HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Mason, Murphy, Brennan, Deane and Dawson JJ.
GOLLIN &CO. LTD. v. KARENLEE NOMINEES PTY. LTD.
13 October 1983
Landlord and Tenant
Landlord and Tenant—Rent—Review—New rent be percentage of mean of sworn valuations obtained by each party—Obligation to appoint valuer within reasonable time—Whether time of essence—Failure to appoint—Whether waiver of right—Valuations by valuers employed by each party—Failure to notify appointment—Whether valuers appointed under lease.
Decision
October 13.
THE COURT delivered the following written judgment: -
This appeal relates to the liability of Gollin &Company Ltd. ("Gollin") for rent under a lease of commercial premises in South Melbourne. The lessors, Karenlee Nominees Pty. Ltd. and Sheralex Nominees Pty. Ltd. ("the lessors"), purchased the premises from Gollin in 1972. The contract of sale provided for a ten year lease back to Gollin which became the tenant of the premises upon completion of the sale. After some two years, the lessors and Gollin renegotiated the lease and a new lease for a term of eight years from 29 September 1974 was drawn up and executed. It will subsequently be necessary to refer in some detail to the provisions of that lease ("the lease") which relate to rent. It suffices, for the moment, to say that the annual rent was payable monthly in advance and was $144,000 for the first three years and an amount determined by a rent review procedure but being not less than $144,000 for the remaining five years. The premises comprised three main sections. Gollin required but one of them for its own activities. It sub-let the other two. (at p460)
2. In 1976, Gollin was in financial difficulties and a provisional liquidator was appointed. A scheme of arrangement between Gollin and its creditors was accepted by the creditors and approved by the Supreme Court of Victoria. It became effective from 1 March 1977. At some time between the appointment of the provisional liquidator and the approval of the scheme of arrangement, Gollin ceased physically to occupy any part of the premises. Considerable difficulty was experienced in obtaining and retaining sub-tenants and the total rents which Gollin was receiving from sub-letting totalled substantially less than the $144,000 which the lease fixed as the rent for the first three years of the term. (at p460)
3. There were some discussions between the parties regarding the amount of rent to be paid by Gollin after the first three years of the lease but no agreement had been reached by 29 September 1977 when the fourth year of the term commenced. At about that time, the lessors informed Gollin that they considered that the appropriate rent for the last five years was $240,000 per year. For its part, Gollin adopted the approach that it opposed any increase at all in the rent and continued to pay rent at the rate of $12,000 per month in advance. In October 1977, the rent receipt was indorsed "without prejudice to rental increase due 1/10/1977". In November and December 1977,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gollin & Co Ltd v Karenlee Nominees Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1983] HCA 38
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the actions of the parties, particularly the landlord's acceptance of rent from a new tenant and the execution of a new lease with that tenant, amounted to a novation of the original lease agreement, thereby releasing the original tenant (the appellant) from its obligations. The central legal issue was the legal effect of the landlord's conduct in relation to the original lease.
The Court held that for a novation to occur, there must be a clear intention by all parties to extinguish the original contract and substitute it with a new one. The mere acceptance of rent from a new party or the execution of a new lease with a new tenant does not, in itself, necessarily discharge the original tenant from liability under the original lease, especially where the original lease contains express provisions to the contrary or where the landlord has not unequivocally released the original tenant. The Court found that the landlord's actions did not demonstrate a clear intention to release the appellant from its obligations under the original lease, and therefore, no novation had occurred.
The appeal was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi