Australian Securities and Investments Commission v iSignthis Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v iSignthis Limited [2024] FCA 669

File number(s): VID 773 of 2020
Judgment of: MCEVOY J
Date of judgment: 21 June 2024
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – continuous disclosure – alleged contraventions of ss 674(2) and 1041H of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) – whether the company (iSignthis Limited) engaged in conduct, in relation to a financial product or a financial service, that was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive – whether the company failed to notify the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) of certain information relating to the breakdown of its revenue and Visa’s termination of its relationship with iSignthis in breach of continuous disclosure obligations – whether non-disclosed information would, if generally available, have a material effect on the price or value of the company’s shares – whether exceptions to ASX Listing Rule 3.1 contained in Listing Rule 3.1A apply to second alleged contravention of s 674(2) – held: iSignthis Limited breached its continuous disclosure obligations on two separate occasions and s 1041H of the Corporations Act

CORPORATIONS – whether second defendant, Mr Karantzis (a director of the company), contravened s 674(2A) of the Corporations Act – whether knowingly concerned in the first contravention by the company of s 674(2) – whether second defendant had actual knowledge – held: the second defendant breached s 674(2A) of the Corporations Act

CORPORATIONS – provision of false or misleading information to ASX – whether the second defendant gave information to the ASX relating to the affairs of iSignthis that was false or misleading in a material particular and, or alternatively, omitted matters that, by their omission, rendered the information misleading in a material respect on two occasions arising in the context of Visa’s termination of its relationship with iSignthis – held: the second defendant breached ss 1309(2) and (12) on one of the occasions alleged

DIRECTORS’ DUTIES – directors’ duties – alleged contraventions of ss 180(1), 181, and 182 of the Corporations Act by second defendant – whether second defendant breached s 180(1) in relation to information provided to the market in relation to and during an analyst briefing relating to the breakdown of revenue of the company – whether second defendant breached s 180(1) in relation to the failure to disclose the termination of Visa’s relationship with the company – whether the second defendant breached s 182(1)(a) by using his position as a director improperly to gain advantage – whether the second defendant breached s 181(1) by failing to use powers and discharge duties in good faith in the best interests of the corporation and for a proper purpose – held: the second defendant breached s 180(1) on two separate occasions – no breaches of ss 181 and 182 of the Corporations Act  

Legislation:

Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth) s 81

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 180(1), 181, 182, 674(2), 674(2A), 1041H, 1309(2), 1309(12), 1317G(1)(b)(iii), 1317S(2), 1318(1)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Treasury Laws Amendment (2021 Measures…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v iSignthis... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 669
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) brought proceedings against iSignthis Limited and its director, Mr Karantzis, alleging breaches of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). ASIC claimed that iSignthis failed to comply with its continuous disclosure obligations and that Mr Karantzis, in his capacity as a director, contravened several sections of the Act, including engaging in misleading conduct and providing false information to the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). The court was tasked with determining whether iSignthis and Mr Karantzis breached their legal obligations under the Corporations Act.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether iSignthis breached its continuous disclosure obligations by not disclosing material information to the ASX, whether Mr Karantzis knowingly participated in misleading conduct, and whether Mr Karantzis breached his director's duties. Specifically, the court needed to assess whether iSignthis' failure to disclose certain financial information and Visa's termination of its relationship with iSignthis constituted breaches of the Act. Additionally, the court examined whether Mr Karantzis was involved in misleading representations about the company's revenue and whether he breached his duties as a director.

The court found that iSignthis breached its continuous disclosure obligations by failing to notify the ASX about the breakdown of its revenue and Visa’s termination of its business relationship. The court concluded that the non-disclosed information would have materially affected the price or value of iSignthis' shares if it had been generally available. Regarding Mr Karantzis, the court determined that he contravened the Act by knowingly participating in misleading conduct and by providing false or misleading information to the ASX. Furthermore, the court found that Mr Karantzis breached his director's duties by failing to use his position properly and by not acting in the best interests of the corporation. The court held that Mr Karantzis breached his duty of care and diligence and his duty to act in good faith and for a proper purpose.

