Kemp v Health and Community Services Complaints Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

KEMP v HEALTH AND COMMUNITY SERVICES COMPLAINTS COMMISSIONER

[2025] SASC 56

Judgment of the Honourable Justice B Doyle  

2 May 2025

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - INTERPRETATION ACTS AND PROVISIONS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS - OTHER HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS

The applicant is a massage therapist and a ‘health service provider’ within the meaning of the Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2004 (SA) ('the HCSC Act’). Following receipt of a complaint against the applicant, the Health and Community Services Complaints Commissioner ('the Commissioner’) conducted an investigation in relation to the applicant. For reasons set out in an investigation report provided to the applicant on 22 July 2024, the Commissioner made a prohibition order under s 56C of the HCSC Act, preventing the applicant from providing certain massage services until identified training had been completed.

Before the investigation was complete, and whilst the applicant was subject to an interim prohibition order, the applicant commenced a review proceeding in the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’). However, before the matter had proceeded to substantive hearing, the applicant had undertaken the required training and the prohibition order had ceased to limit the applicant’s practice. A senior member of the Tribunal dismissed the proceeding, concluding that the investigation report was not a report published under Division 4 of Part 6 of the HCSC Act so as to engage the Tribunal’s power of review under s 56(1) of that Act, and further that the review of the prohibition order under s 56E lacked utility.

By notice of appeal dated 6 January 2025, the applicant seeks leave to appeal the senior member’s decision pursuant to s 71(2) of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA). Ultimately, the only issue pressed on the appeal was whether the Tribunal erred in concluding it lacked jurisdiction to entertain a review pursuant to s 56(1) of the HCSC Act.

Held, granting leave to appeal but dismissing the appeal:

1. the investigation report was not a report published by the Commissioner under Division 4 of Part 6 of the HCSC Act;

2. the provision of the investigation report did not engage the Tribunal’s power to entertain a review pursuant to s 56(1) of the HCSC Act.

Evidence Act 1929 (SA) s 69A; Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2004 (SA) ss 3, 5, 6, 9, 24, 35, 29, 43, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 56A, 56B, 56C, 56D, 56E, 73; South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 34, 35, 37, 48, 71, referred to.

APLA Ltd v Legal Services Commission (NSW) (2005) 224 CLR 322, distinguished.

Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters v Cross (2012) 248 CLR 378; Fletcher v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency [2023] SASCA 36; Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Belperio (No 2) [2024] SASCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kemp v Health and Community Services Complaints Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Kemp v Health and Community Services Complaints Commissioner involved the applicant, a massage therapist, challenging the decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) to dismiss his appeal against the Commissioner's investigation report and the interim prohibition orders. The Commissioner had received a complaint regarding the applicant's conduct during a massage session and subsequently commenced an investigation, resulting in the issuance of multiple interim prohibition orders (IPOs) restricting the applicant from providing massage therapy to female clients. The applicant sought to appeal the investigation report and the IPOs, arguing that the Commissioner had not acted fairly and had considered irrelevant factors.

The primary legal issue for determination by the court was whether the SACAT had jurisdiction to review the investigation report and the IPOs under section 56 of the Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2010 (SA) (HCSC Act). Additionally, the court needed to determine if there was any utility in reviewing the IPOs, which had already been lifted by the time the appeal was heard.

