Reliance Capital Pty Ltd v Caratti [No 11]

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD -v- CARATTI [No 11] [2025] WASC 454

CORAM:   LUNDBERG J

HEARD:   29 - 31 JANUARY, 1 - 2, 5 - 8, 12 - 14 FEBRUARY, 15, 18 - 19, 25 - 27 MARCH, 8 APRIL 2024 AND 31 JULY 2024 (20 DAYS)

DELIVERED          :   29 OCTOBER 2025

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3136 of 2019

BETWEEN:   RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI

First Defendant

TINA MICHELLE BAZZO

Second Defendant

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2283 of 2021

BETWEEN:   RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI

First Defendant

TINA MICHELLE BAZZO

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Banking and finance - Commercial lending arrangements for two property developments with associated security including personal guarantees and mortgages - Joint hearing of two actions between common parties - Defendant guarantors are directors or shareholders of property development companies - Numerous defences and counterclaim raised by the defendants - Numerous amendments to the pleadings before, during and after trial - Turns on own facts

Banking and finance - Manner of appropriation of proceeds of sale by plaintiff financier - Whether appropriation of proceeds to particular outstanding debt a breach of contract - Contractual construction - Knowledge of the debtor and guarantors

Banking and finance - Whether top-up payments made by borrowers credited to loan agreement - Whether lender properly accounted for non-refundable interest charge under loan agreement - Whether payment in effect a prepayment of interest

Banking and finance - Whether plaintiff lender breached loan agreement in refusing or failing to advance further sums to borrowers pursuant to drawdown arrangements - Whether written request made by borrowers - Contractual discretion to withhold payment of further advances - Effect of garnishee notice served on lender by the Australian Taxation Office - Whether borrower has established counterclaim for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds - Causation and issues of proof

Corporations - Statutory unconscionable conduct claims made against plaintiff lender in several respects pursuant to s 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) - Requirements to be established for statutory unconscionability - Whether claims made out

Estoppel - Whether representation made by plaintiff as to method of enforcement of guarantees - Defendants alleged that plaintiff represented it would exhaust its rights against the secured assets before seeking to recover under the guarantees - Whether estoppel demonstrated

Evidence - Rulings as to admissibility - Admission of documentary material pursuant to s 79C(2a) of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA)

Guarantees - Extension of principal loan agreement - Whether guarantor consented to extension of the loan agreement - Application of principles in Ankar Pty Ltd v Westminster Finance (Australia) Limited (1987) 162 CLR 549

Guarantees - Nature of obligations contained within guarantee instruments - Whether amounts claimed by plaintiff lender properly established - Whether prior demands required as element of the claims on guarantees - Whether costs and expenses properly claimed

Interest - Whether interest may be claimed by plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reliance Capital Pty Ltd v Caratti [No 11] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASC 454
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Reliance Capital Pty Ltd, a financier, sued Mr and Mrs Caratti, who are directors or shareholders of two property development companies, over a series of commercial lending arrangements, associated security, and related disputes. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The defendants raised numerous defences and counterclaims, including claims of unconscionability, estoppel, and breaches of duty as a mortgagee in possession. The case involved complex factual issues and required the interpretation of a number of agreements.

The court considered whether the plaintiff breached the loan agreements by not advancing further sums to the borrowers as requested, and whether the borrower had established a counterclaim for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds. The court also considered the effect of a garnishee notice served on the plaintiff by the Australian Taxation Office, and whether the claims for statutory unconscionability were made out. The court further considered the nature of the obligations contained within the guarantee instruments, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to claim interest at contractual rates on the judgment sum.

The court found that the plaintiff had not breached the loan agreements, and that the borrowers had not established a counterclaim for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds. The court found that the garnishee notice served on the plaintiff did not affect the priority of the plaintiff's claim. The court also found that the defendants had not established claims of statutory unconscionability, estoppel, or breach of duty as a mortgagee in possession. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to claim interest at contractual rates on the judgment sum.

The court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings, and that the plaintiff's interest on the judgment sum be calculated at contractual rates. The court further ordered that the defendants' counterclaims be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Reliance Capital Pty Ltd v Caratti [No 11] involves commercial lending arrangements for two property developments with associated security, including personal guarantees and mortgages. The case is a joint hearing of two actions between common parties, where the defendant guarantors are directors or shareholders of the property development companies. The case turns on its own facts, involving numerous defences and counterclaims raised by the defendants. The plaintiffs, Reliance Capital, allege that the defendants breached the terms of the loan agreements by misappropriating the proceeds of sale and failing to make top-up payments as agreed. The defendants, in turn, counterclaimed for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds and statutory unconscionable conduct claims against the plaintiff lender. The case also involves questions about the nature of obligations contained within the guarantee instruments, the admissibility of documentary evidence, and the enforceability of the guarantees.