In summary, the court held that iSignthis Limited breached its continuous disclosure obligations under sections 674(2) and 1041H of the Corporations Act. The court also found that Mr Karantzis contravened sections 674(2A), 1309(2), and (12) of the Act and breached his director's duties under sections 180(1) and 182 of the Act. The final orders included the requirement for the parties to file an agreed minute of orders, a case management hearing, and the reservation of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 4:00pm on 12 July 2024 the parties file and serve an agreed minute of orders to give effect to these reasons and for the further conduct of this proceeding; or, if there is no agreement, competing minutes of orders and short submissions (limited to 3 pages) as to their respective positions.

2. The further hearing of this proceeding be adjourned for case management hearing on a date to be fixed.

3. Costs be reserved.

4. There be liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

[1]

THE CONDUCT OF THE HEARING, THE EVIDENCE AND THE PLEADINGS

[14]

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

[30]

The One-off Revenue period

[31]

The Performance Milestones

[32]

The integration agreements

[37]

The One-off Revenue representation timeline

[44]

The Visa termination period

[62]

Achieving principal membership

[64]

A breakdown of relations

[69]

Communications with the Central Bank of Cyprus

[88]

Communications with the ASX and further disclosures

[93]

ONE-OFF REVENUE REPRESENTATION CLAIMS

[105]

ASIC’s submissions that iSignthis contravened s 1041 of the Act

[108]

iSignthis’ response to ASIC’s One-off Revenue Representation claims

[137]

One-off Revenue Representation: “in writing”

[137]

One-off Revenue Representation: “orally”

[143]

Relevant principles

[148]

Determination

[153]

ASIC’s allegations that Mr Karantzis contravened ss 674(2A) and 180(1) of the Act

[160]

Mr Karantzis’ response to the allegation that he contravened s 180(1) of the Act

[168]

Determination

[173]

BREACH OF CONTINUOUS DISCLOSURE OBLIGATIONS – ONE-OFF REVENUE/COSTS

[181]

ASIC’s submissions that iSignthis contravened s 674(2) of the Act

[181]

Not generally available? The relevance of the 30 June 2018 Appendix 4C statement

[194]

Materiality: the lay evidence

[199]

Materiality: the expert evidence

[203]

iSignthis’ responses to ASIC’s breach of continuous disclosure obligation allegations

[227]

The alleged breakdown was not required by the accounting standards

[229]

Report to shareholders for the fourth quarter of FY2018 – Appendix 4C statement

[230]

Materiality

[240]

Determination

[260]

ASIC’s allegations that Mr Karantzis contravened ss 674(2A) and 180(1) of the Act

[276]

Mr Karantzis’ response to allegations that he contravened ss 674(2A) and 180 (1) of the Act

[287]

Any contravention of ss 674(2A) and/or 180(1) of the Act was not serious

[291]

Any contravention by Mr Karantzis should be excused

[292]

Determination

[293]

NON-DISCLOSURE – VISA INFORMATION

[299]

ASIC’s allegations that iSignthis contravened s 674(2) of the Act

[299]

Was there a Listing Rule 3.1A defence between 17 April and 12 May 2020?

[304]

ASIC’s submissions

[310]

iSignthis’ submissions

[321]

Determination

[336]

Was there a Listing Rule 3.1A defence between 12 May and 21 May 2020?

[344]

ASIC’s submissions

[345]

iSignthis’ submissions

[348]

Determination

[355]

Did iSignthis notify the ASX immediately or at all after 21 May 2020?

[359]

ASIC’s submissions

[361]

iSignthis’ submissions

[365]

Determination

[374]

Was the information material?

