PSC AMGI WSC Pty Ltd v J&P Capital Insurance Pty Ltd
Link copied
CaseCopied
49 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
PSC AMGI WSC Pty Ltd v J&P Capital Insurance Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 1057
File number:
WAD 274 of 2023
Judgment of:
COLVIN J
Date of judgment:
3 September 2025
Catchwords:
CONTRACTS - deed of settlement - competing applications for orders to give effect to terms of deed - where deed provided for one party to transfer certain assets no later than 7 days after the date of deed and the other party to pay the settlement sum of $80,000 no later than 7 days after transfer of remaining assets - where deed provided for forfeiture of the settlement sum if there was default in transferring the assets within 7 days of the date of the deed - proper construction of deed - whether breach of deed - whether termination only remedy - whether estoppel arose - whether forfeiture of settlement sum would operate as a penalty - breach of obligation to transfer assets within 7 days of date of deed provided for forfeiture of settlement sum, no estoppel and provision did not operate as a penalty - orders to enforce the settlement deed
Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs:
87
Date of last submissions:
27 August 2025 (applicants)
Date of hearing:
13 August 2025
Counsel for the Applicants:
Mr AJ Tharby
Solicitor for the Applicants:
Bennett
Counsel…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read PSC AMGI WSC Pty Ltd v J&P Capital Insurance Pty Ltd and more:
PSC AMGI WSC Pty Ltd v J&P Capital Insurance Pty Ltd was a case before the Federal Court of Australia, concerning the enforcement of a deed of settlement. The dispute centred around the obligations of the parties under the deed, particularly the transfer of certain assets and the payment of a settlement sum. The applicants sought orders to enforce the deed, while the respondents argued that the applicants had not performed their obligations, thereby forfeiting their right to the settlement sum.
The court was required to decide several legal issues, including the proper construction of the deed, whether there was a breach of the deed, the consequences of such a breach, whether estoppel applied, and whether the forfeiture clause operated as a penalty. The court also had to consider the factual requirements for the applicants to exercise their rights to the remaining assets and the steps that had been taken to perform the obligations under the deed.
The court found that the applicants had breached their obligation to transfer the remaining assets within the specified timeframe, which triggered the forfeiture of the settlement sum. The court rejected the argument that estoppel prevented the applicants from enforcing the forfeiture clause, and it held that the forfeiture clause did not operate as a penalty. Consequently, the court ordered that the respondents were not entitled to the settlement sum and mandated the transfer of the remaining assets to the applicants. The court also granted the applicants liberty to apply for further orders to enforce the settlement deed and ordered the respondents to pay the applicants' costs of the interlocutory applications.
In summary, the Federal Court enforced the terms of the deed of settlement, ruling that the respondents had breached their obligations, resulting in the forfeiture of the settlement sum. The court issued detailed orders to ensure the transfer of the remaining assets to the applicants and directed the respondents to pay the applicants' costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applicants' interlocutory application dated 20 May 2025 is allowed.
2. The respondents' interlocutory application dated 4 June 2025 is refused.
3. There be judgment for the applicants.
4. There be a declaration that the respondents are not entitled to the payment of the Settlement Sum referred to in the Deed of Settlement between the applicants and the respondents made on 25 March 2025 by exchange of counterparts.
5. The respondents do take all steps to effect the prompt transfer to the applicants (or such of them as is notified by the solicitors for the applicants), including all steps required to port or register as the case may be, each of (a) the four mobile phone numbers specified in the Deed of Settlement; (b) the email address domain '@jpcapitalinsurance.com.au'; and (c) the website operated by the first respondent, including the domain name www.jpcapitalinsurance.com.au.
6. There be liberty to the applicants to apply for further orders to give effect to order 5.
7. The respondents do pay the applicants' costs of the interlocutory applications to be assessed as one set of costs, if not agreed.
