Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825

Citation: Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825
Parties: MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680 v SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708, KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600, CITIC PACIFIC LTD and CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD ACN 119 578 371; SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708 and KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600; MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680; ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
File number: WAD 110 of 2013
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 14 August 2015
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – power of private parties to create rights inconsistent with legislative and regulatory regimes: [397]-[410]

CONTRACTS – implied term of good faith – test for implication of terms – meaning and content of good faith – difference between normative guiding principles and contractual obligations – circumstances in which implication can be made – whether any scope for implication in this case: [993]-[1037]

CONTRACTS – admissibility of subsequent communications between the parties for interpretation of contracts – when subsequent communications are admissible for the purpose of determining whether parties intended to be bound by the contract  – relevance of subsequent communications: [716]-[749]

CONTRACTS – alleged variation by subsequent contracts of contractual terms contained in formal deed – where subsequent contracts are not in the form of a deed – where subsequent contracts do not refer expressly to the term allegedly being varied – importance of context and nature of variation – where term being varied is, at best, ambiguous

EQUITY – declarations and injunctions – need for proper form – improperly formulated declarations and injunctions that are abstract and not referable to concrete facts: [1043]-[1056]

EQUITY – relief against forfeiture – whether relief against forfeiture is available for termination of contractual rights – whether a proprietary right is required before relief will be granted – relationship between relief against forfeiture and implied restrictions upon the exercise of a contractual discretion: [978]-[992]

EQUITY – penalties – whether obligation requiring vacation of possession following termination of agreement is a penalty – meaning of a primary stipulation – meaning of a failure of a primary stipulation – when clause operates as security for primary stipulation – need for clause to be susceptible to assessment in money terms – need for detriment to be inordinate, extravagant, or oppressive: [469]-[492]

ESTOPPEL – estoppel by convention – requirements for an estoppel by convention – whether estoppel by convention can apply to future rights and future conduct – test for causation and connecting links: [756]-[794]

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – joinder of necessary parties – failure by Mineralogy to join a directly interested party, the State of Western Australia, as a party to the proceedings: [941]-[970]

CONTRACTS – waiver of breaches of contract – conduct which amounts to a waiver – whether requiring breach to be remedied a month before the issue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 825
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6), the Federal Court was tasked with resolving a complex dispute arising from a series of agreements and transactions involving land and port facilities in Western Australia. The core of the dispute involved the interpretation of various agreements, the implication of terms into contracts, the application of estoppel by convention, and the availability of relief against forfeiture and penalties. The primary issue was whether Mineralogy, the appellant, could claim ownership, control, or operational rights over certain port facilities, particularly those within a defined area known as the Circled Area.

The court's analysis focused on the contractual terms outlined in the Subleases, Facilities Deeds, Mining Right and Site Lease Agreements (MRSLAs), and subsequent variations. It examined whether the CITIC parties, the respondents, had any obligation to operate and maintain the port facilities. The court found that the Facilities Deeds did not impose such an obligation on the CITIC parties, and Mineralogy's claims for ownership or operational control were unfounded. The court also considered the implications of subsequent agreements and the principle of "new contract overrides old contracts." Given the extensive integration of the Sino Iron Project, the court concluded that Mineralogy's claims were inconsistent with the terms of the Facilities Deeds and subsequent agreements.

Additionally, the court addressed the issue of estoppel by convention, determining that Mineralogy could not rely on an estoppel to assert future rights or conduct. The court further examined the admissibility of subsequent communications and the implication of good faith terms, concluding that no such terms could be implied in the circumstances of this case. The court also rejected Mineralogy's claims for relief against forfeiture and penalties, finding that the termination of contractual rights did not warrant such relief.

The court ultimately dismissed Mineralogy's application, permanently restrained it from acting on the termination notices issued to the CITIC parties, and dismissed the cross-claim. The court's decision highlighted the importance of contractual clarity and the limitations on private agreements in altering public law regimes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant is permanently restrained from acting upon the termination notices issued to the first and second respondents on 25 November 2014.