[377]

ASIC’s submissions

[378]

The lay evidence

[378]

The expert evidence

[384]

Suspension from trading

[399]

iSignthis’ submissions

[401]

Determination

[420]

ASIC’s allegations that Mr Karantzis contravened s 180(1) of the Act

[435]

Mr Karantzis’ response to the allegation that he contravened s 180(1) of the Act

[443]

The preservation of iSeM’s licence was in the best interests of iSignthis

[444]

iSignthis’ shares were suspended

[448]

If there were contraventions of ss 674(2) and 180(1) of the Act they were not serious

[453]

Mr Karantzis ought fairly be excused for the contravention

[454]

Determination

[455]

THE PROVISION OF FALSE AND MISLEADING INFORMATION TO THE ASX BY MR KARANTZIS

[470]

ASIC’s submissions

[472]

The 25 May 2020 response

[477]

The 17 August 2020 response

[501]

Mr Karantzis’ response to the allegation that he contravened s 1309(2) and (12) of the Act

[504]

The 25 May 2020 response

[513]

Question 1(b)

[515]

Question 1(e)

[518]

Question 2(b)

[527]

Question 2(d)

[529]

Question 2(e)

[531]

Question 2(f)

[533]

The 17 August 2020 response

[536]

If there was a contravention of s 1309(2) of the Act it was not serious

[540]

Mr Karantzis ought fairly be excused for any contravention

[544]

Determination

[545]

The 25 May 2020 response

[545]

Question 1(b)

[547]

Question 1(e)

[548]

Question 2(b)

[549]

Question 2(d)

[550]

Question 2(e)

[551]

Question 2(f)

[552]

Mr Seyfort’s advice does not provide a defence

[553]

Mr Karantzis’ contravention of s 1309(2) of the Act was serious, and he should not be excused for any contravention

[561]

17 August 2020 response

[565]

DID MR KARANTZIS BREACH HIS DIRECTOR’S DUTIES IN RELATION TO THE PERFORMANCE SHARES?

[569]

Section 182: use of position to gain an advantage

[570]

The evidence relied upon by ASIC

[574]

Relevant principles

[591]

Did Mr Karantzis breach s 182 of the Act?

[601]

The existence of a legitimate business purpose

[602]

(a) iSignthis’ cash flow positive commercial goal

[611]

(b) The knowledge gained was subsequently applied for faster integrations

[618]

(c) Revenue earned in each 6-month period after 21 December 2018

[619]

(d) iSignthis’ commercial and revenue purpose in entering the integration contracts

[634]

OT Markets

[638]

Corp Destination

[640]

Fcorp

[648]

IMMO

[658]

Rodeler Limited: a missed commercial opportunity

[668]

The June invoices: Corp Destination, Fcorp and IMMO

[671]

(e) An alternate fee structure for the service contracts?

[674]

The Northwood/Moore emails

[683]

Revenue recognition / FY2018 Audit

[692]

Jones v Dunkel inferences against Mr Karantzis?

[719]

Section 181: failure to discharge duties for a proper purpose

[724]

ASIC’s submissions

[726]

Mr Karantzis did not breach s 181 of the Act

[727]

CONCLUSION

[729]