The matter came before the court following amendments to the pleadings before, during, and after the trial. The case involved numerous procedural steps, including applications filed, interlocutory orders made, and procedural rulings relevant to the final hearing. The court had to consider the admissibility of documentary material pursuant to s 79C(2a) of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and the application of principles in Ankar Pty Ltd v Westminster Finance (Australia) Limited (1987) 162 CLR 549. The case also involved claims that the plaintiff acted in breach of duty and unconscionably whilst mortgagee in possession, with no exercise of the power of sale.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appropriation of proceeds of sale by the plaintiff financier to a particular outstanding debt was a breach of contract.
2. Whether top-up payments made by the borrowers were credited to the loan agreement and whether the lender properly accounted for the non-refundable interest charge under the loan agreement.
3. Whether the payment in effect was a prepayment of interest.
4. Whether the plaintiff lender breached the loan agreement in refusing or failing to advance further sums to the borrowers pursuant to drawdown arrangements.
5. Whether a written request was made by the borrowers and whether the lender had a contractual discretion to withhold payment of further advances.
6. Whether the effect of the garnishee notice served on the lender by the Australian Taxation Office was relevant to the case.
7. Whether the borrower has established a counterclaim for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds.
8. What are the requirements to be established for statutory unconscionability under s 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), and whether the claims made out?
9. Whether an estoppel was demonstrated based on a representation made by the plaintiff as to the method of enforcement of guarantees.
10. What is the nature of obligations contained within the guarantee instruments, and whether the amounts claimed by the plaintiff lender were properly established?
11. Whether prior demands were required as an element of the claims on guarantees.
12. Whether costs and expenses were properly claimed.
13. Whether interest may be claimed by the plaintiff lender at contractual rates on the judgment sum or at statutory rates.
14. What is the threshold issue as to whether a claim for breach of duty may validly be made in the absence of the exercise of the power of sale?
15. Whether the conduct of the plaintiff was a breach of duty on the facts.
16. Whether the conduct of the plaintiff was unconscionable contrary to statute.

Held
1. The appropriation of proceeds of sale by the plaintiff financier to a particular outstanding debt was not a breach of contract.
2. The top-up payments made by the borrowers were credited to the loan agreement and the lender properly accounted for the non-refundable interest charge under the loan agreement. The payment was not a prepayment of interest.
3. The plaintiff lender did not breach the loan agreement in refusing or failing to advance further sums to the borrowers pursuant to drawdown arrangements.
4. A written request was made by the borrowers, but the lender had a contractual discretion to withhold payment of further advances.
5. The effect of the garnishee notice served on the lender by the Australian Taxation Office was not relevant to the case.
6. The borrower did not establish a counterclaim for damages based on the alleged delay in advancing funds.
7. The requirements for statutory unconscionability under s 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) were not made out.
8. No estoppel was demonstrated based on a representation made by the plaintiff as to the method of enforcement of guarantees.
9. The nature of obligations contained within the guarantee instruments was such that the amounts claimed by the plaintiff lender were properly established.
10. Prior demands were not required as an element of the claims on guarantees.
11. Costs and expenses were not properly claimed by the plaintiff lender.
12. Interest may be claimed by the plaintiff lender at contractual rates on the judgment sum.
13. The threshold issue as to whether a claim for breach of duty may validly be made in the absence of the exercise of the power of sale was resolved in the negative.
14. The conduct of the plaintiff was not a breach of duty on the facts.
15. The conduct of the plaintiff was not unconscionable contrary to statute.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the contract between the parties, focusing on the specific clauses and terms agreed upon. It examined the appropriation of proceeds by the plaintiff financier, concluding that it was not a breach of contract as it was permitted under the terms. The court also reviewed the top-up payments and determined they were properly accounted for under the loan agreement. Regarding the drawdown arrangements, the court found the lender had discretion under the contract to withhold advances. The garnishee notice served by the Australian Taxation Office was deemed irrelevant to the case. The counterclaim for damages was dismissed due to insufficient evidence of causation and proof. Statutory unconscionability claims under s 12CB were rejected as the necessary criteria were not met. The court found no estoppel was demonstrated based on the alleged representation about the enforcement of guarantees. Obligations under the guarantee instruments were properly established, and prior demands were not required for the claims. The court disallowed improper claims for costs and expenses and allowed interest at contractual rates. The court held that a claim for breach of duty could not be made in the absence of the exercise of the power of sale, and found no breach of duty or unconscionable conduct by the plaintiff. The court's findings on these issues are binding on lower courts in similar circumstances.