3. Other than order 2 above, the cross-claim is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The reasons why Mineralogy’s alternative claims fail are:(1)the alternative relief cannot be ordered in the absence of a directly interested party to these proceedings (the State of Western Australia). Despite being put on notice of this issue as early as 29 April 2013, Mineralogy failed to take any steps to join the State as a party and opposed even the last minute application by the State for limited intervention to make submissions concerning matters of law;(2)Mineralogy’s alternative relief is precluded due to the abstract nature of Mineralogy’s alternative claims, including restating contractual relief in terms which do not resolve the factual controversy;(3)significant parts of Mineralogy’s alternative relief are unavailable in light of the proper concession in closing oral submissions by Mineralogy that private parties cannot, by private agreement, vary or alter a regime of public law legislation and regulation;(4)Mineralogy’s alternative relief depends upon a construction of the Facilities Deeds that I reject;(5)even if Mineralogy’s construction of the Facilities Deeds were correct, those rights cannot be asserted, nor any alternative relief based upon them, due to each of the following, as independent and separate matters: (i) the State Agreement and Approved Proposals, (ii) the MRSLAs, (iii) the Fortescue Coordination Deed, and (iv) the Port Terminal Operator Agreement. In each case the “new contract must override the old contracts so far as their terms clash and the old contracts even if they are not rescinded rendered inoperative to this extent”: Tallerman & Co Pty Ltd v Nathan’s Merchandise (Vic) Pty Ltd [1957] HCA 10; (1957) 98 CLR 93, 128 (Williams J); and(6)if Mineralogy had rights of “possession”, “control”, “ownership” or “operation and maintenance” over the port terminal facilities, which had not been varied by any of the above agreements, then it could not exercise those rights due to an estoppel by convention.2. BACKGROUND, EVIDENCE AND CONCEPTS2.1 Unpleaded matters attempted to be raised by Mineralogy During the course of trial, a number of new, unpleaded matters were raised. Some of those were subsequently withdrawn, although at points during the trial some of those withdrawn points appeared to resurface. First, Mineralogy applied to amend its Reply to make numerous allegations in relation to an alleged Port Terminal Operator Agreement. The CITIC parties had pleaded this agreement as a defence. Mineralogy had pleaded that it was not a legally binding agreement. Mineralogy’s only reason given for this denial was to assert that a “contingency” had not been fulfilled. After opening submissions, and immediately before the weekend preceding the cross-examination of Mineralogy’s witnesses, Mineralogy sought to amend its Reply to raise a suite of other reasons why the alleged Port Terminal Operator Agreement was not binding. Evidence was filed in relation to this amendment application. Submissions were made. Then the amendment application was withdrawn: Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 570. The withdrawn amendment application had included proposed allegations concerning the Port Terminal Operator Agreement that:(1)no agreement was formed because the 23 March 2010 letter was too uncertain;(2)any agreement was abandoned;(3)this was not an agreement to which Sino Iron and Korean Steel were parties;(4)the Port Terminal Operator Agreement did not vary the Facilities Deeds;(5)the Port Terminal Operator Agreement did not permit CPMM to subcontract the role of terminal operator to any other party; and(6)the Port Terminal Operator Agreement was not performed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Again, this matter was not pleaded. The CITIC parties objected to it being raised. Once again, and particularly in the context of this litigation, this unpleaded allegation cannot be raised by Mineralogy. Evidence could have been led on this point from the parties. And the State had no opportunity to respond to it at all.2.2 Objections to evidence in the trial bundle2.2.1 The objections concerning evidence tendered before or during trial The objections were not in an entirely satisfactory state. At the start of this trial I made a number of remarks to counsel about the manner in which I considered it appropriate to deal with the many objections to relevance concerning many exhibits which comprised more than 12,000 pages in the trial bundle. The parties subsequently agreed a regime consistent with my remarks by which objections would be raised and documents would be admitted. One condition of the agreed regime concerning admissibility was that “unless a document is expressly referred to in oral or written submissions it shall be taken as rejected on the ground of relevance and will at the conclusion of the hearing be removed from the Court Book”. I endorsed that regime and the trial proceeded on that basis. After trial, an index to the trial bundle was produced. The parties produced a long list with various different categories of objections in different colours. Some of these