Bell Group NV (in Liq) v Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, BELL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

Matter No S248/2015

BELL GROUP N.V. (IN LIQUIDATION) & ANOR   PLAINTIFFS

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA  DEFENDANT

Matter No P63/2015

W.A. GLENDINNING & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD  PLAINTIFF

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA  DEFENDANT

Matter No P4/2016

MARANOA TRANSPORT PTY LTD (IN LIQ) &
ORS  PLAINTIFFS

AND

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS  DEFENDANTS

Bell Group N.V. (in liquidation) v Western Australia
W.A. Glendinning & Associates Pty Ltd v Western Australia
Maranoa Transport Pty Ltd (in liq) v Western Australia

[2016] HCA 21

16 May 2016

S248/2015, P63/2015 & P4/2016

ORDER

Matter No S248/2015

The questions stated by the parties in the amended special case dated 29 February 2016 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraph 56 of the statement of claim?

Answer

Yes.

Question 1A

Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the statement of claim insofar as the grounds rely on former s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (and alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth))]?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Is the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid in its entirety?

Answer

Yes.

Question 3

If the answer to question 2 is "no", are any of the provisions of Parts 3 and 4 and any of ss 48, 54, 55, 56, 58 and 69 to 74 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid (and, if so, to what extent)?

Answer

Unnecessary to answer.

Question 4

If the answer to question 3 is yes is the invalid provision severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent)?

Answer

Unnecessary to answer.

Question 5

Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer

The defendant.

Matter No P63/2015

The questions stated by the parties in the amended special case dated 26 February 2016 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 [of] the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) (Bell Act) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56 to 58 of the statement of claim?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell Group NV (in Liq) v Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered the validity of the *Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015* (WA) (the Bell Act) in proceedings brought by liquidators of various Bell Group companies. The dispute centred on whether the Bell Act, a state law, was inconsistent with Commonwealth legislation, specifically the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1936* (Cth), the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1997* (Cth), and the *Taxation Administration Act 1953* (Cth), thereby rendering the Bell Act invalid under section 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution. The plaintiffs argued that the Bell Act purported to create a scheme that stripped Commonwealth tax debts of their characteristics as defined by Commonwealth law, thereby altering, impairing, or detracting from the rights and obligations that had accrued to the Commonwealth.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the plaintiffs had standing to challenge the validity of the Bell Act and whether a justiciable controversy arose from the alleged invalidity. Crucially, the Court was required to determine if the Bell Act was invalid in its entirety due to inconsistency with Commonwealth taxation laws, and if not, whether specific provisions were invalid and severable. The Court also considered, but ultimately found unnecessary to decide, whether the Bell Act infringed Chapter III of the Constitution or was inconsistent with the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth) or the *Judiciary Act 1903* (Cth).

The Court reasoned that the Bell Act was invalid in its entirety by operation of section 109 of the Constitution due to its inconsistency with Commonwealth taxation laws. The Court found that the Bell Act purported to create a scheme that fundamentally altered, impaired, or detracted from the characteristics of Commonwealth tax debts, including their existence, quantification, enforceability, and recovery, as prescribed by the Commonwealth tax legislation. These alterations affected rights and obligations that had accrued to the Commonwealth as a creditor prior to the commencement of the Bell Act.

The High Court answered the questions posed in the special case by affirming that the plaintiffs had standing and that a justiciable controversy arose. The Court declared the Bell Act invalid in its entirety due to inconsistency with Commonwealth taxation laws. Consequently, it was unnecessary to consider questions of severability or other grounds of invalidity. The defendant was ordered to pay the costs of the special case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matter No S248/2015

The questions stated by the parties in the amended special case dated 29 February 2016 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraph 56 of the statement of claim?

Answer

Yes.

Question 1A

Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the statement of claim insofar as the grounds rely on former s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (and alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth))]?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Is the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid in its entirety?

Answer

Yes.

