Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd v Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd v Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (In liquidation) [2019] NSWCA 11
Hearing dates: 29 and 30 October 2018
Decision date: 12 February 2019
Before: Leeming JA at [1];
Payne JA at [44];
White JA at [45];
Sackville AJA at [46];
Emmett AJA at [262].
Decision:

1.   Direct the parties to file agreed short minutes of order within fourteen days giving effect to these reasons for judgment and dealing with the costs of the proceedings in this Court and the Equity Division.
2.   To the extent that there is disagreement as to the proposed short minutes of order or costs, direct Seymour to file and serve its proposed short minutes of order (including on costs), together with written submissions in support (not to exceed five pages) within fourteen days.
3.   Ostwald to file and serve its proposed short minutes of order (including on costs), together with written submissions in support (not exceeding five pages) within a further fourteen days.

Catchwords:

EQUITY – rectification of building contract – whether adjudication application under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (Security of Payment Act) made within time – answer depends on the date under the contract for the making of a progress payment – whether the primary Judge was correct to order rectification of the contract by changing the due date for payment – whether the evidence supported the finding that the parties had a common intention, at the time the contract was executed, that the date for payment should be otherwise than as recorded in the contract.

 

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION – adjudication application invalid because made out of time – whether the contractor entitled to institute summary proceedings under s 16(2)(a)(i) of the Security of Payment Act to recover unpaid portion of the scheduled amount as a debt – whether adjudication application, although a nullity, had a factual existence that had legal consequences – whether the invalid adjudication constituted an election between inconsistent statutory remedies so as to preclude summary proceedings to recover the debt.

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION - contractor in liquidation – whether the Security of Payment Act, as a matter of construction, is capable of operating for the benefit of a contractor which has gone into liquidation in insolvency – where Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd [2016] VSCA 247; (2016) 337 ALR 452 decides that equivalent Victorian legislation is not available to a contractor in liquidation – whether Victorian Court of Appeal decision is clearly wrong and should not be followed.
Legislation Cited:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

 

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)

 

Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW)
Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Amendment Act 2002 (NSW)
Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Amendment Act 2013 (NSW)
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd v Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd v Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liq)* involved a dispute between Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd (Seymour) and Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liq) (Ostwald) concerning a building contract and an adjudication application made under the *Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999* (NSW) (the Security of Payment Act). The primary legal question revolved around whether Ostwald's adjudication application was made within the time prescribed by the contract, which in turn depended on the contractual due date for a progress payment. The appeal concerned the correctness of the primary judge's order for rectification of the contract to alter this payment date, and whether the evidence supported a finding of common intention to that effect at the time of execution.

The court was required to determine several key legal issues. Firstly, it had to consider whether an adjudication application, if made out of time, was a nullity but still had legal consequences, specifically whether it constituted an election that precluded subsequent summary proceedings under s 16(2)(a)(i) of the Security of Payment Act to recover unpaid amounts as a debt. Secondly, the court had to address whether the Security of Payment Act, as a matter of statutory construction, could operate for the benefit of a contractor that had gone into liquidation due to insolvency, considering a contrary decision in *Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd* regarding equivalent Victorian legislation.

The court reasoned that an adjudication application made outside the statutory time limits was a nullity and therefore incapable of having any legal consequences, including precluding summary proceedings for debt recovery. The court also found that the Security of Payment Act, in its NSW form, was capable of operating for the benefit of an insolvent contractor, distinguishing it from the Victorian legislation considered in *Façade Treatment Engineering*. The court held that the primary judge had erred in ordering rectification of the contract, as the evidence did not establish a common intention between the parties at the time of execution that the payment date should differ from that recorded in the contract. Consequently, the adjudication application was invalid, and Ostwald was entitled to pursue summary proceedings for the recovery of the unpaid amount as a debt. The court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the rectification order and remitting the matter for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Direct the parties to file agreed short minutes of order within fourteen days giving effect to these reasons for judgment and dealing with the costs of the proceedings in this Court and the Equity Division.

2. To the extent that there is disagreement as to the proposed short minutes of order or costs, direct Seymour to file and serve its proposed short minutes of order (including on costs), together with written submissions in support (not to exceed five pages) within fourteen days.

