Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   MINERALOGY PTY LTD -v- SINO IRON PTY LTD [2021] WASC 45

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   16 - 20 & 24 NOVEMBER 2020

DELIVERED          :   24 FEBRUARY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2840 of 2018

BETWEEN:   MINERALOGY PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

SINO IRON PTY LTD

First Defendant

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Second Defendant

CITIC LIMITED

Third Defendant

SINO IRON PTY LTD

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim

AND

MINERALOGY PTY LTD

First Defendant by Counterclaim


Catchwords:

Contract - Interpretation -Words susceptible to more than one meaning - Mine site remediation obligation promise in contract - Site Remediation Fund to hold funds to be used for Site Remediation Costs - Contributions to be made by defendants on annual basis when notified of annual charge by plaintiff - Charge to be for forthcoming Operating Year of mining operations - Whether designated trust account set up - Attempted notification of annual charge in 2018 - Dispute over validity of 2018 notification - No contribution made to Site Remediation Fund by defendants - Dispute over proper construction of equation for annual charge - Whether to divide Site Remediation Costs over remaining years until Mine Closure as opposed to in full by lump payment - Whether 2018 determination valid

Trustees - Contractual agreement that Site Remediation Fund to be held by plaintiff on trust - Application to remove and replace trustee - Discretionary considerations - Whether valid trust - Whether court should exercise discretion

Legislation:

Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty Ltd) Agreement Act 2002 (WA)
Trustees Act 1962 (WA)

Result:

Plaintiff's claim dismissed
Defendants' counterclaim dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr P Dunning QC, Mr K Byrne & Mr J Kennedy
First Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC, Mr J H Kirkwood & Mr L N Firios
Second Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC, Mr J H Kirkwood & Mr L N Firios
Third Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC, Mr J H Kirkwood & Mr L N Firios

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Kane Jones
First Defendant : Allens
Second Defendant : Allens
Third Defendant : Allens

Counterclaim

Counsel:

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim : Mr S K Dharmananda SC, Mr J H Kirkwood & Mr L N Firios
Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim : Mr S K Dharmananda SC, Mr J H Kirkwood & Mr L N Firios
First Defendant by Counterclaim : Mr P Dunning QC, Mr K Byrne & Mr J Kennedy

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim : Allens
Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim : Allens
First Defendant by Counterclaim : Kane Jones

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australasian Conference Association Ltd v Mainline Constructions Pty Ltd (in liq) (1978) 141 CLR 335

Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australian Performing Rights Association Ltd [1973] HCA 36; (1973) 129 CLR 99

Baden Delvaux & Lecuit v Sociéte Générale pour Favoriser le Développement due Commerce et de L'Industrie en France SA [1993] 1 WLR 509

Barnes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mineralogy Pty Ltd sought relief against Sino Iron Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Western Australia over obligations under a mine site remediation agreement. The primary issue was whether Sino Iron was required to make an annual contribution to a Site Remediation Fund, and if the 2018 notification of the annual charge was valid. The dispute arose from differing interpretations of the contract's provisions regarding the calculation and payment of annual charges, and whether these charges should be spread over the remaining years of mining operations or paid in full upfront. Additionally, the case involved questions about the validity of the trust under which the Site Remediation Fund was held and whether the court should exercise its discretion to remove and replace the trustee.

The court examined the contract language and relevant precedent to determine the parties' obligations. It found that the contract language was ambiguous, and the parties' conduct and communications provided context for interpreting the ambiguous terms. The court held that the annual charge for 2018 was valid, and that Sino Iron was required to contribute to the Site Remediation Fund. The court also held that the trust under which the Site Remediation Fund was held was valid, but that the court should exercise its discretion to remove and replace the trustee due to a conflict of interest.

The court ordered Sino Iron to contribute to the Site Remediation Fund in accordance with the contract, and that the trustee of the fund be removed and replaced. The court also ordered that the parties bear their own costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Harris then identifies multiple and various conditions applicable to the different mining tenements, for instance, obligations in relation to the capping, filling or otherwise making safe of all surface holes drilled for the purposes of exploration or the determination of ore reserves, obligations in respect of the separate stockpiling for replacement after backfilling or completion of operations in relation to all topsoil removed ahead of Mining Operations, the removal of all buildings and structures at the completion of operations to the extent of them being demolished or buried to the satisfaction of the Director, Environmental Division of the Department of Industry and Resources and the like. There are also extensive reporting obligations identified (for instance, see Condition 14 to General Purpose Lease 08/54) concerning project operations, mine site environmental management and rehabilitation work undertaken in the previous 12 months and proposed operations and management plans and rehabilitation programmes for the following 12 months. That is a reporting obligation to the Executive Director, Environmental Division DMP. Under pars 16 and 17 Mr Harris explains a series of sublease agreements that Mineralogy entered with various subsidiary corporations in the period between 25 October and 21 November 2001. In this period, mining subleases were entered into with Sino Iron (under its prior name of Bellswater Pty Ltd). Bellswater later changed its name to Sino Iron, on 8 March 2005. Subleases were also entered with Korean Steel and Balmoral Iron at the same time. On 21 November 2001, a sublease was entered with International Minerals Pty Ltd (International Minerals). Under pars 18 and 19 Mr Harris explains that a State Agreement as entered between the State of Western Australia and Mineralogy, Sino Iron and Korean Steel, was ratified by an Act of Parliament that was assented to on 24 September 2002. This is the earlier mentioned State Agreement Act. Under pars 20 through 23 of his statement Mr Harris then identifies a Joint Development Agreement (JDA) of 12 March 2005 entered into between Mineralogy, Mineralogy Mine Management Pty Ltd, International Minerals, Balmoral Iron and Sino Iron. He explains that at that time each of the companies (other than International Minerals) were subsidiaries of Mineralogy. The purpose of the JDA is explained at par 21 by Mr Harris - by reference to what is outlined by the recitals of the JDA. Mr Harris relates by his pars 21 and 22, and in uncontroversial terms, that:... Mineralogy had granted, through the Subleases described above, rights to mine magnetite iron ore to several of its subsidiaries which were party to the JDA, but the extraction of the ore pursuant to those rights required a single open cut operation. The JDA, accordingly, sought to coordinate the manner in which the mining rights granted under the Subleases were to be exercised, including through the use of a 'Manager' which was initially to be Mineralogy Mine Management Pty Ltd. Schedule 1 to the JDA included an allocation of 'Mine Costs' among each of the companies participating in the mining operations.