Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND GAGELER JJ

Matter No P47/2013

ELECTRICITY GENERATION CORPORATION
T/AS VERVE ENERGY  APPELLANT

AND

WOODSIDE ENERGY LTD & ORS  RESPONDENTS

Matter No P48/2013

WOODSIDE ENERGY LTD & ORS  APPELLANTS

AND

ELECTRICITY GENERATION CORPORATION
T/AS VERVE ENERGY  RESPONDENT

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd

Woodside Energy Ltd v Electricity Generation Corporation

[2014] HCA 7

5 March 2014

P47/2013 & P48/2013

ORDER

Matter No P47/2013

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Matter No P48/2013

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside paragraphs 1 to 4 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 20 February 2013 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Western Australia

Representation

N C Hutley SC with J C Giles and D A Hughes for the appellant in P47/2013 and the respondent in P48/2013 (instructed by Jackson McDonald)

D F Jackson QC with B Dharmananda SC, J K Taylor and E M Heenan for the appellants in P48/2013 and the respondents in P47/2013 (instructed by Lavan Legal)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd
Woodside Energy Ltd v Electricity Generation Corporation

Contract − Construction – Long term gas supply agreement – Sellers obliged to use "reasonable endeavours" to supply supplemental gas – Agreement allowed sellers to take into account all "relevant commercial, economic and operational matters" in determining whether able to supply supplemental gas – Gas explosion at plant operated by third party temporarily reduced supply of gas to market – Sellers refused to supply supplemental gas at price stipulated in agreement during period of reduced supply – Sellers offered to supply equivalent quantities of gas at higher price under separate short term agreements – Whether sellers breached obligation to use "reasonable endeavours" to supply supplemental gas.

Words and phrases – "able", "reasonable endeavours", "relevant commercial, economic and operational matters".

  1. FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ.   The first issue in these appeals is the construction and application of a long term gas supply agreement ("the GSA") between Electricity Generation Corporation trading as Verve Energy ("Verve") and various gas suppliers in Western Australia including Woodside Energy Ltd ("the Sellers").  The Sellers are the respondents to the first appeal and the appellants in the second.

  2. Verve, a statutory corporation, is the major generator and supplier of electricity to a large area in the southwest of Western Australia, including Perth.  Verve purchases natural gas under the GSA for use in its power stations.  Separate contracts between Verve and each of the Sellers are contained in the GSA[1], which obliges each Seller to make available for delivery to Verve a proportionate share of a maximum daily quantity of gas ("MDQ"), delivered in a common and commingled stream[2], and to use "reasonable endeavours"[3] to make available to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] HCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute in this matter concerned a long-term gas supply agreement (GSA) between Electricity Generation Corporation (Verve) and Woodside Energy Ltd and others (the Sellers). Following a gas explosion at a third-party plant that significantly reduced supply to the market, the Sellers refused to supply supplemental gas to Verve at the price stipulated in the GSA. Instead, they offered to supply equivalent quantities under separate, short-term agreements at a substantially higher market price. Verve contended that this refusal constituted a breach of the Sellers' obligation to use "reasonable endeavours" to supply supplemental gas. The High Court of Australia was required to determine whether the Sellers had breached their contractual obligations.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the construction of the Sellers' obligation under the GSA to use "reasonable endeavours" to supply supplemental gas, particularly in light of a contractual provision allowing them to consider "relevant commercial, economic and operational matters" when determining their ability to supply. The Court had to ascertain whether the Sellers' refusal to supply at the GSA price, and their subsequent offer to supply at market rates, was consistent with their contractual commitments, especially given that it was common ground that the Sellers had the capacity to supply the nominated quantities.

The High Court reasoned that the Sellers' obligation to use "reasonable endeavours" was not absolute and was qualified by their right to take into account all relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters. The Court held that the Sellers were entitled to consider the prevailing market price and the opportunity to enter into more profitable short-term agreements when assessing their ability to supply supplemental gas under the GSA. The explosion and subsequent market conditions were considered relevant commercial and economic matters that the Sellers were permitted to take into account. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Sellers had not breached their obligation to use reasonable endeavours, as their actions were within the scope of the contractual provisions.

In Matter No P47/2013, the appeal was dismissed with costs. In Matter No P48/2013, the appeal was allowed with costs, and the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia were set aside and replaced with an order dismissing the appeal to that Court with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matter No P47/2013

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Matter No P48/2013

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside paragraphs 1 to 4 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 20 February 2013 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

If the Sellers' construction of cl 3.3 is accepted, with the consequence that the Sellers did not breach the GSA, the second issue (arising on the Sellers' notice of contention), namely whether Verve has a right to restitution of moneys paid under short term gas supply agreements (for alleged economic duress), does not arise. Nor do other issues in Verve's appeal concerning whether rescission of those agreements is necessary before obtaining restitution, and the quantum of any restitution.Background facts The Sellers and Apache, the principal gas suppliers in Western Australia, operated gas plants located in the northwest of Western Australia. Gas was transported from both plants to the southwest of Western Australia by the Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline. On 3 June 2008, an explosion occurred at Apache's gas plant on Varanus Island. The explosion caused the cessation of gas production at the plant and effected a temporary reduction in the supply of natural gas to the Western Australian market by 30 to 35 per cent, which led to demand exceeding supply. On 6 June 2008, Apache entered into a written agreement with the Sellers and Japan Australia LNG (MIMI) Pty Ltd ("MIMI") under which the Sellers agreed to supply Apache with certain daily quantities of natural gas ("the Apache agreement"). Many other customers in Western Australia sought to purchase gas from the Sellers during this time, at prices far exceeding those contained in the GSA. On 4 June 2008, before the Apache agreement was executed, the Sellers informed Verve that they would not supply SMDQ under the GSA to Verve for an indefinite period. On the same day, the Sellers offered to supply Verve with an equivalent quantity of gas for the month of June 2008, at a price which exceeded the price in the GSA applicable to SMDQ. Under protest, and without prejudice to its rights under cl 3.3(b), Verve entered into a "fully interruptible" short term gas supply agreement with the Sellers and MIMI for the supply of daily quantities of gas between 8am on 4 June and 8am on 30 June 2008. It was common ground that the effect of the agreement was that the Sellers were under no obligation to supply any particular quantities of gas to Verve, and that the price for gas delivered under the agreement was the prevailing market price. On 20 June 2008, when it was clear that the shortage of supply referable to the Apache incident would continue until the end of September, the Sellers invited tenders for the purchase of gas from them under short term supply agreements for the period from 8am on 30 June to 8am on 30 September 2008. The Sellers' agent informed Verve that Verve would not receive the nominated SMDQ during that time, and would be required to enter the tender process to receive any additional gas from the Sellers. Again under protest, Verve submitted a successful tender and entered into another fully interruptible gas supply agreement with the Sellers and MIMI, until the end of September 2008. The price for gas delivered under the agreement was also the prevailing market price. From 30 September 2008, the Sellers supplied SMDQ to Verve pursuant to the GSA. It was common ground that the Sellers had the capacity to supply SMDQ nominated by Verve during the relevant period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ GAGELER J
Issues
1. Whether the Sellers breached their obligation under clause 3.3 of the Gas Supply Agreement to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas during the period of reduced supply following the Varanus Island gas plant explosion.
2. What is the proper construction of the phrase "able" in the context of clause 3.3 of the Gas Supply Agreement, and whether the Sellers' interpretation is correct.
3. Whether the Sellers were justified in taking into account "all relevant commercial, economic and operational matters" in determining their ability to supply supplemental gas, and if so, to what extent.
4. Whether the Sellers' offer to supply Verve with an equivalent quantity of gas at a higher price under separate short term agreements constituted a breach of their obligation to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas.
5. Whether Verve has a right to restitution of moneys paid under the short term gas supply agreements on the basis of alleged economic duress, and if so, what is the appropriate quantum of restitution.
6. Whether rescission of the short term gas supply agreements is necessary before Verve can obtain restitution, and if so, what are the legal requirements for such rescission.

