Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
McHUGH, KIRBY, HAYNE AND CALLINAN JJ

PLACER (GRANNY SMITH) PTY LTD   APPELLANT

AND

THIESS CONTRACTORS PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd

[2003] HCA 10

11 March 2003
P60/2001

ORDER

1.   Appeal allowed with costs.

2.   Set aside the whole of the order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 14 April 2000 and, in lieu thereof, order that the respondent's appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Western Australia

Representation:

J Gilmour QC with C M Duncan for the appellant (instructed by Mallesons Stephen Jaques)

D F Jackson QC with P G Clifford for the respondent (instructed by Hollingdales)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ, McHUGH AND KIRBY JJ.   This appeal arises out of complex and protracted litigation in the Supreme Court of Western Australia in relation to a contract pursuant to which the respondent agreed to carry out mining operations for the appellant at rates based on genuine estimates, reviewed from time to time, of the cost of such operations.  After relations between the parties broke down, the appellant alleged that, in breach of a contractual obligation of good faith, the respondent had inflated its cost estimates and, in consequence, had been overpaid.  By way of counterclaim in proceedings commenced by the respondent, the appellant sought to recover the overpayments.  The trial judge awarded the appellant $4,853,000. 

  2. The contractual provisions, and the relevant facts, appear from the reasons for judgment of Hayne J and Callinan J.

  3. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia rejected an argument that the appellant had failed to make out a case of overpayment.  Accepting that the best evidence of the respondent's true estimates of its costs was to be found in its internal plant department rates, the Full Court said:

    "In consequence of Thiess' breaches of contract, Placer paid Thiess remuneration based on rates higher than those that would otherwise have been agreed.  Placer is therefore entitled to damages for breach of contract represented by the difference between the remuneration paid by it to Thiess and the remuneration it would have paid had Thiess not breached the contract.  On the evidence, the remuneration Placer would have paid had Thiess not breached the contract is to be calculated by reference to the plant department rates.  Placer is entitled to its damages for breach of contract, calculated on this basis."

  4. The Full Court then went on to consider the evidence, and the method of calculation of damages adopted by the trial judge.  The Court concluded that the trial judge's method was erroneous, and that there was insufficient evidence to enable a calculation on proper principles to be made.  In the result, the Court held that there "was a critical lacuna in [Placer's] damages formula", that "Placer did not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd against Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd. The dispute concerned a joint venture mining contract where Thiess Contractors carried out mining operations for Placer. Placer alleged that Thiess Contractors had breached the contract by inflating its cost estimates for the work, thereby overcharging Placer. The core of Placer's claim was that Thiess Contractors had breached a contractual obligation of good faith by submitting rates that were not based on genuine estimates of costs, but rather on inflated figures designed to secure profit beyond the agreed margin.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether there was sufficient evidence for Placer to prove its damages arising from Thiess Contractors' breach, and whether the trial judge had correctly applied the principles for calculating those damages. Specifically, the court had to determine if Placer had adequately demonstrated the amount by which it had been overcharged due to Thiess Contractors' inflated cost estimates and whether the method used by the trial judge to calculate these damages was legally sound, despite criticisms from the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The High Court reasoned that once Placer established a significant discrepancy between Thiess Contractors' inflated estimated costs and its actual costs, and demonstrated that any purported productivity gains were not substantial, the onus shifted to Thiess Contractors to justify any further adjustments to the calculation of damages. The court found that the trial judge's method of calculating damages, which involved deducting the profit actually earned by Thiess Contractors from the amount paid by Placer, thereby arriving at the actual costs incurred, was appropriate. This approach, coupled with the trial judge's adjustments for cost overruns and productivity gains based on evidence, led to a finding that Placer had overpaid $4.853 million. The High Court concluded that the Full Court had erred in setting aside the trial judge's findings and calculation of damages.