8. Save as provided for in order 7, there be no order as to the costs of the proceedings.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Accordingly, the following issues arise for determination:(1)On the evidence, what was required, in fact, for the Applicants to be able to exercise the rights to the Remaining Assets?(2)On the proper construction of the Deed, what was required to be done by the Applicants to perform the obligation to transfer the Remaining Assets to the Applicants?(3)Did the Respondents perform the obligation to transfer within time?(4)If no to (3), are the Applicants estopped from denying that the Respondents performed the obligation to transfer within time?(5)Subject to the answer to (6), if no to (3) and no to (4), what are the consequences, if any, of the failure to perform the obligation?(6)Would the forfeiture of the Settlement Sum in accordance with the terms of the Deed be a penalty?(7)Taking account of the answers to (1) to (6), what is the appropriate relief?Issue (1): On the evidence, what was required, in fact, for the Applicants to be able to exercise the rights to the Remaining Assets? Affidavits of the solicitors involved in arranging the transfer of the Remaining Assets were received without objection. There was no request to cross-examine. I will refer to the relevant communications as having passed between the Applicants and the Respondents, noting that, in fact, all communications were between their respective lawyers. Some of the communications were marked without prejudice, but all were received without objection. In what follows, I will deal with the overall chronology, some of which is relevant to the resolution of later issues. As to the steps that were taken to perform the obligation to transfer the Remaining Assets, the relevant evidence was as follows:(1)By 21 March 2025, the Applicants had executed their counterparts. On that date, the Applicants sent an email to the Respondents which included the following:I confirm that we now hold our clients' executed counterparts of the Deed. Noting that the exchange of counterparts will enliven your clients' obligation to transfer all of the Remaining Assets within 7 days pursuant to clause 2.2, and your clients may need to make additional arrangements to facilitate the transfer of the Remaining Assets within the required timeframe, could you please confirm when you are ready to exchange counterparts?For the purposes of your clients providing the SIM cards to PSC via express post upon execution of the deed, the address details for PSC's nominee are set out below:Attn: [name of contact]PSC Insurance Group Limited [Sydney office address](2)Counterparts of the Deed were exchanged on 25 March 2025.(3)It is common ground that ownership of three of the phone numbers was transferred to the Respondents' chosen IT provider on about 25 March 2025 and the fourth phone number was subsequently transferred to the IT provider.(4)On 26 March 2025, the Applicants sent an email to the Respondents which provided contact details 'for an additional nominee' for the purposes of transferring the Remaining Assets to the Applicants. The email asked for confirmation once the assets had been transferred. The address for the additional nominee was the same as that which had been given for 'PSC's nominee'.(5)On 1 April 2025, the Applicants sent an email to the Respondents in the following terms:Further to your call with [Applicants' solicitor] earlier today, I understand your clients are couriering the SIM cards to my clients' representative and have arranged an IT company to assist with the website and domain transfer.Transfer of phone numbersI anticipate there will be a process to undertake to transfer and/or port the phone numbers from the current account holders to PSC, which may require verification of identity by photo ID. For each of the phone numbers, could you please advise the Telco, account name(s), date(s) of birth, address(es) and other information and documents that will be required?Please also provide courier details and an ETA if possible as this will assist our clients to progress the transfer in a timely manner.Transfer of website and domainI suggest this may be best dealt with by the parties' respective IT personnel. Could you please advise contact details of your clients' IT company?We look forward to hearing from you.It can be seen that, as to the phone numbers, the email anticipated both the physical delivery of the SIM cards as well as the provision of details and 'other information and documents' to transfer or port the phone numbers. These were all steps to be taken by the Respondents. As to the transfer of the website and domain, the email anticipated cooperation between IT personnel for each of the Applicants and the Respondents.