Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL, BELL, GAGELER, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

ECOSSE PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD  APPELLANT

AND

GEE DEE NOMINEES PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd

[2017] HCA 12

29 March 2017

M143/2016

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside orders 2 to 5 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 4 March 2016 and in their place order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria

Representation

M J Colbran QC with G D Bloch for the appellant (instructed by Goldhirsch & Shnider)

N C Hutley SC with A Hanak for the respondent (instructed by SBA Law)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Contract – Construction and interpretation of contracts – Long-term lease – Standard form contract – Where parties entered lease because unable to effect sale and purchase of land due to planning restrictions – Where standard form lease amended by parties – Where clause pertaining to payment of rates, taxes, assessments and other outgoings ambiguous – Whether parties intended lease to resemble sale and purchase of land – Whether lessee liable to pay all rates, taxes, assessments and other outgoings or only liable to pay those payable in lessee's capacity as tenant.

Words and phrases – "commercial purpose and objects", "commercial sense", "deletions from standard form contract", "in respect of the said premises", "payable by the tenant", "reasonable businessperson".

  1. KIEFEL, BELL AND GORDON JJ.   The facts surrounding the making of the lease that is the subject of this appeal and its terms are set out in Gageler J's reasons.  The original lessor was the owner of land which included the land the subject of the lease.  Had it not been for town planning restrictions, a subdivision of that land would have taken place and the land the subject of the lease sold to the original lessee.  When the parties were unable to achieve a sale and purchase they entered into a lease for a long term, ninety-nine years.  The rental for the entire term was paid on entry into the lease. 

  2. The issue on which the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria divided concerned the significance of cl 13 of the lease to the construction of an ambiguous provision governing liability for the payment of rates, taxes and other outgoings.

  3. Clause 13 contained the following information:

    "The parties acknowledge that it was the intention of the Lessor to sell and the Lessee to purchase the land and improvements hereby leased for the consideration of $70,000.00 and as a result thereof the parties have agreed to enter into this Lease for a term of ninety-nine years in respect of which the total rental thereof is the sum of $70,000.00 which sum is hereby acknowledged to have been paid in full."

  4. It is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] HCA 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning the construction of a long-term lease agreement. The dispute between Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd (the appellant, successor to the lessor) and Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd (the respondent, successor to the lessee) centred on clause 4 of the lease, which stipulated the lessee's liability for rates, taxes, assessments, and other outgoings. The core question was whether the respondent was obliged to pay all such charges imposed in respect of the leased land during the term, or only those for which the lessee was liable in their capacity as a tenant.