objections had been conceded expressly or impliedly. The basis for others was not wholly clear. Ultimately, by emails to the court on 22 July 2015, in response to a query from my associate on 13 July 2015, the parties confirmed that the only objections were by the CITIC parties and were in the following categories:(1)the documents in categories 1 and 2 of the Addendum to Mineralogy’s closing submissions;(2)the “Disputed Documents” listed in an email from the legal representatives of the CITIC parties to my associate on 26 June 2015;(3)in relation to document 263 an objection that the signature of the CITIC representative was made without the CITIC parties’ authority; and(4)documents 57, 66 and 352 being annexures AVH-2, AVH-3, and AVH-4 to Mr van der Heyden’s first affidavit on the basis that the whole of the affidavit is inadmissible. As to (1), this is considered separately in section 2.2.2 below. As to (2), at the conclusion of the trial, the parties were in dispute concerning whether reference had been made to 48 documents that Mineralogy asserted to be relevant and which Mineralogy asserted had been relied upon in its written submissions. Those 48 documents, described as the “Disputed Documents” are documents numbered 185, 187, 274, 277, 278, 279, 316, 322, 331, 332, 333, 335, 336, 350, 351, 358, 359, 362, 370, 377, 378, 383, 388, 392, 416, 419, 420, 423, 425, 443, 451, 452, 453, 456, 457, 508, 509, 513, 515, 516, 520, 522, 523, 537, 561, 563, 568, and 569. Mineralogy submitted that all of these documents were referred to in its closing submissions in [2.7.4], [2.7.20], and [4.1.47]. These were three short paragraphs in 250 pages of submissions. It is helpful to set out those paragraphs in full:2.7.4.Each of [International Minerals, Resourcehouse and its subsidiary China First Iron Ore] had an interest in the development of a port for the exporting of any product they produced. The documents at PER-31 to the First Robinson Affidavit make clear that they were closely involved in developing the Port Construction Proposal to accommodate other interests.2.7.20.The correspondence between Mineralogy, the CITIC parties and ProMet consistently contemplated that the Port would be designed to permit of third party use. Much of the relevant correspondence is contained in Attachment PER-31 to Mr Robinson’s first affidavit. [Submissions are then made about a number of particular documents].4.1.47.Mr Northey said that, given the prospective expansion of the operation to ten lines and about 40 million tonnes per annum, as he was designing, he was “leaving space” so as not to impede the future expansion by the construction of a trestle jetty. It is noted, also, that the construction of a trestle jetty features at many points in the correspondence in “PER-31” where Mineralogy and CITIC agreed upon arrangements being made for third party use.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Although there were many factual issues explored, at the heart of this dispute are a series of legal issues. Most of the numerous legal issues were agitated by the respondent CITIC parties. The headline issues concern questions of contractual construction, implication of terms including a protean obligation of good faith, issues of estoppel by convention, relief against forfeiture, the penalties doctrine, and the effect of non-joinder of third parties on a power to grant injunctions or declarations. The CITIC parties have ultimately been successful on almost all of these issues.1.2 Summary of the case and my decision In 2001, a number of companies including Sino Iron and Korean Steel separately entered into Subleases and Facilities Deeds with their then parent company, Mineralogy. The transactions concerned areas of land, including areas within a future port in the West Pilbara region of Western Australia, approximately 100 km to the south-west of Karratha. In a series of transaction documents between 2006 and 2008, the respondent CITIC parties took over Sino Iron and Korean Steel. The CITIC parties paid $415 million as part of the takeover process. Following government approvals in 2008, the CITIC parties began constructing facilities and preparing for mining and export of magnetite ore under the revised agreements with Mineralogy. Those revised agreements included Mining Right and Site Lease Agreements (MRSLAs) which had replaced the Subleases, and variations to the Facilities Deeds. The CITIC parties built facilities, including port facilities. They constructed a fully integrated mining and export project which is described as the Sino Iron Project or the Project. It is hard to express in words the extent to which every aspect of the Project is dependent upon other aspects of the Project. A view of the Sino Iron Project taken by the Court on the third day of the trial made the extent of integration extremely clear. The cessation of operations in relation to any significant aspect of the Project will bring the entirety of the Project to a halt. The CITIC parties spent billions of dollars constructing the facilities. The CITIC parties have always controlled and operated the facilities although there is some ambiguity in the