Question 3

If the answer to question 2 is "no", are any of the provisions of Parts 3 and 4 and any of ss 48, 54, 55, 56, 58 and 69 to 74 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid (and, if so, to what extent)?

Answer

Unnecessary to answer.

Question 4

If the answer to question 3 is yes is the invalid provision severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent)?

Answer

Unnecessary to answer.

Question 5

Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer

The defendant.

Matter No P63/2015

The questions stated by the parties in the amended special case dated 26 February 2016 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 [of] the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) (Bell Act) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56 to 58 of the statement of claim?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Act on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the statement of claim insofar as the grounds rely upon s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)])?

Answer

Yes.

Question 3

Are any of the provisions of Parts 3 and 4 and any of ss 51, 52 and 73 of the Bell Act invalid (and, if so, which and to what extent):

(a) by the operation of s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution by reason of:

(i) inconsistency between that provision (as a law of the State of Western Australia) and:

(1) the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) or the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraph 56 to 58 of the statement of claim; further or alternatively

(2) the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 72 to 88 of the statement of claim; further or alternatively

(3) s 39(2) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 68 of the statement of claim?; further or alternatively

(b) because it infringes Chapter III of the Constitution, on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 68 of the statement of claim?

Answer

(a)(i)(1) Yes. The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.

(a)(i)(2) Unnecessary to answer.

(a)(i)(3) Unnecessary to answer.

(b) Unnecessary to answer.

Question 4

If any provisions of the Bell Act are invalid, are they severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent); or is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety?

Answer

The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.

Question 5

Is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety because it infringes Chapter III of the Constitution on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 69 and 71 of the Statement of Claim?

Answer

Unnecessary to answer.

Question 6

Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer

The defendant.

Matter No P4/2016

The questions stated by the parties in the amended special case dated 26 February 2016 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Do the Plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the [Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of

Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) ("the Bell Act")] on the grounds alleged in:

(a) paragraph 56.1 of the [statement of claim], insofar as the grounds rely upon ss 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)]) and 254(1)(h) of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)]; and

(b) paragraphs 56.2, 56.3 and 56.4 of the [statement of claim]?

Answer

(a) Yes.

(b) Yes.

Question 2

Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Act on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the [statement of claim] insofar as the grounds rely upon s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)]) and s 254(1)(h) of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)]?

Answer

Yes.

Question 3

Are any of ss 9, 10, 22, 25, 27, 28, 29, 30, 33, 35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 47, 54, 55, 56, 68, 69, 71, 72 or 73 of the Bell Act invalid, and, if so, which and to what extent, by the operation of s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution by reason of inconsistency between that provision (as a law of the State of Western Australia) and:

(a) the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) or the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 40 to 56 and 91A of the statement of claim; further or alternatively:

(b) the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 91 and 91B of the statement of claim?

Answer

(a) Yes. The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.

(b) Unnecessary to answer.

Question 4

If any provisions of the Bell Act are invalid, are they severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent); or is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety?

Answer

The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.