The legal issue before the High Court was the proper interpretation of clause 4 of the lease, particularly the phrase "all rates taxes assessments and outgoings whatsoever excepting land tax which during the said term shall be payable by the Landlord or tenant in respect of the said premises". The parties disagreed on whether this clause imposed a broad liability on the lessee for all outgoings, or a more limited one, confined to outgoings attributable to their status as tenant. This interpretation was crucial given that the leased land had, since the lease's inception, been assessed separately for rates and land tax.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Victorian Court of Appeal. The Court reasoned that while poor drafting might justify a court in departing from the literal meaning of contractual terms to avoid an improbable or unbusinesslike intention, it does not permit a court to rewrite a contract to achieve a commercially desirable outcome for one party. The Court found that the language of clause 4, when interpreted in light of the factual circumstances and the commercial purpose of the lease, was susceptible to only one meaning. This meaning imposed a broad liability on the lessee for all outgoings, save for land tax, regardless of whether they were typically payable by a landlord or tenant. The Court emphasised that the commercial approach to contract construction does not license a court to alter the meaning of a clear term to achieve a result it considers more reasonable.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2 to 5 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 4 March 2016 and in their place order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from a decision of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria[43] on appeal from a decision of a judge of the Supreme Court of Victoria[44]. It concerns the correct construction of a lease of land. The question is whether, upon its proper construction, cl 4 of the lease obliges the Lessee to pay "all rates taxes assessments and outgoings whatsoever" (hereinafter "rates and taxes") imposed in respect of the leased land during the term of the lease or to pay only those rates and taxes for which the Lessee is liable qua tenant. The primary judge (Croft J) held in favour of the former construction. On appeal, a majority of the Court of Appeal (Santamaria and McLeish JJA, Kyrou JA dissenting) held in favour of the latter. For the reasons which follow, the majority in the Court of Appeal were correct and the appeal should be dismissed. [43]Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd v Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd (2016) V ConvR ¶54-879. [44]Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd (2014) ANZ ConvR ¶14-020. The facts The facts emerge from the judgment of McLeish JA. The lease was entered into on 19 November 1988 between Westmelton (Vic) Pty Limited (receiver and manager appointed) ("Westmelton") as Lessor and Mr Peter Morris as Lessee for a term of 99 years at a total rent of $70,000 payable in full at the commencement of the lease. In about 1993, Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd ("the appellant") acquired the leasehold reversion from Westmelton. By a transfer of lease dated 15 October 2004, Mr Morris assigned and transferred the term of the lease to Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd ("the respondent"). Accordingly, the parties to the appeal are successors in title to the parties who entered the lease. The lease, which is a printed standard form "farm lease", was extensively amended by the parties before it was executed. Various parts of the printed provisions were struck out and some clauses added. A number of those amendments were to reflect the fact that the lease was granted for a term of 99 years and that the rent for the whole of the term was paid in full at the commencement of the lease. The leased land comprises 12.15 hectares and was part of a larger parcel of land described in Certificate of Title Volume 7484 Folio 127. At the time of entry into the lease, the larger parcel of land was one of three contiguous "broadacre" lots that Westmelton was subdividing in stages for residential development. At that time, the extant planning scheme restrictions on freehold subdivision prevented the freehold sale of the leased land. On 7 November 2011, a separate title was issued in respect of the leased land. Since then, the leased land has been assessed separately for rates and land tax. The leased land has not been subdivided, however, and, until the lease expires, it cannot be. It remains rural farming land. The provisions of the lease The relevant provisions of the lease are as follows. The italicised words and clauses indicate amendments or additions to the printed standard form lease. The parts of the lease that are struck through indicate the intended deletions. "1.THE term of the tenancy hereby created shall be from the First day of November 1988 to the [blank] day of [blank]2.THAT rent for the said term shall be at the clear [blank] rental of [blank] the first of the said [blank] payments to be made on the [blank] day of [blank] next. And the said Lessee covenants with the Lessor as follows: - 3.THAT the Lessee will pay the rent hereinbefore reserved on the days and in manner hereinbefore appointed for payment hereof. And in the event of the said term being determined by re-entry under the proviso hereinafter contained will pay to the Lessor a proportionate part of the said rent for the fraction of the current year up to the day of such re-entry.4.AND also will pay all rates taxes assessments and outgoings whatsoever excepting land tax which during the said term shall be payable by the Landlord or tenant in respect of the said premises (but a proportionate part to be adjusted between Landlord and Tenant if the case so requires).5.AND also will at all times during the said term well and substantially repair maintain scour cleanse and keep in good repair and condition the said premises hereby demised and all fences walls gates hedges ditches drains water courses water holes and other improvements of or belonging to the said demised premises fair wear and damage by fire only excepted.6.AND also will at his own cost and expense during the said term destroy and use his best endeavours to keep the said land free from rabbits and other vermin thistles and other noxious weeds and will comply with the Vermin and Noxious Weeds Act 1958 and any statutory amendments or re-enactments thereof for the time being respectively and without any notice or notices or order or orders to be served or made thereunder respectively.7.AND also will not cut down fell ring-bark damage or destroy any timber or trees now or hereafter during the said term growing or standing on the said land except for fencing and domestic purposes.8.AND also will permit and power is hereby given to the Lessor or its agent with or without workmen or others twice or oftener in every year to enter into and upon the said demised premises or any part thereof to examine the condition thereof and the Lessee agrees to forthwith repair according to notice.9.AND also will not assign transfer sublet or otherwise part with possession of the said premises or any part thereof without on each occasion first obtaining the consent in writing of the Lessor.10.AND also will at the expiration or sooner determination of the said term quit and deliver up possession of the said premises in good repair and condition and generally in such state and condition as shall be consistent with the due performance and observance of the foregoing covenants.11.AND also will use the said land and premises as a farm in a proper and husband like manner and subject to all usual terms covenants and agreements contained in a lease of a farm in addition to those specially contained herein.12.AND also will not commit any nuisance on the said land nor do nor suffer to be done anything that might prejudice any insurance of the said premises or any part thereof or render necessary the payment of any additional premium beyond the ordinary rate.13.AND also will cultivate [blank] of the said land during the currency of this Agreement.13.The parties acknowledge that it was the intention of the Lessor to sell and the Lessee to purchase the land and improvements hereby leased for the consideration of $70,000.00 and as a result thereof the parties have agreed to enter into this Lease for a term of ninety-nine years in respect of which the total rental thereof is the sum of $70,000.00 which sum is hereby acknowledged to have been paid in full.14.Notwithstanding anything contained herein or any act of Parliament Federal or State Regulation or By-law whether as a result of any breach or default of the Lessee or otherwise the Lessor shall not have the power of earlier determination of this Lease or have any power of right of re-entry whatsoever thereby allowing the Lessee quiet and peaceful enjoyment of the land and improvements as aforesaid for the full term of this Lease, regardless of whether or not the Lessee is in breach or default herein.15.The Lessee shall have the right to assign, transfer, sub-let or grant licences in respect of the premises without obtaining the consent of the Lessor.16.The Lessee shall without obtaining the consent of the Lessor have the right to repair, rebuild or replace any dwellings, out-houses or other improvements or build further dwellings and out-houses upon the land whether for personal, commercial purposes or otherwise.PROVIDED ALWAYS and these presents are upon the express condition that in case the said rent hereby reserved or any part thereof shall at any time be in arrear for fourteen days after becoming due although no legal or formal demand shall have been made for payment thereof or in case of the breach or non-observance of any of the covenants by the Lessee herein contained or if the Lessee shall become insolvent or liquidate his estate by arrangement or execute any deed or arrangement within the meaning of the Bankruptcy Act 1924-66 it shall be lawful for the Lessor or [blank] agent or any person authorized by [blank] in his behalf thereupon at any time thereafter notwithstanding the waiver or non-exercise of any previous default or right of re-entry to distrain for such rent or proportionate part thereof as aforesaid and to re-enter upon the said premises or any part thereof with a view to determine this lease and thereupon the lease and the term hereby granted shall cease and determine accordingly but without releasing the Lessee from any liability in respect of the breach or non-observance of any covenants on the Lessee's part herein contained. PROVIDED LASTLY and it is hereby agreed and declared that in the event of any rates agreed to be paid by the Lessee as aforesaid being unpaid at any time or times when due to the Shire or Borough or otherwise it shall be lawful for the Lessor to make payment thereof and to distrain sue for or recover as if same were rent in arrears under the Landlord and Tenant Acts."The proceedings at first instance

