a prime bank instrument ("pbi"). Many, if not all, of those attempts were undertaken at the request of or on the instructions of a Mr Madden or companies with which Mr Madden was associated. One of those companies was Linpar Limited ("Linpar"). None of the attempts to purchase a pbi was successful and, in some cases, money was lost. Moreover, in the course of those attempts, Mr Powles became aware of the existence of fraudsters operating in the pbi market. From August 1991, there was an arrangement between Mr Powles and Mr Madden that, in relation to any purchase of a pbi, Allens would be paid for legal services and Mr Powles would be paid $US100,000 for his "personal contribution". At first instance, Hunter J characterised that arrangement as one involving a "secret commission" payable to Mr Powles and, in that respect, a fraud on his partners. Some time prior to December 1991, Mr Madden and Linpar put forward a proposal, or, perhaps, a series of proposals, to the Nauru Trust for it to invest in the pbi market. The proposal that ultimately evolved was one in which Linpar would purchase pbis with moneys paid by the Nauru Trust to Allens' London office. The Nauru Trust was given details of the number of the US dollar account for that purpose. The Nauru Trust ultimately decided to proceed with Mr Madden's proposal. For that purpose, it caused $US8.7 million to be paid into the US dollar account on 23 December 1991. That money was to be used for the purchase by Linpar of a pbi in the form of a standby letter of credit with a face value of $US10 million. The letter of credit was to be sold within a short period and the proceeds "rolled over" in successive transactions in the pbi market. It was also envisaged that other payments would be made by the Nauru Trust to the US dollar account and would be utilised in the same manner.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ GAUDRON J KIRBY J HAYNE J
Before leaving the decision at first instance, it is important to note one other finding made by Hunter J. The finding was in these terms:"I accept that, had [Mr] Powles informed the Nauruan Trust that (a) doubt hung over the ability of Linpar to effect the transaction, or (b) he was not aware of any transaction of a like nature in which Linpar had successfully obtained a prime bank instrument, or (c) he had been associated with numerous attempts to obtain such an instrument, all without success, and in some cases with the loss of fees, the Nauruan Trust would not have been interested in parting with its funds in the first place."However, his Honour seemed to think that that was of no relevance to the issue to be decided because "that was true of [Mr] Powles' conduct long before 17 January 1992." Seemingly, his Honour was of the view that the act giving rise to Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust occurred on that day when the sum of $US8.55 million was transferred out of the US dollar account.The decision of the Court of Appeal The Court of Appeal held that Hunter J was correct to find that Mr Powles' conduct in authorising payment of the $US8.55 million out of the US dollar account was dishonest[9]. However, the Court of Appeal went further. It was of the view that Mr Powles knew that, in so doing, "he was placing the Trust's moneys at considerable risk."[10] Additionally, the Court of Appeal held:"He treated the Trust in what can only be seen as a blatantly dishonest fashion, deliberately concealing information from it and intentionally concealing the truth in his reports to it. He made no disclosure to the Trust about the commissions he stood to make. [Mr] Powles also participated in arrangements for others to receive secret commissions out of his bank account. This was also kept from the Trust."[11]This conduct was characterised by the Court of Appeal as a breach of trust and a breach of fiduciary duty, which breaches were held to be "dishonest and probably fraudulent."[12][9]Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd v McCann (1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446.[10](1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446 at 75,117 [65].[11](1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446 at 75,118 [69].[12](1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446 at 75,118 [70]. The Court of Appeal further held that Allens' liability was brought about by Mr Powles' dishonest breaches of his trust and fiduciary duties "[i]n allowing the funds to leave the English banking system on or about 15 January 1992, in the circumstances that [he] did"[13]. In so holding, the Court of Appeal emphasised that the exclusion clause is relevantly concerned with liability brought about by dishonest conduct, not loss caused by that conduct[14]. And that being so, there was no basis for treating that clause as concerned simply with dishonest conduct which is the real or proximate cause of the loss covered by the policy.[13](1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446 at 75,121 [92].[14](1999) 10 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61-446 at 75,121 [91].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, GAUDRON J, KIRBY J, HAYNE J

The case of McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd primarily concerns the interpretation and application of an exclusion clause within a professional indemnity policy, specifically whether it excludes liability arising from dishonest or fraudulent acts or omissions of the assured. The Court of Appeal found that the dishonest conduct of Ronald Adrian Powles, a partner at Allens, resulted in a loss to the Nauru Phosphate Royalties Trust, leading to Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust. The exclusion clause in question sought to exclude liability "brought about by [a] dishonest or fraudulent act or omission" on the part of the assured.

The Court of Appeal began by confirming Hunter J's finding that Mr Powles' conduct was indeed dishonest. The dishonest acts included authorizing the payment of $US8.55 million out of the US dollar account, which was used for the purchase of a prime bank instrument. The Court of Appeal went further by characterising Mr Powles' actions as a breach of trust and a breach of fiduciary duty, both of which were "dishonest and probably fraudulent." This conduct was deemed to have placed the Trust's moneys at considerable risk, as Mr Powles concealed information and intentionally misled the Trust.

In addressing the first major issue of whether the exclusion clause excludes liability arising from dishonest or fraudulent acts or omissions of the assured, the Court of Appeal relied on the principle that the exclusion clause is relevantly concerned with liability brought about by dishonest conduct, not simply the loss caused by such conduct. The Court held that the exclusion clause was intended to cover instances where the assured's liability arose directly from their dishonest conduct, rather than merely the loss that resulted from such conduct. This interpretation was supported by the policy's language and the context in which the exclusion clause was inserted.

The second issue concerned whether Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust arose directly out of the dishonest or fraudulent acts or omissions of Ronald Adrian Powles. The Court of Appeal held that Allens' liability was indeed brought about by Mr Powles' dishonest breaches of his trust and fiduciary duties. This was based on the fact that Mr Powles allowed the funds to leave the English banking system under circumstances that were dishonest. The Court emphasised that the liability arose directly from Mr Powles' actions and not from some other source.

The third issue was whether the dishonest or fraudulent acts or omissions of Ronald Adrian Powles were the proximate cause of the loss to the Nauru Trust. The Court of Appeal found that these acts were the proximate cause of the loss, as they led directly to the funds being placed at risk and ultimately lost. Mr Powles' conduct in authorizing the payment of the funds out of the US dollar account was identified as the key event that triggered the loss, making his dishonest conduct the proximate cause.

The fourth issue was whether the dishonest breaches of trust and fiduciary duty by Ronald Adrian Powles were the cause of Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust. The Court of Appeal confirmed that these breaches were indeed the cause of Allens' liability. The Court held that by allowing the funds to leave the banking system under the circumstances described, Mr Powles' actions directly brought about Allens' liability to the Nauru Trust.

Finally, the Court of Appeal clarified that the exclusion clause is concerned with liability brought about by dishonest conduct, rather than merely the loss caused by that conduct. This interpretation was pivotal in the Court's reasoning, as it distinguished the scope of the exclusion clause from simply the cause of the loss. By focusing on the liability arising from dishonest conduct, the Court ensured that the exclusion clause was applied in a manner consistent with the policy's purpose.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an exclusion clause in a professional indemnity policy, which excludes liability "brought about by [a] dishonest or fraudulent act or omission" of the assured, is relevantly concerned with the liability arising from such conduct, rather than simply the loss caused by that conduct. This interpretation ensures that the exclusion clause is applied in a manner that aligns with the policy's purpose and the context in which the clause was inserted. The Court of Appeal's decision departed from a narrower interpretation of the exclusion clause by emphasizing that it covers liability arising from dishonest conduct, not just the loss resulting from such conduct.