De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

DE BOURBEL PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v DISTILLERIA PTY LTD & ANOR

[2023] SASC 88

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein  

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - FORMAL REQUIREMENTS - NECESSITY FOR WRITING

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RENT - BREACH OF COVENANT TO PAY - DISTRESS FOR RENT

PERSONAL PROPERTY - OWNERSHIP AND POSSESSION

PERSONAL PROPERTY - OTHER CASES AND MATTERS

TORTS - INTERFERENCE WITH PROPERTY - INTERFERENCE WITH GOODS - CONVERSION AND DETINUE - CONVERSION

CORPORATIONS - MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION - DUTIES AND LIABILITIES OF OFFICERS OF CORPORATION - FIDUCIARY AND RELATED STATUTORY DUTIES - DUTIES INVOLVING CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

DAMAGES - ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES IN TORT - EVIDENCE

CORPORATIONS - MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION - DUTIES AND LIABILITIES OF OFFICERS OF CORPORATION - FIDUCIARY AND RELATED STATUTORY DUTIES - REMEDIES AND PENALTIES FOR BREACH OF DUTY - COMPENSATION

In 2018, discussions between Mr Christopher Rochfort and Mr Giuliano Ursini resulted in the purchase of a property at Hindmarsh Valley and the incorporation of the applicant to conduct a whisky distillery business.  A distillery was constructed, equipment purchased and the applicant commenced operating the business from the property owned by the first respondent.  The first respondent, or entities associated with the second respondent, paid for the purchase of the property, purchase of equipment and construction of the distillery.  The second respondent was a director of both the applicant and first respondent.  No amount of rent or occupation fee was ever paid by the applicant for the occupation of the property.  The first respondent purported to execute a warrant of distraint for unpaid rent.  The applicant was evicted from the property. The applicant was placed into voluntary liquidation.

The applicant in liquidation brought three principal claims against the respondents:

1.A claim against the first respondent for unlawful distraint.

2.A claim against the first and second respondent for conversion of goods including barrels of whisky containing whisky purchased by Private Barrel Owners (PBOs).

3.A claim against the second respondent for breaches of director’s duties under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

At trial, the applicant asserted there were only ever in principle discussions, there was no contract, the parties never agreed a formal written lease and the applicant occupied the property pursuant to a license.  The applicant contended that if there was an oral lease or occupancy agreement, it was a term that rent was not payable until the applicant’s business was profitable, the first respondent did not have a right to levy rent or a fee for occupancy and the rent levied was not in an agreed amount.  The applicant asserted it owned plant and equipment but that if it did not, the plant and equipment vested in the applicant on its insolvency pursuant to the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth).  The applicant contended that the second respondent breached directors’…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the parties concerning the formation of a whisky distilling venture and associated agreements. The primary issues revolve around whether a binding contract was formed between the parties, the interpretation of their agreements, and the nature of any breach of contract or tortious claims. The court had to determine whether the discussions between the parties constituted a binding agreement, and if so, the terms of that agreement. Additionally, the court examined whether there was a breach of contract and if any tortious claims, such as conversion, were applicable.

The court considered the documentary evidence and the contemporaneous correspondence between the parties. The judge found that while there were numerous discussions, there was no clear, written agreement that defined the terms of the venture. The court emphasised the importance of written agreements in commercial contexts and found that the parties did not reach a binding agreement despite their extensive discussions and mutual intentions. The judge highlighted the inconsistencies in the oral evidence provided by the witnesses compared to the documentary evidence, leading to a conclusion that the documentary evidence was more reliable.

As a result, the court held that no binding contract was formed between the parties. The court dismissed the claims of breach of contract and tortious interference, finding that there was insufficient evidence to support these claims. The judge concluded that the parties' discussions, while indicative of mutual intentions, did not result in a legally enforceable agreement.