Background

Background to the litigation

I record, however, that the final iteration of ASIC’s pleading is the further amended statement of claim dated 9 March 2023. The final iteration of the first defendant’s defence is that dated 15 December 2021, and the final iteration of the second defendant’s defence is that dated 8 March 2023 (and filed 9 March 2023). ASIC also filed a reply dated 15 March 2021. FACTUAL BACKGROUND Under cover of this introduction I turn to those background matters which it is necessary to understand in order to grapple with the case which ASIC brings, and the defendants’ responses. As has been mentioned, there are broadly two periods of time relevant to the alleged contraventions. These periods, and the relevant circumstances, are as follows. The One-off Revenue period The One-off Revenue period begins in March 2015 and runs through until 3 August 2018, but with relevant facts that extend until 15 November 2019. The circumstances relate to: (a)iSignthis’ satisfaction, as at 30 June 2018, of a series of contractual conditions related to its revenue performance, the satisfaction of which led to the issuing of shares in iSignthis to other persons and entities; and(b)representations made by iSignthis and Mr Karantzis that, ASIC alleges, were false or misleading (at the earliest on 18 June 2018 and at the latest on 3 August 2018) about the proportion of iSignthis’ total revenue for the final quarter of FY2018 that was made up of one-off revenue and/or upfront fees, as opposed to recurring revenue. The Performance Milestones In March 2015 iSignthis was reverse-listed on the ASX after it acquired 100 per cent of the shares in two entities involved in the provision of online identification and payment authentication services (iSignthis BV and ISX IP Ltd) from iSignthis Limited BVI (the acquisition). iSignthis Limited BVI is a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands (and also named iSignthis Limited) and controlled by Mr Karantzis, who was both its director and shareholder. The consideration received by iSignthis Limited BVI (as vendor) for the acquisition was the issuing by iSignthis of some 300,000,000 Ordinary Shares and 366,666,667 Performance Shares. The Performance Shares were issued on terms that each class would convert on a one for one basis into Ordinary Shares upon iSignthis meeting certain Performance Milestones by 30 June 2018. The Performance Milestones required iSignthis to achieve revenue of $2.5 million (for Class A), $3.75 million (for Class B), and $5 million (for Class C) over a six-month reporting period. In the event that iSignthis did not achieve the Performance Milestone for a class of Performance Shares before 30 June 2018, all the Performance Shares in that class would convert into a single Ordinary Share. However, as matters controversially transpired, iSignthis was successful in meeting all of the Performance Milestones by 30 June 2018 in the final six-month reporting period before the deadline, being the third and fourth quarters of FY2018, resulting in the issue of the 366,666,667 Ordinary Shares.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Before turning to the detail of these allegations it is convenient to deal with certain preliminary matters and provide some further information by way of background. THE CONDUCT OF THE HEARING, THE EVIDENCE AND THE PLEADINGS The hearing of this matter commenced on 28 February 2023 and took place over 15 hearing days: 28 February 2023 to 3 March 2023, 6 March 2023 to 10 March 2023, then 5 June 2023 to 8 June 2023, followed by oral closing submissions on 26 and 27 June 2023. The hearing covered all questions in the proceeding relating to liability, and ASIC seeks declarations against iSignthis and Mr Karantzis in relation to the various contraventions of the Act which it alleges. The amount of any pecuniary penalty to be paid by reason of any contravention of the Act was not considered. ASIC’s position is that it will seek pecuniary penalties against iSignthis and Mr Karantzis and orders disqualifying Mr Karantzis from managing corporations in the event that it succeeds in obtaining declarations of contraventions. As will be apparent, the hearing was conducted in two tranches. The first was ASIC’s opening and the company’s case, together in part with the position of Mr Karantzis in relation to certain of the claims. The claims relating to false or misleading information given to the ASX and breaches of director’s duties by Mr Karantzis were considered in the second tranche of the trial because these were claims only made against Mr Karantzis. In circumstances where ASIC seeks civil penalties against Mr Karantzis he exercised his right to rely on the penalty privilege; that is to say, the privilege from self-exposure to a penalty: see Macdonald