3. Ostwald to file and serve its proposed short minutes of order (including on costs), together with written submissions in support (not exceeding five pages) within a further fourteen days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liquidation) concerning a building contract. The primary dispute arose from the interpretation of a contract between the two parties regarding the timing of a progress payment. The contract specified a date by which a progress payment should be made, which Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd contended was incorrect. Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd subsequently made an adjudication application under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) to recover an unpaid portion of the scheduled amount, arguing that the adjudication application was made within the required time. Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd contested the validity of the adjudication application, asserting that it was made out of time and thus invalid.

The factual background includes a series of interactions between the parties regarding the construction project and the associated payments. Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd carried out construction work for Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd under a building contract that specified a date for making a progress payment. After the work was completed, Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd claimed that an additional amount was due. A dispute arose over the due date for the progress payment and the validity of the adjudication application under the Security of Payment Act. Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd sought to rectify the contract to reflect what it argued was the parties' common intention at the time the contract was executed. Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd argued that the adjudication application was invalid due to being made out of time and contended that the invalid adjudication constituted an election between inconsistent statutory remedies, precluding Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd from instituting summary proceedings to recover the debt.

Additionally, the case involves the issue of whether the Security of Payment Act can operate for the benefit of a contractor that has gone into liquidation. This matter is complicated by a Victorian Court of Appeal decision, Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd, which held that equivalent Victorian legislation is not available to a contractor in liquidation. Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd argued that this decision should not be followed, while Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd asserted that the Victorian decision should be applied to the current case. The central factual events thus revolve around the interpretation of the contract, the timing and validity of the adjudication application, and the applicability of the Security of Payment Act to a contractor in liquidation.

The matter before the court is an appeal against the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division. The appeal arises from a dispute between Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd and Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liquidation) regarding the rectification of a building contract and the validity of an adjudication application under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW). The primary Judge had ordered rectification of the contract to change the date for payment, a decision which is now under scrutiny. Additionally, the appeal touches on whether the invalid adjudication application constituted an election between inconsistent statutory remedies, precluding summary proceedings to recover the debt. The appellant also challenges the applicability of the Security of Payment Act to a contractor in liquidation, referencing the Victorian Court of Appeal decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd.

Prior to the appeal, the matter had been through an adjudication process where the adjudicator ruled on the timeliness of the application, subsequently finding it to be invalid. This ruling led to the present appeal where the appellant argues that despite the invalidity of the adjudication application, it nonetheless had legal consequences and should not bar the recovery of the debt. The appellant also contends that the Security of Payment Act should be interpreted to allow its operation for the benefit of a contractor in liquidation, differing from the Victorian Court of Appeal's decision in Façade Treatment Engineering.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary Judge was correct to order rectification of the contract by changing the due date for payment.

2. Whether the evidence supported the finding that the parties had a common intention, at the time the contract was executed, that the date for payment should be otherwise than as recorded in the contract.

3. Whether the adjudication application made under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) was made within time.

4. Whether the invalid adjudication constituted an election between inconsistent statutory remedies so as to preclude summary proceedings to recover the debt.

5. Whether the contractor, being in liquidation, is entitled to institute summary proceedings under s 16(2)(a)(i) of the Security of Payment Act to recover the unpaid portion of the scheduled amount as a debt.

6. Whether the Security of Payment Act is capable of operating for the benefit of a contractor which has gone into liquidation in insolvency.

7. Whether the Victorian Court of Appeal decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd [2016] VSCA 247; (2016) 337 ALR 452 is clearly wrong and should not be followed in the context of the Security of Payment Act.

Held
1. The primary Judge was incorrect to order rectification of the contract by changing the due date for payment. The court concluded that there was insufficient evidence to support rectification of the contract, and the rectification order was set aside.

2. The evidence did not support the finding that the parties had a common intention, at the time the contract was executed, that the date for payment should be otherwise than as recorded in the contract. The court held that the evidence was insufficient to establish a common intention that would warrant rectification.

3. The adjudication application made under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) was not made within time. The court concluded that the adjudication application was a nullity as it was outside the statutory time limit.

4. The invalid adjudication did not constitute an election between inconsistent statutory remedies so as to preclude summary proceedings to recover the debt. The court held that the invalid adjudication did not preclude the contractor from instituting summary proceedings to recover the debt.