In summary, the court found that no binding contract was established between De Bourbel and Distilleria, and dismissed the claims of breach of contract and tortious interference. The decision underscores the necessity of clear, written agreements in commercial dealings to avoid disputes and ensure enforceability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In making my findings, particularly in relation to the discussions between Christopher and Giuliano and the topics of what, if anything, was agreed, wherever possible I have considered the contemporaneous documents and paid close attention to the consistency or otherwise of the evidence with those documents. I have primarily relied on those documents wherever possible. I have taken into consideration the matters to which I have referred to above, including Christopher and Lachlan’s inability to adequately explain in a plausible way the differences between their accounts and the contemporaneous documents, the agreement in writing of Christopher and John with certain email correspondence sent by Giuliano and Giuliano’s self interest. Background and commencement of discussions In this part of my reasons, I set out a narrative of the factual findings I have made in relation to the background to, and commencement of, discussions between Christopher and Giuliano and the subsequent start of the whisky distilling venture. The relevant evidence on these matters was largely not in contest. In about 2014, Christopher commenced the whisky distilling venture, MVD, with Mr Jock Harvey. Christopher agreed with Mr Harvey that MVD would rent a shed at 10 percent of the cost of construction of the shed and other buildings used by MVD. The cost of the shed fit out was paid for by MVD. MVD developed a barrel purchase program which allowed PBO purchasers to pay $5,000 to obtain title to 100 litres of whisky and which granted the PBOs various options when the whisky matured. PBOs could obtain a return through a guaranteed buy back price or exercise an option to receive a number of bottles of whisky. Giuliano met Christopher and John in 2015 at a whisky presentation. Giuliano become one of the first PBOs of MVD by buying 10 barrels of whisky for $55,000. Thereafter, Christopher started to have informal discussions with Giuliano, including over lunches, during which Christopher discussed with Giuliano problems he was having with MVD. Christopher regarded Giuliano as a trusted advisor, mentor and a good friend. Following discussions between Christopher and Giuliano, in order to assist MVD with cash flow issues it was experiencing, in December 2017, Giuliano bought some MVD plant and equipment for $35,000 on a leaseback basis over 12 months with a repurchase option. Giuliano also bought a further 12 MVD barrels for $66,000. A number of his friends also purchased barrels.Purchase of land, incorporation of entities and construction activities On 8 January 2018, Distilleria was registered. Giuliano was and still is the sole director, secretary and sole shareholder. Distilleria is the trustee of the Goldilocks Trust. De Bourbel was incorporated on 31 January 2018 with Giuliano and Christopher as directors. The two shareholders, holding 50 percent each of the shares, were Bellfield (SA) Pty Ltd (“Bellfield”), representing the Rochforts’ shareholding, and Flavon Nominees Pty Ltd (“Flavon”), representing Giuliano’s shareholding. Each of Christopher, Lachlan, John and Mr Nicholas Rochfort are directors and shareholders of Bellfield. The directors of Flavon are Giuliano and Rosemary Ursini. Rosemary Ursini holds one fully paid ordinary share and Giuliano holds 10 fully paid ordinary shares in Flavon. Flavon is the trustee of the Dacro Trust.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In this section, I address the evidence about the discussions between Christopher and Giuliano. Contemporaneous documents were put to witnesses during their evidence and many of those documents were significant in my reasoning and findings. I therefore commence by summarising relevant documents and then proceed to address the evidence of the witnesses. Documentary evidence Evidence relevant to what, if any, agreement was reached included documentary evidence both before and after the commencement of the business. On 3 January 2018, Giuliano sent to his solicitors, Minicozzi Lawyers, copied to Christopher and John, an email with a subject entitled “Rochforts. Plans/Program”. The email contained what was described as a letter to the Rochforts which stated:[24] [24] Exhibit A1 – Addendum to Tender Book A at 244-245.Morning Gents,Yesterday it became clear that we are forging ahead in a quasi-random way rather than in pursuit of a resolutely calculated and coordinated plan/program.The respective timing of property fit for commissioning, still availability (existing and new), maturation of MVD barrels, cash flows, MVD lease and Harvey issues seems to be disjointed.Salient factors/issues for consideration in establishing such a plan/program·We are (likely) spending much effort on finding the right property. ·Subject to acquisition of a licence GU can control the future use of the plant and equipment for use of the soon to be established Rochfort Distillery. ·Said equipment is leased to MVD for 12 months, but needed in 5 months. ·A significant number of the current barrel stock at MVD will mature sometime around mid year. ·It is critical that the optimum moment of maturation to produce the best whiskey MUST be the determining factor in the program. No subliminal influences born of other exigencies can be allowed to influence that critical decision. Independent assistance (eg Bill Lark, Mark Nicholson) should be sought to ensure this is for practical purposes and also for appearances to the public. ·The bottling of the spirit in these barrels will create an excise liability with a concomitant and significant income from sales around mid year. ·The current directors (Chris Rochfort, Jock Harvey) of MVD will be in control of these transactions and the risk/reward process. ·Ideally, these barrels are required to kick-start the new Rochfort venture. In light of the above, the following must be achieved before the time of maturation of the existing barrels. ·Rochfort Distillery Pty. Ltd. As Trustee for The Rochfort Distillery Unit Trust should be established after advice from accountants… ·Distilling licence to be acquired in the required names etc. ·Acquisition of the right property by GU Interests. (Entity TBA). ·All required statuary [sic] approvals and licences·Required conversion and improvements to the above. ·Fabrications/acquisition of all required plant and equipment. ·Installation and commissioning of the above. ·Negotiations with barrel owners regarding relocation thereof. Coordination of the relocation and timing vis a vis bottling, excise payment and sales. ·Negotiations with current MVD shareholders. ·Management of the likely difficulties emerging from the above. ·John in consultation with Chris is to consider and advise the time lines for all aspects of the way forward and distribute. ·GU to register on the PPRS the plant and equipment he acquired and leased back to MVD. ·John will email all barrel owners reminding them of his previous advice to register their barrels on PPRS to ensure absolute security. ·GU has advised John R to send him the documents to commission the fabrication of the new stills for lease by Rochfort Distillery as the MVD stills are leased back to them for 12 months yet R.Dist needs stills by May. Upon acquiring the licence, GU will own the new stills. (Cost $220,000). ·All salient issues to be committed to email correspondence to ensure proper records and coordination. Contemporaneous notes to be kept by Chris R and John R with copies issued weekly to Giuliano for information and confirmation.GU has now committed $121,000 for 22 barrels, $35,000 for MVD stills and $220,000 for new stills, with a large amount for the purchase of the new property and development of same to come shortly. This renders the commitment and risk for GU to be great and totally reliant on the strength, skills, probity, good will and health of the Rochforts. Accordingly, there is no room for any misunderstanding, nor wavering in saying what we do and doing what we say in a timely and complete matter. Recording by way of contemporaneous notes is critical in this. Any doubts must be discussed urgently at all times. Gents, the [sic] is no doubt more that I have missed, so feel free to add as required. Further, lets [sic] establish a free email flow which will at once assist us in the in the difficulties to come, and protect all parties in the process. Regards Giuliano.