v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2007) 73 NSWLR 612; Anderson v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] 2 Qd R 401. There was a more complete opening of Mr Karantzis’ case in relation to these matters after ASIC had substantially closed its case. For present purposes then ASIC relied upon the following lay evidence: (a)affidavits of Mr Adam Boscoscuro, a senior lawyer employed by ASIC, sworn on 7 August 2021 and 18 October 2022; (b)an affidavit of Mr Scott Tilden, a program manager employed by ASIC, affirmed on 6 August 2021; (c)an affidavit of Ms Shanny Chen, an accountant employed by ASIC, affirmed on 6 August 2021; and (d)an affidavit of Mr Richard Plews, head of compliance at Morgans Financial Limited, affirmed 31 May 2023. The affidavits of Mr Boscoscuro, Ms Chen, and Mr Tilden broadly relate to the custody of evidence obtained by ASIC on its investigation, the provenance of a certain audio recording, and in relation to various queries raised by ASIC regarding some accounting matters. The affidavit of Mr Plews relates to off-market share trading. Mr Boscoscuro was cross-examined. Mr Tilden, Ms Chen and Mr Plews were not cross-examined. In addition, ASIC tendered a number of documents. iSignthis relied on the following evidence of lay witnesses: (a)an affidavit of Ms Anna Ilina, the Anti-Money Laundering Compliance Officer for iSeM responsible for reporting to the CBC and MOKAS (the Unit for Combating Money Laundering in Cyprus) in relation to AML and counter-terrorism financing laws in Cyprus, sworn on 20 September 2021; (b)an affidavit of Mr Timothy Hart, the independent non-executive chairman of iSignthis, and, from December 2021 the executive chairman of iSignthis, sworn on 21 September 2021 (First Hart Affidavit); (c)an affidavit of Ms Elizabeth Warrell, the chief financial officer of iSignthis from 2 September 2019 and its joint company secretary from 1 November 2019, and the chief financial officer of iSeM from October 2021 until August 2022 when she resigned from iSignthis to focus on the business of iSeM (which is now known as ISX Financial EU Plc), sworn on 21 September 2021 (Warrell Affidavit); (d)an affidavit of Mr Scott William Minehane, a non-executive director of iSignthis since November 2011, sworn on 21 September 2021; and (e)an affidavit of Ms Linda Luu, Head of Legal, Australia, New Zealand and South Pacific for Visa AP (Australia) Pty Ltd, sworn on 12 October 2022 and filed by Visa AP in the proceeding in relation to objections to a subpoena issued by the defendants on 8 March 2022 seeking the production of documents and communications broadly relating to the suspension and/or termination of iSignthis and/or iSeM from around 2019-2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Adopting termination introduced by ASIC, this decision will be referred to as the Visa Termination Decision. The following matters were noted by Visa (in the 17 April letter) as the reasons for its having decided to terminate its relationship with, and the licences of, iSignthis and iSeM:(a)“Inadequate merchant on-boarding processes”;(b)“Inadequate merchant due diligence”;(c)“The transaction monitoring program is not fit-for-purpose” that “had failed to identify the unusual transactional behaviour ”;(d)“General lack of proactive investigation and management”; and(e)“Failure to register and disclose the use of third-party agents”. The 17 April letter set out steps to be taken by both parties “to effect the termination of iSignthis as a Visa client”. The letter stated: The IST Response has not allayed the concerns outlined in the Suspension Letter, and in fact further evidence has been provided that IsignThis is not operating appropriate programs to manage Anti-Money Laundering and Risk. Therefore, in accordance with the Visa Rules, and to safeguard Visa’s global payment system from the excessive level of risk presented by the IsignThis relationship, Visa has decided to terminate its relationship with IsignThis in Europe and Australia. It must also cease acting as a registered third party for any other Visa members or clients. Mr Karantzis and Mr Hart exchanged a number of emails on 18 April 2020 in which Mr Karantzis’ observed that Visa’s 17 April letter “couldn’t [sic] be worse” and “lets [sic] see what we can do re appeal etc”. Also on 18 April 2020, Mr Hart sent an email to Mr Karantzis providing what appears to be a draft announcement to the market. Mr Seyfort of HWL Ebsworth, the company’s principal external legal adviser, received a telephone call from Mr Karantzis on 18 April 2020 in relation to the 17 April letter. Mr Seyfort asked Mr Karantzis a “large number” of questions about the importance of Visa to iSignthis’ business, and the apparent dispute with Visa. Shortly after the call, Mr Seyfort received