Crown Melbourne Ltd v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, BELL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

CROWN MELBOURNE LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

COSMOPOLITAN HOTEL (VIC) PTY LTD &
ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Crown Melbourne Limited v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd

[2016] HCA 26

20 July 2016

M253/2015

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside orders 2 to 6 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 8 April 2015, and in their place order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3.Special leave to cross-appeal granted, limited to ground 4 of the Notice of Cross‑Appeal dated 24 December 2015.

4.Cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria

Representation

B W Walker SC with N D Hopkins QC for the appellant (instructed by Minter Ellison Lawyers)

M R Pearce SC with R S Hay QC for the respondents (instructed by Mills Oakley Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ. In proceedings brought by the respondents ("the tenants"), the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal ("the VCAT")[1] found that the appellant ("Crown") made a statement to the tenants in the course of negotiations for their leases, to the effect that the tenants would be "looked after at renewal time".  The VCAT determined that the statement gave rise to a collateral contract which obliged Crown to offer a renewal of the leases for five years on terms to be decided by Crown.  The VCAT further determined that should that conclusion be wrong, it would have also accepted the tenants' submission that Crown was estopped from denying the existence of the collateral contract.  It ordered that Crown pay the first respondent[2] $467,505.00 and the second respondent[3] $1,143,167.00 in damages for breach of that agreement. 

  2. The primary judge[4] and the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria[5] held that the VCAT was in error and that the statement did not give rise to an enforceable obligation pursuant to a collateral contract.  The primary judge also held that no estoppel arose.  However, the Court of Appeal ordered that the matter be remitted to the VCAT for further determination on the issue of what relief could be given, on the basis that the statement founded a promissory estoppel.

  3. For the reasons which follow, the Court of Appeal was correct to conclude that there was no collateral contract but it was in error in remitting the issue of estoppel.  The tenants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crown Melbourne Ltd v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning a dispute between Crown Melbourne Ltd (Crown) and Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd and another tenant (the tenants). The tenants operated restaurants within Crown's entertainment complex under five-year leases. The core of the dispute revolved around a statement made by a Crown representative to the tenants during lease negotiations, which the tenants alleged constituted a promise of a further lease term upon renewal. Crown subsequently required the tenants to vacate the premises at the expiration of their leases.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the statement made by Crown's representative gave rise to a collateral contract obliging Crown to offer a further lease, and whether the statement could give rise to a promissory or proprietary estoppel preventing Crown from denying such an obligation. The tenants argued that they were induced to enter into the leases and undertake significant refurbishments based on these assurances. A further question arose as to whether the determination of whether the statement amounted to a binding contractual promise was a question of fact or law.

The High Court, in allowing the appeal, found that the Court of Appeal had correctly concluded there was no collateral contract. However, it erred in remitting the estoppel issue, as the tenants could not succeed on that ground. The Court determined that the statement, "you would be looked after at renewal time," was too uncertain to form the basis of a collateral contract. While the VCAT had found this statement was made, it did not find that Crown had expressly promised to renew the leases. The High Court agreed with the reasoning that the statement did not create a contractual obligation inconsistent with the terms of the lease, but rather operated in harmony with the lease's notice provisions.

The High Court allowed Crown's appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal regarding the remittal of the estoppel issue. It also granted special leave to cross-appeal on the ground that a collateral contract had been formed, but ultimately dismissed the cross-appeal, reinstating the Court of Appeal's finding that no collateral contract existed. Consequently, the tenants' claims based on both collateral contract and estoppel failed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2 to 6 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 8 April 2015, and in their place order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3. Special leave to cross-appeal granted, limited to ground 4 of the Notice of Cross‑Appeal dated 24 December 2015.

4. Cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the Court of Appeal was correct to conclude that there was no collateral contract but it was in error in remitting the issue of estoppel. The tenants could not succeed on that issue.Background Crown is the owner of the Melbourne Casino and Entertainment Complex. The tenants held leases of two areas in the Complex in which, after 1 September 2005, they operated two restaurants. Before 1 September 2005, other companies controlled by Mr Zampelis (director of the tenants) had operated those restaurants under leases from Crown which expired at the end of May. In early 2005 negotiations commenced between the tenants and Crown for new leases. It may reasonably be inferred from the discussions which followed that the representatives of both parties were experienced in negotiations of this kind. The new leases which were offered by Crown were limited to a term of five years and did not contain an option for renewal. Clause 2.3 of each lease provided only that Crown was to give at least six months notice to the tenants prior to the expiration of the lease stating whether:"(a)the Landlord will renew this Lease, and on what terms (this may include a requirement to refurbish the Premises or to move to different premises …);(b)the Landlord will allow the Tenant to occupy the Premises on a monthly tenancy after the Expiry Date; or (c)the Landlord will require the Tenant to vacate the Premises by the Expiry Date." It was a condition of the leases that a major refurbishment of the premises be undertaken by the tenants. Mr Zampelis, the tenants' representative in the negotiations, was concerned about the cost of the refurbishment and sought to obtain a commitment from Crown to enable the tenants to continue to trade for a further five years. Crown, for its part, was unwilling to offer any further term on the lease. Leases in the terms offered by Crown, and limited to a term of five years, were signed by the tenants in November 2005 but were not delivered to Crown until March 2006 when Crown demanded them ("the 2005 leases"). In October 2008 Crown invited tenders for new leases of the premises and the tenants put in tenders in March 2009. In December 2009 Crown gave notice, pursuant to cl 2.3(c), requiring them to vacate the premises on the expiration of the 2005 leases, 31 August 2010. In July 2010 the tenants brought proceedings in the VCAT in which they alleged that a series of representations had been made by representatives of Crown to Mr Zampelis, to the effect that the tenants would be given a further term of five years following the expiration of the 2005 leases. These representations were said to amount to a promise that Crown would exercise its power under cl 2.3(a) of the 2005 leases and offer a renewal for a further five year term. The tenants claimed to have been induced by the representations to execute the leases and to carry out the refurbishments. Two, alternative, legal consequences were said to follow from the promise: a collateral contract, by which Crown was obliged to offer the tenants further five year leases, came into existence, or an estoppel arose which prevented Crown from denying that obligation. Importantly, the terms of the further leases were said to be the same (or the same, mutatis mutandis) as for the 2005 leases.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The decision of the VCAT was set aside on appeal to the Supreme Court of Victoria[9]. The Court of Appeal[10] granted the tenants leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal save with respect to the estoppel issue, which it remitted to the VCAT for determination of "what equitable relief, if any, should be granted", in accordance with the Court of Appeal's reasons.[9]Crown Melbourne Ltd v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd [2013] VSC 614 at [98].[10]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd (2014) 45 VR 771 at 812 [200].The evidence and the VCAT's findings Mr Zampelis gave evidence before the VCAT that in meetings with Mr John Williams and in a chance encounter with Mr Lloyd Williams, both representatives of Crown, Mr Zampelis had been assured that the 2005 leases would be renewed after their five year term. Mr Zampelis said that in a further meeting between himself and another Crown representative, Mr Boesley, in December 2005, at which others including Mr Zampelis' bank manager were in attendance, Mr Boesley gave him the same assurance. He said that Mr Boesley repeated this assurance in a telephone conversation following the meeting and in another conversation in February 2006, shortly prior to the executed leases being handed over to Crown. The VCAT did not accept Mr Zampelis' evidence of having received assurances in these terms. It considered[11] that Mr Zampelis was prone to embellishment and exaggeration about Crown's statements. It gave[12] detailed reasons for its finding that it was improbable that Crown made the alleged promise to grant a renewal for the further term. It did accept[13] that Mr Zampelis sought assurances from Crown about a longer lease term, because he believed that a longer trading period was necessary to recoup the substantial costs of refurbishment. And it accepted that a meeting took place in December 2005.[11]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [69].[12]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [70].[13]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [40]. The VCAT preferred[14] to rely upon evidence of a hand-written note, which had been made by Mr Zampelis' bank manager, of the conversations which had taken place at the December meeting. It accorded, to an extent, with aspects of Mr Zampelis' version of what had been said. On the basis of this evidence, the VCAT found[15] that on or about 6 December 2005 Mr Boesley made a statement to the effect that:"if Mr Zampelis spent the money that, under Crown's leases, the tenants were required to spend to achieve a major refurbishment to a high standard, he would be 'looked after at renewal time', and that the leases had been limited to a five year term only because they would thereby be aligned with other tenants' leases."The VCAT made[16] a specific finding that Crown had not expressly stated that it would renew the 2005 leases, but that Mr Boesley had said only that Mr Zampelis (and therefore the tenants) would be looked after at renewal time.[14]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [83].[15]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [84].[16]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [134].The VCAT's reasoning