Decision

Reasons for decision

STEIN J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: STEIN J

De Bourbel tendered signed transcripts of public examinations of Giuliano pursuant to s 597(14) of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”) which enables their use in evidence in legal proceedings against the person. Observations of witnesses Prior to setting out a high level and general summary of the nature of the evidence given by each witness and making some high level observations about each of the witnesses, I refer to the following statements which have been made in the context of the assessment by a trial judge of issues of credit and demeanour. In Evans v Braddock,[2] Hallen J said: The credibility of a witness and his, or her, veracity may also be tested by reference to the objective facts proved independently of the evidence given, in particular by reference to the documents in the case, by paying particular regard to his, or her, motives, and to the overall probabilities…A court, in cases involving events which occurred long before the litigation, usually prefers to rely upon contemporaneous, or near contemporaneous, documents, which will often provide valuable and, usually, more revealing, information than what may be flawed attempts at recollection of those facts by persons with an interest in the outcome of the litigation… Greater weight is usually accorded to such documents, as often they provide a safer repository of reliable fact, particularly when it is clear that they have been prepared by a person with no reason to misstate those facts in the documents and where there is no suggestion that the documents are other than genuine… [2] [2015] NSWSC 249 at [73]-[74]. Justice Hallen continued as follows:[3]In this regard, I have also found useful what Lord Pearce wrote, in his dissenting speech in Onassis v Vergottis [1968] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 403, at 431:“Credibility involves wider problems than mere ‘demeanour’ which is mostly concerned with whether the witness appears to be telling the truth as he now believes it to be. Credibility covers the following problems. First, is the witness a truthful or untruthful person? Secondly, is he, though a truthful person, telling something less than the truth on this issue, or, though an untruthful person, telling the truth on this issue? Thirdly, though he is a truthful person telling the truth as he sees it, did he register the intentions of the conversation correctly and, if so, has his memory correctly retained them? Also, has his recollection been subsequently altered by unconscious bias or wishful thinking or by overmuch discussion of it with others? Witnesses, especially those who are emotional, who think that they are morally in the right, tend very easily and unconsciously to conjure up a legal right that did not exist. It is a truism, often used in accident cases, that with every day that passes the memory becomes fainter and the imagination becomes more active. For that reason a witness, however honest, rarely persuades a Judge that his present recollection is preferable to that which was taken down in writing immediately after the accident occurred. Therefore, contemporary documents are always of the utmost importance. And lastly, although the honest witness believes he heard or saw this or that, is it so improbable that it is on balance more likely that he was mistaken? On this point it is essential that the balance of probability is put correctly into the scales in weighing the credibility of a witness, and motive is one aspect of probability. All these problems compendiously are entailed when a Judge assesses the credibility of a witness; they are all part of one judicial process and in the process contemporary documents and admitted or incontrovertible facts and probabilities must play their proper part.”[3] Evans v Braddock [2015] NSWSC 249 at [75].