emails from Mr Karantzis containing the 17 April letter with some of Mr Karantzis’ commentary and emails Mr Karantzis had sent to Mr Hart, including Mr Hart’s suggested form of a potential announcement. Mr Seyfort deposes that over the weekend of 18 and 19 April 2020 he had conversations with Mr Hart and Mr Karantzis about the 17 April letter, and that Mr Karantzis informed him that iSignthis and iSeM disputed and intended to challenge the contentions in the letter. Mr Seyfort’s evidence is that he informed them that he was inclined to the view that iSignthis did not need to make an announcement on the ASX market platform, but that he would reflect on the matter. On 19 April 2020 Mr Karantzis emailed Mr Hart and Mr Seyfort, with the subject line “Hail Mary”, and set out a draft email he intended to send to Visa. In the email Mr Karantzis stated that “there are two theories at play here” being that: 1. Visa want us out and this was just the medium used. Could be that we represent far too much brand risk for them, decision made at high level, irrevocable or 2. Our friend …, who threatened to "shut us down" mid last year, has succeeded in doing so. Given he would have been one of the authors of this letter, and his newfound rise in authority, and also with a brand new … and also a brand new … - it would not be difficult for him to pull wool over and steer this to where it needs to be.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is relevant to note, on ASIC’s case, that iSignthis had not achieved any of the Performance Milestones in any six-month period to 31 December 2017 following the acquisition. However, in the six-month period ending 30 June 2018, iSignthis reported revenue of approximately $5.5 million. Further detail as to the timing and source of this revenue is outlined below in considering whether Mr Karantzis breached his director’s duties in relation to the Performance Shares. The integration agreements The significant rise in revenue in the reporting period ending 30 June 2018 was due to iSignthis having entered into a series of what have been referred to as integration agreements in that period. These agreements involved iSignthis contracting with particular client entities to integrate those entities into online trading platforms (such as the “Panda” platform) and/or payment platforms, and to secure the relevant licensing services for the client. iSignthis had previously integrated customers onto trading/payment platforms. The agreements entered into in the first half of 2018, however, involved a new and more remunerative integration structure for the company. At a high level, the structure of these agreements was that iSignthis, through a wholly owned subsidiary (Authenticate BV), would contract with the relevant entity to provide some combination of licensing, software, and integration services and simultaneously enter into a corresponding outsourcing agreement with another company to provide those services. iSignthis, through its subsidiary, would therefore book as revenue upfront the full amount of contracted for fees under the integration agreements (including the licensing and other service fees charged by the end-licensor), which would then be passed onto the corresponding out-sourcing party as costs incurred under the outsourcing agreement, less a project management fee of approximately 7.5 per cent. Integration agreements broadly of this type were concluded by Authenticate BV, with a number of start-up companies. These were Corp Destination Pty Ltd, Fcorp Services Ltd, and IMMO Servis Group s.r.o.. There was later a variation agreement with Corp Destination. Corresponding outsourcing agreements were entered into with Fino Software Technologies Ltd, a Cyprus company outsourcing the licencing and integration services to be provided by Authenticate BV to Corp Destination and to Fcorp. An outsourcing agreement in relation to IMMO was entered into with another company, GibiTech Ltd. The relevant details of these agreements are considered further below. iSignthis also had another commercial opportunity presented to it during the fourth quarter of FY2018 which did not proceed. That was the opportunity to provide an integrated third-party customer relationship management (CRM) system and trading platform to Rodeler Limited, working with BitTech Advanced Technologies Ltd. Reference will also be made to this below. Upon contracting with the relevant clients, and in some instances before the contracts were executed, iSignthis, under Mr Karantzis’ direction, issued invoices for the contracted-for fees. All of the revenue was recorded before 30 June 2018. iSignthis recorded a significant increase in revenue for this period on the back of agreements which were substantively low-margin and concluded on a one-off transactional basis.