FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

CITATION:FE Accommodation Pty Ltd & Anor v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] NTSC 103

PARTIES:FE ACCOMMODATION PTY LTD
(ACN 160 943 082)

and

G&C PASTORAL CO PTY LTD
(ACN 008 039 405)

v

GOLD VALLEY IRON ORE PTY LTD
(ACN 618 094 634)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:No 56 of 2018 (21828241)

No 64 of 2018 (21830728)

DELIVERED:  11 December 2024

HEARING DATES:  On the papers following written submissions filed on 12 September 2024 and 1 October 2024

JUDGMENT OF:  Brownhill J

CATCHWORDS:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – Application for costs following determination of a separate question – Guiding principle is that successful party is entitled to costs by way of indemnity – Displacement of general rule where conduct of litigation justifies a different outcome –Whether costs should be awarded on an issue by issue basis – No fixed rule as to the issue by issue basis – Overall, parties had mixed success - Whether the failure of the plaintiff to accept an offer and subsequent failure to better that offer in the substantive litigation displaces the application of the guiding principle – Guiding principle displaced in the circumstances – No order as to costs.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – Application for costs of interim injunction – Injunction granted – No basis to displace the guiding principle

Baller Industries Pty Ltd v Mero Mero Leasing Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 1067, His Eminence Metropolitan Petar, Diocesan Bishop of the Macedonian Orthodox Church of Australia and New Zealand v The Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 142, Northern Territory v Sangare (2019) 265 CLR 164, Taylor v Heading (No 2) [2021] FCA 925, referred to.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT) rr 63.03, 63.19, 63.26

Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT) ss 14(1)(c), 71

Practice Direction No 6 of 2009

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

First & Second Plaintiffs:           A Harris KC

Defendant:A Wyvill SC with R Sanders

Solicitors:

First & Second Plaintiffs:           CCK Lawyers

Defendant:HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Bro2413

Number of pages:  22

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

FE Accommodation Pty Ltd & Anor v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd
(No 2)
[2024] NTSC 103

No. 56 of 2018 (21828241)
No. 64 of 2018 (21830728)

BETWEEN:

FE ACCOMMODATION PTY LTD
(ACN 160 943 082)

First Plaintiff

AND:

G&C PASTORAL CO PTY LTD
(ACN 008 039 405)

Second Plaintiff

AND:

GOLD VALLEY IRON ORE PTY LTD
(ACN 618 094 634)

Defendant

CORAM:    BROWNHILL J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT ON COSTS

(Delivered 11 December 2024)

Factual and procedural background

  1. The factual background of this matter is set out in FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore [2024] NTSC 61 at [7]-[38]. The terms used in those reasons are used consistently in these reasons.

  2. On 28 June 2018, the plaintiffs commenced a proceeding in the Supreme…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NTSC 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of FE Accommodation Pty Ltd v Gold Valley Iron Ore Pty Ltd (No 2), the dispute arose from a contract of sale and subsequent litigation involving claims and counterclaims for breach of contract and damages. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory. The primary legal issues revolved around the costs incurred during the litigation, particularly whether the successful party should be awarded costs by way of indemnity, and if the conduct of the litigation warranted a deviation from this guiding principle.

The court examined whether the principle that the successful party should be awarded costs should be displaced based on the conduct of the parties during the litigation. The court noted that while the guiding principle is that the successful party is entitled to costs by way of indemnity, this principle can be displaced if there is conduct of the litigation that justifies a different outcome. The court found that both parties had mixed success in the proceedings, with the defendant successfully recovering purchase price instalments from both plaintiffs, and the plaintiffs being successful in establishing the defendant's liability for damages for breach of contract, albeit with nominal damages awarded to one plaintiff.

The court concluded that the guiding principle was displaced in this case due to the overall conduct of the litigation, including the plaintiffs' failure to accept an offer and their subsequent failure to better that offer in the substantive litigation. As a result, the court determined that no order should be made as to costs in either proceeding, meaning the parties would bear their own costs. This decision reflects the court's discretion in awarding costs, considering the conduct of the litigation and the outcomes achieved by each party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The defendant argued that the appropriate order is that there be no order as to costs in both proceedings, meaning the parties bear their own costs.Consideration and determination By ss 14(1)(c) and 71 of the Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT) and r 63.03(1) of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT), the costs of a proceeding are in the discretion of the Court.[10] The power to award costs is a discretionary power, to be exercised judicially by reference to considerations relevant to its exercise and upon facts connected with or leading up to the litigation.[11] The most important guiding principle by reference to which the discretion as to costs is to be exercised is that the successful party is generally entitled to his or her costs by way of indemnity against the expense of litigation that should not, in justice, have been visited upon that party.[12] The application of that principle may be modified or displaced where there is conduct of the litigation that would justify a different outcome, which can include unreasonable delay or a want of the cooperation required of litigants to ensure the just resolution of the real issues in civil proceedings with minimum delay and expense.[13] Practice Direction No 6 of 2009 (‘PD6/2009’) addresses such matters and makes clear that the parties’ conduct of the litigation, particularly whether there were offers to settle some or all of the issues in the proceeding, may be taken into account when the Court exercises its discretion as to costs. Proceedings No 64 of 2018 In proceedings No 64 of 2018, the parties all had some measure of success. The defendant was effectively successful in its counter-claim against both plaintiffs (being its claim to recover the $1 million paid by it to the plaintiffs as instalments of the purchase price under the Contract of Sale). The plaintiffs were effectively successful in establishing the defendant’s liability for damages for breach of contract. In the assessment of those damages, it was accepted that the purchase price instalments paid by the defendant to each plaintiff would reduce the amount of damages to which each plaintiff was entitled. After that reduction, the second plaintiff was found to be entitled to damages of $382,555, but the first plaintiff was found to be entitled only to nominal damages, because its established loss did not exceed the amount of the purchase price it had received. The difference of $229,965.29 was payable by the second plaintiff to the defendant by virtue of the successful counter-claim. The plaintiffs argued that they should have their costs up to the resolution of the liability trial, because they both succeeded on liability, with no order as to costs thereafter because the second plaintiff’s entitlement to its costs flowing from its success in its damages claim would be effectively cancelled out by the defendant’s entitlement to be paid by the first plaintiff its costs flowing from its success on the counter-claim. Such an approach ignores two matters. The first is that the defendant succeeded in its counter-claims against both plaintiffs, which would entitle it to its costs against both of them. The second, and more important, is that the first plaintiff’s success on the liability trial came to nothing because it was awarded only nominal damages, having failed to establish any loss.