Facilities Deeds concerning the party who is obliged to operate the facilities. Some of the facilities are contained in an area of the Port of Cape Preston described in the pleadings as the Circled Area. Construction work in the port area at Cape Preston began as early as August 2008. From February 2008, before construction of the facilities, Mineralogy, together with Sino Iron or Korean Steel, submitted a series of project proposals to the State of Western Australia. The proposals were approved. On at least 29 occasions in those proposals, expressly or impliedly, Mineralogy represented that CPMM would be the operator of the port facilities. This was a matter of importance to the State of Western Australia. On 23 March 2010, Mineralogy and the CITIC parties reached an agreement, in a letter signed by Mineralogy and also signed as “acknowledged and agreed” by the CITIC parties. The agreement was that whilst the Port was a single-user port CPMM would perform the role of Terminal Operator in respect of the facilities to be developed for on or behalf of the CITIC parties (which include the facilities in the Circled Area) and that Mineralogy would be responsible for the Harbour Master role. One of the obligations upon CPMM in this Port Terminal Operator Agreement was to pay $3 million to Mineralogy. CPMM made this payment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the very least, the proposed mandatory injunction in ground 4B is unclear and productive of significant confusion.5.1.3 Reason 3: The lack of any legal right in the Facilities Deeds for ownership or operation of Company Facilities As I explained in the introduction to these reasons, Mineralogy’s alternative relief was expressed as a claim of entitlement to the possession and control of the “Port”. Even if this relief were understood to be concerned with possession and control of the port terminal facilities, it was common ground that each of Mineralogy’s grounds for relief 1, 2 and 3 depended on the CITIC parties not having any obligation to operate and maintain the port terminal facilities. Such an obligation would necessarily have required the CITIC parties, or any of them individually, to possess the facilities for this purpose rather than Mineralogy. Mineralogy therefore submitted that cl 23(b) of the Facilities Deeds imposed the obligation to operate and maintain the facilities upon it, not upon the CITIC parties. For the reasons explained in section 3.2 of these reasons, Mineralogy had, and has, no legal right to ownership or operation of the facilities constructed by the CITIC parties under the Facilities Deed (which are currently Company Facilities). Nor did it have any obligation to operate and maintain those facilities as Company Facilities. I reiterate that Mineralogy did not establish, nor did it seek to establish, that the facilities were Shared Facilities. In its pleaded case, Mineralogy relied upon a letter written by CITIC Pacific to its shareholders dated 8 May 2006 and provided to the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. Mineralogy alleged that this letter showed that “at all material times” an admission had been made by the CITIC parties that “the title to the Facilities within the Circled Area comprising the Port remains with Mineralogy”. The letter to which Mineralogy referred to is 40 pages long (including appendices) and discusses in broad terms CITIC Pacific’s transactions with Mineralogy to acquire the mining rights [tb 2291]. The alleged “admission” is contained in one sentence in a paragraph in relation to “Capital Expenditure” [tb 2101] and another in an appendix to the letter [tb 2118]:Some of the infrastructure for which Sino-Iron and Balmoral are required to fund construction is outside the project area of Sino-Iron and Balmoral. According to the preliminary plan which is subject to final feasibility study, infrastructure outside the project area of Sino-Iron and Balmoral may include conveyor belt to the port, port facilities (including jetties, loading and unloading facilities and related infrastructure) and water and power lines and desalination plant (the estimated cost expenditure for which is approximately US$735 million (approximately HK$5,733 million), being part of the US$2,470 million (US$1,370 million for Sino-Iron and US$1,100 million for Balmoral) payable by Sino-Iron and Balmoral for the estimated capital expenditure). Title to those facilities will remain with Mineralogy as it is the owner of the land. However, Sino-Iron and Balmoral will have the right to use the facilities, on paying the operation and maintenance cost and on terms which are fair and equal as compared to other users of the facilities, during the Project life. If there are other projects commenced in the area by participants seeking to use the port or other facilities, those new participants will be obliged to pay an amount to Sino-Iron and Balmoral, to effectively share the capital costs associated with construction of the facilities. The intended capacity of the port to be constructed by Sino-Iron is sufficient to cater for the needs of Balmoral and Sino-Iron in relation to export of the products. (my emphasis).