| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | Not Restricted |
AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL COURT
INSURANCE LIST
S ECI 2021 03192
BETWEEN:
| PRINCESS THEATRE PTY LTD (ACN 007 307 851) (ATF PRINCESS THEATRE DISCRETIONARY TRUST) & ORS (according to the Schedule attached) | Plaintiffs |
| and | |
| ANSVAR INSURANCE LIMITED (ACN 007 216 506) | Defendant |
---
JUDGE: | M Osborne J |
WHERE HELD: | Melbourne |
DATE OF HEARING: | 27 February 2024 – 29 February 2024; 1 March 2024; 7 March 2024 |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 25 June 2024 |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | Princess Theatre Pty Ltd & Ors v Ansvar Insurance Limited |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2024] VSC 363 |
---
INSURANCE – Business interruption insurance – COVID-19 pandemic – Whether insured is entitled to indemnity under industrial special risks policy for losses sustained due to closure of businesses – Infectious disease extension - Hybrid clauses – Infectious disease clauses – Closure of premises by order of or upon advice from a statutory or government authority – Outbreak within 25 kilometres - Meaning of ‘following’ – Whether ‘following’ the outbreak there was an order - Swiss Re International SE v LCA Marrickville Pty Ltd (2021) 394 ALR 461 - LCA Marrickville Pty Ltd v Swiss Re International SE (2022) 290 FCR 435 – Indemnity granted.
INSURANCE – Sublimits – Whether infectious disease extension subject to sublimit – Whether sublimit applies to each venue or across the whole policy - Whether theatre hire fees constitute ‘rent’ under policy such that ‘rent receivable’ sublimit applies – ‘location of risk’ sublimit.
CONTRACT – Insurance contract – Principles of construction – Context – Reading contract as a whole – Perspective of the objective reader of a contract – Contra proferentem rule.
EQUITY – Equitable remedies – Rectification – Mistake - Common intention – State of mind of broker, insurer and insured – Evidence as to intention – Mistaken apprehension of the legal position - No convincing proof provided to prove alleged common intention – Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) – Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth) - Declined relief.
LOSS –Appropriate methodology for calculating losses – When does the loss period end - Whether insured must account for JobKeeper payments and other governmental support during COVID-19 pandemic in calculating loss – application of underinsurance clause.
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Plaintiffs | C M Archibald KC with Dr N M Petrie | Elit Lawyers |
| For the Defendant | Dr A Hanak KC with X Teo and J B Waters | MinterEllison |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction........................................................................................................................................ 1
Policy Terms.................................................................................................................................. 5
Principles of Construction.............................................................................................................. 14
Coverage under the Extension....................................................................................................... 15
The LCA Marrickville Cases........................................................................................................ 19
The Extension.............................................................................................................................. 25
The Marriner Group Submission.............................................................................................. 25
Outbreak within 25 kilometres........................................................................................ 25
‘Following’.......................................................................................................................... 26
Order, consultation or advice.......................................................................................... 26
Closure................................................................................................................................ 26
The Insurer’s Submission........................................................................................................... 28
Closure................................................................................................................................ 28
‘Following’.......................................................................................................................... 29
Consultation or advice...................................................................................................... 29
Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 30
Rectification...................................................................................................................................... 53
Introduction................................................................................................................................. 53
Principles of rectification........................................................................................................... 54
The evidence as to intention...................................................................................................... 57
State of mind of Mr Cleeve, Mr Standfield and Ms Marriner.............................................. 62
Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 62
Sublimits............................................................................................................................................ 69
Infectious Disease Sublimit........................................................................................................ 70
Policy year coverage................................................................................................................... 72
Period of insurance…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Princess Theatre Pty Ltd v Ansvar Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] VSC 363
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the insured was entitled to claim the full loss of income that it would have earned had it not been for the COVID-19 pandemic, or whether that loss should be reduced by the government financial support payments received. The court had to determine the correct approach to calculating the insured's loss in the context of the pandemic, and whether the underinsurance clause in the policy applied to any shortfall in coverage. This required the court to consider the effect of JobKeeper payments and other government financial support on the calculation of loss, and whether these payments should be offset against the insured's loss.
The court found that the appropriate methodology for calculating the insured's loss was to consider the income that the theatre would have earned in the absence of the pandemic, without taking into account any government financial support payments. The court held that the JobKeeper payments and other government support payments were not a reduction in the insured's loss, but rather a form of government assistance to businesses affected by the pandemic. The court further held that the underinsurance clause in the policy did not apply to any shortfall in coverage, as the insured had not underinsured its loss. The court ordered Ansvar to pay Princess Theatre the full amount of its loss, without any reduction for the government financial support payments.
Ansvar Insurance Limited was ordered to pay Princess Theatre Pty Ltd the full amount of its loss, without any reduction for the government financial support payments received. The court held that the appropriate methodology for calculating the insured's loss was to consider the income that the theatre would have earned in the absence of the pandemic, without taking into account any government financial support payments. The court further held that the underinsurance clause in the policy did not apply to any shortfall in coverage, as the insured had not underinsured its loss.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi