Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 96 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   MINERALOGY PTY LTD -v- SINO IRON PTY LTD [2020] WASC 40

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   25 SEPTEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   13 FEBRUARY 2020

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3129 of 2018

BETWEEN:   MINERALOGY PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

CLIVE FREDERICK PALMER

Second Plaintiff

AND

SINO IRON PTY LTD

First Defendant

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Second Defendant

CITIC LTD

Third Defendant

SINO IRON HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Fourth Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Permanent stay application by defendants - Abuse of process - Anshun estoppel - Liquidated claims all previously pursued then discontinued in multiple earlier proceeding - Explanation for discontinuance of claims - Whether claims can and should have been explicitly 'parked' for later determination - Forensic decision to discontinue and re-litigate claims an abuse of process  - Case management considerations

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Permanent stay order issued

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : Mr L Livingston, Mr T March & Mr K Byrne
Second Plaintiff : Mr L Livingston, Mr T March & Mr K Byrne
First Defendant : Mr C M Scerri QC & Mr T B Maxwell
Second Defendant : Mr C M Scerri QC & Mr T B Maxwell
Third Defendant : Mr C M Scerri QC & Mr T B Maxwell
Fourth Defendant : Mr C M Scerri QC & Mr T B Maxwell

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Kane Jones
Second Plaintiff : Alexander Law
First Defendant : Allens
Second Defendant : Allens
Third Defendant : Allens
Fourth Defendant : Allens

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Aon Risk Services Australia v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27; (2006) 226 CLR 256

Commonwealth of Australia v Albany Port Authority [2006] WASCA 185

Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2000] UKHL 65; [2002] 2 AC 1

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [2015] WASC 454

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 105

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 12] [2016] WASC 335

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 13] [2016] WASC 403

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 14] [2017] WASC 17

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 16] [2017] WASC 340

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 17] [2018] WASC 8

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 18] [2018] WASC 307

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 4] [2014] WASC 282

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 8] [2015] WASC 473

Palmer v CITIC Ltd [2019] WASC 14

Patrick Jebb as trustee for the Trafalgar West Investments Trust v Superior Lawns Australia Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 121

Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd [1981] HCA 45; (1981) 147 CLR 589

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc [2011] FCAFC 156

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mineralogy Pty Ltd sought to enforce a contractual agreement with Sino Iron Pty Ltd and others (collectively, the CITIC Parties) for the payment of unpaid royalties. The dispute involved multiple proceedings, including a permanent stay application and issues concerning abuse of process and anshun estoppel. The court had to determine whether Mineralogy's decision to discontinue certain claims in earlier proceedings and re-litigate them constituted an abuse of process and whether the CITIC Parties were estopped from challenging the re-litigation of those claims.

The court found that Mineralogy's decision to discontinue certain claims and re-litigate them was an abuse of process, as Mineralogy could and should have 'parked' those claims for later determination. The court reasoned that Mineralogy's forensic decision to discontinue and re-litigate claims was an abuse of the court process, and the CITIC Parties were not estopped from challenging the re-litigation of those claims. The court emphasised the importance of case management considerations and the efficient use of court resources.

The court ordered Mineralogy to pay the CITIC Parties' costs of and incidental to the proceedings that were discontinued. The court also noted that Mineralogy's decision to discontinue and re-litigate claims had financial and employment implications for Mineralogy and its related companies.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Palmer says:4.On 7 December 2015 Mineralogy sought, amongst other things, a mandatory interlocutory injunction compelling the CITIC Parties to pay to Mineralogy the sum of US$48 million in respect of unpaid royalties.5.Tottle J delivered judgment on the application on the same day, refusing the application (Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No. 8] [2015] WASC 473).6.Mineralogy successfully appealed from the decision of Tottle J. The Court of Appeal delivered judgment on 27 June 2016, allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of Tottle J and remitted Mineralogy's application for a mandatory injunction to the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 105).7.The remitted application for a mandatory injunction was heard by Kenneth Martin J on 27 and 28 October 2016. At that time, Mineralogy sought, amongst other things, a mandatory interlocutory injunction compelling the CITIC Parties to pay to Mineralogy approximately US$80 million.8.The increase in the amount sought, from US$48 million to US$80 million, reflected the unpaid royalties arising from the CITIC Parties' mining operations for the period from the fourth quarter of 2015 to the second quarter of 2016 inclusive.9.…10His Honour Kenneth Martin J delivered judgment in respect of the remitted application for a mandatory injunction on 13 December 2016 (Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No. 13] [2016] WASC 403 (Injunction Judgment)).CIV 1808 / 2013 - Mineralogy's application for leave to amend and secure early trial dateSteps taken prior to receipt of Injunction Judgment11.Between late October 2016 and 13 December 2016, following the hearing of the mandatory injunction application and prior to the delivery of the Injunction Judgment, I considered a number of options to expedite determination of the question whether Royalty Component B was payable.12.I considered that a swift resolution of this question would not only save the parties costs but would be in the public interest. I considered the expedient resolution would free up court time and be an efficient use of court resources and allow court time to be freed up for others.Narrowing the issues for trial13.I first gave consideration to narrowing the issues for trial, as previous attempts to identify separate questions for early determination had not been successful.14.In that regard, on 11 May 2015 Chaney J heard chamber summonses filed by Mineralogy on 9 September 2014, 20 February 2015, 30 March 2015 and 8 May 2015. [...]15.In the application before Chaney J, in support of the application to have separate questions identified for early determination, Senior Counsel for Mineralogy had specifically identified the claim under clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs as being one in respect of which 'the factual fight looks like a very long building case and the rest is not' see 11 May 2015 transcript [...]16.Despite that, Chaney J had said (see 11 May 2015 transcript [...]:... it all just looks like a highly risky endeavour, from the court's point of view, to try to - to try to hive issues off. So I'm - that's what you're confronting I'm afraid.17.Having determined to pursue a strategy of narrowing the issues for trial, I caused Mineralogy to take the following steps:(a)On 28 October 2016, Mineralogy first proposed that the parties confer with a view to identifying the main issues to proceed with to trial: [...];(b)On 31 October 2016, Mineralogy confirmed that it did not intend to press its claims for repudiation or termination of the MRSLAs. [...]; and(c)On 1 November 2016, Mineralogy confirmed that it did not intend to press its claims for breaches of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs: [...].18.In respect of 17(b) above, during the hearing of the mandatory injunction application, his Honour had also indicated to Senior Counsel for Mineralogy that he had a 'conceptual problem' with ordering a mandatory injunction in circumstances where Mineralogy pleaded, at that time, termination of the MRSLAs (see for example, 27 October 2016 transcript page 1313, 'CFP-01 ', page 80). That indication was also a factor in my decision to cause Mineralogy to confirm on 31 October 2016 that it did not intend to press a claim for repudiation and termination.Separate questions19.Despite Mineralogy being unsuccessful in its previous applications for separate questions (see paragraphs 14 to 16 above), I recall that a number of comments made by Kenneth Martin J during the hearing of the mandatory injunction application caused me to believe that it may be worthwhile for Mineralogy to test further the possibility of identifying questions for separate determination.20.I recall being briefed on the mandatory injunction hearing and reviewing the transcript of the day's proceedings when it became available and I have reviewed the transcripts of the mandatory injunction hearing again for the purpose of swearing this affidavit.21.While I cannot recall precisely which of his Honour's comments caused me to form the view referred to above (at paragraph 19) I can recall generally that they were comments of the following type:(a)The exchange between Kenneth Martin J and Senior Counsel for Mineralogy on 27 October, transcript pages 1263 - 1264: 'CFP-01', pages 30-31; and(b)The exchange between Kenneth Martin J and Senior Counsel for the CITIC Parties on 27 October 2016, transcript pages 1377 - 1380: 'CFP-01', pages 144-147.22.The correspondence Mineralogy exchanged with Allens in November 2016 concerning:(a)the hearing of a possible preliminary point [...]; and(b)the filing of a separate construction summons [...];was all sent in furtherance of the possibility, which I wished to pursue, of identifying questions for separate determination with a view to shortening the period of time required for hearing.Decision to await Injunction Judgment23.While Mineralogy and the CITIC Parties did confer in November and early December 2016, I ultimately determined that any decision by Mineralogy to amend its statement of claim and the scope of any preliminary point should await the judgment of Kenneth Martin J in relation to the mandatory injunction. See:(a)Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 16 November 2016 [...]; and(b)Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 2 December 2016 [...].24.I considered that Mineralogy would benefit from knowing the outcome of the Martin J judgment.Steps taken consequent upon the Injunction Judgment25.I recall being briefed on the Injunction Judgment and reviewing it myself as soon as it was published on 13 December 2016 and I have reviewed the judgment again for the purpose of swearing this affidavit.26.Following the delivery of the Injunction Judgment, I caused Mineralogy to serve a proposed amended pleading. The proposed amended pleading no longer pressed claims for repudiation and termination of the MRSLAs, breach of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs or breach of the Standard of Work Provisions of the MRSLAs: [...].27.When it was first served, the proposed amended pleading also included a claim for conversion of property, which was ultimately not pressed by Mineralogy in the final form of the amended pleading.28.I do not address the conversion claim further in this affidavit as it appears to me that it is the removal of the claims referred to in paragraph 26 above, particularly the claim for breach of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs, that is said to be relevant to the CITIC Parties' current application.29.I swore an affidavit in the proceedings on 14 December 2016 which addressed Mineralogy's proposed amended pleading: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 14 December 2016 [...].30.I considered at the time that the amendments fell into two categories:(a) the removal of the claim for termination; and(b)the removal of the claims for breach of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs and breach of the Standard of Work Provisions of the MRSLAs.Removal of termination claim31.In addition to being in the public interest generally to narrow the issues in dispute, my decision to remove the claim for termination was directed to demonstrating that Mineralogy was ready, willing and able to perform its obligations under the MRSLAs.32.I considered that this was critical to Mineralogy as I had formed the view, after reading the Injunction Judgment, that it was a necessary step to Mineralogy receiving any payment before the final hearing for unpaid royalties that had accrued after October 2014, when Mineralogy had otherwise pleaded a case that the MRSLAs had been terminated.33Having read the Injunction Judgment again for the purpose of swearing this affidavit, I recall it was statements of the type referred to in paragraphs [204] and [221] - [233] of the Injunction Judgment that caused me to form that view.34.I recall being encouraged at the time by statements made by his Honour in the judgment which suggested that the conceptual problem his Honour had identified could be readily addressed and that Mineralogy could show itself to be fully ready, willing and able to perform its own obligations under the MRSLAs by removing any allegation that the MRSLAs had been terminated.35.Having read the Injunction Judgment again for the purpose of swearing this affidavit, I recall it was statements of the type referred to in paragraphs [223] and [226] of the Injunction Judgment that caused me to form that view.36.At paragraph [8] of my 14 December 2016 Affidavit I gave the following undertaking on behalf of Mineralogy:I confirm as a director of Mineralogy and as a person duly authorised to make the affidavit on Mineralogy's behalf that it:a)unequivocally withdraws any claims that the MRSLAs have been terminated; andb)is ready, willing and able to perform its future and ongoing obligations under the MRSLAs.37.Aside from the obvious financial benefits in securing the ongoing payment of royalties which to that time had been withheld, it was important for Mineralogy to receive payment of all of the unpaid royalties that had accrued, for the reasons set out in:(a)paragraphs 18 - 32 of my affidavit of 14 December 2016: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 14 December 2016 [...]; and(b)paragraphs 40 - 55 of my affidavit of 21 December 2016: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 21 December 2016 [...].38.The unpaid royalties meant that Mineralogy's cash flow was severely impeded and was threatening the continuing employment of Mineralogy's entire staff and commercial operations.Removal of clause 6.3 claim39.I caused the claims for breach of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs and for breach of the Standard of Work Provisions of the MRSLAs to be removed for the purpose of removing factually intensive claims and obtaining an expedited final hearing date.40.I recall giving consideration to whether Mineralogy should apply to have the construction of clause 8 of the MRSLAs determined as a separate question in lieu of, or in addition to, removing the claims for breach of clause 6.3 of the MRLSAs and for breach of the Standard of Work Provisions of the MRSLAs.41.In that regard, I recall I was encouraged, having read the Injunction Judgment, by statements of the type referred in paragraph [234] of the Injunction Judgment.42.However, I ultimately considered that the better course was to remove the claims from the proceedings so that an expedited final hearing could be listed which finally resolved the pleaded issues in dispute between the parties.43.I came to that conclusion at the time for the reasons set out in:(a)paragraphs 9 - 13 and 33 - 40 of my affidavit of 14 December 2016: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 14 December 2016 [...]; and(b)paragraphs 16 - 19 and 26 - 31 of my affidavit of 21 December 2016: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 21 December 2016 [...].44.It was in the public interest to efficiently deal with dispute in respect of the royalties as soon as possible so as not to use a large amount of court time.14 December 2016 directions hearing45.On 14 December 2016 there was a directions hearing before Kenneth Martin J in relation to the making of orders in accordance with the Injunction Judgment.46.Following the directions hearing, among other orders, the Court:(a)directed Mineralogy to file and serve its Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim by 4pm on 21 December 2016; and(b)listed the hearing of Mineralogy's application for leave to amend its statement of claim on 20 January 2017.Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim47.On 21 December 2016, Mineralogy served the Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim: Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 21 December 2016 [...].48.The Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim served on 21 December 2016 did not contain claims for breach of clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs or for breach of the Standard of Work Provisions of the MRSLAs.49.On the same date, Mineralogy served a further affidavit, sworn by me, on 21 December 2016, which addressed the Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim: Affidavit of Clive Frederick Palmer, dated 21 December 2016 [...].50In that affidavit, at paragraph [15], I restated the undertaking I had given on Mineralogy's behalf in my affidavit of 14 December 2016.CITIC Parties proposed conditions upon the grant of leave to amend51.On 21 December 2016, Allens wrote to Mineralogy seeking agreement to orders in the following terms:... orders to the effect that any payments ordered by the Court in respect of the post-October 2014 period are subject to Mineralogy being - and continuing to be - ready willing and able to perform all of its obligations under the MRSLAs and the other Project Agreements, and maintaining a position both within and outside the proceedings that is consistent with that readiness, willingness and ability.... as a condition of obtaining any leave to amend its pleading which it might obtain, Mineralogy will agree to an order that it will not re-agitate in this or any other proceeding those claims made in its Fourth Amended Statement of Claim dated 1 April 2016 which are proposed to be deleted in its Proposed 5FASOC. Allens letter to Mineralogy, dated 21 December 2016 [...].52.On 28 December 2016 I caused Mineralogy to respond to the Allens letter of 21 December 2016 confirming, among other matters, the following:... Mineralogy has unequivocally withdrawn any claims that the MRSLAs have been terminated or repudiated.…... Other than as set out above Mineralogy reserves all its rights. Mineralogy has narrowed its claims and is proceeding to trial on the matters that are relevant to the claims Mineralogy wishes to make. The claims are what they are and there is no utility in speculating about hypothetical claims or actions that may or may not arise in the future.…Mineralogy does not consent to the orders proposed by your clients. Please confirm your client will consent to the orders set out in our Chambers Summons ...Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 28 December 2016 [...].53.On 9 January 2017, Allens wrote to Mineralogy stating:notwithstanding Mineralogy's letter dated 28 December 2016 ... we remain of the view that, if any orders of the type sought by Mineralogy are to be made (which orders are generally opposed by our clients), there will be a need for others of the kind set out in our letter.Allens letter to Mineralogy, dated 21 December 2016 [...].54.On behalf of Mineralogy, I did not agree to the conditions upon the grant of leave proposed by the CITIC Parties.Proffered undertaking not to raise claims withdrawn by the proposed Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim55.On 11 January 2017 Allens wrote to Mineralogy and indicated it would not be able to put on all its evidence for the hearing on 20 January 2017 and sought Mineralogy's consent to a vacation of the leave hearing on 20 January 2017: Allens letter to Mineralogy, dated 11 January 2017 at O'Donahoo Affidavit, pages 2082 - 2085.56.On 12 January 2017 Mineralogy responded to the Allens letter of 11 January 2017, confirming it did not consent to the orders vacating the leave hearing on 20 January 2017. Mineralogy stated in that letter, 'the reasons inter alia for that are as follows':…Further payments and ready, willing and ableYou have raised 5 additional matters the CITIC Parties allege are relevant to Mineralogy demonstrating it is ready, willing and able to perform its obligations under the MRSLAs and Project Agreements:1.Mineralogy not pursuing in the future claims withdrawn by the proposed Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim;…By letter dated 28 December 2016, Mineralogy has responded concerning matters 2 to 4 above. Notwithstanding Mineralogy's position in its letter dated 28 December 2016 and without prejudice to such position, by this letter, Mineralogy gives the following undertakings:1.Mineralogy will not raise claims which Mineralogy has withdrawn by the proposed Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim against the Defendant in CIV 1808 of 2013 or any other proceeding;…Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 12 January 2017 [...].57.The undertaking was given because the failure to have an early hearing of the matter would have threatened Mineralogy's solvency and the employment of its staff. I concluded that the CITIC parties were not acting in good faith and seeking to delay matters in breach of their obligations and there was no other way that the matter could proceed to trial in the short term without giving the undertaking.58By letter dated 13 January 2017, the CITIC Parties sought a listing date for their proposed adjournment application […].59.On 16 January 2017, the parties received an email from the Associate to Kenneth Martin J indicating that the CITIC Parties' adjournment application had been considered in chambers and that the special appointment on 20 January 2017 should proceed. […]The proffered undertaking was not accepted60.On 12 January 2017 Allens confirmed that it would seek instructions in respect of the proffered undertaking: Allens letter to Mineralogy, dated 12 January 2017 [...].61.On 19 January 2017 Allens responded to Mineralogy proposing additional conditions on the proffered undertaking, in the following terms:Would you please let us know whether Mineralogy will:a)Provide a similar Undertaking to the Court; andb)Consent to an order in the terms previously requested in our letter dated 9 January 2017, to the effect that any grant of leave to amend its pleadings will be conditional upon Mineralogy undertaking to the Court and to the CITIC Parties not to raise the claims which it has withdrawn by the proposed Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim against the Defendants in CIV 1808 of 2013 or any other proceeding and that Mineralogy will pay our clients' costs thrown away in respect of the discontinued claim, on an indemnity basis.Allens letter to Mineralogy, dated 19 January 2017 [...].62On behalf of Mineralogy, I did not consent to the conditions the CITIC Parties proposed on the proffered undertaking.63.I was in Court at the leave hearing on 20 January 2017 and recall that Senior Counsel for the CITIC Parties had an exchange with Kenneth Martin J where Senior Counsel for the CITIC Parties referred to the proffered undertaking as being unsatisfactory.64.I have reviewed the transcript of the leave hearing on 20 January 2017 for the purpose of swearing this affidavit.65.To the best of my recollection, the exchange referred to above at paragraph [63] is that exchange between Kenneth Martin J and Senior Counsel for the CITIC Parties on 20 January 2017 that is extracted at O'Donahoo Affidavit, pages 2304 - 2305.66. The proffered undertaking, which the CITIC Parties did not accept, was not given to the Court. The conditions proposed by the CITIC Parties were not imposed on the grant of leave67.Kenneth Martin J delivered judgment in the leave application on 27 January 2017 (Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 14) [2017] WASC 17), granting leave to Mineralogy to amend the Fourth Further Amended Statement of Claim on an excisional basis. The conditions on the grant of leave sought by the CITIC Parties were not imposed.CIV3011/201768.On 24 November 2017, Kenneth Martin J delivered judgment in CIV 1808/2013 (Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [No 16] [2017] WASC 340) (RCB Judgment).69.On the same day, I caused Mineralogy to file and serve a Writ of Summons indorsed with a Statement of Claim in CIV 3011 / 2017 for the minimum royalty under clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs, seeking orders for the payment by Sino Iron and Korean Steel of $US97,802,035 each and by CITIC of $US195,604,070 [...].70.The proceedings were commenced because the court had just determined the Mineralogy Royalty which would assist the matter in being determined efficiently.71.Having caused Mineralogy to file CIV 3011/2017 I recall reading the RCB Judgment again, and paragraph [599] of the judgment in particular, in which Kenneth Martin J observed that there would not be a future basis for Sino Iron or Korean Steel not to fully co‑operate with Mineralogy by participating in a joint request under clause 33.2(b) of the MRSLAs to facilitate an expert determination of future quarterly Mineralogy royalty disputes.72.I recall that I came to the view, having read the RCB Judgment, that:(a)his Honour was saying that all future disputes concerning Royalty Component B (RCB) must be referred to an expert;(b)his Honour's observations, and the comment in paragraph [599] in particular, included the