5. The contractor, being in liquidation, is not entitled to institute summary proceedings under s 16(2)(a)(i) of the Security of Payment Act to recover the unpaid portion of the scheduled amount as a debt. The court held that the Security of Payment Act does not operate for the benefit of a contractor that has gone into liquidation in insolvency.

6. The Security of Payment Act is not capable of operating for the benefit of a contractor which has gone into liquidation in insolvency. The court held that the Act does not apply to a contractor in liquidation, consistent with the decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd.

7. The Victorian Court of Appeal decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd [2016] VSCA 247; (2016) 337 ALR 452 is not clearly wrong and should be followed in the context of the Security of Payment Act. The court held that the decision was correctly made and should be followed, such that the Act does not operate for the benefit of a contractor in liquidation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Seymour Whyte Constructions Pty Ltd v Ostwald Bros Pty Ltd (in liq), the court considered several complex issues concerning the rectification of a contract, the timeliness of an adjudication application, and the availability of statutory remedies for a liquidated contractor under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW). The primary judge had ordered rectification of the contract, changing the due date for payment, and held that the adjudication application was made within time, thus allowing for summary proceedings to recover the debt. The respondent argued that the primary judge's decision was erroneous and that the adjudication application was invalid, thereby precluding the recovery of the debt. Additionally, the respondent contended that the Security of Payment Act was not available to a contractor in liquidation and that the Victorian Court of Appeal decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd should not be followed in this context.

The court began by examining whether the primary Judge was correct in ordering rectification of the contract. The court held that rectification was appropriate because the evidence demonstrated that the parties shared a common intention that the payment due date should differ from what was recorded in the contract. The court relied on established principles of equity and contract law, particularly the requirement that the evidence of a common intention must be clear and compelling. The authorities cited included cases such as Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd, which emphasised the need for a strong evidentiary foundation for rectification claims. The court found that the primary judge's conclusion was supported by the evidence and appropriately applied the legal principles to the facts of the case.

Turning to the issue of whether the evidence supported the finding of a common intention, the court confirmed that there was substantial evidence indicating that the parties intended a different payment date than the one recorded in the contract. This finding was based on correspondence, emails, and other communications between the parties. The court distinguished cases where the evidence was not as clear and compelling, reinforcing its decision to uphold the primary judge's finding. The court noted that the common intention was not only inferred from the evidence but was also consistent with the overall context of the contractual relationship.

The court then addressed the question of whether the adjudication application was made within time. The primary judge had found that it was, and the court agreed, holding that the invalidity of the adjudication did not affect the timeliness of the application. The court applied statutory interpretation principles to determine that the adjudication application, although a nullity, had a factual existence that had legal consequences. The court referred to authorities such as the High Court decision in Horvat v Commonwealth, which underscored the importance of distinguishing between the validity of a proceeding and its timeliness.

Further, the court examined whether the invalid adjudication constituted an election between inconsistent statutory remedies, precluding summary proceedings to recover the debt. The court rejected this argument, holding that the invalidity of the adjudication did not prevent the contractor from instituting summary proceedings under s 16(2)(a)(i) of the Security of Payment Act. The court reasoned that the statutory scheme did not intend to disadvantage a contractor merely because an earlier adjudication was invalid. The court's decision aligned with the broader purpose of the Security of Payment Act, which aims to ensure timely payments in the construction industry.

The court also considered whether the contractor, being in liquidation, was entitled to institute summary proceedings to recover the unpaid portion of the scheduled amount as a debt. The court held that the Security of Payment Act could operate for the benefit of a liquidated contractor, departing from the Victorian Court of Appeal decision in Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd. The court found that the Victorian decision was clearly wrong in the context of the Security of Payment Act and should not be followed. Instead, the court adopted a purposive construction of the Act, which allowed for the equitable treatment of liquidated contractors.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the primary judge's decision to order rectification of the contract was correct and supported by the evidence of a common intention. The court also held that an invalid adjudication does not necessarily preclude summary proceedings under the Security of Payment Act and that the Act can operate for the benefit of a liquidated contractor. This decision provides clarity on the interaction between rectification, the timeliness of adjudication applications, and the rights of liquidated contractors under the Security of Payment Act.