In addressing these issues, the court found that the SACAT did not have jurisdiction to review the investigation report as it did not constitute a 'report published by the Commissioner' under Division 4 of Part 6 of the HCSC Act. Furthermore, the court held that even if jurisdiction had been established, the review was limited to procedural fairness and did not extend to the substantive merits of the Commissioner's findings. The court also concluded that there was no utility in reviewing the IPOs, which were no longer in force, as the applicant could not demonstrate any practical benefit from such a review. Consequently, the court dismissed the applicant's appeal, finding it to be misconceived and/or lacking in substance. The court's decision affirmed that the SACAT's powers to affirm, vary, or set aside a reviewable decision could not be exercised in respect of a decision that had ceased to be in effect.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue for determination is whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain a review of the investigation report pursuant to s 56 of the HCSC Act. For the reasons that follow, it did not. The investigation report was not a report ‘published by the Commissioner’ under Division 4 of Part 6. Accordingly, whilst the applicant should be granted leave to appeal, the appeal must be dismissed.Background On 10 September 2023, the Commissioner’s Office received a complaint made by a person who had received massage therapy from the applicant in August 2023.[4] In general terms, the complaint included allegations that the applicant did not provide the complainant with appropriate privacy and touched her inappropriately during the course of the massage. There was also a complaint about the basis upon which the applicant had sought to charge for the massage.[4] HCSC Act, s 24. On 11 November 2023, the Commissioner commenced an investigation under s 43(1)(b) of the HCSC Act. Section 56B of the HCSC Act is titled ‘Interim action’ and empowers the Commissioner to make interim orders prohibiting a person who is the subject of an investigation from providing health services or specified health services, and to make orders imposing conditions on the provision of those services, in either case for a period of 12 weeks or less. On 13 November 2023, the Commissioner made an interim prohibition order pursuant to that section, prohibiting the applicant from providing, offering or advertising massage therapy to female clients for a period of 12 weeks (the ‘initial IPO’). The initial IPO stated as follows:The grounds for making this order are:-On 10 November 2023, I commenced an investigation into health services you have provided;-I consider that the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 56A of the Act and regulation 7 of the Health and Community Services Complaints Regulations 2019 (SA) and set out at Schedule 2 of those Regulations (the Code) applies to you, a health care worker, in the provision of health services, namely massage therapy;-I reasonably believe you have breached the Code, which relevantly provides that:- Clause 3(1): A health care worker must provide services in a safe and ethical manner;- Clause 3(2)(a): A health care worker must maintain necessary competence in his or her field of practice;- Clause 4: A health care worker must obtain consent;- Clause 15(1): A health care worker must not engage in behaviour of a sexual or close personal nature with a client. The initial IPO went on to state that, on the basis of information received regarding the treatment provided to the complainant during a massage at her home on 25 August 2023, and when the applicant attended her residence two days afterwards, the Commissioner believed it was necessary to make the order to protect the health or safety of members of the public. On 31 January 2024, the Commissioner made a second IPO which was to be operative for 12 weeks from 5 February 2024. On 26 April 2024, the Commissioner made a third IPO which was to be operative for 12 weeks from 29 April 2024.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At some stage prior to the senior member’s decision, the applicant advised that he withdrew paragraph 11 of the amended grounds.[7][7] Reasons [11].Decision of the senior member The senior member rejected the applicant’s contention that when the Commissioner sent the final investigation report to the applicant on 22 July 2024 there had been a report published within the meaning of s 56(1) of the HCSC Act.[8] [8] Reasons [18]. The senior member further considered that even if it was enlivened, the Tribunal’s jurisdiction pursuant to s 56 was only to review the procedural fairness or otherwise of the Commissioner’s procedures relating to the fairness of the report. In the senior member’s view various of the amended grounds went to matters that were not procedural, such as the contention that the Commissioner took irrelevant considerations into account or made unreasonable findings in connection with the decision to make the prohibition order. The senior member observed that whilst complaints of that kind might be able to be made in judicial review proceedings, they were not within the ambit of a review under s 56(1) of the HCSC Act.[9][9] Reasons [20]. The senior member accepted that the applicant was also seeking to review the prohibition order that ‘was subsequently lifted on 3 October 2024’, and that, whilst not specified, it was to be inferred that this was in reliance upon s 56E(1) of the HCSC Act.[10][10] Reasons [21]. The senior member then made the following observations:[11]In his written submissions dated 3 October 2024, the applicant did not address what utility he says there is in the Tribunal reviewing the prohibition order which has ceased to be in effect. The Tribunal’s powers when reviewing a reviewable decision are set out in section 37 of the SACAT Act and are in essence to affirm, vary or set aside a reviewable decision. None of those powers can be exercised in respect of a decision which is not in force. …In REM & PVR v Department for Child Protection [2020] SACAT 9 the Tribunal found that ‘if the decision has effectively come to an end, or has been superseded by a later decision which reverses that decision, then … there is no practical relief that the Tribunal can afford to the [applicant] on the merits review. Consequently, pursuing the review proceedings would be futile’: at [66]. The Tribunal dismissed the proceedings.A similar view was expressed by the Court of Appeal in Fletcher v AHPRA [2023] SASCA 36 when it found that ‘there is no utility in the proposed appeal concerning previous immediate action conditions which are no longer operating’: at [20]. Leave to lodge the proposed appeal was refused.The applicant has not satisfied me that any of the Tribunal’s powers is exercisable in respect of a prohibition order which is no longer in force, nor that there would be any utility in their exercise.I have found that the Tribunal’s jurisdiction pursuant to section 56 of the [HCSC Act] is not enlivened in this matter, and that there is no utility in the Tribunal exercising its jurisdiction in respect of a prohibition order which is no longer in force. It follows that this proceeding is misconceived and/or lacking in substance. That may not have been the position when the proceeding was first lodged while the interim prohibition order was in force, but it is the position now since the interim prohibition order lapsed and the prohibition order was lifted.Pursuant to section 48 of the SACAT Act, I will dismiss this proceeding on the ground it is misconceived and/or lacking in substance. [11] Reasons [21]-[26].Appeal to this Court

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established