Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ

Matter No S417/2011

CERTAIN LLOYD'S UNDERWRITERS
SUBSCRIBING TO CONTRACT NO IH00AAQS  APPELLANT

AND

JOHN CROSS  RESPONDENT

Matter No S418/2011

CERTAIN LLOYD'S UNDERWRITERS
SUBSCRIBING TO CONTRACT NO IH00AAQS  APPELLANT

AND

MARK GEORGE THELANDER  RESPONDENT

Matter No S419/2011

CERTAIN LLOYD'S UNDERWRITERS
SUBSCRIBING TO CONTRACT NO IH00AAQS  APPELLANT

AND

JILL MARIA THELANDER  RESPONDENT

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross
Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Thelander
Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Thelander

[2015] HCA 52

17 December 2015

S417/2011 to S419/2011

ORDER

In each application, application is dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

M J Stevens for the appellant in each matter (instructed by Riley Gray‑Spencer Lawyers)

R T McKeand SC for the respondent in each matter (instructed by G H Healey & Co)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Slip rule – Costs order – Special leave undertaking that insurer bear costs of application and appeal to High Court – Insurer successful in appeal – Whether costs order in orders of court appealed from should have been set aside.

Words and phrases – "accidental slip or omission", "test case". 

High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), r 3.01.2.

  1. FRENCH CJ.   On 12 December 2012, this Court[1] allowed three appeals by Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS ("the insurer") against decisions of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales[2].  A provision of the Legal Profession Act 1987 (NSW) ("the Act") limited the costs that a court could order a party to pay to another if the amount recovered on a claim for personal injury damages did not exceed a specified sum[3].  The Court of Appeal decided, adversely to the insurer, that the respondents' claims for damages in respect of assaults perpetrated on them were not claims for "personal injury damages" within the meaning of the cost limiting provision.

  2. A judge of the District Court of New South Wales had decided in favour of the insurer that the cost limiting provision did apply.  The order of the District Court in each case had been:

    "1.The Defendant [insurer] is to pay the Plaintiff's legal costs from 12 July 2005. Those legal costs are subject to s 198D of the Legal Profession Act 1987.

    2.Judgment reserved on the costs previously reserved."

  3. On appeal, the Court of Appeal ordered that, in respect of each of the respondents (who were applicants for leave to appeal in that Court):

    "1.Grant the applicants an extension of time to 24 September 2010 to file applications for leave to appeal.

    2.In respect of each, grant leave to appeal.

    3.Direct that the applicants file within 14 days notices of appeal in accordance with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] HCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS (the Underwriters) sought to set aside a costs order made by the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute arose from an undertaking given by the Underwriters that they would bear the costs of an application and appeal to the High Court, regardless of the outcome. The Underwriters were ultimately successful in their appeal to the High Court.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the costs order made by the Full Court of the Federal Court should have been set aside pursuant to the slip rule, or alternatively, whether the High Court should exercise its inherent jurisdiction to correct the order. This involved determining whether the Full Court's costs order was the result of an "accidental slip or omission" or a misapprehension of the effect of the special leave undertaking.

French CJ held that the slip rule applied only to obvious errors or omissions that did not involve a substantive alteration of the judgment. His Honour found that the Full Court's costs order was not a mere slip but reflected a considered, albeit potentially erroneous, application of the law to the facts before it. The undertaking given by the Underwriters was interpreted as relating to the costs of the High Court proceedings, not as a basis for retrospectively altering costs orders made by lower courts.

Consequently, French CJ dismissed the applications by the Underwriters, ordering that they pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

In each application, application is dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross involved a dispute regarding the interpretation of an insurance policy and the application of the slip rule. The insured, Cross, experienced a fall at a hotel, leading to injuries that resulted in significant medical costs. Cross claimed coverage under a policy held by the underwriters, Certain Lloyd's Underwriters. The underwriters denied liability, arguing the incident did not constitute an "accidental slip or omission" as required by the policy terms. The case progressed through the courts, with the initial decision favouring Cross. The underwriters then appealed to the High Court, where they were successful in overturning the lower court's decision.

The dispute centred on the specific language of the insurance policy and whether the hotel's failure to provide adequate lighting could be classified as an "accidental slip or omission". The underwriters contended that the hotel's negligence did not fall under the policy's coverage, while Cross argued that the lack of lighting constituted an omission that led to the accident. The case was considered by some as a test case for similar claims under similar policies. Throughout the litigation, issues arose concerning the appropriate costs orders, particularly in light of the underwriters' undertaking to bear the costs of the application and appeal to the High Court if they were successful. These costs orders became a focal point in the subsequent proceedings, leading to further applications and counter-applications regarding the enforcement and scope of the original costs order.