Question 5

Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer

The first defendant.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, it should be concluded that the Bell Act is invalid in its entirety by the operation of s 109 of the Constitution because of inconsistency between provisions of the Bell Act and provisions of the Tax Acts. The Bell Act purports to create a scheme under which Commonwealth tax debts are stripped of the characteristics ascribed to them by the Tax Acts as to their existence, their quantification, their enforceability and their recovery. The rights and obligations which arose and had accrued to the Commonwealth as a creditor of the WA Bell Companies in liquidation, and to the Commissioner, under a law of the Commonwealth prior to the commencement of the Bell Act are altered, impaired or detracted from by the Bell Act. FactsRelevant entities (a) BGNV The first plaintiff in the BGNV Proceeding, Bell Group NV (in liq) ("BGNV"), is a company formed or incorporated in the Netherlands Antilles. It was registered as a foreign company in each jurisdiction in Australia under s 344 of the Corporations Law on 4 April 1996. In 1995, Troika Holding BV was appointed BGNV's liquidator in the Netherlands Antilles. On 19 July 1996, the second plaintiff in the BGNV Proceeding ("Mr Trevor") was appointed the liquidator of BGNV in Western Australia by order of the Supreme Court of Western Australia to assist the insolvency administration of BGNV in the Netherlands Antilles. On 26 March 1997, the Supreme Court of Western Australia ordered that BGNV be wound up by the Court in insolvency under the Corporations Law and that Mr Trevor be appointed as ancillary liquidator of BGNV in Australia for the purpose of its winding up. The winding up of BGNV has not concluded. (b) TBGL and its subsidiaries The Bell Group Limited (in liq) ("TBGL") is the holding company of a group of companies known as "the Bell Group". TBGL's wholly owned subsidiaries include BGNV, Bell Group Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) ("BGF") (which acted as the treasury entity for the Bell Group) and Maranoa Transport Pty Ltd (in liq) ("Maranoa Transport"), the plaintiff in the Maranoa Transport Proceeding. Mr Woodings is the liquidator (or provisional liquidator) of a number of companies in the Bell Group. The companies relevantly fall into two groups – the WA Bell Companies[7] and those companies[8] that are not WA Bell Companies. Immediately prior to the commencement of the Corporations Act, each WA Bell Company was registered and incorporated in Western Australia under Western Australian law. After the commencement of the Corporations Act, each WA Bell Company was taken, by operation of s 1378 of that Act, to be registered in Western Australia and incorporated in Australia. Under the Bell Act as amended, a reference to a "WA Bell Company" includes Maranoa Transport[9], even though that company was not taken to be registered in Western Australia, but in Queensland. As seen earlier, none of the windings up of the companies in liquidation had concluded prior to 27 November 2015, which was the "transfer day" under the Bell Act. (c) Creditors of the Bell Group companies[7]Albany Broadcasters Ltd (in liq), Ambassador Nominees Pty Ltd (in liq), Belcap Enterprises Pty Ltd (in liq), Bell Bros Holdings Ltd (in liq), Bell Bros Pty Ltd (in liq), Bell Equity Management Ltd (in liq), BGF, Bell Publishing Group Pty Ltd (in liq), Dolfinne Pty Ltd (in liq), Dolfinne Securities Pty Ltd (in liq), Harlesden Finance Pty Ltd (in liq), Industrial Securities Pty Ltd (in liq), Maranoa Transport, Neoma Investments Pty Ltd (in liq), TBGL, TBGL Enterprises Ltd (in liq), Wanstead Pty Ltd (in liq), Wanstead Securities Pty Ltd (in liq), WAON Investments Pty Ltd (in liq), Wigmores Tractors Pty Ltd (in liq). [8]Great Western Transport Pty Ltd (in liq), Maradolf Ltd (in liq), W&J Investments Pty Ltd (in liq), Western Interstate Pty Ltd (Provisional Liquidator Appointed), Western Transport Pty Ltd (in liq). [9]s 3(5) of the Bell Act, inserted by s 4(2) of the Amending Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ GAGELER J
That being so, it is unnecessary to consider the other challenges to the validity of the Bell Act. There is no reason to depart from this Court's settled practice that it does not decide constitutional questions unless necessary for the decision[110].[110]Attorney-General for NSW v Brewery Employés Union of NSW (1908) 6 CLR 469 at 590; [1908] HCA 94; Re Patterson; Ex parte Taylor (2001) 207 CLR 391 at 473-474 [248]-[252]; [2001] HCA 51; ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (2009) 240 CLR 140 at 199 [141]; [2009] HCA 51.Conclusion For these reasons, the questions of law which the parties agreed in stating in the form of a special case for the opinion of the Full Court under r 27.08.1 of the High Court Rules should be answered as follows:Matter No S248 of 2015 – The BGNV ProceedingQuestion 1:Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraph 56 of the statement of claim?Answer: Yes.Question 1A: Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the statement of claim insofar as the grounds rely on former s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (and alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth))]?Answer: Yes.Question 2:Is the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid in its entirety?Answer: Yes.Question 3:If the answer to question 2 is "no", are any of the provisions of Parts 3 and 4 and any of ss 48, 54, 55, 56, 58 and 69 to 74 of the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) invalid (and, if so, to what extent)?Answer: Unnecessary to answer.Question 4:If the answer to question 3 is yes is the invalid provision severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent)?Answer: Unnecessary to answer.Question 5: Who should pay the costs of the special case?Answer: The defendant.Matter No P63 of 2015 – The WA Glendinning ProceedingQuestion 1:Do the plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 [of] the Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) (Bell Act) on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56 to 58 of the statement of claim?Answer: Yes.Question 2:Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Act on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the statement of claim insofar as the grounds rely upon s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)])?Answer: Yes.Question 3:Are any of the provisions of Parts 3 and 4 and any of ss 51, 52 and 73 of the Bell Act invalid (and, if so, which and to what extent):(a)by the operation of s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution by reason of:(i)inconsistency between that provision (as a law of the State of Western Australia) and:(1)the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) or the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraph 56 to 58 of the statement of claim; further or alternatively(2)the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 72 to 88 of the statement of claim; further or alternatively(3)s 39(2) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 68 of the statement of claim?; further or alternatively(b)because it infringes Chapter III of the Constitution, on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 68 of the statement of claim?Answer: (a)(i)(1) Yes. The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.(a)(i)(2) Unnecessary to answer.(a)(i)(3) Unnecessary to answer.(b) Unnecessary to answer.Question 4:If any provisions of the Bell Act are invalid, are they severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent); or is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety?Answer: The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.Question 5:Is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety because it infringes Chapter III of the Constitution on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 69 and 71 of the Statement of Claim?Answer: Unnecessary to answer.Question 6: Who should pay the costs of the special case?Answer: The defendant.Matter No P4 of 2016 – The Maranoa Transport ProceedingQuestion 1:Do the Plaintiffs have standing to seek relief in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the [Bell Group Companies (Finalisation of Matters and Distribution of Proceeds) Act 2015 (WA) ("the Bell Act")] on the grounds alleged in:(a)paragraph 56.1 of the [statement of claim], insofar as the grounds rely upon ss 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)]) and 254(1)(h) of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)]; and(b)paragraphs 56.2, 56.3 and 56.4 of the [statement of claim]?Answer: (a) Yes.(b) Yes.Question 2:Does any justiciable controversy arise in respect of the alleged invalidity of Parts 3 and 4 of the Bell Act on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 56.1 and 56.2 of the [statement of claim] insofar as the grounds rely upon s 215 of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)] (alternatively, s 260-45 of Schedule 1 to the [Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)]) and s 254(1)(h) of the [Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)]?Answer: Yes.Question 3:Are any of ss 9, 10, 22, 25, 27, 28, 29, 30, 33, 35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 47, 54, 55, 56, 68, 69, 71, 72 or 73 of the Bell Act invalid, and, if so, which and to what extent, by the operation of s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution by reason of inconsistency between that provision (as a law of the State of Western Australia) and:(a)the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) or the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 40 to 56 and 91A of the statement of claim; further or alternatively:(b)the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), on the grounds alleged in paragraphs 59 to 91 and 91B of the statement of claim?Answer: (a) Yes. The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.(b) Unnecessary to answer.Question 4:If any provisions of the Bell Act are invalid, are they severable from the rest of the Act (and, if so, to what extent); or is the Bell Act invalid in its entirety?Answer: The Bell Act is invalid in its entirety.Question 5: Who should pay the costs of the special case?Answer: The first defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ, GAGELER J

Full text does not contain this section.