Consequently, the High Court allowed Placer's appeal with costs. It set aside the order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia and ordered in its place that Thiess Contractors' appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the whole of the order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 14 April 2000 and, in lieu thereof, order that the respondent's appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Full Court erred in concluding that the method of calculating damages which the trial judge used was wrong. The appeal to this Court should be allowed with costs, the whole of the order of the Full Court made on 14 April 2000 set aside and in its place there be an order that Thiess Contractors' appeal be dismissed with costs. Facts and previous proceedings The appellant ("Placer") is the operator of the business of the Granny Smith Joint Venture, a gold mine near Laverton in Western Australia in which it has a 60% interest. On 7 July 1989 the respondent ("Thiess") and the appellant entered into a schedule of rates contract for mining work at the mine, to commence on 1 August 1989 for a fixed term expiring on 31 December 1992. The work included the drilling, blasting, excavation, loading and hauling of materials. In 1991 the appellant proposed a different form of contract for the work. Its proposal was for a "partnering" contract requiring the disclosure by the respondent of confidential information about the way in which it would derive its rates for carrying out the various aspects of the work under what would still be a schedule of rates contract. Those rates were to be based upon genuine estimates by the respondent, being the respondent's "internal rates charged by the plant department" having regard to historical data. The contract provided for the recovery by the respondent of a margin of 5% on the estimates. Any gains or losses by reason of productivity improvements or shortfalls were to be brought to account prospectively following monthly reviews under the contract. The respondent was to be entitled to retain the benefit of any productivity gain or to suffer a detriment for productivity shortfalls until a new rate based upon actual cost was adopted following a monthly review. This was substantially the means by which the respondent might earn profits of more than 5%, or suffer losses from time to time. Rates for a period of three years, including plant operating costs per hour, were submitted by the respondent to the appellant in late April 1992 (the "April 1992 submission"). Unbeknown to the appellant, the plant operating costs per hour for 1993 and 1994, and consequently the base rates and revenue to be derived from them had been inflated by the respondent for profit unrelated to productivity gains, of $1.2 million. The respondent provided to the appellant various rates, including plant operating rates per hour derived by it. They were set out in the schedules to the respondent's letter dated 15 July 1992 and were revised versions of earlier rates provided in the April 1992 submission to the appellant. In January 1993, the respondent's internal plant rates were reduced. In a site memo in January 1993, the respondent set out the 1993 rates for a 984 excavator, 773 dump truck and a PC1600 excavator. The rates then proposed by the respondent were not based in fact on expected operating costs. In March 1993 the respondent sent to the appellant proposed plant operating costs per hour for new CAT 785 trucks which were to be operated at the mine in the same way as CAT 777 trucks had been used. The rates proposed were set to ensure that a particular level of profit was maintained by the application of the respondent's formula. The purpose was to ensure that the respondent maintained the same differential revenue as it had been earning from the CAT 777 trucks before replacement by the CAT 785s. The respondent did not inform the appellant of that fact, or that the plant rates it was proposing for the trucks exceeded the genuine estimates by its internal plant department by approximately $40 per hour. On a predicted usage of 4,000 hours the excess could amount to approximately $160,000 per truck per year. The respondent used nine CAT 785 trucks at the mine from time to time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HUGH AND KIRBY JJ HAYNE J CALLINAN J
Once Placer demonstrated that Thiess Contractors' estimated costs closely approximated its actual costs, it was for Thiess Contractors to show why some further adjustment of the figures was necessary. It raised only two matters – cost overruns and productivity gains. The trial judge made adjustments for these considerations in accordance with evidence adduced by Placer. Only if Thiess Contractors introduced into the debate some new or additional occasion for adjustment was it for Placer to go beyond the proof it adduced of the excessive profit which Thiess Contractors had received. Especially was that so where Placer demonstrated not only that there was a very wide discrepancy between profit in fact earned and 5 per cent of actual costs incurred, but also that any productivity gains during the period when Thiess Contractors asserted that they were made were not "significant". It was not enough for Thiess Contractors to answer this evidence by saying that there might have been some other unidentified reason for its profit being as large as it was, or by pointing to the possibility of adopting some other method of assessing Placer's damages. Yet in essence it was these two propositions that underpinned the Full Court's conclusion that Placer had not proved the amount that it had lost as a result of Thiess Contractors' breach. The proof tendered by Placer, and accepted by the trial judge, supported the conclusion that the trial judge reached: that Placer had paid $4.853 million more than it would have paid if Thiess Contractors had not breached its contract.Conclusion The Full Court erred in concluding that the method of calculating damages which the trial judge used was wrong. The appeal to this Court should be allowed with costs, the whole of the order of the Full Court made on 14 April 2000 set aside and in its place there be an order that Thiess Contractors' appeal be dismissed with costs. Facts and previous proceedings The appellant ("Placer") is the operator of the business of the Granny Smith Joint Venture, a gold mine near Laverton in Western Australia in which it has a 60% interest. On 7 July 1989 the respondent ("Thiess") and the appellant entered into a schedule of rates contract for mining work at the mine, to commence on 1 August 1989 for a fixed term expiring on 31 December 1992. The work included the drilling, blasting, excavation, loading and hauling of materials. In 1991 the appellant proposed a different form of contract for the work. Its proposal was for a "partnering" contract requiring the disclosure by the respondent of confidential information about the way in which it would derive its rates for carrying out the various aspects of the work under what would still be a schedule of rates contract. Those rates were to be based upon genuine estimates by the respondent, being the respondent's "internal rates charged by the plant department" having regard to historical data. The contract provided for the recovery by the respondent of a margin of 5% on the estimates. Any gains or losses by reason of productivity improvements or shortfalls were to be brought to account prospectively following monthly reviews under the contract. The respondent was to be entitled to retain the benefit of any productivity gain or to suffer a detriment for productivity shortfalls until a new rate based upon actual cost was adopted following a monthly review. This was substantially the means by which the respondent might earn profits of more than 5%, or suffer losses from time to time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HUGH AND KIRBY JJ, HAYNE J, CALLINAN J