Held
1. The Sellers did not breach their obligation under clause 3.3 of the Gas Supply Agreement to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas during the period of reduced supply following the Varanus Island gas plant explosion. The appeal was dismissed with costs.
2. The proper construction of the phrase "able" in the context of clause 3.3 of the Gas Supply Agreement is that it is a subjective term that depends on the circumstances of each case. The Sellers' interpretation was accepted by the court.
3. The Sellers were justified in taking into account "all relevant commercial, economic and operational matters" in determining their ability to supply supplemental gas. However, the court did not specify the extent to which the Sellers could take these matters into account.
4. The Sellers' offer to supply Verve with an equivalent quantity of gas at a higher price under separate short term agreements did not constitute a breach of their obligation to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas.
5. Verve has a right to restitution of moneys paid under the short term gas supply agreements on the basis of alleged economic duress. However, the quantum of restitution was not determined in this decision.
6. Rescission of the short term gas supply agreements is not necessary before Verve can obtain restitution. The legal requirements for such rescission were not determined in this decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ, GAGELER J

In the case of Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd, the primary issue before the court was whether the Sellers breached their obligation under clause 3.3 of the Gas Supply Agreement (GSA) to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas during the period of reduced supply following the Varanus Island gas plant explosion. The Sellers argued that they were not obliged to supply supplemental gas at the price stipulated in the GSA during the period of reduced supply. They contended that they had the capacity to supply gas but chose not to do so, considering the prevailing market conditions and their other obligations under the GSA. The court had to determine whether the Sellers' interpretation of their obligations under the GSA was correct and if they were justified in taking into account all relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining their ability to supply supplemental gas.

The court began by examining the phrase "able" in the context of clause 3.3 of the GSA. The Sellers argued that the phrase meant having the capacity or ability to supply supplemental gas, which they clearly had. The court noted that the phrase "able" should be given its ordinary and natural meaning, which includes the capacity or ability to do something. However, the court also considered the broader context of the GSA and the Sellers' obligations under it. The court held that the phrase "able" should be interpreted in light of the Sellers' obligation to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas. The court held that the Sellers were obliged to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas, even if they had the capacity to do so, and that the phrase "able" did not preclude them from taking into account relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining whether they could supply supplemental gas.

The court further examined whether the Sellers were justified in taking into account all relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining their ability to supply supplemental gas. The court held that the Sellers were entitled to consider such matters, as they were relevant to the Sellers' obligations under the GSA. However, the court held that the Sellers' interpretation of their obligations under the GSA was too narrow, and that they were obliged to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas, even if they had the capacity to do so. The court held that the Sellers' consideration of relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters did not absolve them of their obligations under the GSA.

The court then considered whether the Sellers' offer to supply Verve with an equivalent quantity of gas at a higher price under separate short term agreements constituted a breach of their obligation to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas. The court held that the Sellers' offer did not constitute a breach of their obligations under the GSA, as they were entitled to consider relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining whether they could supply supplemental gas. However, the court held that the Sellers' offer did not absolve them of their obligations under the GSA, and that they were still obliged to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas.

The court also considered whether Verve had a right to restitution of moneys paid under the short term gas supply agreements on the basis of alleged economic duress. The court held that Verve did not have a right to restitution, as the Sellers' offer to supply gas at a higher price under separate short term agreements did not amount to economic duress. The court held that the Sellers' offer was a legitimate commercial decision, and that Verve had entered into the short term gas supply agreements voluntarily and under protest.

Finally, the court considered whether rescission of the short term gas supply agreements was necessary before Verve could obtain restitution, and if so, what the legal requirements for such rescission were. The court held that rescission was not necessary, as Verve did not have a right to restitution. The court held that the legal requirements for rescission were not applicable, as Verve did not have a cause of action for rescission.

In summary, the court held that the Sellers were obliged to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas, even if they had the capacity to do so, and that they were entitled to consider relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining whether they could supply supplemental gas. The court also held that the Sellers' offer to supply gas at a higher price under separate short term agreements did not constitute a breach of their obligations under the GSA, and that Verve did not have a right to restitution on the basis of alleged economic duress. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the phrase "able" in the context of a clause requiring a party to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas should be interpreted in light of the broader obligations of the party under the agreement, and that the party is obliged to use reasonable endeavours to supply supplemental gas, even if they have the capacity to do so. The court also held that a party is entitled to consider relevant commercial, economic, and operational matters in determining whether they can supply supplemental gas, but this does not absolve them of their obligations under the agreement.