(6)After that, on the same day, being the last day provided for by the Deed, the Respondents sent an email to the Applicants at approximately 5.50 pm Sydney time which said:We confirm that we are couriering the SIM cards to your clients' representative and have arranged with our IT company to assist with the website domain transfer. We confirm the courier delivery has arrived this afternoon at the following address to deliver the sim cards:Attn: [name of additional nominee][Address in Sydney for additional nominee, as notified by the Applicants]We further confirm that there is a process to undertake the transfer of the phone numbers, and our IT specialist will be able to assist with this process and provide further information in due course. For both the transfer of the sim cards and the transfer of the website domain please contact our IT representative [name redacted] via email at [email address redacted] after receiving the sim cards.If you require any further clarification, please contact our office.Significantly, the email contemplated the physical delivery of the SIM cards. Otherwise, it contemplated that the Respondents' IT specialist would provide information and assist 'in due course' with the transfer of the phone numbers. Further, as to the transfer of the SIM cards and the transfer of the website domain the Applicants were directed to contact the Respondents' IT specialist at a specified email address 'after receiving the sim cards' (emphasis added). So, the performance proposed by the Respondents involved physical delivery of the SIM cards by courier followed by contact with the Respondents' IT specialist to obtain further information and assistance as to transfer of the intangible property.(7)There is no dispute between the parties that the statement to the effect that the SIM cards had been delivered was not correct. Rather, at approximately 5.50 pm Sydney time on the same day, someone instructed by the Respondents to do so, arrived at the specified address to deliver the SIM cards but they could not access the floor of the building at that hour of the day.(8)Just over an hour later (at 6.52 pm Sydney time) an email was sent by the Respondents to the Applicants. It said:Further to the below [being the email sent at approximately 5.50pm] and my conversation with [the Applicants' solicitor]. Our courier will re-attempt delivery tomorrow morning.(9)At 7.06 pm Sydney time the following email was sent by the Applicants to the Respondents:I refer to the below emails and my call with [the Respondents' solicitor] a short time ago, from which I understand that the courier arrived at my clients' offices at approximately 6pm (AEDT) but was unable to deliver the SIM cards as the office was closed.I confirm [the Applicants' named additional nominee] has left the office and is not available to receive an after‑hours delivery of the SIM cards. Further, I understand that as the building closes at 6pm, access to Level 24 closes off after this time. As such, the delivery will need to occur tomorrow.I will inform my client that the courier will attempt delivery tomorrow morning. I would be grateful if you could provide an ETA (if possible) and confirmation once delivery has been effected.I will otherwise pass on [the IT specialist's] details to my client for the purposes of arranging the transfer of the website, domain and phone numbers.(10)It is common ground that the SIM cards were physically delivered to the specified address in Sydney the following day.(11)On 3 April 2025, the Applicants sent a letter by email to the Respondents which said, amongst other things:(a)the Respondents had defaulted;(b)the Respondents had forfeited their right to the Settlement Sum;(c)the SIM cards had been received;(d)the SIM cards that were delivered were said to not comply with the Deed because they were not the SIM cards that were 'current' as at the date of the Deed (though they were identified as being the SIM cards for each of the four phone numbers);(e)the Applicants were entitled to apply for judgment to transfer the Remaining Assets; and(f)the Applicants' rights were otherwise reserved.(12)On 4 April 2025, the Respondents sent a letter by email in response which said, amongst other things:(a)there was no obligation to deliver the SIM cards to the Applicants' offices and the Applicants 'could have easily taken possession of the SIM cards from [the Respondents'] office';(b)there was no-one at the Applicants' offices in Sydney to take delivery when there was an attempt to deliver before 6.00 pm Sydney time;(c)the SIM cards were delivered on 2 April 2025; and(d)there had been a failure by the Applicants to perform its obligation under the Deed to carry out all things necessary to give effect to the transfer of the Remaining Assets.(13)The letter of 4 April 2025 also provided the following information under the heading 'Transfer of the Remaining Assets':For completeness we provide further information and instruction as to the transfer of the Remaining Assets with our IT Company.The Domain will need to be transferred, however, the transfer does not change the domain ownership. The Registrant details need to also be updated, and the receiving host should have a process. The further details of the domain are below:[A list of details including passwords were provided for the domain jpcapitalinsurance.com.au]The phone numbers are all registered against [name redacted], they will need a change of ownership performed. The receiving party will need to get 4 prepaid SIM cards, setup the corresponding account and activate each with temporary numbers. Once this has been completed, the IT company will need to initiate a change of ownership at this time we will need to either setup a conference call or Telstra can contact the receiving account holder to confirm and verify details to transfer.