In order to deal with those questions it is necessary to refer to first, how payments to be made for work done by Thiess Contractors were calculated; secondly, the way in which Placer sought, at trial, to prove its damage; thirdly, the trial judge's findings about damage; and, finally, the Full Court's criticisms of the case Placer had sought to make and the findings made by the trial judge.Calculating Thiess Contractors' remuneration As is apparent from what has been said already, calculating the amount to be paid by Placer to Thiess Contractors under the contract began with identifying Thiess Contractors' bona fide estimates of costs it would incur in performing work under the contract. Those costs included the costs of owning and operating various pieces of equipment, some of it large earthmoving equipment. To obtain a cost that could be expressed as an amount of money per unit of material moved, or unit of time worked, it was necessary to take account of such matters as the type of material that was being moved, how far it was being moved, how difficult the trip from loading to unloading would be, how long that trip would take and other similar considerations. The contract stipulated that those calculations would be made using an identified computer program. Because the calculations were made periodically (in some cases monthly) and were made for several different pieces of equipment executing different kinds of work over the period of alleged overpayments by Placer, calculating the amount due from Placer to Thiess Contractors was a large task requiring many separate calculations. All of those calculations required the identification of an amount properly identified as Thiess Contractors' bona fide estimate of costs, but many required the identification of other factors determined by reference to the work that was to be done. On its face, a recalculation of the amount properly payable by Placer to Thiess Contractors would appear to have required prolonged examination of documents or matters of account of a kind that might properly have been referred[9] to a referee. No order of that kind was made and Placer did not attempt to adduce evidence of the result of such a recalculation. Rather, Placer sought to arrive at the amount which it had overpaid by, in effect, working backwards from the amount which it had paid.[9]Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), s 51(1).Placer's proof of damage at trial At trial, Placer sought to arrive at the amount it had overpaid as a result of Thiess Contractors' breach, by deducting from the amount of money which it had paid the amount of profit that Thiess Contractors had, in fact, made in performing the contract during the relevant period. This, so it was alleged, would leave the amount of cost which Thiess Contractors had, in fact, incurred during the period. Under the contract, the agreed profit allowance of 5 per cent was to be calculated on estimated costs. Placer's calculation of its damages at trial took 5 per cent of actual rather than estimated costs and treated the difference between the profit actually earned and profit calculated as 5 per cent of the actual costs as the amount which it had overpaid.