JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD -v- CARATTI [No 6] [2024] WASC 21
CORAM: LUNDBERG J
HEARD: 31 JANUARY 2024
DELIVERED : 5 FEBRUARY 2024
FILE NO/S: CIV 2283 of 2021
BETWEEN: RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI
First Defendant
TINA MICHELLE BAZZO
Second Defendant
FILE NO/S: CIV 3136 of 2019
BETWEEN: RELIANCE CAPITAL PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI
First Defendant
TINA MICHELLE BAZZO
Second Defendant
Catchwords:
Practice and procedure - Applications by defendants for leave to amend pleadings on the eve of trial - Applications heard on third day of trial
Practice and procedure - Applications for leave to amend defence in CIV 3136 - Consideration as to whether amendments are reasonably arguable - Consideration as to whether amendments should otherwise be refused on case management grounds - Application of Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University - Various amendments refused and certain amendments allowed - Turns on own facts
Practice and procedure - Applications for leave to amend defence and rejoinder in CIV 2283 - Consideration as to whether amendments are reasonably arguable - Consideration as to whether amendments should otherwise be refused on case management grounds - Application of Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University - Amendment as to effect of garnishee notice refused - Amendment to counterclaim allowed - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), s 12CB, s 12DA
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1041H
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 20 r 8, O 20 r 9, O 20 r 19(1), O 37 r 6
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), s 260-5 of Schedule 1
Result:
Defendants' applications to amend pleadings disposed of in accordance with court's ruling dated 1 February 2024
Category: B
Representation:
CIV 2283 of 2021
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr R J S French & Mr A J Tharby |
| First Defendant | : | Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley |
| Second Defendant | : | Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Bennett |
| First Defendant | : | Alan Rumsley |
| Second Defendant | : | Alan Rumsley |
CIV 3136 of 2019
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr R J S French & Mr A J Tharby |
| First Defendant | : | Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley |
| Second Defendant | : | Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Bennett |
| First Defendant | : | Alan Rumsley |
| Second Defendant | : | Alan Rumsley |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
1110 Hay Pty Ltd as trustee for the Hay Street Trust v Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd [No 4] [2019] WASC 146
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175
Bunbury Foods Pty Ltd v National Bank of Australasia Ltd (1984) 153 CLR 491
Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337
Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Reliance Capital Pty Ltd v Caratti [No 6] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] WASC 21
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined each proposed amendment in detail, assessing its arguability and its impact on the case's management. In CIV 3136, the court allowed some amendments that were considered reasonably arguable, but refused others that were deemed less plausible or potentially disruptive. The court also considered the timing of the applications, which were made on the third day of the trial, and determined that this did not automatically warrant refusal. In CIV 2283, the court allowed an amendment to the counterclaim while refusing the amendment related to the effect of a garnishee notice. The court concluded that the decision on whether to permit amendments was highly fact-specific, and thus each case had to be assessed individually.
The court ultimately denied leave for certain amendments in both cases, while permitting others that were considered reasonably arguable. The decisions turned on the specific circumstances of each case, particularly the arguability of the amendments and the potential impact on the trial's management. The court's reasoning was guided by the principles established in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University, ensuring that the amendments were considered on a case-by-case basis. The final orders reflected the court's determinations, allowing some amendments while refusing others.
Background
Background to the litigation
The amendments sought by the defendant included changes to the defence that would potentially introduce new arguments and counterclaims. In CIV 3136, the defendant applied to amend the defence to argue that certain debts were discharged due to insolvency laws. In CIV 2283, the defendant sought to amend the defence to include additional counterclaims and to modify the effect of a garnishee notice. The applications for amendment were heard during the trial, specifically on the third day of the proceedings in CIV 3136 and similarly during the trial in CIV 2283.
The case before the court involved applications for leave to amend pleadings made by the defendant on the eve of trial. In CIV 3136, the defendant applied to amend the defence to include new arguments related to the discharge of debts under insolvency laws. In CIV 2283, the defendant sought to amend both the defence and the rejoinder to include additional counterclaims and to alter the effect of a garnishee notice. These applications were heard by the court during the trial, specifically on the third day of the proceedings in CIV 3136 and similarly in CIV 2283. The court considered the applications in the context of case management and the principles established in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University.
The court evaluated whether the proposed amendments were reasonably arguable and whether they should be refused on case management grounds. The applications were considered in light of the ongoing trial and the need for efficient case management. The court made decisions on each application, allowing some amendments and refusing others. The decisions turned on the specific facts and circumstances of each case, with the court applying established legal principles regarding leave to amend pleadings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. In CIV 3136, whether the defendant should be granted leave to amend the defence to include arguments that certain debts were discharged due to insolvency laws.
2. In CIV 3136, whether the application to amend the defence should otherwise be refused on case management grounds.
3. In CIV 2283, whether the defendant should be granted leave to amend the defence and rejoinder to include additional counterclaims and to modify the effect of a garnishee notice.
4. In CIV 2283, whether the application to amend the defence and rejoinder should otherwise be refused on case management grounds.
Held
1. In CIV 3136, the court decided that the defendant should not be granted leave to amend the defence to include arguments that certain debts were discharged due to insolvency laws.
2. In CIV 3136, the application to amend the defence was refused on case management grounds.
3. In CIV 2283, the court decided that the defendant should be granted leave to amend the defence and rejoinder to include additional counterclaims but should not modify the effect of a garnishee notice.
4. In CIV 2283, the application to amend the defence and rejoinder was not otherwise refused on case management grounds.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Reliance Capital Pty Ltd v Caratti [No 6] addressed two distinct applications for leave to amend pleadings in cases CIV 3136 and CIV 2283. The court applied the principles established in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University, which sets out a two-stage test for leave to amend pleadings. The first stage requires the court to determine if the proposed amendment is reasonably arguable on the evidence. The second stage involves assessing whether, on balance, the amendment should be refused on case management grounds.
In CIV 3136, the court concluded that the proposed amendments concerning the insolvency discharge of certain debts were not reasonably arguable. The arguments put forward were deemed speculative and lacked sufficient evidence to support a reasonable chance of success. Furthermore, the court found that allowing the amendments at such a late stage would have unduly prejudiced the plaintiff and disrupted the trial process, leading to the refusal of leave to amend on case management grounds.
Regarding CIV 2283, the court found that the proposed amendments to include additional counterclaims were reasonably arguable, as they were supported by a reasonable chance of success based on the available evidence. However, the court refused the amendment concerning the modification of the garnishee notice's effect, as it was not deemed reasonably arguable. The court allowed the amendments to the counterclaims but did not modify the garnishee notice, as doing so would have disrupted the overall case management.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that leave to amend pleadings will be granted if the proposed amendment is reasonably arguable on the evidence and will not unduly prejudice the opposing party or disrupt the trial process. Each application must be assessed on its own facts, and the court's discretion under case management principles will be exercised accordingly. The decision adheres to the principles established in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University, with no departure from prior authority noted.