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL, BELL AND GORDON JJ (dissent) GAGELER J (dissent) NETTLE J (dissent)
Poor drafting may justify a court in being more ready to depart from the natural and ordinary meaning of the terms of a contract[88], and no doubt, the poorer the drafting, the less willing a court should be to be "driven by semantic niceties to attribute to the parties an improbable and unbusinesslike intention"[89]. But poor drafting provides "no reason to depart from the fundamental rule of construction of contractual documents that the intention of the parties must be ascertained from the language they have used interpreted in the light of the relevant factual situation in which the contract was made"[90]. Where there is ambiguity which permits of two alternative and semantically not improbable interpretations, construction in accordance with what it may be supposed would be the approach of honest and reasonable businesspersons may assist in choosing one such alternative over the other. But where, as here, the language and surrounding circumstances of a commercial contract present a choice between, on the one hand, a plain, ordinary and commercially not irrational meaning of a clause and, on the other, a meaning which is significantly removed from the natural and ordinary meaning of the terms of the clause, which ill-accords with other provisions of the agreement, and which in the end produces an outcome that is more commercially acceptable from one of the parties' point of view only, the precept runs out of application. Unless the Anglo-Australian objective theory of contract is now to be cast aside, the commercial approach to construction[91] is not a licence to alter the meaning of a term that is "clear and fairly susceptible of one meaning only" to achieve a result that the court may think to be reasonable[92]. The court is not authorised under the guise of construction to make a new contract for the parties at odds with the contract to which they have agreed[93]. Where, as here, all things considered, the words of a clause are fairly susceptible of only one meaning, they must be given that effect. [88]Arnold v Britton [2015] AC 1619 at 1628 [18] per Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury PSC, with whom Lord Sumption and Lord Hughes JJSC agreed (Lord Hodge JSC agreeing at 1637 [66]). [89]Mitsui Construction Co Ltd v Attorney General of Hong Kong (1986) 33 BLR 1 at 14, cited with approval in Gan Insurance Co Ltd v Tai Ping Insurance Co Ltd (No 2) [2001] 2 All ER (Comm) 299 at 306 [13] per Mance LJ.[90]Mitsui Construction (1986) 33 BLR 1 at 14. See also Rainy Sky SA v Kookmin Bank [2011] 1 WLR 2900 at 2910 [26] per Lord Clarke of Stone-cum-Ebony JSC, with whom Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers PSC, Lord Mance, Lord Kerr of Tonaghmore and Lord Wilson JJSC agreed; [2012] 1 All ER 1137 at 1147-1148.[91]Cohen & Co v Ockerby & Co Ltd (1917) 24 CLR 288 at 300 per Isaacs J; [1917] HCA 58; Upper Hunter County District Council v Australian Chilling and Freezing Co Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 429 at 437 per Barwick CJ; [1968] HCA 8. Cf Mannai Investment Co Ltd v Eagle Star Life Assurance Co Ltd [1997] AC 749 at 770‑771 per Lord Steyn; Society of Lloyd's v Robinson [1999] 1 WLR 756 at 763 per Lord Steyn (the other Law Lords agreeing at 758, 767-768).[92]Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] AC 827 at 851 per Lord Diplock. See also Arnold v Britton [2015] AC 1619 at 1628 [18] per Lord Neuberger PSC, with whom Lord Sumption and Lord Hughes JJSC agreed (Lord Hodge JSC agreeing at 1637 [66]). [93]Johnson v American Home Assurance Co (1998) 192 CLR 266 at 272 [19] per Kirby J; [1998] HCA 14; Charter Reinsurance [1997] AC 313 at 388 per Lord Mustill (Lords Goff, Griffiths and Browne-Wilkinson agreeing at 381).Conclusion and orders

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: