Walsh v Angels Care (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Walsh v Angels Care (Australia) Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 798

File number: MLG 3966 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 5 September 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – application for unpaid statutory and contractual entitlements – alleged unpaid wages, unpaid annual leave, home office allowance and bonus – whether applicant is employee or independent contractor – effect of admissions made by respondent – determining terms of contract to date of termination – determining hourly rate for purposes of determining entitlements – applicant partially successful – declarations and orders made
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 14, 20, 44, 86, 87, 90, 96, 323, 545, 546, 570

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2)(General Federal Law) Rules 2021, r 13.04, 13.05, 13.13

Cases cited:

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting [2022] HCA 1

Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd [2003] HCA 10

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 159
Date of hearing: 28 – 29 June 2022
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Tierney
Solicitor for the Applicant: Gordon Legal
The Respondent: Mr Harrison

ORDERS

MLG 3966 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

KERRYN WALSH

Applicant

AND:

ANGELS CARE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

5 SEPTEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 545 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘the FW Act’) the Respondent pay to the Applicant, within 28 days of the date of this Order, compensation in the amount of:

(a)$17,999.38 for unpaid wages; and

(b)$19,799.32 for accrued but unused annual leave.

2.Pursuant to section 547(2) of the FW Act the Respondent pay pre-judgment interest to the Applicant on the amounts owed pursuant to Order 1 above within 28 days of the date of this Order, with the interest to be calculated in accordance with the applicable pre-judgment interest rate prescribed by the Federal Court of Australia.

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

3.The Respondent contravened section 90 of the FW Act and thereby breached section 44 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Applicant’s annual leave entitlement.

4.The Respondent breached section 323 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Applicant the annual leave entitlement and the unpaid wages entitlement.

AND THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:

5.Any application for costs be made by way of application in a proceeding within 14 days of the date of these orders.

6.The proceeding be listed for further hearing on the question of penalties and costs (if any), on 31 January 2024 at 10.15am.

7.By no later than 4.00pm on 24 November 2023, the Applicant shall file and serve evidence and an outline of submissions relating to her claim for penalty and costs (if any).

8.By no later than 4.00pm on 22 December 2023, the Respondent shall file and serve evidence and an outline…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walsh v Angels Care (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 798
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Walsh v Angels Care (Australia) Pty Ltd involved Ms. Kerryn Walsh, a Registered Nurse, and Angels Care (Australia) Pty Ltd, a national system employer providing home aged care and disability support services. Ms. Walsh alleged that she was misclassified as an independent contractor rather than an employee, and thus was not provided with the entitlements and protections afforded to employees under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The matter was heard by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which was required to determine whether Ms. Walsh was indeed an employee of Angels Care and, if so, what entitlements she was owed.

The central legal issue in this case was whether Ms. Walsh was an employee or an independent contractor of Angels Care. The Court needed to examine the nature of the working relationship between the parties, considering the control exerted by Angels Care over Ms. Walsh's work, the degree of financial risk undertaken by Ms. Walsh, and the mutual expectation of an ongoing relationship. The Court also needed to determine whether Ms. Walsh was entitled to certain employee entitlements such as minimum wage, annual leave, and redundancy payments.

The Court found that Ms. Walsh was indeed an employee of Angels Care, not an independent contractor. The Court based its decision on several factors, including the level of control exerted by Angels Care over Ms. Walsh's work, the provision of tools and equipment by Angels Care, and the mutual expectation of an ongoing employment relationship. The Court also found that Ms. Walsh was owed several entitlements, including minimum wage, annual leave, and redundancy payments. However, the specific quantum of these entitlements was to be determined at a later hearing.

In conclusion, the Court ruled in favour of Ms. Walsh, finding her to be an employee of Angels Care. The Court determined that Ms. Walsh was owed certain employee entitlements and set a date for a further hearing to determine the precise amount of these entitlements. This ruling has significant implications for both parties, ensuring that Ms. Walsh receives the protections and benefits afforded to employees under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The proceedings will be listed for further hearing in relation to penalties for those contraventions on a date to be fixed.BACKGROUND The facts in this matter are substantially agreed. Based on the pleadings, the affidavits read in the proceeding and the evidence heard at trial, the following matters are uncontroversial or uncontested, unless stated otherwise. The applicant, Ms Kerryn Walsh, is a Registered Nurse Division 1. Ms Walsh has worked as a nurse for approximately 46 years. She has had extensive experience in operating room nursing as well as teaching acute care and anaesthetic care nursing for more than 20 years[2].[2] Affidavit of Kerryn Walsh dated 27 January 2022 (‘Walsh affidavit’), Court Book (‘CB’) 27 The respondent, Angels Care, is engaged in the business of providing home aged care and disability support services. These services include high and low-level care for people with disabilities, respite and home care services. Angels Care has admitted that it is a ‘national system employer’ within the meaning of section 14 of the FW Act. Mr Geoffrey Harrison has been the managing director of Angels Care at all material times since 2016. Mr Harrison is substantially based in Malaysia, although he regularly travels to Australia and internationally with the Angels Care business. Mr Harrison does not contest that he has overall authority to manage the business, is the controlling mind of the company and has the power to make financial decisions on behalf of the business in conjunction with his business partner, a Malaysian doctor. In or around October 2015, Ms Walsh was first contacted by Mr Harrison. At this time, Angels Care operated an aged-care in-home nursing business in Singapore and Malaysia. Mr Harrison offered Ms Walsh an opportunity to assist Angels Care in educating and upskilling its existing staff in Johor Bahru, Malaysia. Ms Walsh agreed to this proposal and went to Johor Bahru in March 2016. Ms Walsh was paid for her time in Malaysia and was reimbursed for her expenses which included a mobile phone and laptop. Angels Care in Australia In or around late 2016, Mr Harrison told Ms Walsh that he was interested in starting an aged care business for Angels Care in Australia[3]. [3] Walsh affidavit, CB 28 Mr Harrison and Ms Walsh met a few times at a café in Pearcedale to discuss this opportunity. At one of these meetings in December 2016 Ms Walsh says that Mr Harrison invited her to join Angels Care and told her to start looking to establish an aged care business in Australia. Ms Walsh suggested that she could commence by working from home, but said she needed some structure. Ms Walsh claims that during a conversation at the café, which was also attended by two other board members, Mr Harrison told her that Angels Care would pay for stationary, home office equipment and money for expenses[4]. When cross-examined about this meeting Mr Harrison agreed that he had told Ms Walsh that he would “pay for everything”.[4] Walsh affidavit, CB 28

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter proceeded on the basis that the Court would determine liability first and that the issue of penalties would be the subject of a separate hearing if liability was established.Evidence Each of Ms Walsh and Mr Harrison (on behalf of the respondent) filed a number of affidavits prior to the hearing. Those affidavits annexed a significant number of documents. Ms Walsh read the following affidavits into evidence:(a)affidavit dated 27 January 2022[14];(b)affidavit dated 21 February 2022[15]; and(c)affidavit dated 23 March 2022[16].[14] Exhibit A1, CB 26[15] Exhibit A2, CB 154[16] Exhibit A3, CB 161 After various evidentiary objections, Mr Harrison sought to rely on the following material:(a)his affidavit of 17 March 2021[17];(b)the first two sentences of paragraph 8 of his affidavit dated 6 May 2022[18]; and(c)a payslip for Ms Walsh for the period 6 April to 20 April 2018 annexed as exhibit GH1(a) to his affidavit of 27 June 2022[19].[17] Exhibit R1[18] Exhibit R2[19] Exhibit R3 Both Ms Walsh and Mr Harrison adopted their affidavits as their evidence in chief and they were each cross-examined. Having regard to the relatively narrow issues to which the substantive hearing was confined, and the fact that many of the background facts are agreed, I have discussed the evidence only as necessary to determine those issues.Was Ms Walsh an employee or a contractor? By its pleaded response filed on 24 February 2021, the respondent admitted the following allegations or asserted the following contentions:(a)The respondent is a national system employer within the meaning of s 14 of the FW Act[20];[20] Response, para 2(c)(b)Ms Walsh commenced employment on a casual basis with Angels Care (although it contends that no terms were ever confirmed by the respondent in writing)[21];[21] Response, para 3(c)that Ms Walsh was entitled to be paid $55 per hour under the casual agreement[22];[22] Response, para 4(a)(d)that Ms Walsh was employed by Angels care on an intermittent, casual basis from February 2017 until March 2018[23];[23] Response para 5(e)that Ms Walsh was employed on a full-time basis between 1 April 2018 until around mid-August 2019[24];[24] Response para 6(f)that Ms Walsh commenced full-time employment pursuant to the first contract of employment on 1 April 2018[25];[25] Response, para 7, note: the first employment contract pleaded by the respondent corresponds to the Third Employment Contract pleaded by the applicant in the Statement of Claim(g)that under the first contract of employment Ms Walsh was entitled to $5000 per month and 10% of the monthly profit derived from clients personally managed by Ms Walsh[26];(h)that on 30 June 2019, Ms Walsh was appointed National Director of Clinical Services under a new contract of employment (second employment contract )[27];(i)that under the second employment contract Ms Walsh was entitled to $15,000 per month, 10% bonus of the profit received for all Mornington based clients and 2% of the profit received for all other office-based clients and use of a fully maintained company car[28];(j)Ms Walsh was offered a new contract of employment on 8 August 2019 (but only as Mornington manager and not National Director of Clinical Services)[29];(k)that Walsh refused the third employment contract offer[30];(l)that Walsh’s final day of employment was 4 September 2019[31];(m)that Walsh was entitled to four weeks of paid annual leave per year during the Permanent Employment Period, pursuant to ss 86 and 87 of the FW Act[32];(n)upon termination, Walsh was entitled to be paid the amount that would have been paid to her if she had taken annual leave, pursuant to s 90 of the FW Act[33];(o)that Walsh’s last payment of wages from Angels Care was for the period from 12 July 2019 to 25 July 2019[34]; and(p)that Walsh was entitled to bonuses pursuant to the terms of the first employment contract and the second employment contract[35].[26] Response, para 8[27] Response, para 11, note: the second employment contract pleaded by the respondent corresponds to the Fourth Employment Contract pleaded by the applicant in the Statement of Claim[28] Response, para 12[29] Response, para 14[30] Response, para 16[31] Response, para 18[32] Response, para 19[33] Response, para 20[34] Response, para 24[35] Response, paras 30 and 31

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.