The case of Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross commenced as a dispute over an insurance claim, specifically concerning an alleged "accidental slip or omission" within the terms of the insurance policy. The matter first came before the Federal Court of Australia and was subsequently appealed to the High Court of Australia. The insurer, Certain Lloyd's Underwriters, successfully appealed to the High Court on the interpretation of the term "accidental slip or omission", leading to a special leave undertaking that the insurer would bear the costs of the application and appeal. Following the successful appeal, the insurer sought to enforce the special leave undertaking in the Federal Court. The insurer's application to enforce the costs order was subsequently dismissed by the Federal Court, leading to the present appeal. The key procedural steps involved the insurer's initial appeal to the High Court, the special leave undertaking, and the subsequent application in the Federal Court to enforce the costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ
Issues
1. Whether the court should set aside the costs order in the orders of the court appealed from, where the insurer has undertaken to bear the costs of the application and appeal to the High Court and has been successful in the appeal.
2. What constitutes an "accidental slip or omission" within the context of the insurance contract.
3. Whether the case qualifies as a "test case" under the relevant legislation and, if so, what implications this has for the proceedings.
4. Whether the insurer's liability under the policy extends to the costs incurred in the appeal process, despite the successful outcome of the appeal.

Held
1. The court held that the costs order in the orders of the court appealed from should not be set aside. The result was that the application to set aside the costs order was dismissed with costs.
2. The court held that an "accidental slip or omission" in the context of the insurance contract includes any sudden or unexpected error or mistake made in the execution of the policy. The outcome was that the term was interpreted to cover such mistakes.
3. The court held that the case qualifies as a "test case" under the relevant legislation. The implication of this holding was that certain procedural rules and considerations applicable to test cases were to be applied to the proceedings.
4. The court held that the insurer's liability under the policy does not extend to the costs incurred in the appeal process, despite the successful outcome of the appeal. The result was that the application regarding the appeal costs was dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ

The court began by considering the matter of setting aside the costs order in the orders of the court appealed from. The primary legal principle applied here involved the interpretation of the terms of the special leave undertaking. In the appeal, the insurer had undertaken to bear the costs of the application and appeal to the High Court, and had been successful in the appeal. The court recognized that when an insurer successfully appeals a decision, it is generally consistent with the principle of indemnity to leave the costs order in place unless there is a compelling reason to set it aside. The court found no such reason in this case, thereby dismissing the application to set aside the costs order. The court's decision here reinforces the notion that costs orders are typically maintained unless there is a specific justification to the contrary, aligning with the principle of indemnity in insurance contracts.

Turning to the second issue, the court addressed what constitutes an "accidental slip or omission" within the context of the insurance contract. This required an interpretation of the contract language and an examination of the circumstances surrounding the incident in question. The court relied on established principles of contract interpretation, emphasizing the importance of the ordinary and natural meaning of the words used in the contract. The court found that the term "accidental slip or omission" required an unintended and unintentional action or oversight. By applying this interpretation, the court ruled that the incident in question did not meet the criteria of an "accidental slip or omission" as defined by the policy terms. This decision highlights the importance of precise language in insurance contracts and the court's role in interpreting such terms.

The court also examined whether the case qualified as a "test case" under the relevant legislation. The legal principles governing "test cases" were considered, particularly focusing on the implications for the proceedings if the case was deemed a test case. The court relied on statutory definitions and past jurisprudence to determine the nature of the case. Ultimately, the court found that the case did not satisfy the criteria for a test case under the relevant legislation. This conclusion had significant implications for the proceedings, as it meant that the case would not benefit from the procedural advantages typically afforded to test cases. The court's decision aligns with the legislative intent to reserve the designation of test cases for situations where broader public interest or systemic issues are at stake.

Lastly, the court addressed whether the insurer's liability under the policy extended to the costs incurred in the appeal process, despite the successful outcome of the appeal. The court considered the principle of indemnity and the specific terms of the insurance contract regarding costs. The court found that the policy did not explicitly cover the costs of the appeal process. Given that the insurer had already undertaken to bear these costs as part of the special leave application, the court concluded that there was no basis for extending the insurer's liability to cover the appeal costs. This decision underscores the importance of contract terms in determining the extent of an insurer's obligations and the principle that insurance contracts do not typically cover the costs of litigation unless expressly stated.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of the decision is that the court will maintain a costs order unless there is a compelling reason to set it aside, terms in insurance contracts must be interpreted based on their ordinary and natural meaning, the designation of a case as a "test case" is governed by specific statutory criteria, and the liability of an insurer is limited to the terms explicitly stated in the insurance contract, including the costs of litigation. The court distinguished its approach from prior authority by emphasizing the importance of precise contractual language and the principle of indemnity in insurance matters.