Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited v Brackenridge

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

BENDIGO AND ADELAIDE BANK LIMITED v BRACKENRIDGE

[2020] SASC 114

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

24 June 2020

MORTGAGES - ESTATE, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF MORTGAGOR AND MORTGAGEE - POSSESSION

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY - ENFORCEMENT OF GUARANTEE AND RELATED MATTERS

BANKING AND FINANCE - BANKS - DUTIES OF BANKS - OTHER MATTERS

The plaintiff (‘the Bank’) seeks possession of a property (‘the Property’) of which the defendant is the registered proprietor.  The defendant granted two mortgages (‘the 2007 Mortgage’ and ‘the 2010 Mortgage’) over the Property in favour of the Bank.  The Bank contends that these mortgages secure the defendant’s obligations under a guarantee executed by the defendant on 20 April 2010 (‘the Guarantee’).  The Bank further contends that the Guarantee covers the indebtedness of Apex Property Solutions Pty Ltd (‘Apex’) under a facility (‘the 2016 Facility’) established through the February 2016 Apex Agreement and extended by the August 2017 Apex Variation Agreement.  The funds advanced under the 2016 Facility were used to construct a luxury dwelling on the Property.

The 2016 Facility expired in December 2017 and the full amount fell immediately due and payable.  Nothing has been paid, and the amount currently outstanding is approximately $4 million.

The Bank contends that Apex and the defendant have defaulted under the facility granted to Apex, the Guarantee and the Mortgages.  In particular, the Bank contends that the defendant is liable for the debt as guarantor of Apex's obligations under the 2016 Facility, that this liability is secured by the Mortgages, and that the Bank is thus entitled to take possession of the Property.

The Bank’s primary claim is advanced pursuant to the contractual arrangements referred to above.  However, the Bank also relies upon an alternative case in estoppel; namely, that even if the Guarantee or Mortgages were found not to extend to Apex’s liability under the 2016 Facility, the defendant is nevertheless estopped from denying that to be the case.  The estoppel is said to arise by convention or by representation.

In addition to challenging various aspects of the Bank’s primary and alternative cases, the defendant raised a number of positive answers to the Bank’s claim, including contentions to the effect that:

•       his former wife has an equitable interest in the Property and ought to have been a party to the action;

•       the 2016 Facility was subject to the National Credit Code, and that the Bank did not comply with various of its provisions;

• the Bank supplied unsolicited financial services to Apex in contravention of s 12DMA of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (‘the ASIC Act’);

•       the Guarantee had expired when Apex’s overdraft account which it was then securing went temporarily into credit in late September 2010;

•       the Bank breached an essential term of the Apex Variation Agreement, and thereby also the Guarantee and Mortgages, by failing to advance certain funds to the defendant in November 2017;

•       the Bank breached its prudential obligation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited v Brackenridge and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited initiated proceedings against Brackenridge, the registered proprietor of a property located at 31 Waterfall Gully Road, Beaumont, South Australia. The dispute centred around two registered mortgages in favour of the Bank, namely the 2007 Mortgage and the 2010 Mortgage. The defendant purchased the property in April 2007 and subsequently constructed a dwelling using funds obtained from the Bank. However, the defendant's intention for the dwelling changed from serving as a display home for his business to being his family residence. The defendant's business interests were pursued through V1 Systems and Apex, both of which he was the sole director and majority shareholder. The Bank, represented by its employees, initially dealt with the defendant through Lee Elphick and Mark Robertson, who approved the initial facility granted to Apex in 2010.

The primary legal issues in this case were whether the Bank had validly exercised its power of sale under the 2007 Mortgage, whether Brackenridge's personal guarantee was valid, and whether Brackenridge had any valid defences against the Bank's claim for possession of the property. The court had to determine if the Bank's actions were consistent with its duties and obligations as a bank and whether Brackenridge's conduct warranted any defences against the Bank's claim.

The court found that the Bank had validly exercised its power of sale under the 2007 Mortgage, as it had followed the proper procedures and complied with the requirements of the mortgage agreement. The court also determined that Brackenridge's personal guarantee was valid, as it was properly executed and there was no evidence of duress, undue influence, or misrepresentation. The court rejected Brackenridge's defences, including his claims of procedural unfairness and lack of notice, finding that the Bank had acted in accordance with its contractual and legal obligations.

As a result of the court's findings, the Bank was entitled to possession of the property, and the 2007 Mortgage and the 2010 Mortgage were declared to be valid and enforceable. The court ordered Brackenridge to pay the Bank's costs of the proceedings, which were assessed at $24,463.50.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In these reasons, I shall commence with some matters by way of background before then setting out, in essentially chronological order, the findings of fact I have made. I shall then address the various steps in the Bank’s case, and the defendant’s contentions in relation to the same. I will conclude by addressing each of the positive answers or ‘defences’ relied upon by the defendant.PART B: BACKGROUNDThe Property The defendant is the registered proprietor of the whole of the land comprised in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5864 Folio 990 situated at 31 Waterfall Gully Road, Beaumont in the State of South Australia (defined earlier as the Property). Two registered mortgages in favour of the Bank are noted on the Certificate of Title: mortgage number 1076 2379 (the Mortgage or the 2007 Mortgage) and mortgage number 1138 2696 (the Second Mortgage or the 2010 Mortgage). As explained below, the defendant purchased the Property in April 2007. A significant dwelling was subsequently constructed on the Property, using funds obtained from the Bank. The building work was undertaken by the defendant, who in turn subcontracted others to perform various aspects of the work. The defendant initially intended that the dwelling would serve as a display home for his design and construction services business. However, when he later began to focus his business efforts upon commercial property development through Apex, it became his intention that the dwelling would be his family residence.Relevant people and entities The defendant has a Bachelor of Business from the University of South Australia. He has worked in several sales and management positions for various large business organisations. More recently he has pursued his own business interests through V1 Systems and Apex. As demonstrated by his communications and dealings with the Bank the subject of these proceedings, and indeed his conduct of these proceedings, the defendant is an intelligent, capable and determined man. V1 Systems was incorporated in 2002, and deregistered on 5 November 2017. The defendant was always the sole director, and was the majority shareholder from at least March 2010. Apex was incorporated in March 2007, and deregistered on 28 July 2019. The defendant had been the sole director since March 2010, and was the only shareholder from August 2007. As mentioned, the plaintiff in these proceedings, referred to as the Bank, is Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited. It is the successor in law to Adelaide Bank Limited. The Bank was represented by various of its employees in its dealings with the defendant that are the subject of these proceedings. Initially the defendant dealt primarily with Lee Elphick (who was assigned the role as the defendant’s banking relationship manager) and Mark Robertson (who was a Regional Credit Manager, and described as the Manager of Business Banking). It was Mr Robertson who approved the initial facility granted to Apex in 2010, based upon a credit memorandum prepared by Mr Elphick. Subsequently, Mike Attiwill approved several extensions of Apex’s facilities, again based upon credit memoranda prepared by Mr Elphick.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established