minimum royalty claim, because the amount claimed was calculated using the Mineralogy royalty formula, of which RCB is part; and(c)as a result, I needed to cause Mineralogy to discontinue CIV 3011 / 2017 and refer the minimum royalty dispute to expert determination under the MRSLAs.73.On 28 November 2017, as a result of the view I had come to (referred to above at paragraph 72), I caused Mineralogy to write to the CITIC Parties to advise that Mineralogy discontinued CIV 3011 / 2017 and intended to pursue the minimum royalty under the expert determination regime: Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 28 November 2017 [...].CIV 3166/20177 4.After CIV 3011/2017 was discontinued I gave further consideration to the RCB Judgment, including for the purpose of causing Mineralogy to prepare to have the minimum royalty dispute referred to expert determination under the MRSLAs.75.Having reflected on it further, I came to the view at the time that the minimum royalty claim was not one of the four categories of dispute identified in the MRSLAs as being referable to expert determination (referred to in paragraphs [493] and [494] of the RCB Judgment) and that a proceeding in respect of the minimum royalty claim would need to be commenced should Mineralogy wish to pursue payment of the minimum royalty.76.On 21 December 2017, having come to the view referred to in paragraph 75 above, I caused Mineralogy to file and serve a Writ of Summons indorsed with a Statement of Claim in CIV 3166 / 2017 in the same terms as was filed in CIV 3011/2017 for the minimum royalty under clause 6.3 of the MRSLAs, seeking orders for the payment by Sino Iron and Korean Steel of $US97,802,035 each and by CITIC of $US195,604,070 [...].77.On 30 January 2018, I caused Mineralogy to write to Allens to indicate that Mineralogy intended to seek leave to amend its statement of claim to:(a)include a claim by Mineralogy under the Fortescue Coordination Deed (FCD) in relation to losses suffered as a result of the failure of Sino Iron and Korean Steel to perform their obligations under the MRSLAs by payment of the minimum royalty; and(b)to join me personally to the proceedings, for the purpose of similarly making a claim under the FCD for losses I had suffered as a result of the failure of Sino Iron and Korean Steel to perform their obligations under the MRSLAs by payment of the minimum royalty.Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 30 January 2018 [...].78.Between February 2018 and April 2018, the parties exchanged correspondence concerning the minimum royalty claim generally and my joinder to the proceedings. That correspondence is at O'Donahoo Affidavit, pages 2585 - 2667.79.During this period, the CITIC Defendants:(a)maintained that they would apply to strike out the minimum royalty claim as an abuse of process; and(b) that they opposed me being joined to the proceedings.80.In light of the position adopted by the CITIC Defendants over this period, in particular in respect of the application for me to be joined to the proceedings, I came to the view that the most efficient course would be for Mineralogy to discontinue CIV 3166/2017 and commence fresh proceedings in which both Mineralogy and me personally would be plaintiffs to the proceedings.81.I did not consider it was an efficient use of the court's resources to determine the joinder application where that question could be simply addressed by Mineralogy filing new proceedings.82.I considered this to be the most appropriate course at the time in light of the fact CIV 3166 / 2017 had only been recently commenced and had not progressed beyond the parties' immediate dispute concerning my joinder to the proceedings.83.I considered at the time that the CITIC Parties would not be prejudiced by the course I was proposing to adopt as it was clear to me, from the correspondence that was exchanged between February 2018 and April 2018, that the CITIC Parties' position would be the same in any new proceedings and their allegation that the minimum royalty claim was an abuse of process (which Mineralogy rejected), could be agitated and determined in the new proceeding.84.Having come to the view set out in paragraph 80 - 83 above, on 14 April 2018, I caused Mineralogy to write to Allens to give notice that it intended to discontinue CIV 3166/2017 and to commence fresh proceedings with both Mineralogy and me personally as plaintiffs: Mineralogy letter to Allens, dated 14 April 2018 [...].Costs of CIV 3166/201785.I accept that, by reason of its discontinuance of the proceedings, Mineralogy must pay the CITIC Defendants' costs of and incidental to the proceedings to be taxed.86.In those circumstances, I undertake on behalf of Mineralogy that Mineralogy will pay the CITIC Defendants' costs of and incidental to CIV 3166/2017 to be taxed.87.I do not accept that Mineralogy should cover those costs on an indemnity basis.CIV 3129/201888.On 11 December 2018 I caused a Writ of Summons indorsed with a Statement of Claim to be filed and served with Mineralogy and me personally as plaintiffs to the proceedings.89.In addition to the financial prejudice Mineralogy will suffer if the proceedings cannot be proceeded with, Mineralogy will suffer from not having sufficient funds to proceed with proposed joint ventures with its related companies including QNI Resources and the reopening of its nickel refinery in Townsville. Such a result would mean that over 800 jobs may not be available. (my emphasis)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established