FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

CITATION:FE Accommodation Pty Ltd & Anor v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd [2024] NTSC 61

PARTIES:FE ACCOMMODATION PTY LTD
(ACN 160 943 082)

and

G&C PASTORAL CO PTY LTD
(ACN 008 039 405)

v

GOLD VALLEY IRON ORE PTY LTD
(ACN 618 094 634)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:64 of 2018 (21830728)

DELIVERED:  22 August 2024

HEARING DATES:  10, 11 and 12 April 2024, with further written submissions filed on 16 and 26 April 2024

JUDGMENT OF:  Brownhill J

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACT – Remedies – Damages – Assessment of damages – General principles – ‘Ruling Principle’ –Onus of proof on the Plaintiff – Damages must be proved with degree of precision as reasonably available – Entitlement to damages limited to damages that arise naturally – Plaintiff has a duty to mitigate of loss – Plaintiff cannot recover losses which are avoided – Plaintiff cannot be placed in a superior position to which they would have been if the contract had been performed.

DAMAGES – Claim for interest – Calculation of interest on damages – s 84(1) Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT) – Interest as damages – Requirement to prove loss not satisfied by first plaintiff – Award of nominal damages.

DAMAGES – Assessment of damages – Prima facie measure – Whether prima facie measure applies – Whether s 52(3) Sale of Goods Act 1972 (NT) applies – s 52(3) Sale of Goods Act 1972 (NT) not applicable to claim for damages.

DAMAGES – Assessment of damages – Prima facie measure at common law – Whether prima facie measure applies – Defendant did not plead any prima facie measure of damages outside of the Sale of Goods Act 1972 (NT) – Departure from the general rule when in the ‘interests of justice’– Prima facie measure displaced.

DAMAGES – Assessment of damages – Whether legal costs incurred in relation to another proceeding are claimable as damages – Whether there is a causal connection between legal costs and the defendant’s breach of contract – Legal costs incurred may reasonably be supposed to have been a probable result of the defendant’s breach – Entitled to share of legal costs.

BREACH OF CONTRACT – Counter-claim – Whether res judicata, issue estoppel or Anshun estoppel preclude counter-claim being made – Res judicata, issue estoppel and Anshun estoppel do not arise – Whether defendant is entitled to recover moneys paid – Defendant is entitled to recovery.

Clark v Macourt (2013) 253 CLR 1, The Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64, Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Ex 341, TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Hayden Enterprises Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 130, Sabouni v Revelop Building and Developments Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 31, Troulis v Vamvoukakis [1998] NSWCA 237, Barrow v Arnaud (1846) 8 QB 595, Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613, Motor Accidents (Compensation) Commission v Motor Accidents Insurance Board (No 2)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NTSC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd, the dispute centered around the assessment of damages arising from a breach of contract. The Northern Territory Supreme Court was tasked with determining the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff, FE Accommodation, against Gold Valley Iron Ore, and whether certain costs were recoverable. Additionally, the court examined a counterclaim by Gold Valley Iron Ore seeking recovery of a payment made to the plaintiff.

The central legal issues involved the principles governing the assessment of damages in contract law, specifically whether the prima facie measure of damages applied, and whether certain legal costs incurred due to the breach could be claimed. The court also had to decide whether the defendant was entitled to recover moneys paid to the plaintiff as part of the counterclaim.

The court found that the onus was on the plaintiff to prove damages with a reasonable degree of precision, and the plaintiff could not recover losses that were avoidable or that would place them in a better position than if the contract had been performed. The court ruled that the plaintiff was entitled to nominal damages only as they failed to prove a quantifiable loss. Regarding the legal costs, the court held that such costs could be claimed if they were a probable result of the breach. The counterclaim by the defendant for the recovery of a sum paid to the plaintiff was upheld, as it did not fall under res judicata, issue estoppel, or Anshun estoppel. The court ordered that the defendant was entitled to recover $500,000 from the plaintiff. Interest on the awarded amounts was to be calculated from the date of the breach to the date of judgment at a rate determined by relevant court rules.

In conclusion, the court ordered that FE Accommodation was to pay nominal damages of $1 to Gold Valley Iron Ore, while Gold Valley Iron Ore was to pay FE Accommodation damages of $382,555 plus interest. Additionally, FE Accommodation was to refund $500,000 to Gold Valley Iron Ore, also with interest. The counterclaim against the second plaintiff was dismissed. The court further directed the parties to address the issue of costs and the final terms of the orders, including interest and GST implications.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Consequently, I find that the defendant is entitled to recover the sum of $500,000 paid to the first plaintiff in part payment of the purchase price for the Camp under the Contract of Sale.Pre-judgment interest The first plaintiff is entitled to nominal damages only. The second plaintiff is entitled to damages from the defendant totalling $382,555 (subject to any impacts of GST). The defendant is entitled to restitution from the first plaintiff of $500,000. On these two amounts, I will award interest under s 84 of the Supreme Court Act from the date of termination of the Contract of Sale on 30 August 2018, being the date when the cause of action arose, to the date of judgment. I consider that a fair and reasonable rate of interest[137] is the rate applicable on a judgment of the Court under Order 59.02(3) of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT), which is the rate fixed for s 52(2)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) from time to time. That section refers to the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and Rule 39.06 of those Rules fixes the rate under s 52(2)(a) as six percent above the cash rate last published by the Reserve Bank prior to 1 January to 30 June in any year and prior to 1 July to 31 December in any year.Disposition Subject to the impacts of GST, I will make the following orders.(1)The first plaintiff is entitled to judgment against the defendant for nominal damages only and the defendant is to pay the first plaintiff nominal damages of $1.(2)The second plaintiff is entitled to judgment against the defendant for damages and the defendant is to pay the second plaintiff damages of $382,555, plus interest at the rate prescribed by Order 59.02(3) of the Supreme Court Rules for the period from 30 August 2018 to the date of judgment.(3)The defendant is entitled to restitution against the first plaintiff on the counterclaim and the first plaintiff is to pay the defendant restitution of $500,000, plus interest at the rate prescribed by Order 59.02(3) of the Supreme Court Rules for the period from 30 August 2018 to the date of judgment.(4)The defendant’s counterclaim against the second plaintiff is dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs and the terms of final orders, including the amounts of interest and the impacts of GST.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.