SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
DE BOURBEL PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v DISTILLERIA PTY LTD & ANOR
[2024] SASC 33
Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein
TORTS - INTERFERENCE WITH PROPERTY - INTERFERENCE WITH GOODS - CONVERSION AND DETINUE - REMEDIES - ACTION OF DETINUE
EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - GENERALLY
STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - ENFORCEMENT OF STATUTORY RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - GENERALLY
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - PLEADINGS - PARTICULARS - FUNCTION
TORTS - INTERFERENCE WITH PROPERTY - INTERFERENCE WITH GOODS - CONVERSION AND DETINUE - POSSESSION OR RIGHT TO POSSESSION
PROCEDURE - STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY - DECLARATIONS - APPROPRIATE FORM OF RELIEF - DISCRETION OF COURT
Following a trial in the Supreme Court, the Court sought further submissions concerning the orders to be made to give effect to the judgment.
The most significant issue was whether the Court should make orders for delivery up of wrongfully distrained assets and assets found to have vested in the applicant (“assets”) pursuant to provisions of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (“PPSA”) or award damages.
The applicant sought delivery up of the assets. The applicant contended it was open for the Court to find that the unlawful distraint constituted a detinue and that the Court could give judgment on any cause of action open on the evidence. It submitted that the respondents were on express notice that delivery up orders were sought and the respondents would not suffer prejudice if the Court made such orders. As the Court found the assets were wrongfully distrained or vested in the applicant, the applicant submitted that limiting it to an award of damages would be an inadequate and unjust remedy and would result in the respondents receiving a windfall.
While the PPSA does not contain an express statutory power for delivery up of the assets which vested in the applicant, the applicant contended the PPSA does not cover the field of remedies that may be ordered and s 269 of the PPSA does not operate as a statutory set off.
In the alternative, the applicant sought damages, submitting that distrained assets should be identified by reference to the list of assets in the Hilco Global report and it was not necessary to prove that each individual asset was not a fixture.
The respondents opposed orders for delivery up. The respondents contended the applicant must be limited to an award of damages on the basis of the case pleaded and run at trial. However, the respondents assert the applicants should receive no award of damages for whisky on the basis the applicant failed to prove its value. The respondents submitted that a claim in detinue or specific restitution was not expressly pleaded or notified, if they had been on notice they may have taken a different approach and they would be prejudiced by such orders which would give the applicant a "windfall".
The respondents contended that distrained assets should be…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] SASC 33
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the auction list prepared by Mr Eglinton could be used to identify the distrained assets, given that the Hilco Global report and De Bourbel's accounting records were deemed insufficient for this purpose. The court found that the auction list, while not perfect, was the most reliable document for identifying the distrained assets. Additionally, the court had to assess the admissibility of an affidavit from a liquidator, which was challenged by the defendants on the basis of relevance and hearsay. The court ruled that the affidavit was admissible as it was relevant to the liquidator's knowledge and actions concerning the distrained assets.
The court's reasoning centred on the identification of the distrained assets, finding that the auction list was the most reliable document for this purpose. The court rejected the argument that the claim for damages should be set off against the unpaid rent, noting that the liquidator had not provided sufficient evidence to support this contention. The court also held that the affidavit from the liquidator was admissible and that it demonstrated the liquidator's awareness of the distrained assets. The court calculated the damages for the distrained assets at $20,335, subject to a set off in the insolvency administration. The court granted the liquidator's application for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendants from selling the distrained assets.
In conclusion, the court found in favour of the liquidator, granting an interlocutory injunction and awarding damages for the distrained assets. The court's decision highlighted the importance of accurately identifying distrained assets and the admissibility of relevant evidence in such disputes. The court's orders were that the defendants were restrained from selling the distrained assets and that the liquidator was awarded damages for the distrained assets, subject to the set off in the insolvency administration.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The respondents’ position is that the claim for damages for the distrained assets might be allowed at $20,335 subject to a set off in the insolvency administration in which they assert De Bourbel’s unpaid rent will be offset against the damages, resulting in no amount to be paid after the set off. ConsiderationAuction list The first question for consideration is whether the auction list prepared by Mr Eglinton[1] can be used to identify the distrained assets. [1] Exhibit A1 – Applicant’s Tender Book A at 1079-1083. De Bourbel did not prove at trial that all items listed in the Hilco Global report were assets owned by De Bourbel. I found that some assets were owned by De Bourbel and some assets were owned by Distilleria,[2] or other entities associated with Mr Ursini, and leased to De Bourbel. The Hilco Global report which listed all assets present on the property at the date of inspection could not be used to identify ownership of assets. I did not accept the accounting records of De Bourbel necessarily correctly recorded ownership of plant and equipment.[3][2] De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] SASC 88 at [383]-[384].[3] De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] SASC 88 at [372]. The inventory of assets present on the premises at the time of distraint was prepared by Mr Eglinton and attached to the first version of the statement of claim as Schedule A. During cross-examination, Mr Naudi said that Schedule A to the statement of claim was meant to be a list of the distrained goods. He understood that the inventory identified all assets on the property and said that was the same as the list of things distrained against. Mr Naudi also agreed that Schedule A was a list of unsecured creditors and that the list did not give any assistance about the distrained goods. Mr Naudi described Mr Eglinton’s inventory as a list of distrained goods which was not complete and the auction list as a list prepared after taking into account any declarations under s 22 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1936 (SA). Mr Naudi agreed that the inventory was reduced to a list of items for auction and that the auction list should only contain items which the landlord maintained could be, and ought to be, sold pursuant to the distraint process. Mr Naudi also agreed it would be wrong for the landlord to insist that items not owned by the tenant go up for auction and agreed that the distraint was actioned by the auction process through the auction list. Mr Naudi was subsequently asked a series of questions which were described as questions to establish with certainty the scope of De Bourbel’s claim. The following exchange occurred.[4] Q.… Where does one find on the list of the things within the first category 'It's mine not yours, Mr Naudi, it's the things owned by De Bourbel'. Where do I go to get, with certainty, a list of those things.A.You would have that, that's what you referred to as the auction list.[4] T747.10-15.