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ GAGELER J (dissent) KEANE J
Mr Zampelis did not have an expectation of the kind to which the VCAT's findings refer. The tenants could never make out an estoppel unless they were given the opportunity to alter Mr Zampelis' evidence. There was no utility in the order for remittal. It should not have been made.Conclusion and orders The appeal from the Court of Appeal should be allowed. We agree with the orders proposed by Keane J. Substantially for the reasons given by Gordon J, I would grant special leave to cross-appeal on the ground that there was a binding and enforceable collateral contract between Crown and each Tenant as found by VCAT, allow the cross-appeal on that ground, and make consequential orders reinstating the decision of VCAT. That disposition of the cross-appeal operating to remove the substratum of the appeal, I would dismiss the appeal accordingly. The collateral contract found by VCAT comprised a promise made by Crown to each Tenant in consideration of the Tenant entering into that Tenant's lease with Crown for a term of five years. Crown's promise was that, at least six but no more than 12 months before the expiry date of the lease, Crown would give the Tenant a notice under cl 2.3(a) of the lease. The notice would state that Crown would renew the lease, which in the context of a notice under cl 2.3(a) would mean that Crown would renew for a further term of five years. The notice would go on to state the terms on which Crown would renew the lease. The choice of the terms to be included in the promised notice was to be left to Crown[60]. Like any other notice under cl 2.3(a) of the lease, the promised notice was to constitute an offer to renew the lease which the Tenant could in turn choose to accept within 60 days by giving notice to Crown under cl 3.1 of the lease. [60]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2012] VCAT 225 at [133], [139], [141]-[142], [168], [173]-[176]. Crown's promise under the collateral contract was therefore a promise to make an offer on terms which, if accepted by the Tenant, would result in a new agreement for lease for a further term of five years. Crown's argument that the collateral contract was inconsistent with the lease was accepted by the primary judge[61] and by the Court of Appeal[62]. The argument is met in this Court by the reasoning of Nettle J[63] and of Gordon J[64]. Their reasoning, with which I agree, makes redundant the Tenants' invitation to reopen and overrule Hoyt's Pty Ltd v Spencer[65] and Maybury v Atlantic Union Oil Co Ltd[66]. [61]Crown Melbourne Ltd v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd [2013] VSC 614 at [80].[62]Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd v Crown MelbourneLtd (2014) 45 VR 771 at 787-788 [65]-[70], 809 [186].[63]Reasons of Nettle J at [203]-[205].[64]Reasons of Gordon J at [264].[65](1919) 27 CLR 133; [1919] HCA 64.[66](1953) 89 CLR 507; [1953] HCA 89. The critical point of distinction between the present case and each of those cases is that cl 2.3 of the lease did not operate to confer a contractual discretion which is circumscribed by the collateral contract. The clause operated instead to impose a contractual obligation on Crown to give notice of a decision to be made by Crown outside the terms of the lease. Crown's obligation to give notice under the collateral contract did not conflict with its obligation to give notice under the lease. To the contrary, the two obligations operated in harmony: performance of the obligation to give notice under the lease was necessary to constitute performance of the obligation to give notice under the collateral contract; giving one notice would satisfy both obligations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ, KEANE J

Full text does not contain this section.