Merilla Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   MERILLA PTY LTD -v- COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA [2015] WASC 309

CORAM:   BEECH J

HEARD:   22­24 JULY 2015

DELIVERED          :   20 AUGUST 2015

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1879 of 2014

BETWEEN:   MERILLA PTY LTD

ARTUS PTY LTD
Plaintiffs

AND

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Defendant

Catchwords:

Contracts - Lease - Proper construction - Whether rent review provision void for uncertainty - Whether parties reached an informal agreement as to rent for review period - Effect of determination of rent by valuer - Whether determination complied with terms of lease - Turns on own facts

Equity - Equitable estoppel - Whether circumstances gave rise to an estoppel - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Parties not bound by the determination of rent made by valuer

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs:     Mr M J Feutrill

Defendant:     Ms C H Thompson

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs:     Lawfield Legal Practice

Defendant:     Minter Ellison

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Adams v Lambert [2006] HCA 10; (2006) 228 CLR 409

Alpine Shire Council v MHSC Transportation Services Pty Ltd [2002] VSC 22

Anaconda Nickel Ltd v Tarmoola Australia Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 27; (2000) 22 WAR 101

Australian Financial Services and Leasing Pty Ltd v Hills Industries Ltd [2014] HCA 14

Australian Goldfields NL (in liq) v North Australian Diamonds NL [2009] WASCA 98; (2009) 40 WAR 191

Biotechnology Australia Pty Ltd v Pace (1988) 15 NSWLR 130

Birla Nifty Pty Ltd v International Mining Industry Underwriters Ltd [2014] WASCA 180; (2014) 47 WAR 522

Boland v Yates Property Corp Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 64; (1999) 167 ALR 575

Brisbane Water County Council v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [1979] 1 NSWLR 320

Coghlan v SH Lock (Australia) Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 158

Commonwealth v Verwayen [1990] HCA 39; (1990) 170 CLR 394

Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2014] VSCA 353

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Fazio v Fazio [2010] WASC 263

Fazio v Fazio [2012] WASCA 72

Fitzgerald v Masters (1956) 95 CLR 420

Giumelli v Giumelli [1999] HCA 10; (1999) 196 CLR 101

Gollin & Co Ltd v Karenlee Nominees Pty Ltd [1983] HCA 38; (1983) 153 CLR 455

Government Employees Superannuation Board v Martin (1997) 19 WAR 224

Grundt v Great Boulder Pty Ltd Gold Mines Ltd (1937) 59 CLR 641

Hughes v St Barbara Ltd [2010] WASC 160

Jowett v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1926) 38 CLR 325

Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd [1999] HCA 25; (1999) 199 CLR 413

Kidd v The State of Western Australia [2014] WASC 99

Legal and General Life of Australia Ltd v A Hudson Pty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 314

Letizia Building Co Pty Ltd v Redglow Asset Pty Ltd [2013] WASC 171

Mander Pty Ltd v Clements [2005] WASCA 67

Meehan v Jones [1982] HCA 52; (1982) 149 CLR 571

Melreef Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Merilla Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] WASC 309
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Merilla Pty Ltd, as the owners of a property leased to the Commonwealth of Australia, commenced legal proceedings against the Commonwealth in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking a declaration that a rent review clause in their lease was void for uncertainty. The dispute arose from a disagreement over the amount of rent payable for a specific period, with the Commonwealth contending that the rent should be reduced based on a valuer's determination. The Commonwealth, in turn, counterclaimed for a declaration that the rent should be reduced as per the valuer's determination, asserting that the determination was binding under the terms of the lease.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the rent review provision in the lease was uncertain, whether an informal agreement had been reached between the parties regarding the rent for the review period, and whether the valuer's determination complied with the lease terms. Additionally, the court had to determine if the circumstances of the case gave rise to an estoppel that would prevent the Commonwealth from asserting certain rights under the lease.

The court found that the rent review provision was not uncertain and required a determination of market rent in accordance with the lease terms. The court concluded that no formal or informal agreement had been reached between the parties regarding the rent for the fourth Rent Period, and the valuer's determination did not comply with the lease terms. The court also found that the Commonwealth had not established any estoppel preventing it from asserting its rights under the lease. Consequently, the court declared that the rent payable for the period in question had not been agreed or determined in accordance with the lease terms, and that the valuer's determination was not binding on the parties.

