Bell Group Ltd (in liq) v Westpac Banking Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 100 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   THE BELL GROUP LTD (In Liquidation) & ANOR -v- WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION & ANOR (4) [2004] WASC 162

CORAM:   OWEN J

HEARD:   31 OCTOBER 2002, 5 & 6 MAY 2003, 16 DECEMBER 2003, 23 FEBRUARY 2004, 3 MARCH 2004, 7 APRIL 2004

DELIVERED          :   23 JULY 2004

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1464 of 2000

BETWEEN:   THE BELL GROUP LTD (In Liquidation) (ACN 008 666 993)

First Plaintiff

OTHER ENTITIES *
Second to Thirteenth Plaintiffs

AND

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION (ACN 007 457 141)
First Defendant

OTHER ENTITIES *
Second to Fifth Defendants

(BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION (ACN 007 457 141)
First Plaintiff by Counterclaim

OTHER ENTITIES *
Second and Third Plaintiffs by Counterclaim

AND

THE BELL GROUP LTD (In Liquidation)
First Defendant by Counterclaim

OTHER ENTITIES *
Second to Tenth Defendants by Counterclaim

(BY COUNTERCLAIM)
 

* Refer to WASC 93 [2004] for full list of entities

Catchwords:

Procedure - Overseas witnesses - Application for taking evidence abroad - Relationship between Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and Foreign Evidence Act 1994 (Cth) - Participating jurisdiction - Recognised court - Taking evidence on commission - Letter of request to foreign State - Video link - Audio link - Advocates' immunity from suit - Defamation - Discretion to hear witnesses by video link or attend in person - Federal jurisdiction - Whether State Evidence Act picked up and applied as surrogate Federal law

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1906 (WA), s 110(1), s 120, s 120(1), s 120(2), s 121, s 121(1), s 121(2), s 121(3), s 121(4), s 132

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 47, s 47A
Foreign Evidence Act 1994 (Cth), s 3, s 7, s 7(1), s 7(2)(a), s 8, s 8(1)(a), s 18, s 19, s 19(3)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 78B, s 79

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 29, r 2(1)(c)

Result:

Application allowed in part

Category:    A

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

First Plaintiff  :        Mr T K Tobin QC

Second to Thirteenth Plaintiffs  :        Mr T K Tobin QC

First Defendant  :        Mr D E J Ryan SC

Second to Fifth Defendants  :        Mr D E J Ryan SC

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff  :        Blake Dawson

Waldron

Second to Thirteenth Plaintiffs  :        Blake Dawson

Waldron

First Defendant  :        Freehills

Second to Fifth Defendants  :        Freehills

Counterclaim

Counsel:

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim                  :        Mr D E J Ryan SC

Second and Third Plaintiffs by Counterclaim     :        Mr D E J Ryan SC

First Defendant by Counterclaim                  :        Mr T K Tobin QC

Second to Tenth Defendants by Counterclaim    :        Mr T K Tobin QC

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim                  :        Freehills

Second and Third Plaintiffs by Counterclaim     :        Freehills

First Defendant by Counterclaim                  :        Blake Dawson  Waldron

Second to Tenth Defendants by Counterclaim    :        Blake Dawson

Waldron

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Anderson v Eric Anderson Radio & TV Pty Ltd (1965) 114 CLR 20

Anderson v Gorrie [1895] 1 QB 668

ASIC v Rich…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell Group Ltd (in liq) v Westpac Banking Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] WASC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bell Group Ltd (in liq) v Westpac Banking Corporation, the court was presented with an intricate commercial dispute involving multiple parties and extensive international transactions. The primary focus of the litigation was on the solvency of the Bell group companies, the state of mind of the directors and officers of the banks involved in the refinancing arrangements, and the priority of certain debts and loans. The dispute necessitated the examination of numerous witnesses, many of whom were located outside Australia, adding a significant international dimension to the case. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate means of obtaining evidence from these overseas witnesses, considering factors such as the relevance of their testimony to the case and the feasibility of their attendance in Australia.

The legal issues central to this case revolved around the application and interpretation of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and the Foreign Evidence Act 1994 (Cth) (FEA). Specifically, the court needed to decide whether the State Evidence Act could be applied as surrogate federal law in the context of taking evidence abroad, and how to reconcile the provisions of the FEA with those of the State Act. Additionally, the court had to consider the discretion to hear witnesses by video link or require their physical attendance in court, as well as the implications of the Federal jurisdiction over the matter. These issues were crucial in determining the procedural steps to be taken for obtaining evidence from witnesses located overseas.

The court meticulously analysed the relevant provisions of the FEA, noting that it does not exclude or limit the operation of any Australian law that facilitates the examination of witnesses outside Australia for Australian proceedings. It emphasised that the Federal jurisdiction was applicable given the international nature of the dispute. The court also highlighted that the FEA does not address video link evidence directly, leaving this matter to be governed by state law. The court concluded that it had the discretion to hear witnesses by video link, taking into account the interests of justice and the specific circumstances of each case. Ultimately, the court ruled in favour of allowing the taking of evidence from overseas witnesses via video link, balancing the need for efficient case management with the necessity of ensuring a fair trial.

