APLA Ltd v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW)

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE, CALLINAN AND HEYDON JJ

APLA LIMITED & ORS  PLAINTIFFS

AND

LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER OF NEW SOUTH
WALES & ANOR  DEFENDANTS

APLA Limited v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW)

[2005] HCA 44

1 September 2005
S202/2004

ORDER

Questions asked in the special case answered as follows:

(1)Q. Is Part 14 of the Regulation invalid in whole or in part by reason that it:

(a)impermissibly infringes the freedom of communication on political and governmental matters guaranteed by the Constitution;

(b)impermissibly infringes the requirements of Ch III of the Constitution and of the principle of the rule of law as given effect by the Constitution;

(c)impermissibly infringes the freedom of interstate intercourse or alternatively trade and commerce guaranteed by s 92 of the Constitution;

(d)exceeds the legislative powers of the State of New South Wales by virtue of the nature of its extra-territorial operation;

(e)exceeds any powers to make regulations under the Legal Profession Act, by virtue of the nature of its extra-territorial operation;

(f)is inconsistent with the rights, duties, remedies and jurisdiction conferred, regulated or provided for by:

(A)ss 39(2), 39B, 55A, 55B, 55D, and 78 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth);

(B)Divisions 1 and 2 of Part III and Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth);

(C)ss 52, 53(a), 74B, 74D, 75AD, 82, 86 and 87 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth);

(D)Parts II, IV, V and VI of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), together with Parts IV and IVA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);

(E)Parts 4, 6 and 7 of the Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth), together with Parts 27 and 28 of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth).

A.No.

(2)Q. If yes to any part of (1), does Part 14 of the Regulation validly prohibit:

(a)the First Plaintiff from publishing an advertisement in the form of Annexure A to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(b)the Second Plaintiff from publishing:

(i)an advertisement in the form of the three advertisements which are Annexure B to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(ii)on its website, material substantially in the form of the material contained in Annexures C and D to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(iii)a letter in the form of Annexure E to the Amended Statement of Claim to group members of the group on behalf of whom proceedings are brought in Federal Court proceedings N932 of 2001.

(c)the Third Plaintiff from publishing an advertisement in the form of Annexure F to the Amended Statement of Claim?

A.Does not arise.

(3)Q.       If yes to any part of (2), ought the declaratory relief sought in the Amended Statement of Claim be withheld in the discretion of the Court by reason of the facts set out in paragraph 17 in relation to the advertisements which the plaintiffs say they wish to publish but which have not in fact been published?

A.Does not arise.

Representation:

S J Gageler SC with J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read APLA Ltd v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] HCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a special case brought by APLA Ltd, Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd, and Robert Leslie Whyburn (the plaintiffs) against the Legal Services Commissioner (NSW). The dispute concerned the validity of Part 14 of the *Legal Profession Regulation 2002* (NSW), which prohibited barristers and solicitors from advertising legal services related to personal injury claims. The plaintiffs argued that this prohibition infringed various constitutional protections.

The court was required to determine whether Part 14 of the Regulation was invalid on several grounds. These included whether it impermissibly infringed the implied freedom of political communication guaranteed by the Constitution, violated requirements of Chapter III of the Constitution and the principle of the rule of law, offended the freedom of interstate trade, commerce, and intercourse guaranteed by section 92, exceeded the legislative powers of New South Wales due to its extra-territorial operation, or was inconsistent with Commonwealth legislation, rendering it inoperative under section 109.

The High Court rejected the plaintiffs' arguments, finding that the Regulation did not impermissibly infringe the implied freedom of political communication or the requirements of Chapter III. The Court also found no contravention of section 92 of the Constitution, nor did it exceed the legislative powers of New South Wales. Crucially, the Court held that there was no inconsistency between the Regulation and the various Commonwealth Acts cited by the plaintiffs, and therefore section 109 did not operate to invalidate the Regulation. The Court emphasised that the motive behind the Regulation was irrelevant; its validity depended solely on whether it was inconsistent with federal law.

Consequently, the High Court answered "No" to the primary question of whether Part 14 of the Regulation was invalid in whole or in part. As a result, the subsequent questions regarding whether the Regulation validly prohibited specific advertisements and whether declaratory relief should be withheld did not arise.

