Orora Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Orora Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2024] ARTA 48 (26 November 2024)

Applicant/s:  Orora Ltd

Respondent:  Comptroller-General of Customs

Tribunal Number:                2022/8930

Tribunal:General Member C. Willis

Place:Melbourne

Date:26 November 2024  

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

...............................[SGD].......................................

General Member C. Willis

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS – Customs Act 1901 - tariff concession orders - classification to a single tariff heading – existence of a functional unit - whether goods described in terms of their intended use - whether goods described in terms other than generic terms – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Customs Act 1901 (Cth), Part XVA, Sections 269F, 269H, 269HA, 269SJ; Part XVII, Paragraphs 273GA(1)(m), 273GA(1)(ma)

Customs Tariff Act 1995 (Cth), Schedule 2; Schedule 3, Section XVI, Notes 3, 4 and 5 to Section XVI

Cases

Re Gissing and Collector of Customs (1977) 1 ALD 144

Re Tridon and Collector of Customs (1982) 4 ALD 615

Comptroller-General of Customs v ACI Pet Operations Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 56

STI Tyres as trustee for On Track Tyre Trust v Chief Officer of Customs [2009] AATA 877

Comptroller-General of Customs v Pharm-A-Care Laboratories Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 2

Ceramic Oxide Fabricators Pty Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs [2021] AATA 2770

Secondary Materials

Replacement Explanatory Memorandum to the Customs, Excise and Bounty Legislation Amendment Bill 1995

Explanatory Notes to the International Convention on the Harmonized Commodity Description and Coding System (Harmonized System) (HSEN)

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter involves a review of a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs (the Respondent) to reject an application for a tariff concession order (TCO) under Part XVA of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) (Customs Act). TCOs provide concessional customs duty treatment for imported goods where there is no known Australian manufacturer of those (or substitutable) goods.

  2. Orora Ltd (the Applicant) is an Australian company which provides packaging products and services, including beverage cans. The Applicant lodged an application (the TCO Application) with the Respondent for a TCO in relation to goods described as a Can Conveyance System, being a component of a beverage can production line to be operated by the Applicant.

  3. The TCO Application was refused by the Respondent on the basis that it was unable to classify the goods to a single tariff classification as required by the Customs Act. The Respondent said that the goods were not a single functional unit but comprised multiple sections of machines which would need to be classified separately and which therefore might fall under different sub-headings.

  4. The Applicant sought a review of this decision. After lodgement of the application for review with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), the Respondent outlined a further reason for refusing the TCO Application in its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC). The Respondent said that the TCO Application described the goods in terms of their intended end use and the Customs Act prohibits a TCO being made on this basis.

  5. This matter was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Orora Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orora Ltd sought review of a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs to reject their application for a tariff concession order (TCO) for certain industrial equipment. The equipment in question was a specialised can conveyance line used in beverage can production. The central issue before the court was whether the Comptroller-General was legally required to reject the TCO application under specific sections of the Customs Act. The primary legal questions revolved around whether the description of the goods in terms of their intended end use violated section 269SJ(1)(a) and whether the goods could be classified under a single tariff classification as required by section 269F. The court examined whether the description of the can conveyance system, which included terms like 'beverage can', constituted a condition specifying the end use of the goods, which would violate section 269SJ(1)(a). The court also evaluated whether the goods could be classified under a single tariff classification as mandated by section 269F. The court found that while section 269SJ(1)(a) did not necessarily require rejection of the TCO application, the description of the goods did not meet the criteria for a single tariff classification under section 269F. Consequently, the court affirmed the Comptroller-General's decision to reject the TCO application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties agree that two key issues arise, namely whether the Respondent was required to reject the TCO Application:·under section 269HA(1) because under section 269SJ(1)(a) the Respondent must not make a TCO in respect of goods described in terms of their intended end use; and/or·under section 269H(1) because the Respondent was not satisfied that the application complied with section 269F, the goods not being covered by a (single) tariff classification for the purposes of section 269F(3).BACKGROUNDThe Can Conveyance System The goods the subject of the TCO Application were described as a ‘can conveyance line’ and more fully as:[1][1] T3.4. References to T Documents are to the documents that were lodged by the Respondent under section 37 of the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).CONVEYANCE LINE, BELT, BEVERAGE CAN, having ALL of the following:(a)cup conveyance unit, including ALL of the following:(i)elevator in-feed conveyance unit;(ii)vacuum cup elevator;(iii)mechanical conveyance unit;(b)wet can conveyance unit, including BOTH of the following:(i)gripper elevators;(ii)mechanical conveyance units;(c)bright can conveyance unit, including ALL of the following:(i)inverter feed conveyance unit;(ii)bright can vacuum inverter;(iii)mechanical conveyance units;(iv)mechanical can flow divider conveyance unit;(v)centre drive bi-directional accumulation conveyance unit;(d)printed can system conveyance units;(e)necker/flanger in-feed system conveyance unit, including ALL of the following:(i)internal bake oven (IBO) mechanical discharge conveyance unit;(ii)mechanical conveyance units;(iii)bi-directional accumulation conveyance unit;(iv)vacuum transfer unit;(f)palletiser in-feed system mechanical conveyance units An ‘Equipment Proposal ##PP-4413 New Line 2 Conveyance’ from Pride Conveyance Systems (Pride), a Californian company, to Orora Beverage Cans dated 14 April 2022 (the Pride Contract),[2] set out an extensive list of items of equipment to be supplied to the Applicant for a ‘new line 2 conveyance project’. Some of those items were to be manufactured in Poland (the Debno equipment), with others to be sourced from the United States and China.[2] T4.1. The TCO Application noted:The subject conveyance line is specially designed for the movement of beverage cans through each stage of the manufacturing process in a can production line. Demand is too limited to justify local production.Please note that, although the supplier’s quotation refers to numerous peripheral components within the line (such as mist collectors, filers, gravity tracks, lowerators etc.), the only items to which this TCO application applies are the actual specialised conveyors which move the cans from station to station during the production operation. These conveyors are made in Europe and the peripheral items NOT included in the TCO wording are to be supplied from the USA.[3][3] T3.1 at Question 8 of the TCO Application Form (‘Justification for application’).

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing the parties did not seek to take this issue further, and for the reasons given above it is not necessary for the Tribunal to make a finding on this point. However, it is noted again that examples offered by the Applicant of other TCOs that might breach Part XVA of the Customs Act do not by themselves provide support for the Applicant’s claims in respect of TC22282925. Any TCO application must be considered on its particular facts and by applying the relevant provisions of Part XVA to those facts.CONCLUSION Although I do not believe sections 269SJ and 269HA would have required rejection of the TCO Application, I find that it was not possible to be satisfied for the purposes of section 269H that the TCO Application complied with section 269F. This is because it was not possible to classify the subject goods to a (single) tariff classification. The decision under review is therefore affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent agreed that the Explanatory Memorandum was an appropriate extrinsic aid to the interpretation of paragraph 269SJ(1)(a),[20] although disagreed that it narrowed the application of that paragraph. The Respondent disputed the relevance of the other historic material provided by Mr Rodda.[21][20] The use of Explanatory Memoranda as an extrinsic aid to interpretation is generally not controversial: see Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters v Cross (2012) 248 CLR 378 at [68] per Crennan and Bell JJ; see also Harvey v Minister for Primary Industry and Resources [2024] HCA 1 per Gageler CJ.[21] However, it is noted that some of the references from 1983 were considered by the Full Court of the Federal Court in making their decision in Comptroller-General of Customs v ACI Pet Operations Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 56 (ACI Pet Operations). Both parties accept that the Explanatory Memoranda may be considered in interpreting section 269SJ. The highlighted extracts from the Explanatory Memorandum contain very specific statements of the policy and purpose behind the introduction of paragraph 269SJ(1)(a), identifying legal and administrative issues which needed to be addressed. The Explanatory Memorandum also makes clear that the new provision was required to counter a potential consequence of a decision of the Federal Court (although the question of defining a class of goods by their end use arose in a different context in that case).[22][22] In ACI Pet Operations (n 21), the actual or intended use of the goods was noted as a factual matter that could provide guidance as to essential character of goods. Therefore there is merit in the Applicant’s submissions that there are limitations to the scope of TCOs that can be refused under paragraph 269SJ(1)(a), and that previous Tribunals might not have had the opportunity to consider relevant extrinsic material when making their findings. Unfortunately, as this issue was not canvassed during the original screening and decision-making process there was limited evidentiary material available. However this may not determine the finding on this point. If the Applicant is correct that section 269SJ only prohibits TCOs being made with ‘conditions’ as to the end use of the goods being included in the description of goods, then the description of the can conveyance line containing phrases such as ‘beverage can’, ‘wet can’, ‘bright can’ and similar does not present ‘conditions’ as to end use. Section 269SJ would not apply. However, if the Respondent is correct that any description involving intended end use is prohibited unless it goes to identifying the goods on the basis of objective characteristics, I am not convinced that the reference to ‘beverage can’ breaches section 269SJ. The Respondent argued that it was possible that the resulting cans could be used to hold products other than beverages. However ‘beverage can’ might denote certain objective characteristics (size, shape or location of openings) that distinguishes it from other types of cans or tins, containing foodstuffs or otherwise, even if hypothetically it could be filled with a non-beverage product. The mere possibility of other uses for the cans would not be sufficient reason to reject TCO on this basis, and I am not convinced that adding the adjective ‘beverage’ went beyond what was necessary for a ‘full description of the goods’ for the purposes of section 269F.