Bilson v Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd; Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd v Bilson

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bilson v Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd; Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd v Bilson [2024] QCA 171

PARTIES:

In Appeal No 5634 of 2024:

LEIGH BILSON
(appellant)
v
VATSONIC COMMUNICATIONS PTY LTD (ACN 093 786 004)
(first respondent)
TOWNSVILLE CITY COUNCIL
(second respondent)

In Appeal No 5563 of 2024:

VATSONIC COMMUNICATIONS PTY LTD (ACN 093 786 004)
(first appellant)
WORKCOVER QUEENSLAND
(second appellant)
v
LEIGH BILSON
(first respondent)
TOWNSVILLE CITY COUNCIL
(second respondent)

FILE NOS:

Appeal No 5634 of 2024
Appeal No 5563 of 2024
DC No 130 of 2021

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Townsville – [2024] QDC 42 (Coker DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

13 September 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 July 2024

JUDGES:

Bowskill CJ and Boddice JA and Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal in proceeding CA 5634 of 2024 (Mr Bilson’s appeal) is allowed.

2.    The appeal in proceeding CA 5563 of 2024 (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd and WorkCover’s appeal) is allowed, in so far as grounds 8 and 9 are concerned, but is otherwise dismissed.

3.    Set aside the orders made at first instance and substitute the following orders.

4.    There be judgment for the appellant (Mr Bilson) against the first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) in the sum of $359,689.84.

5.   There be judgment for the appellant (Mr Bilson) against the second respondent (Townsville City Council) in the sum of $590,801.57.

6. The first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) is entitled to recover 30% of the damages assessed against Vatsonic from the second respondent (Townsville City Council) pursuant to s 6(c) of the Law Reform Act 1995.

7. The second respondent (Townsville City Council) is entitled to recover 70% of the damages assessed against the Council from the first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) pursuant to s 6(c) of the Law Reform Act 1995.

8.    The parties file and serve on one another brief submissions (of no more than 3 pages), together with any necessary affidavit(s), in relation to the costs orders they, respectively, propose, within 7 days.

9.    The parties file any submissions in reply to the primary costs submissions filed (of no more than 2 pages), together with any necessary reply affidavit(s), within 14 days.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – NEW TRIAL – IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS – where Mr Bilson was employed by Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd to operate a hydro vac truck to remove water and debris from drainage pollution pits – where Vatsonic had a contract with the Townsville City Council under which it agreed to provide “wet hire” of a vac truck, which included the truck, vacuum hose and operator – where Mr Bilson was required to work in cooperation with workers employed by the Council, who operated a Council truck with a crane and sling to manoeuvre the hose into and out of pits – where Mr Bilson suffered an injury to his eye whilst working at a particular pit in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bilson v Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd; Vatsonic Communica... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Bilson v Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd and Townsville City Council, the Court of Appeal was tasked with reviewing the decision of a trial judge who had found both Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd and the Townsville City Council liable for the injuries sustained by Mr Bilson, who was employed by Vatsonic to operate a hydro vac truck. The trial judge had apportioned 70% of the liability to Vatsonic and 30% to the Council, and had entered judgment against Vatsonic alone, assessing damages against it. The key legal issues the Court of Appeal needed to decide included whether the trial judge erred in failing to assess damages against the Council, whether the trial judge was correct in finding the Council liable, and whether the trial judge was correct in finding Vatsonic liable. The Court also needed to consider whether the Council's common law claim should be assessed under the statutory regime applicable under the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge did not err in rejecting the expert opinion of Mr Kahler, and that the Council did indeed cause or contribute to Mr Bilson’s injury. With regard to the liability of Vatsonic, the Court found that the trial judge was correct to find that Vatsonic had breached its duty of care to Mr Bilson, as there was no safe system of work established. The Court also found that the trial judge did not err in finding the Council liable for the injury to Mr Bilson, as both parties were required to foresee the risk of harm to Mr Bilson and should have taken proper precautions. Finally, the Court held that the trial judge did not err in finding that the indemnity agreement between Vatsonic and the Council was not voided by s 236B of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003.

The Court of Appeal allowed Mr Bilson's appeal and allowed Vatsonic and WorkCover's appeal in part. The Court set aside the orders made at first instance and substituted new orders, including that there be judgment for Mr Bilson against both Vatsonic and the Council, and that Vatsonic and the Council could recover from each other under the Law Reform Act 1995. The Court also ordered that the parties file and serve on one another brief submissions in relation to the costs orders they proposed, within 7 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal in proceeding CA 5634 of 2024 (Mr Bilson’s appeal) is allowed.

2. The appeal in proceeding CA 5563 of 2024 (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd and WorkCover’s appeal) is allowed, in so far as grounds 8 and 9 are concerned, but is otherwise dismissed.