Orders

Orders of the court

Questions asked in the special case answered as follows:

(1) Q. Is Part 14 of the Regulation invalid in whole or in part by reason that it:

(a) impermissibly infringes the freedom of communication on political and governmental matters guaranteed by the Constitution;

(b) impermissibly infringes the requirements of Ch III of the Constitution and of the principle of the rule of law as given effect by the Constitution;

(c) impermissibly infringes the freedom of interstate intercourse or alternatively trade and commerce guaranteed by s 92 of the Constitution;

(d) exceeds the legislative powers of the State of New South Wales by virtue of the nature of its extra-territorial operation;

(e) exceeds any powers to make regulations under the Legal Profession Act, by virtue of the nature of its extra-territorial operation;

(f) is inconsistent with the rights, duties, remedies and jurisdiction conferred, regulated or provided for by:

(A) ss 39(2), 39B, 55A, 55B, 55D, and 78 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth);

(B) Divisions 1 and 2 of Part III and Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth);

(C) ss 52, 53(a), 74B, 74D, 75AD, 82, 86 and 87 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth);

(D) Parts II, IV, V and VI of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), together with Parts IV and IVA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);

(E) Parts 4, 6 and 7 of the Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth), together with Parts 27 and 28 of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth).

A. No.

(2) Q. If yes to any part of (1), does Part 14 of the Regulation validly prohibit:

(a) the First Plaintiff from publishing an advertisement in the form of Annexure A to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(b) the Second Plaintiff from publishing:

(i) an advertisement in the form of the three advertisements which are Annexure B to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(ii) on its website, material substantially in the form of the material contained in Annexures C and D to the Amended Statement of Claim;

(iii) a letter in the form of Annexure E to the Amended Statement of Claim to group members of the group on behalf of whom proceedings are brought in Federal Court proceedings N932 of 2001.

(c) the Third Plaintiff from publishing an advertisement in the form of Annexure F to the Amended Statement of Claim?

A. Does not arise.

(3) Q. If yes to any part of (2), ought the declaratory relief sought in the Amended Statement of Claim be withheld in the discretion of the Court by reason of the facts set out in paragraph 17 in relation to the advertisements which the plaintiffs say they wish to publish but which have not in fact been published?

A. Does not arise.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ HEYDON J HUGH J
The argument for the plaintiffs appears to be based upon the motive of the New South Wales Parliament, or of the regulation-making authority. That is irrelevant. If the regulations are inconsistent with federal legislation, then they are inoperative to the extent of the inconsistency. It does not matter why they were promulgated. If they are not inconsistent with federal legislation, then they are not inoperative. Again, it does not matter why they were promulgated. Inconsistency between a State law and a federal law does not spring from the political motives of the respective law-making authorities. Section 109 is concerned with inconsistency of laws, not inconsistency of political opinion. Different legislative policies might, or might not, result in inconsistent laws. There is nothing to show that restrictions on advertising by lawyers conflict with any federal legislative scheme. As has been noted, most of the federal laws in question were enacted at a time when such restrictions were normal.Conclusion The questions should be answered as follows:(1) No.(2) Does not arise. (3) Does not arise. Mc The ultimate issue in this case is whether the Legal Profession Regulation 2002 enacted under the Legal Profession Act 1987 (NSW) ("the Act") is contrary to the Constitution. Broadly, the Regulation prohibits barristers and solicitors from advertising their availability to perform legal work in respect of personal injury matters. The plaintiffs[33] and amici curiae contend that the prohibition offends the Constitution in several ways. They contend that it:.violates the implied freedom of political communication recognised in Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation[34];.violates an implied freedom of communication arising from Ch III of the Constitution;.offends the freedom of interstate trade, commerce and intercourse guaranteed by s 92; and.conflicts with federal legisation and is inoperative by reason of s 109.[33]APLA Limited (first plaintiff, then trading as "Australian Plaintiff Lawyers Association", now trading as the "Australian Lawyers Alliance"); Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd (second plaintiff); and Robert Leslie Whyburn (third plaintiff).[34](1997) 189 CLR 520. They also contend that the Regulation is invalid because it has an extra‑territorial operation and is not a law for the peace, welfare and good government of New South Wales. The Regulation, in its relevant form[35], came into effect on 23 May 2003. Clause 139 provides:[35]Legal Profession Amendment (Personal Injury Advertising) Regulation 2003."(1)A barrister or solicitor must not publish or cause or permit to be published an advertisement that includes any reference to or depiction of any of the following:(a) personal injury,(b)any circumstance in which personal injury might occur, or any activity, event or circumstance that suggests or could suggest the possibility of personal injury, or any connection to or association with personal injury or a cause of personal injury,(c)a personal injury legal service (that is, any legal service that relates to recovery of money, or any entitlement to recover money, in respect of personal injury).Maximum penalty: 10 penalty units.(2)A contravention of this clause by a barrister or solicitor is declared to be professional misconduct...."Clause 138 defines "advertisement" as:"any communication of information ... that advertises or otherwise promotes the availability or use of a barrister or solicitor to provide legal services, whether or not that is its purpose or only purpose and whether or not that is its only effect."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, HEYDON J, HUGH J

Full text does not contain this section.