In summary, the court granted the application for taking evidence from overseas witnesses via video link, recognising the importance of international evidence in resolving the complex commercial dispute. The decision underscored the flexibility of the court in managing international litigation, ensuring that justice is served while accommodating the practicalities of global evidence gathering. The orders made by the court facilitated the continuation of the trial, allowing for the efficient and fair examination of critical international evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 3 of FEA defines a "superior court" to include a Supreme Court when exercising federal jurisdiction. Sections 7 and 8, which appear under the heading "Examination of witnesses abroad", are in these terms:"7. Orders for taking evidence abroad (1)In any proceeding before a superior court, the court may, if it appears in the interests of justice to do so, on the application of a party to the proceeding, make an order, relating to a person outside Australia: (a)for examination of the person on oath or affirmation at any place outside Australia before a judge of the court, an officer of the court or such other person as the court may appoint; or (b)for issue of a commission for examination of the person on oath or affirmation at any place outside Australia; or (c)for issue of a letter of request to the judicial authorities of a foreign country to take the evidence of the person or cause it to be taken. (2)In deciding whether it is in the interests of justice to make such an order, the matters to which the court is to have regard include the following: (a)whether the person is willing or able to come to Australia to give evidence in the proceeding; (b)whether the person will be able to give evidence material to any issue to be tried in the proceeding; (c)whether, having regard to the interests of the parties to the proceeding, justice will be better served by granting or refusing the order.8. Directions and requests relating to orders (1)If a court makes an order of the kind referred to in paragraph 7(1)(a) or (b), the court may, at the time of making the order or at a later time, give such directions as it thinks just relating to the procedure to be followed in relation to the examination, including directions about: (a)the time, place and manner of the examination; and (b)any other matter that the court thinks relevant. (2)If a court makes an order of the kind referred to in paragraph 7(1)(c), the court may include in the order a request about any matter relating to taking that evidence, including any of the following matters: (a)examination, cross-examination or re-examination of the person, whether the person's evidence is given orally, on affidavit or otherwise; (b)attendance of the legal representative of each party to the proceeding in question and participation of those persons in the examination in appropriate circumstances; (c)any matter prescribed by the regulations." Section 18 makes it clear that this part of FEA is not intended to exclude or limit the operation of any Australian law that provides for the examination of witnesses outside Australia for the purposes of a proceeding in Australia. Section 19 provides that the power to make rules of court regulating practice and procedure extends to the making of rules that are necessary or convenient for the carrying out or giving effect to, among others s 7 and s 8. Section 19(3) provides that the specific power in relation to rules does not affect the power to make rules under any other law. FEA is silent on the subject of video link evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The various causes of action and defence and the material facts on which they are based are described in some detail in The Bell Group Ltd & Ors v Westpac Banking Corporation & Ors (3) at [52] to [88]. It is sufficient at the moment to identify two broad questions on which issue has been joined. During the period July 1989 to January 1990 negotiations for the refinancing arrangements were being pursued in earnest. A welter of material passed between the Bell group companies and the banks and between members of the banking syndicates. There were numerous meetings between representatives of the Bell group companies and the banks and within the banking syndicates. This documentary material and what transpired at those meetings is critical to the state of mind of the directors and of the relevant officers of the banks as to the solvency of the Bell group companies and the effect of the impugned transactions. State of mind is a material element of many of the causes of action and the defences to them. Another significant question in the case is whether (before the transactions) the debts due to the banks ranked in priority to, or pari passu with, loans made from the proceeds of certain convertible bond issues that Bell group companies had issued. A related question concerns the state of mind of officers of the banks concerning the subordinated status of the loans made from the proceeds of the bond issues. These two issues are at the heart of much of the litigation. Evidence about them will be central to the resolution of the case. Much of the evidence that is the subject of this litigation goes, in one way or another, to those two broad questions. The trial began on 22 July 2003. Present indications are that the hearing is likely to be protracted and that it will not conclude until some time in 2005. The plaintiffs opened at length as their case is largely documentary and I wished to be taken to the documents. They are now progressing through their witnesses and the last estimate relayed to me was that their case would conclude some time in September or October 2004. The defendants then intend to open their case; an exercise presently envisaged to take 10 weeks. The evidence to which this application relates will come during the defendants' case. But many of the defendants' witnesses will give evidence in Perth before the focus of attention turns to the overseas witnesses. It is therefore unlikely that the overseas witnesses will be called until some time in 2005. I need to say something about the nature of this application, the way it developed and the general approach of the parties to the taking of evidence from overseas witnesses. One of the banking syndicates (the Lloyds syndicate) is comprised purely of overseas, mainly European, banks. The Lloyds syndicate facility had been advanced to an English subsidiary of the Bell group, namely Bell Group (UK) Holdings Ltd. The convertible bond issues had been arranged using a company registered in the Netherlands Antilles as an intermediary and had been listed on the European bond market. The trustee of the issues was a UK company. The Lloyds syndicate banks were intimately involved in the refinancing negotiations and many of the meetings took place in London. There had been intra‑group dealings in which moneys had been passed to and from the English sub‑group. It is not surprising, therefore, that the dispute has a decidedly international flavour. Nor is it surprising that many of the key players are residents of countries other than Australia or that much of the evidence has its source outside Western Australia.