3. Set aside the orders made at first instance and substitute the following orders.

4. There be judgment for the appellant (Mr Bilson) against the first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) in the sum of $359,689.84.

5. There be judgment for the appellant (Mr Bilson) against the second respondent (Townsville City Council) in the sum of $590,801.57.

6. The first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) is entitled to recover 30% of the damages assessed against Vatsonic from the second respondent (Townsville City Council) pursuant to s 6(c) of the Law Reform Act 1995.

7. The second respondent (Townsville City Council) is entitled to recover 70% of the damages assessed against the Council from the first respondent (Vatsonic Communications Pty Ltd) pursuant to s 6(c) of the Law Reform Act 1995.

8. The parties file and serve on one another brief submissions (of no more than 3 pages), together with any necessary affidavit(s), in relation to the costs orders they, respectively, propose, within 7 days.

9. The parties file any submissions in reply to the primary costs submissions filed (of no more than 2 pages), together with any necessary reply affidavit(s), within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Further, at [70] of Makita, Heydon JA referred to the statement by King CJ in R v Fowler (1985) 39 SASR 440 at 442, that:“… It must be kept steadily in mind that the court (the jury in a jury trial) is the tribunal of fact and that it is no part of the function of a witness to decide what version or interpretation of the facts is to be accepted or rejected.” As the passages from the Reasons set out at paragraph [32] above make plain, the key factor which lead the trial judge to reject the revised opinion of Mr Kahler, following his further testing, was the disconnect between the factual hypothesis underpinning that opinion, and the facts as his Honour found them to be based on the “unchallenged evidence of [Mr Bilson]”. The Council’s submissions on this appeal do not address this. In the circumstances, the trial judge did not err in rejecting the expert opinion of Mr Kahler. It follows that the Council’s overall contention, that the trial judge ought to have found that the Council did not cause or contribute to Mr Bilson’s injury, is rejected. The first three grounds of Vatsonic and WorkCover’s[23] appeal concern the finding of liability on the part of Vatsonic.[23]For ease of reference, I will refer to Vatsonic only. By ground 1, Vatsonic contends the trial judge erred in finding that Vatsonic breached its duty of care to Mr Bilson because “on the facts found by the trial judge, or which ought to have been found, there was a safe system of work established, based on instructions provided by the employer”. The reasoning of the trial judge, in relation to the finding of breach of duty, was as follows:“[80] [Mr Bilson] argues the risk was clear and should have been considered. At paragraphs 68, 69 and 70 [of Mr Bilson’s submissions], the following is put:68There was no risk assessment undertaken by [Vatsonic] to consider the risk of harm to Mr Bilson, when [Vatsonic] knew that the [Council’s] workers were also involved in moving, slinging and lifting the hose, and knowing that [Mr Bilson] was required to work in cooperation with the [Council’s].69The hose was a heavy industrial hose with metal camlocks on it. It was owned by [Vatsonic]. It knew of the characteristics of the hose. It is reasonably foreseeable, without hindsight bias, that moving or lifting the hose could cause harm to Mr Bilson as he was handling it in several ways:• The hose twisting or pulling against Mr Bilson's body could cause a strain injury.• The hose twisting or pulling against Mr Bilson's body could cause is body to be pinched by the camlocks.• The hose twisting with the camlocks spinning in Mr Bilson’s hands could cause an injury to any part of his body within range. As it happened here, the eye was unfortunately the part injured.70A guide to machinery and equipment safety was available before the injury under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011. It refers to identifying, de-energising and isolation procedures for stored energy.[81]I have already in these reasons addressed the matters arising regarding the expert evidence of Mr Contoyannis and Mr Kahler, and have indicated my preference for the opinions of Mr Contoyannis. Only his opinions answered the question that arose from the evidence which I accepted, in respect of [Mr Bilson] and what he said happened with the hose upon uncoupling, and his subsequent observations.[82]These findings combined with the opinions expressed by Mr Contoyannis lead to the obvious need to consider the risks associated with the work conducted by [Mr Bilson] in conjunction with the assistance provided by the [Council’s] workers [such that] a safe work method statement (‘SWMS’) was required for the task of clearing the GPT.[83]The risk of injury from the tasks required to be performed was evident and foreseeable. The need for a SWMS was apparent, but, no SWMS existed. Notwithstanding this need, no person undertook a site assessment or considered an assessment of the task necessary to identify what risks might arise to workers in the course of performing the informal system of work that had developed and how those risks might be addressed.[84]Both [Vatsonic and the Council], and the [Council’s] workers, ought to have foreseen the risk of harm to [Mr Bilson], as that risk was not insignificant not far fetched or fanciful. [Vatsonic and the Council’s] and the [Council’s] workers breached their duties by failing to take proper precautions, and the [Council] is vicariously liable for the breach of its workers.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established