The court ordered that the Commonwealth pay the Owners' costs of the action, including the counterclaim, due to the Commonwealth's failure to achieve a better outcome in the proceedings and its refusal to accept that the valuer's determination was not binding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts There were no issues of primary fact of any significance, or any credibility disputes between the witnesses. I make the following findings of fact. I begin with communications between the parties in April 2013. On 1 April 2013, the Owners issued an invoice to Centrelink care of JLL for the rent and variable outgoings for the Busselton premises for May 2013. The amount of the invoice was $25,664.77 plus GST.[4][4] Exhibit A61. On 2 April 2013 Ms Sara Zhang, of JLL, had sent an email to Ms Sara Ronald of Property Matrix. The email stated that the Busselton premisesis due for CPI review on 4 May 2013. We require CPI review notice, copy of service contracts, air‑con certificate and NABERS certificate prior to processing the increase. Although we have to wait for March quarter index to be published to calculate the CPI increase, it is better to obtain all other required documents now so we can process the increase on time.[5][5] Exhibit A65, 1029 ‑ 1030. By letter of 4 April 2013 Ms Cynthia Becher, business manager of Property Matrix, wrote to Centrelink, care of JLL.[6] Property Matrix was agent for the Owners; JLL was agent for the Commonwealth.[6] Exhibit A62. The letter was in the following terms:Please be advised that in accordance with your lease agreement the annual rent for [the Busselton premises] is due for increase as of 4 May 2013.As per your lease agreement we use the calculation of the greater figure between 3.5% and that of the annual CPI increase. The March 2013 CPI figure is due out on 26 April 2013.I will calculate the rent increase after that has been published and include a rental increase back to 4 May 2013 in your May 2013 invoice.If you have any questions in regards to this matter please do not hesitate to contact me. The Owners issued an invoice dated 1 May 2013 for rent and variable outgoings for the Busselton premises for June 2013 in the amount of $25,664.77 plus GST.[7][7] Exhibit A64. After a follow‑up to the email of 2 April 2013, by email of 8 May 2013, Ms Becher advised Ms Zhang that Ms Ronald no longer worked at Property Matrix and that the CPI adjustment was being attended to by David Henry.[8][8] Exhibit A65. On 30 May 2013, David Henry of Property Matrix sent an email to Russell Smith at JLL.[9] In substance, the email:(a)stated that the Owners had undertaken a NABERS assessment for the premises leading to a 4 star rating, whereas the previous rating had been 4.5 stars;[10](b)provided an explanation for the decrease in NABERS rating, relating to a change in use of part of the office leading to a higher energy use per square metre of assessable area;(c)stated that the change of use had not been initiated by the owners; and (d)sought confirmation that the annual rent review, now due, would not be affected by the reduced NABERS rating.[9] Exhibit A66, 1038.[10] NABERS means National Australian Built Environment Rating Scheme. By email of 3 June 2013 John Sullivan of JLL sought further information from David Henry.[11][11] Exhibit A66, 1037.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion I have reached the following conclusions:(1)cl 5.7.1 is not uncertain;(2)on its proper construction, cl 5.7.1 requires the determination of market rent for the fourth Rent Period of the Term, such determination to be made in accordance with sch 7, with all necessary changes;(3)the necessary changes to sch 7 when it is applied to the determination of market rent for the fourth period are:(a)the insertion of the words 'the fourth Rent Period of the Term' immediately before the words 'the Further Term' in cl A.2.1; (b)the modification of cl B.1.1(a) to read that the 'Valuer must determine the market rent of the premises at the commencement date of the fourth Rent Period of the Term (Effective Date)'; and(c)the deletion of cl B.4.2;(4)the Owners and the Commonwealth did not make an agreement during 2013 as to the rent for the fourth Rent Period;(5)the Owners' contention that cl 5.7.1 was never engaged fails;(6)the Valuer Agreement does not alter the rights of the parties under the Lease, except insofar as cl 9 does so;(7)the parties are not bound by the Determination, because it was not made in accordance with the Lease; and(8)the Commonwealth has not established any estoppel in its favour. I will hear further from the parties as to the declarations and orders that should be made to give effect to these conclusions. I will also hear from the parties as to costs. On 20 August 2015, I delivered reasons for decision after the trial of this action.[199] On that day, I made declarations that:[199] Merilla Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2015] WASC 309 (Primary Reasons). In these reasons I use the terminology and abbreviations used in the Primary Reasons.(1)the rent payable under the Lease for the period from 4 May 2013 to 3 May 2014 has not been agreed or determined in accordance with cl 5.7.1 of the Lease;(2)the rent determination (the Determination) of Mr Ross A Hughes dated 17 April 2014 was not made in accordance with the terms of the Lease and is not binding on the plaintiffs and the defendant; and(3)cl 5.7.1 of the Lease is not void for uncertainty. I also made orders otherwise dismissing the plaintiffs' claims and dismissing the defendant's counterclaim; and for the exchange of submissions and affidavits on the question of costs. I ordered that the question of costs be determined on the papers. These reasons deal with the costs of the action, including the counterclaim. The Owners seek an order that the Commonwealth pay their costs of the action, including the counterclaim. In summary, they point to the following matters in support of that conclusion:[200][200] Plaintiffs' submissions dated 28 August 2015 [2].(1)the Commonwealth was entirely unsuccessful in its counterclaim;(2)the Owners were generally successful in their claim, in that they obtained declaratory relief inconsistent with the Commonwealth's assertion that the Determination was binding;(3)although the Owners were unsuccessful on some issues, those issues did not add to the costs of the proceedings in a significant and readily discernible way, and were, in any event, part of a single substantive contest about whether the Commonwealth was entitled to a reduction of the rent for the fourth Rent Period to $250,000 per annum, plus GST, in accordance with the Determination; and(4)in 2014, the Owners asked the Commonwealth to accept that the Determination was not binding and that the Commonwealth was obliged to continue paying the rental for the previous rent period. The Commonwealth's refusal to accept that position was the effective cause of the action and the costs associated with it, and the Commonwealth failed to achieve a better outcome than that in the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established